it makes sense for CBS if their intent is to cross pollinate the shows with STO. other threads talk about episodes airing then adapting into the game, but with the lead time necessary to integrate, Game staff would have to be in the know during the show development. I suspect 4-5 people @ Cryptic know about whats going down with each program early into the production process.. of course they all signed NDAs so they really can't even hint they know...
Ok, so we can kinda confirm that at least maybe one STO ship could be in hte background shots or something??, that must be the "biggest thing" that they are announcing..
Congrats Thomas and Hector; you are living your dreams.
That’s actually really smart for Picard too though. CBS was already outsourcing ship design. And Cryptic said the Emerald chain ship model was made using the same standards (file types, textures) as STO uses. You need a bunch of alternate Fed ships for Q timelines, and there are people who have a bunch of compatible models for cheap or free— that is a win, win.
Didn't Thomas comment that he recently got to do something that he never in his life would have imagined he would get to do? I'm thinking they got to design an on screen ship. Probably the Stargazer. The brief glimpse from that teaser that's out shows a section of hull that has an awful lot in common with an STO Odyssey or Yorktown class.
Wow! Congrats to Thomas Marrone and Hector Ortiz from Cryptic Studios! What an honor to represent Star Trek Online in Star Trek: Picard Season 2.
Still yes, that was very nice to see. I found at the end of Season 1, them having a fleet of just one type of ship exclusively behind Riker a bit odd. So yes very great honor indeed, and possibly also expand some STO ships to Canon!
I wonder if the new Stargazer we saw is in fact the namesake for the Stargazer-class we got in game (or at least the version of it from this alt future), could explain why people from Cryptic are in the credits as the Stargazer-class is a Cryptic design and they most certainly would had to redesign it as its one older ships in the game currently and would look like TRIBBLE if put into Picard as is.
Augmented Dictator released a picture of the ISS “Hecate.” Presumably this is Hector’s contribution to Picard Season 2. I don’t know if he has insider knowledge or this is just his educated guess. But the ship is the Cygnus.
rattler2Member, Star Trek Online ModeratorPosts: 58,531Community Moderator
Eh... I honestly wouldn't read too much into it. Hecate was the ancient greek goddess "variously associated with crossroads, entrance-ways, night, light, magic, witchcraft, knowledge of herbs and poisonous plants, ghosts, necromancy, and sorcery."
Also its a pretty cool sounding name, but I'd probably use it more for a science ship than a cruiser.
Perfect name for a Terran ship - especially with the necromancy association...the Terrans strike me as the kind of people who would go all-in on something like that, even moreso than the Kobali or Borg do.
And poisonous plants...anyone remember Archer and Hoshi?
A normie goes "Oh, what's this?"
An otaku goes "UwU, what's this?"
A furry goes "OwO, what's this?"
A werewolf goes "Awoo, what's this?"
"It's nothing personal, I just don't feel like I've gotten to know a person until I've sniffed their crotch." "We said 'no' to Mr. Curiosity. We're not home. Curiosity is not welcome, it is not to be invited in. Curiosity...is bad. It gets you in trouble, it gets you killed, and more importantly...it makes you poor!"
Passion and Serenity are one.
I gain power by understanding both.
In the chaos of their battle, I bring order.
I am a shadow, darkness born from light.
The Force is united within me.
Wow! Congrats to Thomas Marrone and Hector Ortiz from Cryptic Studios! What an honor to represent Star Trek Online in Star Trek: Picard Season 2.
Still yes, that was very nice to see. I found at the end of Season 1, them having a fleet of just one type of ship exclusively behind Riker a bit odd. So yes very great honor indeed, and possibly also expand some STO ships to Canon!
Very nice indeed!
I watched an analysis video on youtube, and the ships with Riker weren't all the same. They were similar in convention to the Odyssey line of ships. Similar build, with minute differences, but in different flavours of specialty.
"You don't want to patrol!? You don't want to escort!? You don't want to defend the Federation's Starbases!? Then why are you flying my Starships!? If you were a Klingon you'd be killed on the spot, but lucky for you.....you WERE in Starfleet. Let's see how New Zealand Penal Colony suits you." Adm A. Necheyev.
Different studios are brought in to help with TV and movie productions, whether it's for VFX, 3D modelling, etc.
The scope of what Thomas Marrone and Hector Ortiz (Thomas Marrone wrote ship specs and discriptions for Eaglemoss ship models, for example) might be doing could be anything from consulting to lending a hand in ship design to working on cross-pollination of assets. After all, STO is very close to the time period to Star Trek: Picard.
I wonder if the U.S.S. Veritas from the Picard countdown comics is going to make an onscreen appearance?
Or they were brought as "consultants", got told "thank you so much for your feedback" and then CBS tossed all this feedback into the bin, since they're listed solely as "Cryptic Studios" and not really a specific position.
*cynical mode off*
But it's still good they were brought in the production in any way and got credited properly.
I watched an analysis video on youtube, and the ships with Riker weren't all the same.
Dude 1: we don't have time to design multiple ships, just copy/paste the same one.
Dude 2: but won't people say we're being lazy?
Dude 1: ok just change some extremely minor thing so there are a few variants.
Dude 2: but they're still so similar they all basically look the same.
Dude 1: yeah, but now some guy on the internet can defend us by pointing out some tiny little difference.
^^^
You do realize it was a result of ALL production being shutdown because of the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, and once they were able to get post production going again (after setting up ways to do SFX production remotely from their homes) - they had a very short time to complete the post production needed, right?
Formerly known as Armsman from June 2008 to June 20, 2012
PWE ARC Drone says: "Your STO forum community as you have known it is ended...Display names are irrelevant...Any further sense of community is irrelevant...Resistance is futile...You will be assimilated..."
It makes sense to have STO Developers involved in the television show. The developers of this game have a lot of general Star Trek knowledge that perhaps the writers of that show don't have.
RIP (2022) : Officer Wilbert Mota, Corporal Charles Galloway, Detective Jason Rivera, Officer Fernando
Arroyos, Officer John Painter, K9 Jedi, K9 Maya, Deputy Constable Neil Adams, Officer Jorge
David Alvarado, Sergeant Joshua Cordell, Trooper Martin Mack, Trooper Branden Sisca,
Lieutenant William Lebo
You do realize it was a result of ALL production being shutdown because of the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, and once they were able to get post production going again (after setting up ways to do SFX production remotely from their homes) - they had a very short time to complete the post production needed, right?
And it just happens that all the rest looks good, EXCEPT this specific armada.
"Guys, we have two choices: make overly-complicated and frankly ridiculous-looking giant flower-ship thingies that have complex animations... or grab ship models we already have in our database, or make two-three static new ship models, heck we could even have some Borg Cube action to show the Borg, even liberated, don't mess around, even against a Romulan armada and it could be some payback for the Romulans exploiting it and its crew before!
... Na, just kidding! Flower power!"
#TASforSTO
0
rattler2Member, Star Trek Online ModeratorPosts: 58,531Community Moderator
You know... I kind of find it funny that the Fed fleet takes so much flak for being copy/paste, and yet other than the lead ship the Romulan fleet is pretty much all one class of ship as well.
I watched an analysis video on youtube, and the ships with Riker weren't all the same. They were similar in convention to the Odyssey line of ships. Similar build, with minute differences, but in different flavours of specialty.
I think there are more or less 3 main variants scattered among the ships. The Zheng He, the Maui and one other. With the biggest difference being the nacelles.
Different studios are brought in to help with TV and movie productions, whether it's for VFX, 3D modelling, etc.
The scope of what Thomas Marrone and Hector Ortiz (Thomas Marrone wrote ship specs and discriptions for Eaglemoss ship models, for example) might be doing could be anything from consulting to lending a hand in ship design to working on cross-pollination of assets. After all, STO is very close to the time period to Star Trek: Picard.
I wonder if the U.S.S. Veritas from the Picard countdown comics is going to make an onscreen appearance?
If you look at the brief teaser we’ve seen of the Stargazer from Picard S2, the main hull looks an awful lot like that of the Legendary Verity. Or some blend of the Verity and Yorktown. I mean there are some very clear and unique STO design cues. Enough to make me suspect Thomas and Hector may have had a hand in some design work. If the external shots of the Stargazer, which only show a bit of the forward saucer from the bridge forward, match up with the interior scenes that we have seen, the LCARS in the background would imply it is a 4 nacelle starship not unlike a newer larger Constellation. The Saucer seems a bit rounder than a Yorktown or Odyssey. More in line with the Verity or Soujorner.
I have a feeling we may be looking at a Legendary Stargazer bundle in the not too distant future.
I watched an analysis video on youtube, and the ships with Riker weren't all the same.
Dude 1: we don't have time to design multiple ships, just copy/paste the same one.
Dude 2: but won't people say we're being lazy?
Dude 1: ok just change some extremely minor thing so there are a few variants.
Dude 2: but they're still so similar they all basically look the same.
Dude 1: yeah, but now some guy on the internet can defend us by pointing out some tiny little difference.
^^^
You do realize it was a result of ALL production being shutdown because of the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, and once they were able to get post production going again (after setting up ways to do SFX production remotely from their homes) - they had a very short time to complete the post production needed, right?
Star Trek Picard came out three months before Covid19 started shutting down Hollywood, the first season was completely finished with production well before Covid had any effect. The rubber-stamp fleet was nothing but corner-cutting that Kurtzman probably did not think the viewers would notice.
I cannot really blame them for trying to cut costs, but they could have avoided the problem in a more traditional Trek way by cutting the number of ships and only showing a small squadron of maybe half a dozen or less (like a flagship and her escorts) on each side rather than going for the "so many they darken the sky" cliche they went with.
I really like the idea of shared a universe between TV and games (like Defiance, though the cooperation was so incredibly bad they might as well not bothered), but the NuTreks are so far off the beam of the traditional ones the game is based on that I have doubts about how well something like that would work here without the show going to the all-encompassing parallel/quantum timelines like the way the game does, (and in the process quit trying to write TOS out of existence the way they seem to want to do).
I watched an analysis video on youtube, and the ships with Riker weren't all the same.
Dude 1: we don't have time to design multiple ships, just copy/paste the same one.
Dude 2: but won't people say we're being lazy?
Dude 1: ok just change some extremely minor thing so there are a few variants.
Dude 2: but they're still so similar they all basically look the same.
Dude 1: yeah, but now some guy on the internet can defend us by pointing out some tiny little difference.
^^^
You do realize it was a result of ALL production being shutdown because of the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, and once they were able to get post production going again (after setting up ways to do SFX production remotely from their homes) - they had a very short time to complete the post production needed, right?
Star Trek Picard came out three months before Covid19 started shutting down Hollywood, the first season was completely finished with production well before Covid had any effect. The rubber-stamp fleet was nothing but corner-cutting that Kurtzman probably did not think the viewers would notice.
I cannot really blame them for trying to cut costs, but they could have avoided the problem in a more traditional Trek way by cutting the number of ships and only showing a small squadron of maybe half a dozen or less (like a flagship and her escorts) on each side rather than going for the "so many they darken the sky" cliche they went with.
I really like the idea of shared a universe between TV and games (like Defiance, though the cooperation was so incredibly bad they might as well not bothered), but the NuTreks are so far off the beam of the traditional ones the game is based on that I have doubts about how well something like that would work here without the show going to the all-encompassing parallel/quantum timelines like the way the game does, (and in the process quit trying to write TOS out of existence the way they seem to want to do).
In looking back, yep - the post production was done before the shutdowns hit. I stand corrected.
Formerly known as Armsman from June 2008 to June 20, 2012
PWE ARC Drone says: "Your STO forum community as you have known it is ended...Display names are irrelevant...Any further sense of community is irrelevant...Resistance is futile...You will be assimilated..."
You know... I kind of find it funny that the Fed fleet takes so much flak for being copy/paste, and yet other than the lead ship the Romulan fleet is pretty much all one class of ship as well.
Maybe I'm just mis-remembering my Trek, but it seems more appropriate for Roms than Feds, IMO. Like, in TNG whenever the Roms showed up it was always Warbirds; no real variety. On the other hand, almost every Fed fleet had a variety of different types of ships in it.
But even setting in-universe explanations aside, the Feds are the heroes in the story and fans are just paying closer attention to their stuff IMO.
If you look at the brief teaser we’ve seen of the Stargazer from Picard S2, the main hull looks an awful lot like that of the Legendary Verity. Or some blend of the Verity and Yorktown. I mean there are some very clear and unique STO design cues. Enough to make me suspect Thomas and Hector may have had a hand in some design work. If the external shots of the Stargazer, which only show a bit of the forward saucer from the bridge forward, match up with the interior scenes that we have seen, the LCARS in the background would imply it is a 4 nacelle starship not unlike a newer larger Constellation. The Saucer seems a bit rounder than a Yorktown or Odyssey. More in line with the Verity or Soujorner.
I have a feeling we may be looking at a Legendary Stargazer bundle in the not too distant future.
I'd be more inclined to think we're just getting a T6 Constellation in the same way we got the T6 Luna after the USS Titan appeared in the s1 finale of Lower Decks. New ship on TV doesn't mean instant Legendary.
If you look at the brief teaser we’ve seen of the Stargazer from Picard S2, the main hull looks an awful lot like that of the Legendary Verity. Or some blend of the Verity and Yorktown. I mean there are some very clear and unique STO design cues. Enough to make me suspect Thomas and Hector may have had a hand in some design work. If the external shots of the Stargazer, which only show a bit of the forward saucer from the bridge forward, match up with the interior scenes that we have seen, the LCARS in the background would imply it is a 4 nacelle starship not unlike a newer larger Constellation. The Saucer seems a bit rounder than a Yorktown or Odyssey. More in line with the Verity or Soujorner.
I have a feeling we may be looking at a Legendary Stargazer bundle in the not too distant future.
I'd be more inclined to think we're just getting a T6 Constellation in the same way we got the T6 Luna after the USS Titan appeared in the s1 finale of Lower Decks. New ship on TV doesn't mean instant Legendary.
Funny thing is, legendary means nothing anymore. See TOS "legendary miranda". Um...what? Yeah, that was never "legendary", they just wanted to sell it for that price.
So if they want to sell a T6 Constellation for a legendary price, they definitely will regardless of it making no sense.
Funny thing is, legendary means nothing anymore. See TOS "legendary miranda". Um...what? Yeah, that was never "legendary"
As an iconic villain ship from TWoK I personally think the Miranda was plenty prominent enough to qualify for a Legendary. The criteria the devs have given are:
1) Hero ship or a ship that "carried" an episode/movie
2) Has at least two existing in-game variants before the Legendary is released so that cosmetics, consoles, and traits can be bundled
Funny thing is, legendary means nothing anymore. See TOS "legendary miranda". Um...what? Yeah, that was never "legendary"
As an iconic villain ship...
The Miranda is not an "iconic villain ship". It was the ship an iconic villain captured. Those are not the same thing. Kind of like how Khan and his crew temporarily captured the Enterprise in TOS, but that did not make the Enterprise a "villain ship". But semantics aside,
The criteria the devs have given are:
1) Hero ship or a ship that "carried" an episode/movie
2) Has at least two existing in-game variants before the Legendary is released so that cosmetics, consoles, and traits can be bundled
In that case the Constellation certainly qualifies. It was the center of an entire episode already(not to mention whatever happens in Picard), and has all the in game variants. So yeah, why is anyone arguing against that again?
1) Hero ship or a ship that "carried" an episode/movie
2) Has at least two existing in-game variants before the Legendary is released so that cosmetics, consoles, and traits can be bundled
In that case the Constellation certainly qualifies. It was the center of an entire episode already(not to mention whatever happens in Picard), and has all the in game variants. So yeah, why is anyone arguing against that again?
I wasn't arguing against the Constellation, I was arguing against your opinion that the Miranda shouldn't qualify The Constellation would need a normal T6 first to meet the second criteria though, imo the list of potential Legendary ships based on the criteria would be something like this (I could be forgetting some ships atm):
Eligible Now
Prometheus
Nova
Negh'Var
Jem'Hadar Attack Ship
Jem'Hadar Dreadnought Carrier
Potentially Eligible if Non-Faction Ships are allowed
Galor
D'Kora
Need More In-game Variants First
Constellation
Olympic (maybe eligible now if Thomas could get the Daedalus and Nautilus parts to work with it)
Luna (maybe eligible now depending on if free and fleet variants count for the "at least 2" rule)
La Sirena
Kwejian Pilot Frigate (Book's ship)
Vengeance
Einstein (USS Kelvin)
Jellyfish
Freedom (USS Franklin)
Disco D7
Jem'Hadar Light Battlecruiser
Debatable
Inquiry (Riker's hero ship in Picard, but only appears in one scene)
Mogai (two helped the Enterprise fight the Scimitar and it's the last canon Romulan design, but it isn't very prominent)
The only way the Miranda-class is iconic is how it's the perfect Red Shirt ship of Star Trek in general.
If you see a Miranda-class in an episode, it's almost guaranteed it's gonna get destroyed or crippled. Not even The Sisko or Khan could save one while being onboard, and in the latter case where it did cripple the Enterprise, it was due to Kirk's stupidity and a surprise attack. And even then, whenever it managed to hit the Connie Queen, it got struck back harder.
Heck, even when it's not technically destroyed, it causes troubles, like in Cause and Effect.
1) Hero ship or a ship that "carried" an episode/movie
2) Has at least two existing in-game variants before the Legendary is released so that cosmetics, consoles, and traits can be bundled
See, no mention of a T6, so that's great.
And I know you are not one of those incredibly lame people that move the goalposts, so your original requirements are met
1) Hero ship or a ship that "carried" an episode/movie
2) Has at least two existing in-game variants before the Legendary is released so that cosmetics, consoles, and traits can be bundled
See, no mention of a T6, so that's great.
And I know you are not one of those incredibly lame people that move the goalposts, so your original requirements are met
They aren't MY requirements, they are the devs. Sure, the Constellation technically has enough variants to meet Bort's "at least two" requirement now with the free version, the low level variant that was moved from the C-Store to the ship vendor, the T5 Mirror version, and the T5 Fleet version, but no ship has received a Legendary without a pre-existing T6 yet so I assume they will wait until after that happens. It could happen, but I doubt it.
Comments
That’s actually really smart for Picard too though. CBS was already outsourcing ship design. And Cryptic said the Emerald chain ship model was made using the same standards (file types, textures) as STO uses. You need a bunch of alternate Fed ships for Q timelines, and there are people who have a bunch of compatible models for cheap or free— that is a win, win.
Still yes, that was very nice to see. I found at the end of Season 1, them having a fleet of just one type of ship exclusively behind Riker a bit odd. So yes very great honor indeed, and possibly also expand some STO ships to Canon!
Very nice indeed!
https://www.reddit.com/r/sto/comments/t39ra4/iss_hecate_terran_cygnus_battlecruiser/
Also its a pretty cool sounding name, but I'd probably use it more for a science ship than a cruiser.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hecate
And poisonous plants...anyone remember Archer and Hoshi?
#LegalizeAwoo
A normie goes "Oh, what's this?"
An otaku goes "UwU, what's this?"
A furry goes "OwO, what's this?"
A werewolf goes "Awoo, what's this?"
"It's nothing personal, I just don't feel like I've gotten to know a person until I've sniffed their crotch."
"We said 'no' to Mr. Curiosity. We're not home. Curiosity is not welcome, it is not to be invited in. Curiosity...is bad. It gets you in trouble, it gets you killed, and more importantly...it makes you poor!"
I watched an analysis video on youtube, and the ships with Riker weren't all the same. They were similar in convention to the Odyssey line of ships. Similar build, with minute differences, but in different flavours of specialty.
The scope of what Thomas Marrone and Hector Ortiz (Thomas Marrone wrote ship specs and discriptions for Eaglemoss ship models, for example) might be doing could be anything from consulting to lending a hand in ship design to working on cross-pollination of assets. After all, STO is very close to the time period to Star Trek: Picard.
I wonder if the U.S.S. Veritas from the Picard countdown comics is going to make an onscreen appearance?
Or they were brought as "consultants", got told "thank you so much for your feedback" and then CBS tossed all this feedback into the bin, since they're listed solely as "Cryptic Studios" and not really a specific position.
*cynical mode off*
But it's still good they were brought in the production in any way and got credited properly.
Dude 1: we don't have time to design multiple ships, just copy/paste the same one.
Dude 2: but won't people say we're being lazy?
Dude 1: ok just change some extremely minor thing so there are a few variants.
Dude 2: but they're still so similar they all basically look the same.
Dude 1: yeah, but now some guy on the internet can defend us by pointing out some tiny little difference.
The-Grand-Nagus
Join Date: Sep 2008
You do realize it was a result of ALL production being shutdown because of the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, and once they were able to get post production going again (after setting up ways to do SFX production remotely from their homes) - they had a very short time to complete the post production needed, right?
PWE ARC Drone says: "Your STO forum community as you have known it is ended...Display names are irrelevant...Any further sense of community is irrelevant...Resistance is futile...You will be assimilated..."
Arroyos, Officer John Painter, K9 Jedi, K9 Maya, Deputy Constable Neil Adams, Officer Jorge
David Alvarado, Sergeant Joshua Cordell, Trooper Martin Mack, Trooper Branden Sisca,
Lieutenant William Lebo
"Guys, we have two choices: make overly-complicated and frankly ridiculous-looking giant flower-ship thingies that have complex animations... or grab ship models we already have in our database, or make two-three static new ship models, heck we could even have some Borg Cube action to show the Borg, even liberated, don't mess around, even against a Romulan armada and it could be some payback for the Romulans exploiting it and its crew before!
... Na, just kidding! Flower power!"
I think there are more or less 3 main variants scattered among the ships. The Zheng He, the Maui and one other. With the biggest difference being the nacelles.
If you look at the brief teaser we’ve seen of the Stargazer from Picard S2, the main hull looks an awful lot like that of the Legendary Verity. Or some blend of the Verity and Yorktown. I mean there are some very clear and unique STO design cues. Enough to make me suspect Thomas and Hector may have had a hand in some design work. If the external shots of the Stargazer, which only show a bit of the forward saucer from the bridge forward, match up with the interior scenes that we have seen, the LCARS in the background would imply it is a 4 nacelle starship not unlike a newer larger Constellation. The Saucer seems a bit rounder than a Yorktown or Odyssey. More in line with the Verity or Soujorner.
I have a feeling we may be looking at a Legendary Stargazer bundle in the not too distant future.
Star Trek Picard came out three months before Covid19 started shutting down Hollywood, the first season was completely finished with production well before Covid had any effect. The rubber-stamp fleet was nothing but corner-cutting that Kurtzman probably did not think the viewers would notice.
I cannot really blame them for trying to cut costs, but they could have avoided the problem in a more traditional Trek way by cutting the number of ships and only showing a small squadron of maybe half a dozen or less (like a flagship and her escorts) on each side rather than going for the "so many they darken the sky" cliche they went with.
I really like the idea of shared a universe between TV and games (like Defiance, though the cooperation was so incredibly bad they might as well not bothered), but the NuTreks are so far off the beam of the traditional ones the game is based on that I have doubts about how well something like that would work here without the show going to the all-encompassing parallel/quantum timelines like the way the game does, (and in the process quit trying to write TOS out of existence the way they seem to want to do).
In looking back, yep - the post production was done before the shutdowns hit. I stand corrected.
PWE ARC Drone says: "Your STO forum community as you have known it is ended...Display names are irrelevant...Any further sense of community is irrelevant...Resistance is futile...You will be assimilated..."
Maybe I'm just mis-remembering my Trek, but it seems more appropriate for Roms than Feds, IMO. Like, in TNG whenever the Roms showed up it was always Warbirds; no real variety. On the other hand, almost every Fed fleet had a variety of different types of ships in it.
But even setting in-universe explanations aside, the Feds are the heroes in the story and fans are just paying closer attention to their stuff IMO.
The-Grand-Nagus
Join Date: Sep 2008
I'd be more inclined to think we're just getting a T6 Constellation in the same way we got the T6 Luna after the USS Titan appeared in the s1 finale of Lower Decks. New ship on TV doesn't mean instant Legendary.
Funny thing is, legendary means nothing anymore. See TOS "legendary miranda". Um...what? Yeah, that was never "legendary", they just wanted to sell it for that price.
So if they want to sell a T6 Constellation for a legendary price, they definitely will regardless of it making no sense.
The-Grand-Nagus
Join Date: Sep 2008
As an iconic villain ship from TWoK I personally think the Miranda was plenty prominent enough to qualify for a Legendary. The criteria the devs have given are:
1) Hero ship or a ship that "carried" an episode/movie
2) Has at least two existing in-game variants before the Legendary is released so that cosmetics, consoles, and traits can be bundled
The Miranda is not an "iconic villain ship". It was the ship an iconic villain captured. Those are not the same thing. Kind of like how Khan and his crew temporarily captured the Enterprise in TOS, but that did not make the Enterprise a "villain ship". But semantics aside,
In that case the Constellation certainly qualifies. It was the center of an entire episode already(not to mention whatever happens in Picard), and has all the in game variants. So yeah, why is anyone arguing against that again?
The-Grand-Nagus
Join Date: Sep 2008
I wasn't arguing against the Constellation, I was arguing against your opinion that the Miranda shouldn't qualify The Constellation would need a normal T6 first to meet the second criteria though, imo the list of potential Legendary ships based on the criteria would be something like this (I could be forgetting some ships atm):
Eligible Now
Prometheus
Nova
Negh'Var
Jem'Hadar Attack Ship
Jem'Hadar Dreadnought Carrier
Potentially Eligible if Non-Faction Ships are allowed
Galor
D'Kora
Need More In-game Variants First
Constellation
Olympic (maybe eligible now if Thomas could get the Daedalus and Nautilus parts to work with it)
Luna (maybe eligible now depending on if free and fleet variants count for the "at least 2" rule)
La Sirena
Kwejian Pilot Frigate (Book's ship)
Vengeance
Einstein (USS Kelvin)
Jellyfish
Freedom (USS Franklin)
Disco D7
Jem'Hadar Light Battlecruiser
Debatable
Inquiry (Riker's hero ship in Picard, but only appears in one scene)
Mogai (two helped the Enterprise fight the Scimitar and it's the last canon Romulan design, but it isn't very prominent)
If you see a Miranda-class in an episode, it's almost guaranteed it's gonna get destroyed or crippled. Not even The Sisko or Khan could save one while being onboard, and in the latter case where it did cripple the Enterprise, it was due to Kirk's stupidity and a surprise attack. And even then, whenever it managed to hit the Connie Queen, it got struck back harder.
Heck, even when it's not technically destroyed, it causes troubles, like in Cause and Effect.
Good news! A T6 is not part of the requirements per your earlier post:
See, no mention of a T6, so that's great.
And I know you are not one of those incredibly lame people that move the goalposts, so your original requirements are met
The-Grand-Nagus
Join Date: Sep 2008
They aren't MY requirements, they are the devs. Sure, the Constellation technically has enough variants to meet Bort's "at least two" requirement now with the free version, the low level variant that was moved from the C-Store to the ship vendor, the T5 Mirror version, and the T5 Fleet version, but no ship has received a Legendary without a pre-existing T6 yet so I assume they will wait until after that happens. It could happen, but I doubt it.