test content
Logo
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc
Player Voice
captw
Member Posts: 492 Arc User
just as the title suggest giving the player character a voice actor, I would say one two voice actors per a race, one male, and one female. I think it would add a little more depth to the story arc and cut scenes that are in the game.
"I rather believe that time is a companion who goes with us on the journey, and reminds us to cherish every moment... because they'll never come again. What we leave behind is not as important as how we lived" Picard to Riker
Post edited by rattler2 on
0
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
And this isn't Mass Effect, where you are playing a hero in a storyline. You are the captain and it's your adventure.
so you sit there and read aloud your lines, just asking... kinda weird for me to read it since I play a female Romulan. My main is a male, pretty much me but still wouldn't mind a Voice actor portraying them.
"I rather believe that time is a companion who goes with us on the journey, and reminds us to cherish every moment... because they'll never come again. What we leave behind is not as important as how we lived" Picard to Riker
Elder Scrolls series and Fallout for example. And as azurianstar said, this isn't a game like Mass Effect or Saint's Row where even though you can customise your character, your still playing the same character as everyone else.
And though technically thats true in an MMO since were all playing the same story, but you have guilds/fleets and PVE/PVP where thats not the case, more or less.
Personally I wouldn't mind seeing this done. on the federation side it wouldn't be too hard, with the exception of aliens basically everyone would talk very similar and you could get away with maybe 2 female and 2 male voices as options.
Klingon would be a bit tougher since all of their species talk differently so the lines would have to be rerecorded for klingon, gorn, orion and the other species. thats a lot of work, and a lot of money.
Assuming 2 voices for male/female romulan would require at least 8 since Romulans and Remans don't talk alike, and you could just choose romulan or reman voice for alien.
But also, forcing aliens to choose a predone species voice would upset some alien players, and then they would turn voice off. And in the end, it's a lot of money and a lot of work for something that the majority of players most likely wouldn't use.
However, i'll end by saying that Cryptic is really going all out with VO's over the past year and maybe in a year or so they'll decide to do this. I sure won't complain. It would be nice for all bridge officers and captains to have a VO for the story lines. And Bethesda with TES4 Oblivion only used like 20 actors for 200 parts so it can be done with just a few actors, your just going to hear the same voice a lot lol.
1) I cant stand the Tovan actor. I mean he ruins every mission. I would hate to find my own character as grating
2) They dont give you any actual "part" to play. Mostly all you say is continue or agree with what ever you BO just told you.
3) I am so SICK of games with VOs. I feel like I spend most of my sitting there waiting for a freaking cutscene to end. Like in SWTOR, if you played 20 hours, 15 of that was just sitting there.
4) I have usually read all the text before the actors even get past the first sentance
5) A good deal of the writing is bad. Hearing it aloud just makes it even more obvious.
then how about suggesting new story content so if it was spoken it would sound better, yes I agree there are parts of the story that just don't make any sense.
"I rather believe that time is a companion who goes with us on the journey, and reminds us to cherish every moment... because they'll never come again. What we leave behind is not as important as how we lived" Picard to Riker
read it aloud no but i do read it in the "voice" i have selected for the character as it is my character with my personality i have selected for said character. there are many missions where my character gives a responce sarcasticly even though it was not writen as such and i doubt it would be voiced as such
example getting a drink for cassidy in night of the comet
ok now thinking back on those missions I can hear the voices of James Doohan and DeForest Kelley :P, since no one could ever do their voices... EVER again. If I even hear a hint of suggesting the actors from JJ I will throw a brick at them... wherever they are... O^O
"I rather believe that time is a companion who goes with us on the journey, and reminds us to cherish every moment... because they'll never come again. What we leave behind is not as important as how we lived" Picard to Riker
LOL. IN DCUO I swear there are spots they have spliced together a few lines from someones earlier VO work.
from a lot of what i have heard the actors here have no clue what they are actually even talking about so they are reading than voicing. which is why a lot it sound so disconnected
And they are loud because Every! Line! in the Copy! has and exclamation point!
Agreed, this is what I do as well.
Even though I'm still waiting for the option to just slap Cassidy, shout "Snap out of it!" and skip this whole nerve tonic business.:P
You mentioned SW TOR, true game sucks in many-many aspects, but one thing I enjoyed was dialog thanks to voiceover and cutcene-like setup
similar thing in GW2, simpler but still
not to mention regular cRPG's, first deus Ex anyone? was it bad? job they did rocked at the time and still rocks hard
in other words I'd welcome to hear my character's voice, be it only in some episodes where we see ourselves talking in cutscenes like in 2800
your need suitable voices for Gorn, vulcan, ferengi and the lists goes on. then a female version and there is no guarantee people will like it.
even then the tech might not be adaptable enough to know which species you are and use the right VO at the right time.
A Romulan Strike Team, Missing Farmers and an ancient base on a Klingon Border world. But what connects them? Find out in my First Foundary mission: 'The Jeroan Farmer Escapade'
A lot of awesome game storywise were fully voiced. Some not, and the lack VO was pointed as a weakness (Da:O comes to mind).
I played SWTOR, and storywise, it was the best MMO I ever played. That's also the opinion of my friends. GW2 was bad, but not because of the voice acting, but because it was endless boring cutscene were nothing happen, and where the player have no action possible. Not to mention the boring and full of cliche story.
In SWTOR, you choose what the character say.
I'm playing Defiance from time to time, and the hero is a HL2 Freeman like. Never say a single word. Just like in TSW. He look like a complete idiot, especially because he is asked to do stupid things, and like a good dog he always obey.
In SWTOR, the voices are really good, and they are usually appropriate for the character.
However, in STO, it wouldn't be appropriate. There are simply too many aliens, and you never know what the player will do. Hirogen ? Suliban ? Jem'hadar ? Vorta ? Something small ? Tall ?
I think no voices in STO is fine. However, I don't think it's fine everywhere, just STO. And I want to have at least a character that talk, using subtitle, not a mute.
Some games are better fully voiced (Mass Effect, swtor), some not. And some you wish there were no cutscene (gw2).
STO Forum member since before February 2010.
STO Academy's excellent skill planner here: Link
I actually avoid success entirely. It doesn't get me what I want, and the consequences for failure are slim. -- markhawman
That said, I seem to recall Everquest II had a system where you were able to pick from a selection of different voices depending on your race and gender that mostly covered emotes and combat grunts and groans.
Complete player dialogue voiceovers though? No. Not gonna happen.
But anything over 30 days without comments is a big no no, unless its in the bug reporting section which is not prone to being locked upon necromancing..
Most likely one of the mods will be along any minute now to close the thread..
Perhaps start a new thread on the subject...
*casts Holy Photon Torpedo*