[Community] Review Request Thread (Forms/Spreadsheets)

brunomalta · June 2013

Because it is using google doc stuff. It asks you to log into your email because it opens on the google drive (i think)

ash4ll · June 2013

you don't have to be logged in to access it, just tried to log out and it showed for me in full. Perhaps you have to click the link second time, I had to.
Personally I'm never logged out of my gmail, so I never found any issue with that.

ash4ll · June 2013

bump for love sharing!

lumicakery · June 2013

this post could use a sticky

brunomalta · June 2013

evening bump

anrix2 · June 2013

I did 6 reviews and got 1 review in turn...I think this system isn't working for me.

ash4ll · June 2013

@draconusxx, @visigoth18, @oerek, @rathenau15 - your quests were removed from the queue for not posting any feedback in section made for that. This rule is set up for dealing with greedy people inserting their quests without publishing any feedback.
If you think I made a mistake - please fill in the form again and fill in feedback form too.

Also bump, and obey the rules!

anrix2 · June 2013

oerek, just left me a review in game. So I am 2 for 6 now.

brunomalta · June 2013

anrix2...i will play yours soon.

anrix2 · June 2013

Thank you brunomalta, I've been trying to play your quest for a couple days but it isn't in the catalog. Did you withdraw it?

brunomalta · June 2013

Yes, i had too. Will publish it again soon.

Update: anrix2...just posted my feedback on the spreadsheet

anrix2 · June 2013

Thanks for the compliment. Do you want me to put a bridge in to get out the exit at the end? I've maxed my details, so I'll have to delete a mug or something to do that

brunomalta · June 2013

LOL...no! No need for that....

midnightsigh · June 2013

I like this format. Added mine, and on to reviewing some more.

hawthornberry · June 2013

I've done six reviews and gotten two back. Maybe I need to find other places to look for reviews.

ash4ll · June 2013

Every review thread consists of people that are willing to trade, and those that are too lazy to do that. It's appreciate that you're doing your job, but perhaps - maybe you would mind filling the feedbacks form for any of the quests? I'm removing people's quests that haven't posted anything in the feedback thread.
Even if you don't want to post any futher note, just write down what score you have put to each quest.

I'll be removing lazy authors quests again today evening.

j54219 · June 2013

Thanks @midnight for the review.

I'll checks yours tonight after work.

---
edit:
midnight I just ran yours but couldn't make it past the first room. couldn't click the thing on the floor next to the door.
Will try purples next.

luck all

brunomalta · June 2013

Evening bump!

ash4ll · June 2013

Ok, I removed the stupid rule about 20 reviews, it narrows the number of people wanting review.
But I added another one - if you want to keep your quest on the list, you'll need to review others quest.

Also I made a shield against greeders - I'll be filling myself the "Review me" list out of the requests that are sent to other spreadsheet. And it created another rule - if you want your quest to be added to "review me" list, you'll have to review at least one quest and post feedback via 2nd form. Those that were added will stay there of course.

I hope it will increase in the quality of this thread and sift out the non-reviewing from reviewing so they won't feel underappreciated.

And posting the rules here, so you don't have to scroll back.

Rules:
Use the first form to apply

Once you've applied, review quest from the "Review me" list

After you review and post feedback in 2nd form I'll put your quest into the "Review me" list.

You have 5 days to review again if you want to keep your quest on the list

If you review a couple of quests in the row, your quests existence in "Review me" will be extended by another 5 days additively. Eg. you reviewed 4 quests, your quest will stay here for 20 days.

PS. Deleting another batch of non-reviewing people.

brunomalta · June 2013

After reworking, my quest is back. Hope everyone can play it now.

ash4ll · June 2013

small side note - spreadsheets tend to work differently today, I try to make them work, so visibility may be compromised :P

Edit:I removed some of the quests from the visible list, so that you don't review quests not approved for reviewing.

xpurpleinsanityx · June 2013

Added my quest, and I'm going through some of the other quests on the list now.

docsc00ter · June 2013

Looking for feedback on my first quest:

Quest Name: "Danger in the Fog"
Short Code: NW-DUXO7DEP9
Mission Type: save a village; brief cavern crawl
Duration: 15-20 minutes
Amount of Combat: moderate (a bunch of "easy" encounters and a couple of "standard" encounters)

xpurpleinsanityx · June 2013

Hmm, it looks like somehow my form entry bugged the "Review Me!" page, because it's listed multiple times

ash4ll · June 2013

fixed /10c

PS. Today is not a good day for google forms

xpurpleinsanityx · June 2013

It seems I also had some kind of mindless moment and put my character name instead of the quest name XD (facepalms) That should be the questname "Save My Sister!"

wrtat · June 2013

Submitted. Will play listed quests in the mean time

j54219 · June 2013

anrix2 wrote: »

Thanks for the compliment. Do you want me to put a bridge in to get out the exit at the end? I've maxed my details, so I'll have to delete a mug or something to do that

HAHAHAahahahahaaahhhaa!!! toofunny

j54219 · June 2013

Got my twenty so you can take me down.
I just finishing bag of holes. (Edit: Forrest Chickens!!!!! love it!!!! hahaaha)

I was clicking the wrong thing in the shack the first time I tried to run it.

Thanks again Ash... I should have another in a week'ish
I'll be back

brunomalta · June 2013

docsc00ter wrote: »

Looking for feedback on my first quest:

Quest Name: "Danger in the Fog"
Short Code: NW-DUXO7DEPD
Mission Type: save a village; brief cavern crawl
Duration: 15-20 minutes
Amount of Combat: moderate (a bunch of "easy" encounters and a couple of "standard" encounters)

(I posted a longer description of what I've done, what things I'm wondering about, etc., over here:
http://nw-forum.perfectworld.com/showthread.php?376301-First-Quest-NW-DUXO7DEPD)

I'm starting to work my way through the thread and play some of yours as well, and will post notes here. Thanks!

Reviewed:
NW-DH25ZWZ9T -- "A Mysterious Mage"
NW-DHNVMMGVJ -- "The Dragons Horde" [sic]

I really want to play your quest, but is no showing up on the search

[Community] Review Request Thread (Forms/Spreadsheets)

Comments