Rate a Character thread. Hot or Not.

Susylu - Heavens Tear wrote: »

Actually, lol, I haven't bothered rating this new makeover even before the lip color change; the only thing I said was she looks more mature briefly in another thread. b:sweat

Maybe I should have rated her the first time I saw her like this, idk. My mistake. I've just come to expect more from you, that's all. No need to keep pressing that you didn't change anything when to me it looks like she changed quite a bit, and as a result, lost her originality which mainly came from her facial and lip structure from before.

It's just my opinion. No one probably agrees with me but just thought I'd say it *shrugs*

As much as I respect your opinion, no need to also press that I changed anything. I don't know how she looks unoriginal, is it a preset you've seen over the PW-CN forums? I don't even go to those to begin with (doesn't know Chinese or anything). b:surrender

But nonetheless, it doesn't matter since I don't need expectations from anyone. But thank you anyways. b:cute

KuiXing: I think her body proportions improved as far as I can see. Give us a better shot of the face sometime so we can get a good idea of the color changes cause I can't tell atm. b:laugh

Cocobelle - Sanctuary wrote: »

As much as I respect your opinion, no need to also press that I changed anything. I don't know how she looks unoriginal, is it a preset you've seen over the PW-CN forums? I don't even go to those to begin with (doesn't know Chinese or anything).

But nonetheless, it doesn't matter since I don't need expectations from anyone. But thank you anyways.

Coco, it's my opinion. I can press all I want because you asked for my thoughts by posting here to be rated, and you keep arguing my opinion was wrong.

I'll explain for the final time - She looks unoriginal. Why? Cause she looks the same in concept as my characters, as many other players I've seen in game that don't post here, as well as hundreds more on the CN servers before you changed to this look in the middle of December. Fact that you didn't see them doesn't change the fact that I have, making her not unique to me anymore.

Subtle details and changes might not mean a lot to you, but I like to take in details and often even one change can cause a great difference and sway my opinion drastically.

Either way, it doesn't matter. I just hope you continue to develop your own style which I thought you had going for you before. b:cute

Honestly I can't say it better than you said here:

Cocobelle - Sanctuary wrote: »

I never said anything's wrong with your character. It's my opinion and I'm sorry if you're offended about it. But this is a rating thread and I gave my honest opinion. b:surrender

edit: I hope you didn't think I meant you copied someone else's character when I said not original. I'm just saying it's an image that's used often that's all.

XuiXing I like how she looks Its a very elegant style.



Sooo pwi was my first mmo and as such i was a little more concerned with playing it versus character creation and as such i picked a preset, gave it colors i liked and hopped ingame. My bm has had the same look for 90 lvls. Finally after some nitpicking and weeks of working on presets, ditching them and trying again I made one i like. I wanted to keep it looking relatively close to my old bm, but well... younger or less... something XD. Anyway she's not perfect but I adore how it came out. I try to keep my characters more or less natural looking (exception being my veno).

Anyway! Here's old Tearle (top) vs Made-over





Like I said I really wanted to keep it looking similar but but maybe younger and I think I hit it? I'd love it if anyone could spot anything I messed up in the face. I messed the bone structure somewhat and I dunno if I made it look ok >.<

Aha, thank you Dorset, I did like her old look but it was basically a preset If you go in the bm creation screen you can pick out which one it was in a heartbeat. As weird as it is I miss the bigger nose XD It was one of the features you dont see often =P most people use little noses. Thank you for the feed back! ^_^
So far i'm liking the makeover, but I just hope it lasts past the "omg new look!" hype. Might end up changing back/to something different if it doesn't D,:

Your character has a lovely nose =P It just seemed like a unique feature. I'm probably just being silly from lack of sleep due to studying and gaming but ah well x) It happens.

Susylu - Heavens Tear wrote: »

Coco, it's my opinion. I can press all I want because you asked for my thoughts by posting here to be rated, and you keep arguing my opinion was wrong.

I'll explain for the final time - She looks unoriginal. Why? Cause she looks the same in concept as my characters, as many other players I've seen in game that don't post here, as well as hundreds more on the CN servers before you changed to this look in the middle of December. Fact that you didn't see them doesn't change the fact that I have, making her not unique to me anymore.

Subtle details and changes might not mean a lot to you, but I like to take in details and often even one change can cause a great difference and sway my opinion drastically.

Either way, it doesn't matter. I just hope you continue to develop your own style which I thought you had going for you before. b:cute

edit: I hope you didn't think I meant you copied someone else's character when I said not original. I'm just saying it's an image that's used often that's all.

I never said you're opinion's wrong or implied it. I'm just stating the fact that there was barely any changes which isn't the case for you, simple as that. Just because she has the same concept of your characters does not mean I copied them or anything. I've changed my character's looks not just since December, but for quite awhile now. I don't even know where you got the "since the middle of December". b:surrender

Cocobelle: I know I'm not one to talk with almost all mine looking like that but bleh.

Does this mean yours is unoriginal as well since you use the same concept?

I hope you don't think that I'm copying your "style" which is definitely not the case here. How else would it be unoriginal if I didn't copy someone else's character? Because it looks like other characters in another server?

But thank you for your opinion anyways.

Dorset - Heavens Tear wrote: »

Coco Shut the HELL up! theres no need to throw your toys out of the pram every single time somebody doesnt act as if the sun shines out of your chars ****. just learn when to quit will you Su has the right to her opinion theres no need to argue against it tirelessly for pages on end. you are getting BORING.

I really like how flaming in this thread is so common nowadays. I'm not arguing against it, you're just reading it all wrong. It's simply a discussion, as far as I'm concern. I'm just wondering why she thought of those things so I basically just responded to what she said. Simple as that. So no need to create further "arguments", Dorset.

Cocobelle - Sanctuary wrote: »

I never said you're opinion's wrong or implied it. I'm just stating the fact that there was barely any changes which isn't the case for you, simple as that. Just because she has the same concept of your characters does not mean I copied them or anything. I've changed my character's looks not just since December, but for quite awhile now. I don't even know where you got the "since the middle of December". b:surrender

Does this mean yours is unoriginal as well since you use the same concept?

I hope you don't think that I'm copying your "style" which is definitely not the case here. How else would it be unoriginal if I didn't copy someone else's character? Because it looks like other characters in another server?

But thank you for your opinion anyways.

Well - You kept telling me you didn't change anything when I specifically wrote several times it looks TO ME you changed her quite a bit. So why bother tell me over and over that no, you didn't change anything, if you're not implying or even saying my opinion was wrong?

Middle of December was when you first posted the "pointer" chin version of your veno, saying that you now had winter break. Before that, you still had the other look I liked better, at least on the forums.

Yes, I already mentioned several times my characters have the same image. I made them the way they are, saw that others have done the same and said, okay cool, so they weren't as unique as I thought they were.

I haven't posted any of my characters to be rated since I realized it, hoping to come up with something new. I also don't flatter myself to think that someone with as much confidence in her characters to even take a simple critical comment to "copy" me or anyone.

Unoriginal = been done before. I already said it doesn't mean you copied, just that it's been done before on my server, and on the chinese server (don't play the other servers so idk). So the look is overused and not unique to ME.

Dorset - Heavens Tear wrote: »

Coco Shut the HELL up! theres no need to throw your toys out of the pram every single time somebody doesnt act as if the sun shines out of your chars ****. just learn when to quit will you Su has the right to her opinion theres no need to argue against it tirelessly for pages on end. you are getting BORING.

Sorry for the bickering Dorset. I'm just too stubborn to let things go sometimes. b:laugh

Diva cat fights are sexy
SOOOOOOO anyway here is heart with her newest colorsb:cute

and this is my psy b:cute

Cocobelle - Sanctuary wrote: »

I didn't expect a slight change would make a character's look so similar to others so I had to clarify that with you.

I still think your characters are unique in their own way (doesn't matter which server you're on because no matter what, there will be a character who may resemble you).

Well, you implied it in your posts before you even mentioned your definition of unoriginal. Anyone can be unoriginal with their character styles (i.e. white hair, blonde hair, big eyes, etc.). So it's not just you, it's technically all of us. It's just how we pull it off.

I think we both know that we're both stubborn sometimes. b:chuckle

I think it's precisely what you said about how similar character designs can get that one slight change IS what makes a character unique or not. In your veno's case, I'd say 3 things look different to me, and she lost it, in my view. I'm sorry I can't express my thoughts in any better way, it's just what I feel.

Yes, you're right, everyone is unoriginal, there isn't much that can be done that hasn't been done before. In knowing that, I'm glad I don't know yet what all that can be done with the character creation so I'm just poking my head into this thread for someone to surprise me.

Also, stubborn doesn't even come close to describing me sometimes b:laugh

@heartandsoul:

sin - 5/5 something about her i really like, cant put my tongue on it but she's really cute (:

psy - ehh idk how to rate this lol... hmm, i like the originality (imo anyway) with the hairstyle, colour and overall design. that said, im not hot on the hairstyle or colour x3 i do however like the face very much, the frown works (im not sure if you screenie'd it at the exact moment or if she was made that way, but it works for her defo! cant imagine her smiling really lol... >.>") hats off to you for designing outside the box! 5/5 for originality (imo) but 3/5 for me personally

@tearle:

i definitely like the makeover loads more than the original... i may not be able to differentiate if a TB is close to a preset or not, but your original really strikes as a preset to me X.x imo you definitely achieved the younger look you were going for and you did it quite well i think she'd look cute in the renaissance hair... one thing you could do is darken her lips a touch? the pink (i think that's the colour haha cant distinguish it very well from the screenie >o>") looks kinda off with the rest of the colour scheme... and i'll leave the bone structure comment to someone more professional than me lol x3 overall 4/5 PS. can you post your toon instead of the avatar?

Xxdistance - Heavens Tear wrote: »

I attempted to make my sin look less like a preset >o< So here is her final makeover for awhile ( because I'm on my last day of free character customization D': ) .
I'm pretty pleased with her ~ b:thanks
As for anyone who asks about seeing a full shot: Her body is the same as it was before, I only changed the face .

As a human, I'm flattered that you're trying to emulate one of our common skin tones with your character design. b:cute

Kynx - Lost City wrote: »

My first character I guess...



b:bye

omg looks like a sad arielle or how/ that mermaid is spelled. i like it! xD 4/5

_Neve_ - Heavens Tear wrote: »

okay, here my cleric, neve, my bm and veno will follow sooner or later
[IMG][/img]

let me know what u think^^

5/5 Cute and sexy