Rate a Character thread. Hot or Not.

Jellytoast - Sanctuary

Narevi - Raging Tide

Aww, thanks to Sneakret, Alphae and Dorset for very nice feedback

@ Alphae - There is something strange with her eyes. The rest is really pretty. 7.5/10
@ Jellytoast - I would turn her eyes more horizontal, make her ears less protruding, and change her eye- or haircolor. I like her mouth, nose and face shape tho. 7/10

Nymella - Archosaur

So guess who's back! After some serious fashion hunting and buying a makeover scroll I made my character into this, I'm putting up 2 pics bc I'm a night owl and its hard to see all her features.

Ziraia~ 9/10 for the sin, I only knocked off 1 point for the unknown bc you can't see her very well with the far shot. 6/10 for the Veno, I knocked off points bc sure her hair and dress are pretty but her face looks way to dull. She has nice features, but she needs a tad of color on her lips, and possibly her nose to be smaller.

Alphae~ 8/10 she is adorable, but her eyes might be a bit too big, and a bit too far apart.

Jelly~ 10/10 I love her makeup and everything very pretty ^.^ Great job! The shape of her face is great, and thats hard to get with elves, and I like the colors on her.

Susylu - Heavens Tear

Cocobelle - Sanctuary

Susy - Your Tideborn's eyebrows bother me a lot. b:surrender They create this edge on its face which is kind of distracting. I do like its shape though. Her lips are also a bit large for her small face. I do like its haircolor though. 2.5/5

Kahurangi - Sanctuary

Susylu, very cute, and love the hair colour. I'd give her 4/5, 1 point detraction because I personally find the eyes too large, and it's not the brows but the ridge between them that is noticable, I had a similar problem when creating a tideborn with a very similar face shape. Couldn't find a way to correct it and keep the shape I wanted

Here's my latest makeover on my veno

Graviora - Dreamweaver

Wow Kahurangi... Your veno is so pretty. I rarely find venos I think are pretty, but yours is up there. I like how mature she looks, and I'm a fan of wide eyes instead of doll eyes. 5/5


Figured I'd post my Gravi here

Q____Q - Dreamweaver

Graviora - Dreamweaver wrote: »

b:dirty Grav

Susylu - Heavens Tear

Cocobelle - Sanctuary wrote: »

Susy - Your Tideborn's eyebrows bother me a lot. b:surrender They create this edge on its face which is kind of distracting. I do like its shape though. Her lips are also a bit large for her small face. I do like its haircolor though. 2.5/5

Kahurangi - Sanctuary wrote: »

Susylu, very cute, and love the hair colour. I'd give her 4/5, 1 point detraction because I personally find the eyes too large, and it's not the brows but the ridge between them that is noticable, I had a similar problem when creating a tideborn with a very similar face shape. Couldn't find a way to correct it and keep the shape I wanted

Here's my latest makeover on my veno

Thank you for your opinions Yeah I was bored and had half an hour and that's what I got.. Deleted her already, but like you both said I really liked the hair color b:laugh I think Kahurangi was being too nice with her rating, I woulda given her like a 3/5 similar to Coco. And I really couldn't figure out the ridge either - messed with it a bit but I've had trouble creating a smooth profile for TBs unless I made their faces large.



Also, very pretty veno! I don't find many wearing that hair (and if they do it rarely looks good) but I like it on her. The orange eyeliner I'm not sure about but 9/10 b:victory

Kahurangi - Sanctuary

Thanks Gravoria and Susylu for the feedback and the nice comments Grav, 5/5, you're character always looks good

To be honest, I'm not good at rating, only cos I'd give everyone 5/5, even with what I might consider to be not to my taste, I love uniqueness and individuality of peoples characters, beauty's in the eye of the beholder and all that b:chuckle

Alphae, sorry I didn't reply to your post earlier, as to which hair, I really love the Pearl Blossom on her, hard to decide though cos they all look good!

Nymella - Archosaur

ummm did I get skipped?

Linval - Harshlands

Nymella - Archosaur wrote: »

ummm did I get skipped?

I'll look back at that then, quickly, I guess. Not that I'm really any sort of expert in general taste, or even what I like. Expect a lot of gut instinct.

Personally, I like the outfit and the hair, but there's not a lot of definition in the face, so it looks a bit plain to me? I don't see anything particularly distinctive in the cheekbones or jaw in particular. However, you've avoided almost anything that would be off-putting either. No gigantic eyes or anything of the sort. 3.5/5, perhaps?

Graviora - Dreamweaver

Q____Q - Dreamweaver wrote: »

b:dirty Grav

b:dirty Thriv.

XXMid_niteXx - Heavens Tear

XXMid_niteXx - Heavens Tear

Susylu - Heavens Tear

Mid_Nite, I'm not sure I can rate your character until I see her up closer. She looks a tad scary from that screenshot tho...

I was bored and did a more conventional makeover b:surrender Think I've seen a couple venos with similar, almost same look.

Kahurangi - Sanctuary

Nymella - Archosaur wrote: »

ummm did I get skipped?

Nymella, do apologise, I would give her 4/5. I love the lips and the nose, I'd have to disagree with Linval about your face not having much distinction The lips and nose do to me. The one point detraction was for the shape of the eyes, I would make them a little less slanted, or maybe narrow them a bit?

Mid_nite, would love to see a closer shot of her face Feel I can't really rate because the screenshot is too indistinct.

Susylu, give it 4/5, but the 1 point less is for the very reason you stated, she needs more of your personal style so she looks more unique. If I find my characters are too similar to others, I play around with the bone structure and the lips

XXMid_niteXx - Heavens Tear

lol srry >.< here's a bit better pic, i suck at screenshoting

Cocobelle - Sanctuary

XXMid_niteXx - 2/5 Your cleric's lips looks really squished and the skin tone and the hair color makes her look too orange imo. I do like how the blue eyeshadow compliments her skin tone but a different hair colour would be nice.

Susylu - 3/5 The eyebrow colour compared to her hair colour is too different and it's distracting since I really like the eyebrow shape. The lips are fine but I suggest you make them a bit thicker? It looks a bit thin in the first two screenshots. But nonetheless, I think you design your characters cutely, Susy.

Anyways, since I am on hiatus from the game, here are some screenshots of Skybelle. I'm too lazy to switch profiles. >.>;

Susylu - Heavens Tear

Kahurangi - Sanctuary wrote: »

Susylu, give it 4/5, but the 1 point less is for the very reason you stated, she needs more of your personal style so she looks more unique. If I find my characters are too similar to others, I play around with the bone structure and the lips

Cocobelle - Sanctuary wrote: »

Susylu - 3/5 The eyebrow colour compared to her hair colour is too different and it's distracting since I really like the eyebrow shape. The lips are fine but I suggest you make them a bit thicker? It looks a bit thin in the first two screenshots. But nonetheless, I think you design your characters cutely, Susy.

Thanks~ Maybe I'll try changing the eyebrow color to a lighter shade! I like thin lips so I won't be changing that tho b:laugh

MidNite... I'm not found of the colors you used. I like the top half of her head, but I think she starts to lose it on the bottom half... meaning I think her lips are a little too far down on her face and the random purple shade is making me want something else purple on her. I like the hairstyle! 2.5/5

Skybelle... I still like Coco better. They have a similar design but for some reason the cleric looks off... I think it might be her lips being too thick idk b:shocked I like her eyes, they are simply beautiful 3/5

Also why hiatus? This section of forums is almost dead enough already You must post more!!

Cocobelle - Sanctuary

Susylu - Heavens Tear wrote: »

Thanks~ Maybe I'll try changing the eyebrow color to a lighter shade! I like thin lips so I won't be changing that tho b:laugh

MidNite... I'm not found of the colors you used. I like the top half of her head, but I think she starts to lose it on the bottom half... meaning I think her lips are a little too far down on her face and the random purple shade is making me want something else purple on her. I like the hairstyle! 2.5/5

Skybelle... I still like Coco better. They have a similar design but for some reason the cleric looks off... I think it might be her lips being too thick idk b:shocked I like her eyes, they are simply beautiful 3/5

Also why hiatus? This section of forums is almost dead enough already You must post more!!

I think the only reason why they look similar is because they're both blonde with the Aegean hair. b:chuckle

Graviora - Dreamweaver

Cocobelle - Sanctuary wrote: »

I think the only reason why they look similar is because they're both blonde with the Aegean hair. b:chuckle

No, thats not it. They look really similar and its not just the hair. They have a similar face shape, mouth shape (although Skybelle's is a lot thicker), eye shape, and similar colors.

Cocobelle - Sanctuary

I still don't think they have the exact same features but oh well. Anyways, I got bored and did a makeover anyways. I aimed for the cute look.

Susylu - Heavens Tear

She looks a lot better, just that she lost a little color b:chuckle Her eyes need to be a little closer but I like her a lot more than the original! 4/5

And I also think she looked very much like your veno before you changed her, but perhaps that's just the way it was portrayed in the screenshots. Tbh, I've always thought your characters looked similar to my bm, just with bigger lips, a little more slanted eyes and squarer face b:laugh

Maybe I'm just hallucinating tho b:surrender

LifeHunting - Lost City

Coco: I don't know what you do to make your characters look like that but it's another 5/5 from me. b:chuckle

And ah **** my classic music station is playing rock version of christmas carols T_T......I hate my life right now.

Cocobelle - Sanctuary

Susylu - Heavens Tear wrote: »

She looks a lot better, just that she lost a little color b:chuckle Her eyes need to be a little closer but I like her a lot more than the original! 4/5

And I also think she looked very much like your veno before you changed her, but perhaps that's just the way it was portrayed in the screenshots. Tbh, I've always thought your characters looked similar to my bm, just with bigger lips, a little more slanted eyes and squarer face

Maybe I'm just hallucinating tho b:surrender

I tried moving the eyes closer but it looks really weird imo so I think it looks good that way. My veno looked a lot different compared to what she is now. Nothing close to Skybelle's new look. b:laugh The loss of colour is with the screenshots. I wanted a baby doll look so I went with a lighter lip shade.

I don't really see how my characters resemble your BM. Maybe in certain angles/screenshots. Since I only post my veno, cleric and rarely my psychic. b:surrender

LifeHunting - Thank you. I appreciate it. Didn't see your post when I was posting. x3 Christmas Carols are addicting and they get stuck in your head so easily.

Susylu - Heavens Tear

Cocobelle - Sanctuary wrote: »

I don't really see how my characters resemble your BM. Maybe in certain angles/screenshots. Since I only post my veno, cleric and rarely my psychic.

No, I meant loss in color as in like you said, her overall look is lighter. But that is what you wanted, just not what I prefer.

Hmm... I was mainly thinking like your veno (and since to me skybelle originally looked like coco I just generalized, forgot about your psy x-x). Here's a comparison... but maybe it is just the angles?



I don't know... I still think they're pretty close :P Similar eye shape, same eyeliner, almost same mouth... Been thinking that since the first time I saw Cocobelle b:laugh

Which makes me realize I post more pictures of me and hubby's alts more than bm xD Here's a couple





Your cleric's new look is similar to my catshop's xD (then again I guess if you don't see the similarity it's probably just me again)

EDIT: I'm looking through some of the older posts... there were so many pretty character designs!! I wish they all still were active so i can see em =/ I still love Casey's characters the best though they're so pretty xD You better read this and post some more Casey...

Cocobelle - Sanctuary

Susylu - Heavens Tear wrote: »

Now you pointed it out, I do see some similarities. That's quite funny. Nonetheless I love how our characters turn out. I just like that eyeliner because it extends the eyes more. Plus light makeup looks good with cherry red lips. Your BM's eyes are a bit more opened and my veno's lips are a bit thicker, though. Your character looks like the younger, cuter version of Coco and my character is the mature version of Susy. b:laugh




You need to show me your catshop character still! xD

Edit: I fell in love with the Celestial Bard hair like you but the Aegean Hair has a special place for Coco. Just wait until the new Christmas sets. Heehee.

Susylu - Heavens Tear

Cocobelle - Sanctuary wrote: »

Now you pointed it out, I do see some similarities. That's quite funny. Nonetheless I love how our characters turn out. I just like that eyeliner because it extends the eyes more. Plus light makeup looks good with cherry red lips. Your BM's eyes are a bit more opened and my veno's lips are a bit thicker, though. Your character looks like the younger, cuter version of Coco and my character is the mature version of Susy. b:laugh

Edit: I fell in love with the Celestial Bard hair like you but the Aegean Hair has a special place for Coco. Just wait until the new Christmas sets. Heehee.

b:laugh I agree agree!

And yeah don't you just really love that hair b:dirty It looks really cute And yea, if they release both the christmas sets... omg getting both xD

I don't wear the Aegean much ever since I got the bard hair, but this is how it looks on Susylu xP Love it lots more on Coco

Cocobelle - Sanctuary

I really like the celestial bard hair. I just prefer the Aegean still because it shows Coco's eyes more. But I really can't decide which hair to choose for the ballet set.

I think celestial bard hair suits Susy a lot compared to any other character I've seen with it so far.

Susy and Coco looks fairly similar with the celestial bard hair but looks totally different with the aegean hair. It's interesting imo. b:chuckle

Still can't decide which one's for the ballet set. I think I need to get a different one for the Aegean/bard.