Rate a Character thread. Hot or Not.

Xainou - Sanctuary

Brillance - Raging Tide wrote: »

Yeah - get to work on that siggy if you dislike EG's so much (I know - its a Veno).

No clue what you're talking about but most people nowadays edit their eye texture or hair to an earthguard/tideborn style. Simply because it does look more with the times and prettier. All I stated is that although I'm quite in favor of this, I didn't do it to my veno. I like her with the original textures.

As for your comment about proportions: I wasn't aware you saw much of those in my cropped screenshot. But if that's you opinion, ah well. Just save me the sarcastic side remarks, thanks.

Hazumi_chan - Sanctuary

@Brillance: I fail to see where Xai's proportions aren't right... o.o

@Xai: I like the fact that your character looks so mature, and that she isn't as skinny as most characters you see ^.~

Ziraia - Raging Tide

*random rate*

Brillance

I likey her new look, and i love her waist/torso/chest shape and small shoulders. That Thunder Pants (or what it's called..) looks good on her. I have a black one myself, and i loves eeet b:chuckle And about the hair.. Alot of people like giving their chars white hair, it doesn't mean they're like presets, and i like the Thunder Ponytail, it looks good on most mystics imo xD Her eyes are a bit too big (looks like she stares at something), and her mouth/lips looks a little big too maybe, but that's nothing.

If i had to pick something i would change about her, it might be the hair color. Cause im personally not a fan of pure white hair, unless your char got gray skin color or something

Brillance - Raging Tide

I see your getting mad Xainou. Sorry to upset you.

All venos have this long lanky appearance to me - as if they dont get enough to eat or something. It looks like her hips spead out from the long straight torso though. Your shoulders still look small in both shots.

The side ponytail is very mainstream right now, so if you are looking to avoid that...oh well. I see people spamming chat all the time for them. I do think the Road Warrior top (?) is an improvement over the Thundercoat.

Her face is pleasant, but the bridge of the nose appears larger than the nostrils, or maybe in making the eyes bigger you spread them a bit to far apart.

I will be more generous than you, and give her a 3.5/5.

Brillance - Raging Tide

Ziraia - Raging Tide wrote: »

*random rate*

Brillance

I likey her new look, and i love her waist/torso/chest shape and small shoulders. That Thunder Pants (or what it's called..) looks good on her. I have a black one myself, and i loves eeet b:chuckle And about the hair.. Alot of people like giving their chars white hair, it doesn't mean they're like presets, and i like the Thunder Ponytail, it looks good on most mystics imo xD Her eyes are a bit too big (looks like she stares at something), and her mouth/lips looks a little big too maybe, but that's nothing.

If i had to pick something i would change about her, it might be the hair color. Cause im personally not a fan of pure white hair, unless your char got gray skin color or something

Thanks Ziraia. I was either going with white or black for the color. Black is the absence of light. White is the combination of all colors - so I went with the white. Pink only seems to go with pink. xD

Idk what ur screenie looks like - but I give your siggy a 5 of 5. I love the cat ears & wiskers.

Xainou - Sanctuary

Brillance. I appreciate your rating. If you could do it without provoking me and dropping snippy, butthurt sidelines that would be perfect.
But it seems you cannot do that even after I responded without any insults or snide remarks to you, it's enough.

Sorry if you can't take critique. I just know I'm sick of those remarks. I guess that's what the blacklist is for. b:bye

Ziraia - Raging Tide

Brillance - Raging Tide wrote: »

Thanks Ziraia. I was either going with white or black for the color. Black is the absence of light. White is the combination of all colors - so I went with the white. Pink only seems to go with pink. xD

Yeah, pink is not easy to use, unless you know you will wear pink or something that will go with it. I love colors that goes with everything

Brillance - Raging Tide

Ziraia - Raging Tide wrote: »

Yeah, pink is not easy to use, unless you know you will wear pink or something that will go with it. I love colors that goes with everything

That was the problem. I found all my fashion was either purple/hot violet or pink. I wanted some variety. b:chuckle

Oh, and I agree I have a 'far away' look on face. Not happy & not sad.

onlydolly

Hahaha I love this pics I don't remember when I did them xD

Haha You're too short.



Are You listening to me? STOP IT!



Oh... F*ck Off... -.-

Ziraia - Raging Tide

onlydolly
Im sorry, but i can only see the top part of your pics, seems like the site wont load them atm b:surrender I'll get back to it later if i remember.


Ok, so here's my new-ish seeker, that i decided to lvl. And yes, she have Ziraia's Thunder Ponytail, and yes, he might look kinda common to you.. o.o You cant see much of her body, but it's ok, cause im happy with how it looks, and i only want your opinions on her face Oh, and i like her big black eyes, she can look under water b:quiet



Tyvm.

onlydolly

Ziraia - Raging Tide wrote: »

OMG. I love her b:dirty I want Mystic looking like Your Seeker b:cry

Ziraia - Raging Tide

VenusArmani - Dreamweaver wrote: »

Shes okay, I think that hairstyle works well for her. 3/5

Since no one else replied...

The reason is this: same eyebrow shape, same hairstyle, same eyeshape, same nose shape, same mouth shape, same cheeks even if they are now smaller. I can tell because there is no variation to that giant tat on her cheek. If you tweak more things on the cheeks you can change that just a tiny bit. You've made the features more cute by making them all more smaller, to give her a more roundish look but the major features of a face (eyes, eyebrows, lips) are all the same so it still looks like a preset. Feel free to hate me now.b:surrenderb:avoid

^ I missed this when you wrote it, so here's my answer thingy. ^^

I made the hairstyle look the same in the screenie for you guys, so it would be easier to see the difference, but it's not really the same in-game, and i have changed alot on that umm.. idk what it's called.. the cheek bone-editor thingy, to make her look more "normal" and not like something heavy just crashed into her face (you know, where you can lift the cheeks, and almost cover the eyes with it). Also, the chin is shorter and more narrow, mouth is smaller, same with the nose. About the eyes and the eyebrows, i've been going back and forth from editing my char and into game to see what looked best on her. Had to make an alt for it, so now she have a lil twin b:chuckle

Blah blah blah
Just wanted you to know, no reply needed, cause im not good at discussing things in english.. it takes forever b:quiet

Ziraia - Raging Tide

onlydolly wrote: »

OMG. I love her b:dirty I want Mystic looking like Your Seeker b:cry

wow, thank you b:chuckle

I've been talking too much now, i'll try to stay quiet for a few pages, lol

Brillance - Raging Tide

Ziraia - Raging Tide wrote: »

Ok, so here's my new-ish seeker, that i decided to lvl. And yes, she have Ziraia's Thunder Ponytail, and yes, he might look kinda common to you.. o.o You cant see much of her body, but it's ok, cause im happy with how it looks, and i only want your opinions on her face Oh, and i like her big black eyes, she can look under water b:quiet



Tyvm.

I have a few friends with what look like black eyes in real life, and I have always thought they were beautiful. +1 for originality there. You dont see that much ingame.

I also like what you did to the face shape, reducing the nose, mouth and chin while bringing up the cheeks gives her a heart shaped face and seems to reduce the bigheaded effect created by the Thunder Ponytail hair-style. It also gives her a youthful quality wthout making her look like a child.

If I were to change anything for myself personally, I would make the eyes a tiny bit larger overall and try to straighten out the tilt a bit - but again, that would be just my personal preference, and I am not saying you should do so.

Good work, and if I ever find the time to want to work on my own chars face again, you have certainly provided me with the inspiration to do so, lol.

Taking that screenie from under water (at least thats how it looks) is also a novel approach. I would easily give the screenie & your chars face a rating of 5/5 - you have pretty much done all you can to her face with the EGs limited options. If you love it, dont change a thing! She is definately unique.

Exiirah - Lost City

Ziraia - Raging Tide wrote: »

onlydolly
Im sorry, but i can only see the top part of your pics, seems like the site wont load them atm b:surrender I'll get back to it later if i remember.


Ok, so here's my new-ish seeker, that i decided to lvl. And yes, she have Ziraia's Thunder Ponytail, and yes, he might look kinda common to you.. o.o You cant see much of her body, but it's ok, cause im happy with how it looks, and i only want your opinions on her face Oh, and i like her big black eyes, she can look under water b:quiet



Tyvm.

She reminds me of rikku from final fantasy X <3b:dirty

Ziraia - Raging Tide

Brillance - Raging Tide wrote: »

I have a few friends with what look like black eyes in real life, and I have always thought they were beautiful. +1 for originality there. You dont see that much ingame.

I also like what you did to the face shape, reducing the nose, mouth and chin while bringing up the cheeks gives her a heart shaped face and seems to reduce the bigheaded effect created by the Thunder Ponytail hair-style. It also gives her a youthful quality wthout making her look like a child.

If I were to change anything for myself personally, I would make the eyes a tiny bit larger overall and try to straighten out the tilt a bit - but again, that would be just my personal preference, and I am not saying you should do so.

Good work, and if I ever find the time to want to work on my own chars face again, you have certainly provided me with the inspiration to do so, lol.

Taking that screenie from under water (at least thats how it looks) is also a novel approach. I would easily give the screenie & your chars face a rating of 5/5 - you have pretty much done all you can to her face with the EGs limited options. If you love it, dont change a thing! She is definately unique.

Wow, I dont know what to say.. Thanks alot! Oh, and I see that too now, that her eyes could've been a lil bigger maybe. ^^

Xainou - Sanctuary

Xainou - Sanctuary wrote: »

Yea, that fashion is part of my rather *cough* big wardrobe. However, I barely wear it anymore, it's kind of too mainstream. lol My siggie needs an update too. ~_~

Hm I don't think I actually posted my veno since PWINTM o_o
Xain has come a loong way. Started from a preset cutie veno over various makeovers gone to an adult woman.
I had that look for the longest time but it started to bug me. Something was off there. So makeover time:



That's what she looks like now and I'm fully happy with it. No earthguard eyes or hair. I just don't think it fits her. I like my kitty the way she is

*shameless bump cause too much talk drowned my post*

Azephiel - Raging Tide

Hya ! Love most of the cute chars i've seen so far !

Since this is a esthetic comment post . I'd like you pple to Review these 2 "temporary " looks .
You see i have both a mystic and a seeker, and been working on new faces for them , the thing is i can only Makeover one (gold sale left me poor ), plss review and tell me wich class should i revamp into one of these b:sad

For the Seeker





For the mystic

Xinaeco - Harshlands

Azephiel, I'd love to rate you but you failed to rate anyone else, don't expect to get many reviews on your character unless you rate atleast 1 other person.

Ziraia, I love your seeker. There's something so cute about her. She looks very innocent for a melee class. I like her eyes the most, very simple but very unique looking. 5/5

Xainou, she's a breath of fresh air imo. I like her lip colour. Only thing I can say is I think her lips could be smaller (not like in width i mean in length). 4/5

So I don't know if I showed a close up to my clerics face after I changed her. I tried to model her face shape after Susy but I obviously didn't wanna fully copy her.


From the side, her face looks like it got hit by a truck. >_>

Kerona - Sanctuary

@ Xainou - I don't really like the nose or how far apart the eyes are. Combined with the very low mouth it looks kinda like a flattened face more than a real one. 6/10

@ Azphiel - I can't even see the faces so can't really rate. From afar the seeker looks pretty nice, though.

@ Xinaeco - The ears are a bit low making the face seem low. Otherwise cute. 8/10

@ Ziraia - She somehow looks like a tideborn Pretty cute. 8.5/10 Eyebrows could be moved a bit over so:


@ Zanryu - I'd hit that.

@ TiikeriLilja - Pretty normal look for a Psyfish. 6/10

@ Brillance - The Eyes are big and the pupils are small so she looks shocked all the time. Mouth a bit fish like for my taste. 7/10

Xainou - Sanctuary

Thanks for the rating Xinaeco
I like your clerics face. She does look pretty adult in a way, although I can't point my paw on why o_o Brown hair and green eyes
Only thing that bugs me is that her bottom lip is a little thick. But yea, you saw on my char, I prefer somewhat wider mouths and less thick lips. lol
And her head might be a little big for her body o_o Unless you were going for that look.
4/5


Ziraia...
I absolutely love the shade of blonde her hair has. Together with that skin colour it makes her look so perfect. Not really a fan of black eyes though, I prefer colours b:surrender
And the thunderpony bugs me. lol So many people post with it but you can't even see the second half of face or judge all face
And I agree with Xinaeco: She does look very very nice. If you didn't say she's a seeker, I'd have thought mystic 100% b:chuckle
4/5

SerenityMare - Dreamweaver

@Xinaeco Your cleric looks cute and puffy. b:chuckle I actually like the style xD 4/5


I recently got this hat (Forgot the actual name and I'm in school so can't get it xD) which I've been dying to get since I came back to game. o: I really like long hair on my veno. b:cute So this is how she looks like with it~

Brillance - Raging Tide

@ Brillance - The Eyes are big and the pupils are small so she looks shocked all the time. Mouth a bit fish like for my taste. 7/10


Thanks for the rating, Kerona. And, I agree about the mouth & eyes. Just started a Tideborn (bored of FC already) and its the same thing (looks like the same presets), but at least this one is a fish so a fishy mouth will work. b:chuckle

I played with the Psys mouth and face for hours, especially the mouth, and I have concluded that something goes slightly askew when you try to change it. She takes on a 'suckerfish' quality when she smiles as the lower lip begins an odd curl. xD

I did pretty much the same with the Psys eyes, and she has that wide awake look I like, but doesnt have the 'far away' look of my Mystic. I just think of the song by the Rolling Stones - "If your down right disgusted, and life aint worth a dayum, get a girl with far away eyes." ^^

Azephiel - Raging Tide

oh thx for the info xP sry i forgot to, Okkies ^^ , so then let the rating START ~

@Xinaeco , Kerona is right , the ears are a bit low, making her face look a bit flat, The best thing to do is to Touch your own face , or see yourself in a mirror, not for the details / colours , but for the general display : you'll see ears are beteen eye level and cheeckbone level , Like the overall a lot. LOVE the lip colour and the light v shape the chin has ~

@Ziraia : Love the cute face, my only widdle problem would be at the eye/nose relation , the eye level is low, making the eyes pop halfway the nose bridge , my suggestions would be either raise eye level a bit (along with brows so they look same high from eye as before ) Or lower the nose so it's tip reaches a bit lower .

@onlydolly : Adorable face ! just give her face a lil more vertical proportions and it'd be perfect, the face looks too roundish making it a bit too small for the body, nice doll work !

@yuima : The face depth proportions are too low, I'd suggest giving it more caracteristics : the ear is a bit too low, raise em ans see how it affects the hfacial side , the cheeckbone / cheeck levels are too similar, raising cheeckbone depth a little and lowering cheeck depth makes more shadows on the face . Last lil thing bothering me, look at your face in the mirror, you'll notice your eyebrows aren't that separated ;P , make the horizontal length a bit bigger and make em close to each other, like the little eyes


I'll keep rating pple that post after this too ~, and will really apreciate crittics , and for the close ups here,

Mystic



Seeker :

Ayasu - Sanctuary

The seeker looks beautiful :]

Brillance - Raging Tide

Azephiel, the top shot of the Mystic that you posted before your last post is awesome. She is quite lovely, and nicely centered. The location and her clothing all compliment each other well. I'm not even getting into knitpicking little details, her face slightly shadowed while catching the light on her shoulders - its great. 10/10.

The composition in its entirety pretty much meets all the basic requirements of a work of art. (Balance, unity, focal point, & junk like that.) b:victory

onlydolly

Well...Reanbell is not perfect but I still love her b:laugh







Rate if You want
b:cute

Ziraia - Raging Tide

Xinaeco - Harshlands wrote: »

Ziraia, I love your seeker. There's something so cute about her. She looks very innocent for a melee class. I like her eyes the most, very simple but very unique looking. 5/5

Thanks

Kerona - Sanctuary wrote: »

@ Ziraia - She somehow looks like a tideborn Pretty cute. 8.5/10 Eyebrows could be moved a bit over so:

Tyvm, i'll see what i can do. ^^

Xainou - Sanctuary wrote: »

Ziraia...
I absolutely love the shade of blonde her hair has. Together with that skin colour it makes her look so perfect. Not really a fan of black eyes though, I prefer colours b:surrender
And the thunderpony bugs me. lol So many people post with it but you can't even see the second half of face or judge all face
And I agree with Xinaeco: She does look very very nice. If you didn't say she's a seeker, I'd have thought mystic 100% b:chuckle
4/5

Yeah, thunder ponytail kinda covers most of the face xD maybe i'll post a screenie of her with her normal hair later ^^ and thanks.

Azephiel - Raging Tide wrote: »

@Ziraia : Love the cute face, my only widdle problem would be at the eye/nose relation , the eye level is low, making the eyes pop halfway the nose bridge , my suggestions would be either raise eye level a bit (along with brows so they look same high from eye as before ) Or lower the nose so it's tip reaches a bit lower .

Hmm, i see that too now xD thanks, i'll deff change it next makeover

DarkMystica - Sanctuary

Here my Cleric in her Nurse fash ^-^
My super cute main Mystic was so lovely, but I didnt save it + changed.. So ugly nowb:cry
Need to start over ig ..

Xinaeco - Harshlands

Azephiel, your mystic... I'd give her a 3/5 o.o I LOVE her lips, they are really beautiful. The only thing is... that hairstyle. b:spit I wish we could erase it from the database ;_; It's just... so nappy looking. Dx I like the colours tho x
Your seeker, she's really pretty. I would give her a 4/5. Once again she's got really nice lips and colours but there's really nothing about her that makes me wanna say "WOW!" She just looks kinda common. ;_; Sowwy