test content
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc

Zen only respec makes this game pay-to-win

135

Comments

  • drenchkatdrenchkat Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users Posts: 40 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    shahualing wrote: »
    You can probably make the 200k or so AD by the time you are 45...BUUUT the problem with that is you need AD for other things in the game. If you spend all your AD on a respec, you start from 0 for all the other things you need.

    You can EASILY make over 100k AD a day selling items and watching the Auction House. If you want extra stuff in the game then you have to work for it.

    The game is 100% FREE. Lets keep in mind on how much content is given to players for literally NOTHING. You want a little extra and dont feel like working for it, then spend $6, $10, OR $60. The game is well worth the typical $60 pricetag that is on almost everygame that is released that has about a 10hr lifespan.
  • jorealjoreal Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Hero Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    thehadriel wrote: »
    To begin, let me say that I thought I needed 20 points to unlock the third rank of a power. Apparently this is not true. I am now level 45 with rank 2 in every power. This is not good. I will now be inferior to every single wizard in the game. How do I fix this? Spend $6. Spend $6 and be up to par with the other wizards. Even if I didn't make the mistake of unlocking rank 2 of every power, I still would have made some mistakes in powers I didn't want.

    The cash shop as it is currently is ridiculous. It is pay-to-win. Cosmetic stuff? Dyes? Outfits? Mounts? Astral Diamonds? Companions? Fine. But the ability to respec? That's just way over the line. Cryptic, you're restricting us from choosing our skills. Please change this.

    Just because you CAN buy a cash shop items for $10 doesn't mean you HAVE too. You can grind up the AD and get the respec as well.

    Just because you CAN get ZEN with cash and AD with ZEN does NOT mean that AD = Cash. You need to stop thinking that they are taking your cash out of your wallet because they are letting you buy things with AD.

    You can EITHER buy cash shop items with the zen you get from cash OR you can buy it with the ZEN you get from exchanging AD.

    AD!=Cash so stop pretending that the AD you earn in game is irrelevant or automatically treated as cash. NO ONE can pull money from your wallet unless YOU want to spend it.

    If you don't like the prices in the shop then don't pay cash for them. If you think the AD cost of zen is too high then complain that people are asking too much for ZEN on the AD/Zen exchange. The price of AD/Zen has already come down to 380:1 from 500:1. It will likely continue to fall until it reaches a comfortable balance. That DOESN'T mean that you have to buy things with Cash.
  • chai23chai23 Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    Charging to redo every little thing on a character is plain wrong. To me its not about how much it is, its about charging people to figure out what the best combination of abilities for their playstyle is. And for the inevitable folks who will talk about how you can grind for it in game which seems to be the main justification for p2w, having to grind for weeks to figure out what your character abilities do is unreasonable.
  • spyke2009spyke2009 Member Posts: 674 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    drenchkat wrote: »
    You can EASILY make over 100k AD a day selling items and watching the Auction House. If you want extra stuff in the game then you have to work for it.

    The game is 100% FREE. Lets keep in mind on how much content is given to players for literally NOTHING. You want a little extra and dont feel like working for it, then spend $6, $10, OR $60. The game is well worth the typical $60 pricetag that is on almost everygame that is released that has about a 10hr lifespan.

    The quality of a game is a subjective matter really. Can't just throw that out as fact, when it's really just an opinion, same as the opinion that respecs costing zen fell too restrictive and diminish the quality of the game.

    The "easily" part is not a guaranteed, and the economy being designed the way it is will eventually mean that making THAT amount of AD a day, won't always be as possible and given that AD can only lose value as more and more of it is introduced into the market means that you'll get a lot less zen for your AD.
  • travail01travail01 Member, Neverwinter Beta Users Posts: 151 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    Respecs don't make this game pay to win. The fact that you can raise the fusion chance from 1% to 100% with a ward which is purchased using Zen makes this game pay to win.

    Some may claim this is pay for convenience, because there is still a 1% chance to succeed without spending money, and because technically you have a chance to obtain a ward once per week (by exchanging 7 celestial tokens.) However, I would argue that when the "convenience" factor is the difference between a 1% chance and a GUARANTEED SUCCESS, then that has become pay to win.

    -Travail.
    Eagles may soar, but weasels don't get sucked into jet engines.
  • spyke2009spyke2009 Member Posts: 674 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    travail01 wrote: »
    Respecs don't make this game pay to win. The fact that you can raise the fusion chance from 1% to 100% with a ward which is purchased using Zen makes this game pay to win.

    Some may claim this is pay for convenience, because there is still a 1% chance to succeed without spending money, and because technically you have a chance to obtain a ward once per week (by exchanging 7 celestial tokens.) However, I would argue that when the "convenience" factor is the difference between a 1% chance and a GUARANTEED SUCCESS, then that has become pay to win.

    -Travail.

    Those are TERRIBLE design, but they are being sold on the AH, not sure what they're going for now but they were being oddly auctioned starting at something like 1500AD starting bid... Keep an eye on them though so you can see if they jump in price, or something dodgy is done with them. Seems far too good to be true.
  • lyokiralyokira Member Posts: 882 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    travail01 wrote: »
    Respecs don't make this game pay to win. The fact that you can raise the fusion chance from 1% to 100% with a ward which is purchased using Zen makes this game pay to win.

    Some may claim this is pay for convenience, because there is still a 1% chance to succeed without spending money, and because technically you have a chance to obtain a ward once per week (by exchanging 7 celestial tokens.) However, I would argue that when the "convenience" factor is the difference between a 1% chance and a GUARANTEED SUCCESS, then that has become pay to win.

    -Travail.
    Except that Zen is not the only way to get said wards, so that doesn't quite count. Granted you'd have 2 chances a week (counting both alts) to get that ward, but still..
  • lyokiralyokira Member Posts: 882 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    spyke2009 wrote: »
    Those are TERRIBLE design, but they are being sold on the AH, not sure what they're going for now but they were being oddly auctioned starting at something like 1500AD starting bid... Keep an eye on them though so you can see if they jump in price, or something dodgy is done with them. Seems far too good to be true.

    Hm... just an offthought, but since this is F2P and those wards can somewhat easily be gotten from celestial coin trading, possibly it's from someone making multiple accounts? (note: please don't make multiple accounts. It'd just make people dislike you. And also against ToS)
  • riven84riven84 Member, Banned Users Posts: 574 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    spyke2009 wrote: »
    Those are TERRIBLE design, but they are being sold on the AH, not sure what they're going for now but they were being oddly auctioned starting at something like 1500AD starting bid... Keep an eye on them though so you can see if they jump in price, or something dodgy is done with them. Seems far too good to be true.

    Um you must be talking about Preservation Wards… the ones you want for 'fixing' the 1% chance are the Coalescent Wards, and they currently go for about 100K.
  • jorealjoreal Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Hero Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    riven84 wrote: »
    Um you must be talking about Preservation Wards… the ones you want for 'fixing' the 1% chance are the Coalescent Wards, and they currently go for about 100K.

    And they will continue to go down in price as more and more people farm up the 7 coin tokens and buy them with AD and buy them with Cash and resell them. This is all just volatile market <font color="orange">HAMSTER</font> at the beginning of the game. Everything is always overpriced at the beginning of games until it all settles down.
  • vesolcvesolc Member, Neverwinter Beta Users Posts: 5 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    djleber wrote: »
    So running dungeons that take 30-40 minutes if u know what ur doing means u have no life? u could do 3 a day after work and socializing. ur telling me theres not millions of ppl who sit in front a tv instead of a pc for hours on end out there? get real

    Id call u a <font color="orange">HAMSTER</font> but thatd be insulting mentally challenged

    Who are you ? Did I say anything to you ? I was just joking with riven84. Who is now <font color="orange">HAMSTER</font>.
  • spyke2009spyke2009 Member Posts: 674 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    riven84 wrote: »
    Um you must be talking about Preservation Wards… the ones you want for 'fixing' the 1% chance are the Coalescent Wards, and they currently go for about 100K.

    No, there was coalescent wards which were listed as their initial asking price at around 1600AD when I checked them the other day after it was brought to my attention.
  • ozzilupoozzilupo Member Posts: 17 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    You can respec with AD without even buying a respec token from item mall just going to cost a lot more in AD.
  • chai23chai23 Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    travail01 wrote: »
    Respecs don't make this game pay to win. The fact that you can raise the fusion chance from 1% to 100% with a ward which is purchased using Zen makes this game pay to win.

    Some may claim this is pay for convenience, because there is still a 1% chance to succeed without spending money, and because technically you have a chance to obtain a ward once per week (by exchanging 7 celestial tokens.) However, I would argue that when the "convenience" factor is the difference between a 1% chance and a GUARANTEED SUCCESS, then that has become pay to win.

    -Travail.

    Yes exactly. At some point the "you can earn it in game" argument becomes completely absurd, and a 1616 shard grind on average (and this is not missing one day of playing), compared to 100% success crosses that line of absurdity at about the halfway point. This is also for one detail of the game, and isnt even getting into all the other stuff one could be doing that they can also pay for.
  • riven84riven84 Member, Banned Users Posts: 574 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    chai23 wrote: »
    Yes exactly. At some point the "you can earn it in game" argument becomes completely absurd, and a 1616 shard grind on average (and this is not missing one day of playing), compared to 100% success crosses that line of absurdity at about the halfway point. This is also for one detail of the game, and isnt even getting into all the other stuff one could be doing that they can also pay for.

    Did you not understand anything that was said regarding this, or did you just conveniently choose to ignore the truth?

    I'll spell it out for you: it's much faster to farm 16 shards, and the AD needed to buy the C-Wards, than it is to farm the ~1616 shards.
  • chai23chai23 Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    riven84 wrote: »
    Did you not understand anything that was said regarding this, or did you just conveniently choose to ignore the truth?

    I'll spell it out for you: it's much faster to farm 16 shards, and the AD needed to buy the C-Wards, than it is to farm the ~1616 shards.

    Not really much of a difference. The "you can get it in game" argument still isnt a justifiction when youre still comparing insane amounts of grind -vs- simply paying. Those wanting to rules lawyering the definition of p2w need to consider the reasonability of what it actually means to farm all this stuff in game timewise rather than just doing so on an item by item basis. As for conveniently ignoring the truth, Im not the one who fell into the trap, or trying to justify it. The fact that it CAN be farmed in game doesnt make it reasonable timewise to do so.

    Oh, and not completely agreeing with you =/= lack of understanding.
  • terradraconisterradraconis Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users, Neverwinter Knight of the Feywild Users Posts: 17 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    You don't need a respec token to respec your powers or your feats. Each of those tabs has a respec button that if you hit will charge you Astral Diamonds.

    The token respecs your entire character in one shot.

    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • riven84riven84 Member, Banned Users Posts: 574 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    chai23 wrote: »
    Oh, and not completely agreeing with you =/= lack of understanding.

    Indeed, but you implied that you have farm ~1616 shards, which is far from the most efficient way to do it without paying. At least be honest about that.
  • riven84riven84 Member, Banned Users Posts: 574 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    You don't need a respec token to respec your powers or your feats. Each of those tabs has a respec button that if you hit will charge you Astral Diamonds.

    Wrong.

    /10char
  • deathknightx1082deathknightx1082 Member Posts: 16 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    I still think when it's "open beta" that respecs shouldn't be charged, just because some skills are still bugged or broken. If the game was live already then I could care less if they charged or not. That's just MHO.
  • riven84riven84 Member, Banned Users Posts: 574 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    I still think when it's "open beta" that respecs shouldn't be charged, just because some skills are still bugged or broken. If the game was live already then I could care less if they charged or not. That's just MHO.

    The game is live.
  • terradraconisterradraconis Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users, Neverwinter Knight of the Feywild Users Posts: 17 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    riven84 wrote: »
    Wrong.

    /10char

    No I'm afraid you are.

    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • gorbulasgorbulas Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    1. the game more or less launched already when they have a cash shop up. open beta is an excuse from f2p publishers like pwe to not compensate the money lost from bugs.
    2. zen doesn't magically appear in-game. someone has to buy it. if you buy it using AD, you bought it off someone that paid for it. pwe can care less where the money is coming from as long as they are getting paid.
    3. why would someone reroll when they can easily quit? its not as easy to level as you think it is. if you don't exploit the foundry or play all day, it will take a few months maybe to reach endgame.
    4. just sit back and relax. enjoy the game as it is. if you take a f2p seriously, its going to be more expensive than a sub game. thats what the f2p model is based on.
  • riven84riven84 Member, Banned Users Posts: 574 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    No I'm afraid you are.

    Okay bro, keep dreaming.
  • flayedawgflayedawg Member Posts: 475 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    wondyr wrote: »
    When it states 20 points to unlock it means you have to spend 20 points in the tree then when you go to spend point 21 you can apply it to the skill for rank 3.

    Yes, this. I'm level 27, & have many of my skills at rank 3. I'm not sure what the OP was thinking.
    Fare you well
    Let your life proceed by its own designs
    Nothing to tell
    Let the words be yours, I'm done with mine ...
  • deathknightx1082deathknightx1082 Member Posts: 16 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    riven84 wrote: »
    The game is live.

    true but it's still open beta, the word beta still basically mean its in a test phase.
  • flayedawgflayedawg Member Posts: 475 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    You don't need a respec token to respec your powers or your feats. Each of those tabs has a respec button that if you hit will charge you Astral Diamonds.

    I just checked this. You can respec FEATS without a token; there's a button on the lower-left which will cost you some 19k ADs to respec feats.

    There is no such button on the POWERS tab; only a button marked "buy a respec token," & another one marked "view paths."
    Fare you well
    Let your life proceed by its own designs
    Nothing to tell
    Let the words be yours, I'm done with mine ...
  • mutharexmutharex Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    riven84 wrote: »
    Okay bro, keep dreaming.

    You can respec your feats for AD
    You can respec powers for respec tokens. BTW I just tried and when I tried the powers it told me that I had one purchased respec token. I never bought that, not sure if it was part of the Guardian package or not. Anyone else can bother to check if they have one?
  • riven84riven84 Member, Banned Users Posts: 574 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    true but it's still open beta, the word beta still basically mean its in a test phase.

    The game is live and everything you do is permanent. The exact meaning of the word 'beta' is irrelevant here, given my previous statement. Don't fool yourself.
  • riven84riven84 Member, Banned Users Posts: 574 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    mutharex wrote: »
    You can respec your feats for AD

    Yes, and that is not what the other guy was claiming.
    mutharex wrote: »
    You can respec powers for respec tokens. BTW I just tried and when I tried the powers it told me that I had one purchased respec token. I never bought that, not sure if it was part of the Guardian package or not.

    It is.
This discussion has been closed.