test content
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc

Arcgames.com is Ready for your Feedback

1313234363772

Comments

  • o0kami87o0kami87 Member Posts: 590 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    Okay... 102 pages, nice.

    To Captain Smirk, I have repeatedly reported to PWE via the feedback button on arc and posted here some time ago about a problem with arc. While arc remembers my user name and password it seldom successfully logs me in at startup, generally Arc will time out seven times or more before a successful login. With a keylogger on the standalone launcher this was never an issue. The logger would automatically open the launcher and input my information, logging me in almost immediately. As of yet I've not heard from anyone as to whether or not this issue is even on the radar. Could you please pass the note for me?
    First, Vice Admiral, U.S.S. Wolf Pack-F, NX-101687-FFirst., Vice Admiral, A.R.W. Moon WolfWolf, I.K.S. Frost Bite
  • synchronicity75synchronicity75 Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    I would like to download the program(s) those of you that have used that throw up all sorts of red flags. I have put ARC through Malwarebytes, Bazooka and Spyware blaster and no flags were raised and have also run it through AVG and Norton with the same results. I'm not discounting the positive results that pop up threats for other users but would like to see something tangible for myself. I've never been the lucky type so something just doesn't sit right with all that I've read and my results.

    I play STO only and was a steam user (also the only game I played on steam) but so far for the past month and a half of using ARC nothing has changed on my end.

    Just help me understand if 5 programs show no threats, what am I missing? :(
  • jonsillsjonsills Member Posts: 10,433 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    I would like to download the program(s) those of you that have used that throw up all sorts of red flags. I have put ARC through Malwarebytes, Bazooka and Spyware blaster and no flags were raised and have also run it through AVG and Norton with the same results. I'm not discounting the positive results that pop up threats for other users but would like to see something tangible for myself. I've never been the lucky type so something just doesn't sit right with all that I've read and my results.

    I play STO only and was a steam user (also the only game I played on steam) but so far for the past month and a half of using ARC nothing has changed on my end.

    Just help me understand if 5 programs show no threats, what am I missing? :(
    You're missing paranoia. You're also missing a racist conviction that if a particular software package is produced by a company headquartered in China, then of course it must be spyware, malware, and a virus. All at the same time.
    Lorna-Wing-sig.png
  • hrisvalarhrisvalar Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    I'm happy enough that the program doesn't try to shoehorn itself into my startup queue. That said, I would like to know what it is that the Arc plugin does on the website that should be reason for me to allow it to execute...

    I use only one account to post on the forums, but I have two accounts on which I play STO. This main lifetime alt-infested one on which I own almost every C-store ship and where I slave diligently in the dilithium mines for the Overlord (fleet starbase) and another I've started recently to play through the reworked Federation missions, without all the flashy C-store and vet award junk, for the whole nostalgia of a simpler, worry-free time, when the only people who were upset were the Klingons.

    If it's going to mess with which account I'm signed in on the site, I don't want to give that plugin permission to run. Cause I can't see what it could possibly do (for me) that cookies aren't doing already.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
    Reave
  • rinksterrinkster Member Posts: 3,549 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    I'm on the fence about ARC.

    My problem is what I read about this ongoing process once the game starts.

    I just need to know what its doing.

    Answer me that satisfactorily and I D/L Arc the same day.
  • kwoutkwout Member Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    Couldn't care less about arc so long as I can launch sto through steam. I guarantee you I will never install another digital distribution system except for steam, though, merely by principle.
  • iikkajarviiikkajarvi Member Posts: 36 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    Honestly, Arc seems fine except for lacking overlay chat support (which says it is coming). I previously ran STO through Steam and I noticed that when running the game out of Steam, either directly from the .exe or through Arc I don't have framerate issues and the wewird 2-3 minutes hiccup startup (where the game begins at 1-2 FPS and remains that way for almost three minutes!).

    Steam runs many games in compatibility mode to support the overlay, so for anyone who has had framerate issues or slow loading, I would definitely recommend using Arc or loading the games directly.

    Seems to help minor framerate issues I had running NWO through Steam as well. Very odd.
    Current Server: Mindflayer
    History Class in the Realms: "Elves did it better first. Also, magic was probably involved somehow and maybe gods. Or godly magic. Now go outside so the orcs and bandits have someone to menace."
  • kazapskykazapsky Member Posts: 77 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    jonsills wrote: »
    You're missing paranoia. You're also missing a racist conviction that if a particular software package is produced by a company headquartered in China, then of course it must be spyware, malware, and a virus. All at the same time.

    I couldn't care less what country it came from. If a program insists on running long after I have no further use for it, sucks down several times the memory it has any business doing, refuses to tell me what it's actually doing with any of those resources, attempts to supplant/takeover my native web browser, and has an EULA that effectively gives it access to every single byte of data on my hard drive, it's spyware. End of discussion.
    Arc is garbage. End of discussion.
  • jonsillsjonsills Member Posts: 10,433 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    kazapsky wrote: »
    I couldn't care less what country it came from. If a program insists on running long after I have no further use for it, sucks down several times the memory it has any business doing, refuses to tell me what it's actually doing with any of those resources, attempts to supplant/takeover my native web browser, and has an EULA that effectively gives it access to every single byte of data on my hard drive, it's spyware. End of discussion.
    So, STO is spyware. End of discussion.

    So is every other MMO out there.

    (You, ah, did read the EULA before signing it, right?)
    Lorna-Wing-sig.png
  • kazapskykazapsky Member Posts: 77 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    jonsills wrote: »

    (You, ah, did read the EULA before signing it, right?)

    Apparently, you didn't. The EULA of STO (and any other MMO) gives them the rights to check for known cheating/hacking programs, and nothing more. The EULA of Arc doesn't specify ANY limits on what they can look at - it pretty bluntly states your entire HD is up for grabs.
    Arc is garbage. End of discussion.
  • salem1574salem1574 Member Posts: 187 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    kalani2 wrote: »
    1) A lot of people fear the unknown and there is a lot of unknowns surrounding Arc
    2) It feels like something is being forced on us (not the first time if you've been here long enough to remember the forum merger)
    3) It adds no functionality that is essential to the game
    4) It takes away some functionality of the game like running multiple clients on the same machine
    5) It adds an extra server that can and will go down that we must access to play the game
    6) It uses more than the insignificant amount of resources that has been claimed be the Arc PR

    Some of these points have workaround for now while we can still close Arc after launching the game through the task manager but if that is ever taken away every point becomes very valid and unavoidable.

    I absolutely agree with this especially with the adds no further functionality to STO. It?s just another HOOP for the player base to needlessly jump thru.

    Ask yourselves some basic questions:

    1. How does Arc benefit the Star Trek Online player in ANY way shape or form?

    2. Who does Arc REALLY benefit?

    3. Does ARC offer ANY LONG TERM benefits at all to the Star Trek Online community at all?

    4. It?s Really worth having all the additional headaches and frustrations that WILL come with having a 3rd party style launcher in place?
  • rinksterrinkster Member Posts: 3,549 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    I just want to know what ARC does once the game is launched.

    Apparently its still active and, even talking to some entities via the internet.

    Tell me whats happening there, then I'll know whether or not to install it.

    However, without clarity on that singular point, I don't know why anyone sensible would run this software.
  • sparkiesoftsparkiesoft Member, Cryptic Developers Posts: 47
    edited February 2014
    kazapsky wrote: »
    I couldn't care less what country it came from. If a program insists on running long after I have no further use for it, sucks down several times the memory it has any business doing, refuses to tell me what it's actually doing with any of those resources, attempts to supplant/takeover my native web browser, and has an EULA that effectively gives it access to every single byte of data on my hard drive, it's spyware. End of discussion.

    Hey!

    So, I'm going through the EULA myself, and I think this is the part that may have you concerned, but let me know if I'm off base.

    "12. Data Collected To Prevent Cheating And Unauthorized Software
    12.1 You understand and agree that when user our Service and/or run our Game software, this can and may involve software functions designed to detect cheating or unauthorized and malicious programs. In this context, we may access, collect, monitor and/or remotely store screenshots of game play, information relating to hardware capacity, modifications related to our Game software, signatures, profiles or names of known unauthorized or malicious third party programs, files or processes that enable or facilitate cheating, unfair advantage or hacking of the Games or Service. If unauthorized or malicious programs are detected, the Game software may also communicate to us the users account and User ID and information about the unauthorized or malicious program or its use."

    To clear this up, this is set forth to ensure we cover all ends on our side. The only thing it will be doing is making sure no cheat software is being ran, which is fairly standard for most launchers/games. Other than that, if you want us to collect system information you have to opt-in, otherwise we can't.

    Now you may be asking, well then why does Arc need to run after I launch? In particular, it's because it's used to detect cheat software, something it can't do when it's off. As I said in a previous post though, this may change. Nothing is set in stone atm, which is why we still carry the Beta tag. There's been a lot of talk on ways to improve this feature and to allow users to close Arc after launching. I can't make any promises or give any specifics, as I don't have them, but we are well aware of players' concern regarding this issue.

    I hope this helps clear the air, and if not, let me know. I'd be more than happy to answer your questions.
  • monkeybone13monkeybone13 Member Posts: 4,640 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    Hey!

    So, I'm going through the EULA myself, and I think this is the part that may have you concerned, but let me know if I'm off base.

    "12. Data Collected To Prevent Cheating And Unauthorized Software
    12.1 You understand and agree that when user our Service and/or run our Game software, this can and may involve software functions designed to detect cheating or unauthorized and malicious programs. In this context, we may access, collect, monitor and/or remotely store screenshots of game play, information relating to hardware capacity, modifications related to our Game software, signatures, profiles or names of known unauthorized or malicious third party programs, files or processes that enable or facilitate cheating, unfair advantage or hacking of the Games or Service. If unauthorized or malicious programs are detected, the Game software may also communicate to us the users account and User ID and information about the unauthorized or malicious program or its use."

    To clear this up, this is set forth to ensure we cover all ends on our side. The only thing it will be doing is making sure no cheat software is being ran, which is fairly standard for most launchers/games. Other than that, if you want us to collect system information you have to opt-in, otherwise we can't.

    Now you may be asking, well then why does Arc need to run after I launch? In particular, it's because it's used to detect cheat software, something it can't do when it's off. As I said in a previous post though, this may change. Nothing is set in stone atm, which is why we still carry the Beta tag. There's been a lot of talk on ways to improve this feature and to allow users to close Arc after launching. I can't make any promises or give any specifics, as I don't have them, but we are well aware of players' concern regarding this issue.

    I hope this helps clear the air, and if not, let me know. I'd be more than happy to answer your questions.

    There is no option in Arc to opt in or out of sharing system information. The only time I saw it was the window for finalizing the instillation and the box was checked by default for sharing data. For someone not paying attention and just clicking the finish button, they will be automatically opted in for sharing data and there is no way to reverse that without uninstalling and reinstalling Arc and unchecking the box in the final install window. I looked all over the settings in Arc itself and could not find the option anywhere.

    Edit: See my post earlier in the thread here http://sto-forum.perfectworld.com/showpost.php?p=14441821&postcount=527 Screenshots included. There is no option in Arc to opt in or out of data sharing.
  • robdmcrobdmc Member Posts: 1,619 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    To clear this up, this is set forth to ensure we cover all ends on our side. The only thing it will be doing is making sure no cheat software is being ran, which is fairly standard for most launchers/games. Other than that, if you want us to collect system information you have to opt-in, otherwise we can't.

    Question: does this mean you also record all our system processes for your review? Does this include Window Services?

    Really how can you know what software we are running cheat or otherwise if you don't.

    Also what is classified as cheat software? I use calc.exe and Excel.exe to help to plan and co-ordinate my fleet holdings. is that kind of maximizing prohibited. I use a dps parcer to Figure out how to maximize my builds. Is the fact that any of those process are running on my system being sent to you. These improve my strategizing.

    What if I have a keyboard where the driver software includes macros for faster response into windows. Even though it has no code injected into your game does it count as a cheat since people would appear to have faster then normal response?

    Maybe I don't want you to know what software I'm using. In my mind it is none of your business to know what software I'm running.

    Can you please show us an example of the information on the software you collect?
  • rinksterrinkster Member Posts: 3,549 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    Hey!

    So, I'm going through the EULA myself, and I think this is the part that may have you concerned, but let me know if I'm off base.

    "12. Data Collected To Prevent Cheating And Unauthorized Software
    12.1 You understand and agree that when user our Service and/or run our Game software, this can and may involve software functions designed to detect cheating or unauthorized and malicious programs. In this context, we may access, collect, monitor and/or remotely store screenshots of game play, information relating to hardware capacity, modifications related to our Game software, signatures, profiles or names of known unauthorized or malicious third party programs, files or processes that enable or facilitate cheating, unfair advantage or hacking of the Games or Service. If unauthorized or malicious programs are detected, the Game software may also communicate to us the users account and User ID and information about the unauthorized or malicious program or its use."

    To clear this up, this is set forth to ensure we cover all ends on our side. The only thing it will be doing is making sure no cheat software is being ran, which is fairly standard for most launchers/games. Other than that, if you want us to collect system information you have to opt-in, otherwise we can't.

    Now you may be asking, well then why does Arc need to run after I launch? In particular, it's because it's used to detect cheat software, something it can't do when it's off. As I said in a previous post though, this may change. Nothing is set in stone atm, which is why we still carry the Beta tag. There's been a lot of talk on ways to improve this feature and to allow users to close Arc after launching. I can't make any promises or give any specifics, as I don't have them, but we are well aware of players' concern regarding this issue.

    I hope this helps clear the air, and if not, let me know. I'd be more than happy to answer your questions.



    Thank you for that much clarification.

    I do see what you're aiming at with the anti-cheat system.

    Thing is, does it have to be live?

    By which I mean, I see why the program needs to monitor my side of the router, but what purpose is served by it communicating to other computers while I'm playing?

    Couldn't it do that sort of thing on start up?
  • sparkiesoftsparkiesoft Member, Cryptic Developers Posts: 47
    edited February 2014
    There is no option in Arc to opt in or out of sharing system information. The only time I saw it was the window for finalizing the instillation and the box was checked by default for sharing data. For someone not paying attention and just clicking the finish button, they will be automatically opted in for sharing data and there is no way to reverse that without uninstalling and reinstalling Arc and unchecking the box in the final install window. I looked all over the settings in Arc itself and could not find the option anywhere.

    For now that is how it is, but we are looking into a way to get it integrated into the platform.
    robdmc wrote: »
    Question: does this mean you also record all our system processes for your review? Does this include Window Services?

    Really how can you know what software we are running cheat or otherwise if you don't.

    Also what is classified as cheat software? I use calc.exe and Excel.exe to help to plan and co-ordinate my fleet holdings. is that kind of maximizing prohibited. I use a dps parcer to Figure out how to maximize my builds. Is the fact that any of those process are running on my system being sent to you. These improve my strategizing.

    What if I have a keyboard where the driver software includes macros for faster response into windows. Even though it has no code injected into your game does it count as a cheat since people would appear to have faster then normal response?

    Maybe I don't want you to know what software I'm using. In my mind it is none of your business to know what software I'm running.

    Can you please show us an example of the information on the software you collect?

    It will only look for malicious software, so things like calc.exe and excel.exe will not put up any red flags. The same can be said for keyboard/mouse drivers, etc. As for what it monitors and looks for, it's all in the EULA, part 12.1. Essentially, screenshots of gameplay, user ID/password if said player has been flagged running file processes to enable hacking/cheating, etc. Most of it's pretty straight forward and what you'd expect from any online gaming service. Think of it as a built in Game-Guard, except not Game-Guard. If you've played any online game in the past with a anti-cheat software, it functions basically the same way. (Note: I just used Game-Guard as an example)

    Hope that helps.
  • virusdancervirusdancer Member Posts: 18,687 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    I hope this helps clear the air, and if not, let me know. I'd be more than happy to answer your questions.

    sparkie, it may end up being a case of pointing out examples of similar features that are literally all over the place...whether it's somebody using Steam (with their VACS) or Blizzard (with Warden) or NCSoft (with Gameguard) or yeah...the list goes on and on and on and on and on...eh?
  • vengefuldjinnvengefuldjinn Member Posts: 1,521 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    Now you may be asking, well then why does Arc need to run after I launch? In particular, it's because it's used to detect cheat software, something it can't do when it's off. As I said in a previous post though, this may change. Nothing is set in stone atm, which is why we still carry the Beta tag. There's been a lot of talk on ways to improve this feature and to allow users to close Arc after launching. I can't make any promises or give any specifics, as I don't have them, but we are well aware of players' concern regarding this issue.

    So It IS spying on us...... to "detect cheat software".

    This should put an end to all debate on the subject.

    There is NO such thing as just spying on you a little, just like one can't be a little bit pregnant.
    You either are spying, or you aren't. It's really quite simple as that.

    So today it's to "detect cheat software", what assurances do we have that tomorrow it won't be for something else?
    Because from what I'm gathering, it has the capabilities to collect data on other things as well.

    You know, the more I read about this issue the madder I get, Why? It's the half truths and the activities of the "Foil hat brigade".

    I don't cheat, I'm a good customer and I don't appreciate the patting down of my system every time I log on either.

    You want us to trust YOU? How's about showing us a little trust in return?
    tumblr_o2aau3b7nh1rkvl19o1_400.gif








  • jonsillsjonsills Member Posts: 10,433 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    My new sig line grows more appropriate every time you post, djinn. What exactly makes you think Cryptic/PWE wants to spy on you? Are you really just that freaking special?
    Lorna-Wing-sig.png
  • vengefuldjinnvengefuldjinn Member Posts: 1,521 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    jonsills wrote: »
    My new sig line grows more appropriate every time you post, djinn. What exactly makes you think Cryptic/PWE wants to spy on you? Are you really just that freaking special?

    Just the response I was anticipating and equally just as fast.

    I protect my privacy on line diligently and I consider someone who doesn't crazy.
    tumblr_o2aau3b7nh1rkvl19o1_400.gif








  • rinksterrinkster Member Posts: 3,549 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    Originally Posted by monkeybone13
    There is no option in Arc to opt in or out of sharing system information. The only time I saw it was the window for finalizing the instillation and the box was checked by default for sharing data. For someone not paying attention and just clicking the finish button, they will be automatically opted in for sharing data and there is no way to reverse that without uninstalling and reinstalling Arc and unchecking the box in the final install window. I looked all over the settings in Arc itself and could not find the option anywhere.

    For now that is how it is, but we are looking into a way to get it integrated into the platform.


    May I strongly suggest that you publicise this easy to miss button a little harder.

    Just because its there doesn't shield you from liability, especially if its in a non-intuitive place.

    And the current inability to revisit this option may also be an actual offence under current data protection laws.
  • sparkiesoftsparkiesoft Member, Cryptic Developers Posts: 47
    edited February 2014
    rinkster wrote: »
    Originally Posted by monkeybone13
    There is no option in Arc to opt in or out of sharing system information. The only time I saw it was the window for finalizing the instillation and the box was checked by default for sharing data. For someone not paying attention and just clicking the finish button, they will be automatically opted in for sharing data and there is no way to reverse that without uninstalling and reinstalling Arc and unchecking the box in the final install window. I looked all over the settings in Arc itself and could not find the option anywhere.

    For now that is how it is, but we are looking into a way to get it integrated into the platform.


    May I strongly suggest that you publicise this easy to miss button a little harder.

    Just because its there doesn't shield you from liability, especially if its in a non-intuitive place.

    And the current inability to revisit this option may also be an actual offence under current data protection laws.


    It's a work in progress and I've already brought it up with the team, so we're well aware of it!
  • rinksterrinkster Member Posts: 3,549 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    It's a work in progress and I've already brought it up with the team, so we're well aware of it!

    Glad to hear it.

    But, if I were you, I'd have a little chat with your company lawyer regarding whether you're exposed right now.

    Not being able to opt out of data gathering is something that gets succesfully prosecuted around the world nowadays.

    I don't think calling it a 'beta' would shield you from liability.
  • monkeybone13monkeybone13 Member Posts: 4,640 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    rinkster wrote: »
    Originally Posted by monkeybone13
    There is no option in Arc to opt in or out of sharing system information. The only time I saw it was the window for finalizing the instillation and the box was checked by default for sharing data. For someone not paying attention and just clicking the finish button, they will be automatically opted in for sharing data and there is no way to reverse that without uninstalling and reinstalling Arc and unchecking the box in the final install window. I looked all over the settings in Arc itself and could not find the option anywhere.

    For now that is how it is, but we are looking into a way to get it integrated into the platform.


    May I strongly suggest that you publicise this easy to miss button a little harder.

    Just because its there doesn't shield you from liability, especially if its in a non-intuitive place.

    And the current inability to revisit this option may also be an actual offence under current data protection laws.

    Shield me from....? How the hell am I liable for anything? And what do you mean I should "publicize this easy to miss button a little harder"? Are you saying I shouldn't be telling anybody where to find the option?

    They keep saying we will be opted out by default and have to manually op into data sharing and I was pointing out that the option is not in Arc at all and where the only place to see the option is. Sparkiesoft finally clarified that the option isn't added to Arc yet.

    I don't know if you're being sarcastic or not, but you're coming off as a jackass.
  • vengefuldjinnvengefuldjinn Member Posts: 1,521 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    Shield me from....? How the hell am I liable for anything? And what do you mean I should "publicize this easy to miss button a little harder"? Are you saying I shouldn't be telling anybody where to find the option?

    They keep saying we will be opted out by default and have to manually op into data sharing and I was pointing out that the option is not in Arc at all and where the only place to see the option is. Sparkiesoft finally clarified that the option isn't added to Arc yet.

    I don't know if you're being sarcastic or not, but you're coming off as a jackass.

    No, I think you misunderstand. I believe Rinkster is talking to the dev, not players.
    tumblr_o2aau3b7nh1rkvl19o1_400.gif








  • monkeybone13monkeybone13 Member Posts: 4,640 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    It's a work in progress and I've already brought it up with the team, so we're well aware of it!

    I just want to say thank you for looking into it and finally letting us know. I was starting to think you guys weren't being honest with us because you never said before that the feature wasn't added yet. You just kept saying we will be opted out by default and have to manually opt in to data sharing if we wanted to do that.

    P.S. When I launch Arc the left/right scrolling news stuff on the page shows Season 8 Dev Blog #35 first. I believe we are up to at least #48 now lol. So it seems the news isn't completely up to date yet, but I'm sure they're working on it. :)
  • monkeybone13monkeybone13 Member Posts: 4,640 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    No, I think you misunderstand. I believe Rinkster is talking to the dev, not players.

    It's a possibility. I wish people could be more specific as to who they are talking to when talking to more than 1 person in a single post, because idiots like me think we're the center of the universe. :P
  • captfabulouscaptfabulous Member Posts: 292 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    I've been using SweetFX with STO for a long time now, but when I log in via Arc it seems to bypass it completely. I can still play but without the SweetFX enhancements.

    This is a real dealbreaker for Arc. If SweetFX can work with Steam I see no reason why it can't work with Arc.
  • ruminate00ruminate00 Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited February 2014
    Just the response I was anticipating and equally just as fast.

    I protect my privacy on line diligently and I consider someone who doesn't crazy.

    The only way to protect your privacy online is to not go online in the first place.
This discussion has been closed.