Everyone is always free to quit a group. if you don't like it, quit the group and start/join another. That's the way it should be.
Inactive/non-functioning/DC players should be handled automatically and not by the players themselves.
If this has been going on on the PC side for years there is no excuse for this to have happened here. You should have learned your lessons there that people always sink to the lowest form of behavior when given an opportunity to do so. Game developers need to understand this and code to prevent it (or in the case of COD code to encourage it).
This game is a disaster due to this one issue alone (although there are other serious issues). Until this gets fixed, this game is insulting to all of us who have spent time and money attempting to live with it. If the developers have any respect for the people who support them, they'll fix this immediately. And if they don't fix this promptly (as seems to be the case already) it speaks volumes about how they feel about us.
Everyone is always free to quit a group. if you don't like it, quit the group and start/join another. That's the way it should be.
Inactive/non-functioning/DC players should be handled automatically and not by the players themselves.
If this has been going on on the PC side for years there is no excuse for this to have happened here. You should have learned your lessons there that people always sink to the lowest form of behavior when given an opportunity to do so. Game developers need to understand this and code to prevent it (or in the case of COD code to encourage it).
This game is a disaster due to this one issue alone (although there are other serious issues). Until this gets fixed, this game is insulting to all of us who have spent time and money attempting to live with it. If the developers have any respect for the people who support them, they'll fix this immediately. And if they don't fix this promptly (as seems to be the case already) it speaks volumes about how they feel about us.
The most amazing thing happened last night. Joined the que, first amazing thing was i didnt just jump half way into someone else's dungeon. Myself and one other (tr) appear, we wait for the others. They appear, as there is another hr (i am one) i wait for the vtk on him as his gs is several k lower.
Never comes, i can tell we are all gun shy waiting for a vtk , we inch towards the start... and... we start!
We get to the boss and lose first try. Low,gs cleric leaves, we wait around, a sw with horrid lag shows up, we lose twice... everyone but myself and the orginal tr leave. Another three people show up, and guess what? We try again and win!
This happens not once, not twice but three times in a row! I was able to do three dungeons in a row and not once was there even a vtk.
When people didnt think we could do it, they just left. I dunno if they changed anything, but now im convinced we really dont need the vtk at all. Even a disconnected person will eventually time out.
Im just so happy
The most amazing thing happened last night. Joined the que, first amazing thing was i didnt just jump half way into someone else's dungeon. Myself and one other (tr) appear, we wait for the others. They appear, as there is another hr (i am one) i wait for the vtk on him as his gs is several k lower.
Never comes, i can tell we are all gun shy waiting for a vtk , we inch towards the start... and... we start!
We get to the boss and lose first try. Low,gs cleric leaves, we wait around, a sw with horrid lag shows up, we lose twice... everyone but myself and the orginal tr leave. Another three people show up, and guess what? We try again and win!
This happens not once, not twice but three times in a row! I was able to do three dungeons in a row and not once was there even a vtk.
When people didnt think we could do it, they just left. I dunno if they changed anything, but now im convinced we really dont need the vtk at all. Even a disconnected person will eventually time out.
Im just so happy
Can't tell if that's sarcasm or not lol. Honestly this was the first time in a long time i tried an epic dungeon as last time i wasted 4 hours. And haven't hqd a chance to play today, so could be a random fluke of great people
im tired of people who rage quit or dc and never come back why cant u kick them it lowers your team odds of winning kick them let some one else join sigh
Give people the ability to kick in PvP and the same same ****e will happen as it does in pve, oh btw the guild <Removed> on Xbox one are boot and loot so beware, kicked us out on shores when the burning necklace dropped, I reported them to xbl.
well let me tell u. i have been playing since a couple days after it came out. i have a sw and cw both are at around a 11k gs. that is sad, cant get anything good being kicked all the time. last night i tried again epic temple of spiders, the guys were great finished it and got a peice for my cw. **** i was like a kid in a candy store. i told my kids i was so excited(sad i know lol). well tried another spellpl. reality set in quick got kicked. i try to get my kids to play but they are burnt out of being kicked and they are good.
0
zebularMember, Neverwinter Moderator, NW M9 PlaytestPosts: 15,270Community Moderator
edited June 2015
They've begun taking steps to combat Vote-Kick abuse on the PC version. Hopefully this helps things out on the PC side so you guys too can get these changes, and upcoming changes, patched to you as soon as possible.
Again, this is only on the PC Version at the time of this post, yet is something to look forward to and see as a sign that they are indeed working on resolving Vote-Kicking abuse as well as that you're not alone. We struggle with it too on the PC side.
Queue Improvements: We have made a number adjustments to the queue system to help improve the overall experience. It is still recommended that players who want specific group requirements or players group up before entering the queue. These features may be tuned while the server is active should any of the initial settings be too strict or lax.
When queues fill a player who has left they now respect roles. Ie. If a Devoted Cleric leaves a map the queue will only replace them with another Devoted Cleric or an Oathbound Paladin of the appropriate specialization.
After a map has had a number of players leave the queue will no longer attempt to fill players from the queue. This is both to prevent maps that are in a stuck state to continually send players there as well as discourage frequent use of vote kicking.
There is now a minimum amount of time that must pass before a player may be vote kicked from a party. It should be enough time that it will be worth attempting any content before being able to kick the player.
Possible to get a direct link to those notes for ease of reference. I'd be curious to see if some of the questions I have about those changes are being asked/answered.
Those fixes alone would be a good start, but unfortunately would do nothing to discourage loot kicking.
A lot of kicking comes from over geared players looking to short man the dungeon as well. This fix actually encourages that. Just keep kicking till no one can re queue and boom you have your 3 man team.
Easy way to fix this is to just allow us to create custom teams and stop forcing people to use 5 man teams and allowing teams to join or leave the queue at will while in the dungeon rather than make it to where you're forced to kick multiple people to do so.
Possible to get a direct link to those notes for ease of reference. I'd be curious to see if some of the questions I have about those changes are being asked/answered.
Yeah, I am pretty frustrated with the kick system. If I felt like I was a poor player, I'd probably wouldnt be as pissed. However, more time than not I do the most damage. I don't have the highest gs score, but its not bad neither, over 11K. The situation I am seeing a lot is that their will be a group the kicks anyone not in their group when the boss dies and not giving them a chance at loot. This is not necessarily the final boss, but anytime there is a chance for epics. I believe it is from people trying to farm epics to change to ADs. Here I am trying to improve my gear and can't because I keep getting booted. Easy solution for me is to go in with friends, but I work different hours so I cant always do that. I get stuck running solo a lot.
I know this isn't happening just to me. Got into another random group and some of them had mics. We lost a player right before the start of the end boss and another guy joined. When the boss dropped, the new guy tried to kick people. We all were talking and voted no. It's a HAMSTER move for sure.
Anyhow, I hope devs do something to improve this. The other improvement I would like to see is that que searches to try to match 3 DPS with a tank and healer. WoW has that ability so I know it can be done.
I'm sure this has been said zebular but this doesn't help with the kicking at/during/immediately after boss keeping you from rolling on boss loot and getting your chest. That is the single most annoying and frustrating thing in this game.
0
zebularMember, Neverwinter Moderator, NW M9 PlaytestPosts: 15,270Community Moderator
I'm sure this has been said zebular but this doesn't help with the kicking at/during/immediately after boss keeping you from rolling on boss loot and getting your chest. That is the single most annoying and frustrating thing in this game.
I agree with you. Just keep in mind, as stated, this is just the beginning of us seeing them actively combat Vote Kicking. I just wanted to pass this change along here to show you all that they are working on it and are now taking steps, starting with the PC.
I agree with you. Just keep in mind, as stated, this is just the beginning of us seeing them actively combat Vote Kicking. I just wanted to pass this change along here to show you all that they are working on it and are now taking steps, starting with the PC.
Howdy,
So starting with PC? So does that mean xbox will not be looked at for 6 months. What sort of time line are we looking at for xbox? Xbox is several patches behind PC. I liked to see it caught up and updated as PC is updated.
"After a map has had a number of players leave the queue will no longer attempt to fill players from the queue. This is both to prevent maps that are in a stuck state to continually send players there as well as discourage frequent use of vote kicking."
Keep in mind this is a PC version patch but this very well could be the outcome of our fix as well. What this basically means is, if someone uses the VTK too many times, new players will no longer be added to that Dungeon. In my opinion this is not a fix! As the damage is already done by the ******ed little twits that kicked at and after the boss is dead. At that point they wouldn't want anyone new to join the Dungeon. Lets hope this is not the way the Xbox is "fixed".
"After a map has had a number of players leave the queue will no longer attempt to fill players from the queue. This is both to prevent maps that are in a stuck state to continually send players there as well as discourage frequent use of vote kicking."
Keep in mind this is a PC version patch but this very well could be the outcome of our fix as well. What this basically means is, if someone uses the VTK too many times, new players will no longer be added to that Dungeon. In my opinion this is not a fix! As the damage is already done by the ******ed little twits that kicked at and after the boss is dead. At that point they wouldn't want anyone new to join the Dungeon. Lets hope this is not the way the Xbox is "fixed".
in pc there is no more lootable loot.
the loot if drops, drops randomly on the floor. Its always for your class or not class specific and you are the only one to see it.
Most of the time is bind to pick up.
if they are going to apply this to you too, there will be no reason to kick.
0
zebularMember, Neverwinter Moderator, NW M9 PlaytestPosts: 15,270Community Moderator
So starting with PC? So does that mean xbox will not be looked at for 6 months. What sort of time line are we looking at for xbox? Xbox is several patches behind PC. I liked to see it caught up and updated as PC is updated.
Thrills
Not necessarily. I do not believe these changes are tied to any of the modules, so theoretically they could implement them on the XBOX without waiting for Module 6. I'll ask though but I doubt they're ready to give any sort of ETA on when these changes will start hitting the XBOX.
in pc there is no more lootable loot.
the loot if drops, drops randomly on the floor. Its always for your class or not class specific and you are the only one to see it.
Most of the time is bind to pick up.
if they are going to apply this to you too, there will be no reason to kick.
Sadly that wouldn't stop the twits on Xbox. Some groups have even went so far as to name their guild after the fact that they kick people before they get to loot anything. So even if they set it like this, some people still would abuse to stop YOU from getting anything just for spite. Its a very sad state of affairs on the Xbox.
in pc there is no more lootable loot.
the loot if drops, drops randomly on the floor. Its always for your class or not class specific and you are the only one to see it.
Most of the time is bind to pick up.
if they are going to apply this to you too, there will be no reason to kick.
Sadly that wouldn't stop the twits on Xbox. Some groups have even went so far as to name their guild after the fact that they kick people before they get to loot anything. So even if they set it like this, some people still would abuse to stop YOU from getting anything just for spite. Its a very sad state of affairs on the Xbox.
I agree. Some just do it because they think its fun. All I know is I was happy to see a true MMORPG come to console that was similar to WoW. I hate playing on a PC. However, if things don't change, it will not be worth my time. I haven't touched Destiny with the latest DLC since I started Neverwinter. I have the Witcher 3 that I haven't messed with. Next week Elder Scrolls Online comes out to xbox, so I might switch it up if I feel like things are not gonna change. Tired of the BS.
Now thats it Cryptic... how can you NOT have got the thumb out of your A*** yet ... played since beta on PC and im now on Xbox and its the same HAMSTER over and over again with the vote kick .. dungeon delves final boss kill and i see the loot on the ground and i get vote kicked so i wont get the chance to roll on greater mark of potency and some other stuff or open the chest... im flipping furious at this HAMSTER ... SORT THE **** OUT and i dont give a flying rats HAMSTER if you actually ban me on here because it wont be the first flipping time either, was banned on here back on pc due to your ****ty Vote kick HAMSTER ... REMOVE IT .. ONLY ALLOW VOTE KICK IF PPL ARE OFFLINE end of story im done playing this untill this vote kick system is sorted out... no more CASH from this person and i ENCOURAGE EVERYONE ELSE THAT HAS A VOTE KICK ISSUE TO STOP PLAYING let them NOT make ANY money off us untill they sort it.. ITS THE CUSTOMERS WORLD HAMSTER
Now thats it Cryptic... how can you NOT have got the thumb out of your A*** yet ... played since beta on PC and im now on Xbox and its the same HAMSTER over and over again with the vote kick .. dungeon delves final boss kill and i see the loot on the ground and i get vote kicked so i wont get the chance to roll on greater mark of potency and some other stuff or open the chest... im flipping furious at this HAMSTER ... SORT THE **** OUT and i dont give a flying rats HAMSTER if you actually ban me on here because it wont be the first flipping time either, was banned on here back on pc due to your ****ty Vote kick HAMSTER ... REMOVE IT .. ONLY ALLOW VOTE KICK IF PPL ARE OFFLINE end of story im done playing this untill this vote kick system is sorted out... no more CASH from this person and i ENCOURAGE EVERYONE ELSE THAT HAS A VOTE KICK ISSUE TO STOP PLAYING let them NOT make ANY money off us untill they sort it.. ITS THE CUSTOMERS WORLD HAMSTER
Howdy!,
I feel ya. I stopped paying for ZEN. I am not gonna spend another dime until this is fixed. If they eliminate kick system all together, then I think the ques should automatically search for 3 dps, a tank, and a healer. I know this is possible because WoW has had this for a long time. Other option is that everyone gets their own loot. No more rolling for loot. Its annoying anyway to be in combat and some jerk is picking up greens. Have something like in the CTA skirmishes where if loot drops on the ground, you are the only one to see it. On boss drops, everyone gets something. I know there's a way to set it up where you can still have the individual have a chance at rear loot from time to time and still have common epics drop in there. Make it where they dont have to roll for it. I don't like the bind on pick up option. One thing I like about this game is that most things are bind on equip. Gives me the ability to auction it if I dont needed it.
FIX THE KICK SYSTEM AND MAKE WHERE WE ARE NOT FIGHTING OVER LOOT!
The new content does not make up for the fact that this issue is not fixed. In fact, none of the severe launch issues have been fixed to date. While some might think it's nice to have a double seals weekend, most of us NEVER go into dungeons because of this vote kicking HAMSTER. So until you fix that you can skip the double seals BS as far as I'm concerned. I'm not going into dungeons to let a bunch of COD kids **** all over me.
I have to say, I'm not totally convinced about this "after so many players leave an instance, we'll not send anymore to the queue" thing.
I was in the Epic Mad Dragon the other day and it was taking some time. After wipe 2 on the second boss (cos some people couldn't get that you had to kill adds) someone had to leave cos they had to go to work. We decided to try to 4-man it and failed. Then someone else lost interest and left.
We got a couple more in and killed it.
Moving on to the Dragon and we had a similar story. Someone had to leave due to RL issues, we tried a few times, making more and more progress as the each attempt went on. But along the way we had the odd person give up. One of them we had to kick due to persistent disconnect. All in all we must have lost somewhere between 5 and 10 people. I was the only original member left from the group that started from the beginning.
But we killed it eventually. And there was much whooping and cheering on party chat. And that was my first time. And despite the wiping and the rotation of players. I really enjoyed it. I added a new friend because of that experience, cos he was a **** fine GWF.
I would hate to think that the new rules would have prevented us from getting those last attempts in. Note that of those potential 10 player rotations, we only used VTK once and that was to get rid of a perm-disconnected player.
I welcome attempts to fix this problem, but I fear you're still fixing the wrong problem. "Stuck games" are not what people complain about here. At least thats not what I'm reading.
I am equally unconvinced by this "we'll respect roles and only replace a cleric with a cleric" change.
So what happens if our original group gets 2 clerics in it from the start? We'll never be able to replace one with another class? Even if one chooses to leave to get party balance right, you'll continually fill with a Cleric?
And what happens when you get to a boss that needs a tank and you continually get given a replacement DPS class?
You're on the right lines here, but you're still missing the mark. Respecting roles in the queuing system is needed, but you need to put the control of the role selection in the hands of the party. If I'm short a player, let me choose what I want; Heal, Tank, DPS. Don't try to 'guess' what I want and assume that the original role distribution was what we actually wanted in the first place. This is a VERY poor assumption since the current queuing system is awful and doesn't anywhere near guarantee an ideal party composition.
I am equally unconvinced by this "we'll respect roles and only replace a cleric with a cleric" change.
So what happens if our original group gets 2 clerics in it from the start? We'll never be able to replace one with another class? Even if one chooses to leave to get party balance right, you'll continually fill with a Cleric?
And what happens when you get to a boss that needs a tank and you continually get given a replacement DPS class?
You're on the right lines here, but you're still missing the mark. Respecting roles in the queuing system is needed, but you need to put the control of the role selection in the hands of the party. If I'm short a player, let me choose what I want; Heal, Tank, DPS. Don't try to 'guess' what I want and assume that the original role distribution was what we actually wanted in the first place. This is a VERY poor assumption since the current queuing system is awful and doesn't anywhere near guarantee an ideal party composition.
This is a very good point. If a player leaves (without a VTK) the vote system is already in place. Just have a vote window pop up with 3 options.
DC
Tank
DPS
Let the players decide what they want as the replacement.
If a player was VTK'd however it should be auto replace with the exact same class no matter what. Otherwise it'll be abused.
There is an issue with the booting system and there is an easy fix. Booting is important since it allows for dead-weight players to be booted from the party in order to make room for players who will earn their shot at gear. However, this system is currently being abused at the higher levels of epic dungeons, especially on Epic Castle Never. I played with a group, presumably with a team of three or four friends, and I, the solo player. We got to the final boss, fought him, and beat him in a single try. I didn't go down once and did quite a bit of damage to the boss and mobs. Once the boss was defeated, I saw a the Ancient Trapper's ornate Longbow on the ground. I was excited as I was the only Hunter Ranger in the group, so the bow would have definitely be mine. I went to pick it up, pressed "A" for need, then my screen promptly loaded to Protector's Enclave. I got booted. Not because I was doing poorly and could not keep my own, not because I wasn't contributing, but because I wan't part of their guild or team, and booting the random (or the two randoms if they were in a group of three), would mean that all loot, and profits from the loot, could be split between the rest of them.
This isn't the first time this has happened either. Actually, only once have I not been attempted to be booted from a group, and that group was impressed enough by my character to invite me from their guild. Every other time, I have either been successfully kicked from a group after the final boss has been defeated, or I have seen in the feed "Vote kick failed" without having received a prompt to boot anyone, meaning that the vote kick was intended for me.
This system is broken and promotes unethical decisions by players, and robs solo players from rewards that they earned just so the people who know each other can make a few Astral Diamonds.
Now, I'm not saying that the boot system should be removed, because it is entirely necessary. However, I think it should be reworked. I also believe that the solution is simple: Do not allow vote kicking during or after the final boss fight in a dungeon. This still allows people to boot during the bulk of the dungeon, and allows for people to boot if the entire group dies at the final boss. What it doesn't allow is people booting simply to eliminate competition for gear.
The reason as to why vote kicking shouldn't be allowed specifically during or after the final boss fight is because of the same reason. If vote kicking isn't allowed after the boss fight, then small groups wouldn't be able to get rid random players simply to eliminate competition for items. For that same reason, vote kicking shouldn't be allowed during the boss fight because players could simply wait until the boss is very close to dead, then vote kick the other players, and finish the boss themselves. I feel like the cut off for vote kicking should be once the "group gathering" timer reaches zero and everyone is transported to the boss's chamber. That way, everyone who contributed to the boss's death has a chance for the boss's rewards.
As a closing statement, I do not believe that this system is ever going to be balanced or perfect. However, the kicking of random players at the end of Epic dungeons to eliminate competition for loot is a quite common practice, and it has a simple fix. I would appreciate as much support on this thread so that the appropriate changes can be implemented. I would like PW support to see this and empathize with my plight.
Thank you to everyone who read this all the way though, and thank you for all those who chose to support this. This change needs to happen, and, with your support, it can.
Xbox GT: BeastNHisHarlot
Main Character: Jimbo Bob Bill
Comments
Everyone is always free to quit a group. if you don't like it, quit the group and start/join another. That's the way it should be.
Inactive/non-functioning/DC players should be handled automatically and not by the players themselves.
If this has been going on on the PC side for years there is no excuse for this to have happened here. You should have learned your lessons there that people always sink to the lowest form of behavior when given an opportunity to do so. Game developers need to understand this and code to prevent it (or in the case of COD code to encourage it).
This game is a disaster due to this one issue alone (although there are other serious issues). Until this gets fixed, this game is insulting to all of us who have spent time and money attempting to live with it. If the developers have any respect for the people who support them, they'll fix this immediately. And if they don't fix this promptly (as seems to be the case already) it speaks volumes about how they feel about us.
Totally and utterly agree with everything here!
Never comes, i can tell we are all gun shy waiting for a vtk , we inch towards the start... and... we start!
We get to the boss and lose first try. Low,gs cleric leaves, we wait around, a sw with horrid lag shows up, we lose twice... everyone but myself and the orginal tr leave. Another three people show up, and guess what? We try again and win!
This happens not once, not twice but three times in a row! I was able to do three dungeons in a row and not once was there even a vtk.
When people didnt think we could do it, they just left. I dunno if they changed anything, but now im convinced we really dont need the vtk at all. Even a disconnected person will eventually time out.
Im just so happy
congrats.. do you have another success story ?
Can't tell if that's sarcasm or not lol. Honestly this was the first time in a long time i tried an epic dungeon as last time i wasted 4 hours. And haven't hqd a chance to play today, so could be a random fluke of great people
maintaining HR, DC, GWF, TR, SW, CW, OP, 4 Kids and 1 wife
Tweet me @ nem3sis_AUT
Streaming NWXbox daily @ 7PM CEST My Twitch
When is this for you? Worldtime Buddy
I miss you Boo
Again, this is only on the PC Version at the time of this post, yet is something to look forward to and see as a sign that they are indeed working on resolving Vote-Kicking abuse as well as that you're not alone. We struggle with it too on the PC side.
[ Support Center • Rules & Policies and Guidelines • ARC ToS • Guild Recruitment Guidelines | FR DM Since 1993 ]
Possible to get a direct link to those notes for ease of reference. I'd be curious to see if some of the questions I have about those changes are being asked/answered.
Those fixes alone would be a good start, but unfortunately would do nothing to discourage loot kicking.
Easy way to fix this is to just allow us to create custom teams and stop forcing people to use 5 man teams and allowing teams to join or leave the queue at will while in the dungeon rather than make it to where you're forced to kick multiple people to do so.
Get the Forums Enhancement Extension!
Sure thing.
Live Notes: Patch Notes: NW.45.20150515a.3
Preview Notes: Elemental Evil Preview Patch Notes NW.45.20150515a.2
News Article: Patch Notes: NW.45.20150515a.3
[ Support Center • Rules & Policies and Guidelines • ARC ToS • Guild Recruitment Guidelines | FR DM Since 1993 ]
Yeah, I am pretty frustrated with the kick system. If I felt like I was a poor player, I'd probably wouldnt be as pissed. However, more time than not I do the most damage. I don't have the highest gs score, but its not bad neither, over 11K. The situation I am seeing a lot is that their will be a group the kicks anyone not in their group when the boss dies and not giving them a chance at loot. This is not necessarily the final boss, but anytime there is a chance for epics. I believe it is from people trying to farm epics to change to ADs. Here I am trying to improve my gear and can't because I keep getting booted. Easy solution for me is to go in with friends, but I work different hours so I cant always do that. I get stuck running solo a lot.
I know this isn't happening just to me. Got into another random group and some of them had mics. We lost a player right before the start of the end boss and another guy joined. When the boss dropped, the new guy tried to kick people. We all were talking and voted no. It's a HAMSTER move for sure.
Anyhow, I hope devs do something to improve this. The other improvement I would like to see is that que searches to try to match 3 DPS with a tank and healer. WoW has that ability so I know it can be done.
Thrills
PS - I play the xbox version.
I agree with you. Just keep in mind, as stated, this is just the beginning of us seeing them actively combat Vote Kicking. I just wanted to pass this change along here to show you all that they are working on it and are now taking steps, starting with the PC.
[ Support Center • Rules & Policies and Guidelines • ARC ToS • Guild Recruitment Guidelines | FR DM Since 1993 ]
Howdy,
So starting with PC? So does that mean xbox will not be looked at for 6 months. What sort of time line are we looking at for xbox? Xbox is several patches behind PC. I liked to see it caught up and updated as PC is updated.
Thrills
I just read a bit of information from the PC side that has me concerned towards the fix for the VTK abuse.
http://www.arcgames.com/en/games/nev...45.20150515a.3
"After a map has had a number of players leave the queue will no longer attempt to fill players from the queue. This is both to prevent maps that are in a stuck state to continually send players there as well as discourage frequent use of vote kicking."
Keep in mind this is a PC version patch but this very well could be the outcome of our fix as well. What this basically means is, if someone uses the VTK too many times, new players will no longer be added to that Dungeon. In my opinion this is not a fix! As the damage is already done by the ******ed little twits that kicked at and after the boss is dead. At that point they wouldn't want anyone new to join the Dungeon. Lets hope this is not the way the Xbox is "fixed".
the loot if drops, drops randomly on the floor. Its always for your class or not class specific and you are the only one to see it.
Most of the time is bind to pick up.
if they are going to apply this to you too, there will be no reason to kick.
Not necessarily. I do not believe these changes are tied to any of the modules, so theoretically they could implement them on the XBOX without waiting for Module 6. I'll ask though but I doubt they're ready to give any sort of ETA on when these changes will start hitting the XBOX.
[ Support Center • Rules & Policies and Guidelines • ARC ToS • Guild Recruitment Guidelines | FR DM Since 1993 ]
Sadly that wouldn't stop the twits on Xbox. Some groups have even went so far as to name their guild after the fact that they kick people before they get to loot anything. So even if they set it like this, some people still would abuse to stop YOU from getting anything just for spite. Its a very sad state of affairs on the Xbox.
Thanks for you efforts.
Thrills
I agree. Some just do it because they think its fun. All I know is I was happy to see a true MMORPG come to console that was similar to WoW. I hate playing on a PC. However, if things don't change, it will not be worth my time. I haven't touched Destiny with the latest DLC since I started Neverwinter. I have the Witcher 3 that I haven't messed with. Next week Elder Scrolls Online comes out to xbox, so I might switch it up if I feel like things are not gonna change. Tired of the BS.
Thrills
Howdy!,
I feel ya. I stopped paying for ZEN. I am not gonna spend another dime until this is fixed. If they eliminate kick system all together, then I think the ques should automatically search for 3 dps, a tank, and a healer. I know this is possible because WoW has had this for a long time. Other option is that everyone gets their own loot. No more rolling for loot. Its annoying anyway to be in combat and some jerk is picking up greens. Have something like in the CTA skirmishes where if loot drops on the ground, you are the only one to see it. On boss drops, everyone gets something. I know there's a way to set it up where you can still have the individual have a chance at rear loot from time to time and still have common epics drop in there. Make it where they dont have to roll for it. I don't like the bind on pick up option. One thing I like about this game is that most things are bind on equip. Gives me the ability to auction it if I dont needed it.
FIX THE KICK SYSTEM AND MAKE WHERE WE ARE NOT FIGHTING OVER LOOT!
Thrills
Fix it.
I was in the Epic Mad Dragon the other day and it was taking some time. After wipe 2 on the second boss (cos some people couldn't get that you had to kill adds) someone had to leave cos they had to go to work. We decided to try to 4-man it and failed. Then someone else lost interest and left.
We got a couple more in and killed it.
Moving on to the Dragon and we had a similar story. Someone had to leave due to RL issues, we tried a few times, making more and more progress as the each attempt went on. But along the way we had the odd person give up. One of them we had to kick due to persistent disconnect. All in all we must have lost somewhere between 5 and 10 people. I was the only original member left from the group that started from the beginning.
But we killed it eventually. And there was much whooping and cheering on party chat. And that was my first time. And despite the wiping and the rotation of players. I really enjoyed it. I added a new friend because of that experience, cos he was a **** fine GWF.
I would hate to think that the new rules would have prevented us from getting those last attempts in. Note that of those potential 10 player rotations, we only used VTK once and that was to get rid of a perm-disconnected player.
I welcome attempts to fix this problem, but I fear you're still fixing the wrong problem. "Stuck games" are not what people complain about here. At least thats not what I'm reading.
So what happens if our original group gets 2 clerics in it from the start? We'll never be able to replace one with another class? Even if one chooses to leave to get party balance right, you'll continually fill with a Cleric?
And what happens when you get to a boss that needs a tank and you continually get given a replacement DPS class?
You're on the right lines here, but you're still missing the mark. Respecting roles in the queuing system is needed, but you need to put the control of the role selection in the hands of the party. If I'm short a player, let me choose what I want; Heal, Tank, DPS. Don't try to 'guess' what I want and assume that the original role distribution was what we actually wanted in the first place. This is a VERY poor assumption since the current queuing system is awful and doesn't anywhere near guarantee an ideal party composition.
This is a very good point. If a player leaves (without a VTK) the vote system is already in place. Just have a vote window pop up with 3 options.
DC
Tank
DPS
Let the players decide what they want as the replacement.
If a player was VTK'd however it should be auto replace with the exact same class no matter what. Otherwise it'll be abused.
This isn't the first time this has happened either. Actually, only once have I not been attempted to be booted from a group, and that group was impressed enough by my character to invite me from their guild. Every other time, I have either been successfully kicked from a group after the final boss has been defeated, or I have seen in the feed "Vote kick failed" without having received a prompt to boot anyone, meaning that the vote kick was intended for me.
This system is broken and promotes unethical decisions by players, and robs solo players from rewards that they earned just so the people who know each other can make a few Astral Diamonds.
Now, I'm not saying that the boot system should be removed, because it is entirely necessary. However, I think it should be reworked. I also believe that the solution is simple: Do not allow vote kicking during or after the final boss fight in a dungeon. This still allows people to boot during the bulk of the dungeon, and allows for people to boot if the entire group dies at the final boss. What it doesn't allow is people booting simply to eliminate competition for gear.
The reason as to why vote kicking shouldn't be allowed specifically during or after the final boss fight is because of the same reason. If vote kicking isn't allowed after the boss fight, then small groups wouldn't be able to get rid random players simply to eliminate competition for items. For that same reason, vote kicking shouldn't be allowed during the boss fight because players could simply wait until the boss is very close to dead, then vote kick the other players, and finish the boss themselves. I feel like the cut off for vote kicking should be once the "group gathering" timer reaches zero and everyone is transported to the boss's chamber. That way, everyone who contributed to the boss's death has a chance for the boss's rewards.
As a closing statement, I do not believe that this system is ever going to be balanced or perfect. However, the kicking of random players at the end of Epic dungeons to eliminate competition for loot is a quite common practice, and it has a simple fix. I would appreciate as much support on this thread so that the appropriate changes can be implemented. I would like PW support to see this and empathize with my plight.
Thank you to everyone who read this all the way though, and thank you for all those who chose to support this. This change needs to happen, and, with your support, it can.
Xbox GT: BeastNHisHarlot
Main Character: Jimbo Bob Bill