test content
Logo
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc
Crafting Balance is COMPLETELY out of whack!
dndjess
Member Posts: 47
Some of this is really hard to excuse, because it's so BLINDINGLY obvious! Case in point:
Two Leadership Lvl 2 tasks:
Guard Duty: 2 hours. Reward: 40 Leadership Exp, 150 Exp, 1 Silver
Martial Training: 4 hours. Reward: 80 Leadership Exp.
So in the same amount of time (4 hours), I can do:
Martial Training once for 80 leadership exp, or
Guard Duty twice for 80 leadership exp, 300 exp and 2 silver.
So who in their right mind would ever do Martial Training? That is really inexcusable. Either you guys didn't put the slightest consideration into balancing these, or you're really, really bad at simple math.
Leveling other crafts is just as ludicrous - the lowest level shirt/chest piece is always the most efficient leveling method, by far.
And my biggest issue - why does crafting always have to be a boring time-waster? Make it an actual mini-game that could actually be (yes, this is a bizarre concept for a game) FUN! I don't give the new Final Fantasy MMORPG credit for much, but at least they tried to do something new and fun with crafting.
Two Leadership Lvl 2 tasks:
Guard Duty: 2 hours. Reward: 40 Leadership Exp, 150 Exp, 1 Silver
Martial Training: 4 hours. Reward: 80 Leadership Exp.
So in the same amount of time (4 hours), I can do:
Martial Training once for 80 leadership exp, or
Guard Duty twice for 80 leadership exp, 300 exp and 2 silver.
So who in their right mind would ever do Martial Training? That is really inexcusable. Either you guys didn't put the slightest consideration into balancing these, or you're really, really bad at simple math.
Leveling other crafts is just as ludicrous - the lowest level shirt/chest piece is always the most efficient leveling method, by far.
And my biggest issue - why does crafting always have to be a boring time-waster? Make it an actual mini-game that could actually be (yes, this is a bizarre concept for a game) FUN! I don't give the new Final Fantasy MMORPG credit for much, but at least they tried to do something new and fun with crafting.
Post edited by dndjess on
0
Comments
Someone who can't be at their computer every two hours.
You don't have to be at your computer - there's an app for that.
And it doesn't change the fact that one task is clearly more profitable and beneficial than the other. And can you give a valid reason why Martial Training shouldn't also have additional rewards besides just exp? It's a p*** poor job of balancing. You can try to rationalize it if you want, but it's just plain bad.
I dunno, I don't mind it simply because I do on-call work, which means if they call me to leave for certain jobs I know I'll be gone 8 or 12 or 16 hours, so sometimes the longer slightly less options are still better then only one of the shorter ones.
I suppose if I was sitting here never moving, sure...it's not completely logical, but why whine when you can just min/max?
Ah, I see, now the real reason.
Crafting is balanced fine. You get more rewards if you're willing to push the button every five minutes.
Sounds like Farmville.
I personally used martial training the most when leveling leadership. Its not imbalanced its called them giving choices for those that do not have the time in the day to que stuff regularly. Simple solution don't use that option for yourself. /thread
And there are still plenty of people who can't be at their computer/browser/app every two hours.
Apps work fine, unless you work a job where you actually have to WORK and you can't be on your phone all the time...
Furthermore, I found that "Explore Local Area" with one hour is the best way to grind up leadership. 40 exp plus bonus stuff in one hour is pretty good.
Speaking of. Does anyone else feel that the tailoring/etc professions are utterly pointless and impossible to keep up with your character level?
The thing you arent thinking about is what else the other tasks give, for instance protect caravan is half the crafting xp since its 40/2hr but it also gives AD. lots of people level up alts to 11 just so they can invoke and do protect caravan for the extra AD, its not a lot but it does add up. Theres also a couple tasks that give quite a bit of silver, which could be great for the player that only does dungeons and needs pots/injury kits.
As to the disparity between tasks, I'd agree somewhat that SOME of them are a bit off. I think its fine that a 1-2hr task gives a better reward than a 6-8hr task. The player consistently updating their crafting that often deserves more than the guy that only has to update 2 or 3 times all day. A good example is the mass resource crafting for the non leadership professions, its 6-8hrs long and only gives the resources of like 4 regular resource crafting, but when a player is going to bed and gets to pick ONE task to do overnight, whats the better choice? when they wake up they'll either have 2 resources or 8 resources. The only ones I have much of a problem with are the rare tasks with super long cd's (12-16hr from what i remember) that only give just slightly higher rewards than a 2hr task, because with them being rare, they arent always available so you wont always have a good option when you are logging off for a long period of time, you have whatever rares the game decides to give you.
As to the other crafting professions, personally the only good things i've seen are the lvl 60 crafted shirt/pants that you cant get anywhere else, and to make the rank 3 versions of those you need atleast 1 set of purple tools, 4 purple tools for a decent 60% chance. Unless you plan to make dozens of em, its WAY cheaper to just buy the shirt/pants and not have to bother with getting crafting to 20 and buying that many purple tools.
I think what he means is that in four hours you can come back and find that the two hour reward is STILL better than that 4 hour reward and there is no way to make that not true.
Do they not make math teachers anymore?
This is a big deal for me, too. As a casual player, I have mules to do my invoking for me once/day so I don't outlevel the PVE content. I don't want experience from leadership (or I try to minimize it) and can only check in a few times a day, anyway. Things like Martial Training are perfect for me.
Some people have to work for a living doing a job that requires that they pay attention and not mess around with their mobile devices, also, it's useful for the last job of the evening before you go to sleep.
If there is a crafting method that works better for you then by all means use it :P
Well just to make sure, does 80 xp is greater than 40 xp or my math sucks?
Great there's an app, but it happens i have to sleep for a period longer than 2 hours, i know i'm lazy, don't laugh at me. It happens that i'm working too (actually 5 days a week, strangely enough) and i can't watch my mobile at every hour or so, my boss is a monster he wants me to work while at my the job instead of letting me levelling my Leadership profession.
I know, right? sheesh, some people just ask too much. :P
Side note, is it a bug that Chart Region gives a Bill of Sale as a reward? You think it'd be a District Map instead.
Task 1 - 6 hours - 3 silver, 40 leadership xp
Task 2 - 2 hours - 1 silver, 40 leadership xp, 200 astral diamonds, 75 exp
Now try and tell me that's not seriously messed up...
At level 60 is where the zen/AD sink is at. The sooner you hit 60 the bigger the chance you start buying something. Its just marketing.
I'm not in the habit of setting my alarm to wake me up every 2 hours during the night so I can log on Gateway and refresh my leadership tasks.
We don't all intend on downloading an app and grinding professions all day. Some of us play once a day and will simply pick whichever task works best with our schedule
What level are they? Because Protect Caravan is lv4. (Me, when I want to put up a 6 hour project, I do Battle Undead. But that's a lv11.)