Trading Reviews/Feedback

skratchx · May 2013

Hey guys,
Just finished my 2nd Foundry quest, hoping to trade some Reviews/Feedback. Gonna be leveling up my GWF so I'll have plenty of time to play other's quests.

Just post your foundry code in here, as well as the name that I should look for on the reviews.

I don't do well with reading blocks of text, so please keep feedback in a summarized/bulleted format, thanks so much guys.

NW-DQLT4ER2H
Trials of Atlantis

10-15 Minutes
Maps created from empty ocean layout
Standard Difficulty
Intended for solo play
Took roughly 15-20 hours to design and create

If you have any questions about anything, feel free to include in your post and I'll respond as soon as possible.

Thanks again everyone,
Skratch

duskdweller78 · May 2013

Check my sign

skratchx · May 2013

Starting your quest now, should have some feedback for you in little bit

Ill pay attention to the dialogue to try and help with the language barrier too

Make sure you check out mine!

snowballo · May 2013

I finished my 1st Foundry earlier but since it doesn't show up outside of my code its hard to get some feedback.
It is an arena made to adjust the challenge to the players liking. Hope you can check it out.
I ll be playing yours in about 10-20 min from now, thanks in advance.
I ll review yours as Snow@snowballo

My code: NW-DMT7STJ9E

duskdweller78 · May 2013

skratchx wrote: »

Starting your quest now, should have some feedback for you in little bit Ill pay attention to the dialogue to try and help with the language barrier too

Make sure you check out mine!

Sure, I already got your quest, but I'm fixing a couple of things in my quest before starting the foundry review session

dzogen · May 2013

Pls see sig below, thanks.

skratchx · May 2013

Ok @duskdweller78 here it goes

Here are some suggestions and things I found in your quest that you might want to fix/change:

Quest "Follow the Eastern Path" --- The 1st group of monsters that appear after the chickens seemed way too difficult to solo as a melee (Even with my cleric companion).
Quest "Talk to the Frightened Bartender" --- In the first branch of dialogue, "Calm down you fool...." should be "you'd" instead of "you'll
In the Thieves Hideout --- Consider making the girl's encounter a "Submission" encounter, where she kneels after you get her to 10% instead of killing her then respawning as an npc
Invisible Wall on "Locate the Burial Chambers" --- In the dialogue with the invisible wall "together" is mispelt
The other Questing party (Pendragon) --- Consider making them "Submit" as well, instead of die
The final fight --- Consider making it a tad easier, I didn't enable hard mode, but soloing it was still difficult, and wouldve eaten all my potions if I were on a higher level character.

Accidentally exited out of the review window after the quest cause of a skype popup. Ill end up replaying it at another time to give you the review in game tho

Overall tho man, great job. Enjoyed the combat, the dialogue was witty and entertaining.
Hope this helps some,
Skratch

skratchx · May 2013

@snowballo Here it is!

Here are some suggestions and things I found in your quest that you might want to fix/change:

Quest "Melee friendly combat exp arena!" --- When interacting with the Sewer Grate to teleport it says "Press F to Talk to the Astral Guide to help you on the way. (Seems like it should say "to head to the Arena" or something else
Design of the Area --- The area design looks sort of "griddy", everything is lined up (ex. fire fx, graves, rivers,
Design of the Area --- All the teleporters see unnecessary and make the area "clunky"
Astral Guide --- The Astral guide functions seem to be working "weirdly" (Summon ogre summoned 2, summon allies didn't do anything, and clearing the ogres made them disappear, but they came out of a wall and attacked me after I walked in the arena)

*For some reason I was never asked to review your project in game, not sure if that is a known foundry bug or what

Overall man, the idea is good, but execution seems it could use a bit more TLC and tweaking. Not bad for your first, just put a little bit more time into it

Hope that helps somewhat,
Skratch

snowballo · May 2013

skratchx I played through your awesome quest, but ended up pressing W just when the review came up thus couldn't rate it.
I will defenitely play it again to give an in game review.
But here r the things I found that could be tweaked.

(I played this on a lvl 17 Guardian Fighter)

- Not a bug, but the 1st 3 guards could be made into 6, as 3 easy melee opponents die in like 1-2 seconds.

- When the fire bird spirit appears and gives you 2 options to choose from.
WhenI choose "I probably should prepare more before I continue" it actually continued the quest and I could not talk to it again.
Either remove this option of choice or let this option not progress the quest.

- Once again not a bug, but the 2 guards that come before Aethyn are harder than Aethyn.
While the effects of Aethyn make the fight feel like it should be harder.
That once could either use minions or be some harder enemy.

- After Aethyn when you have to loot the "Dagger of the Sly" it's actually very hard to get in a position where it is clickable.
This might be because my Half Elf is rather small, but it would make it easier if it was placed somewhere lower or even more to the edge of the fountain.

All with all, the look and feel of the map is amazing.
The quest is well written and I really enjoyed playing through it.
Amazing job there!

duskdweller78 · May 2013

skratchx wrote: »

Ok @duskdweller78 here it goes

Here are some suggestions and things I found in your quest that you might want to fix/change:
Quest "Follow the Eastern Path" --- The 1st group of monsters that appear after the chickens seemed way too difficult to solo as a melee (Even with my cleric companion).

Quest "Talk to the Frightened Bartender" --- In the first branch of dialogue, "Calm down you fool...." should be "you'd" instead of "you'll

In the Thieves Hideout --- Consider making the girl's encounter a "Submission" encounter, where she kneels after you get her to 10% instead of killing her then respawning as an npc

Invisible Wall on "Locate the Burial Chambers" --- In the dialogue with the invisible wall "together" is mispelt

The other Questing party (Pendragon) --- Consider making them "Submit" as well, instead of die

The final fight --- Consider making it a tad easier, I didn't enable hard mode, but soloing it was still difficult, and wouldve eaten all my potions if I were on a higher level character.

Accidentally exited out of the review window after the quest cause of a skype popup. Ill end up replaying it at another time to give you the review in game tho

Overall tho man, great job. Enjoyed the combat, the dialogue was witty and entertaining.
Hope this helps some,
Skratch

Thanks for the feedback, I just published the update and I'm going to try your quest

About the submit thing, I had some instances of enemies starting to beat the HAMSTER out of the submitting character, that's why I removed it from both encounters

Which class/level is your char?

gavell1 · May 2013

Wayward Ruins: NW-DMBDJAWAV
Author: @Gavell1
Solo or 2 players
20-30 Minutes

Thanks

skratchx · May 2013

@snowballo Thanks man really appreciate the feedback, gonna work on getting fixes in on those things you brought up, definitely valid ideas/concerns

@duskdweller78 Hope you enjoy it, the character I played it on was a 19 GWF. Generally my best solo character.

eulerdmoogle · May 2013

A small dwarvish grudge: NW-DUI8A8I7R
Author name: @cphonx
Solo
about 20 min.
Story and combat. Some humor.

duskdweller78 · May 2013

I liked your quest, it was short but it's really a great original idea!

Quest feedback:
I think Aethyn is a bit underpowered, he was too easy compared to the rest (I tested with a level 45 GF)
There was something odd with Paug's behaviour, he kept standing a bit behind the other golem and didn't perform any attack until I deliberately moved near him (my companion was just beside him). Did you use AI nodes?
Moreover I think you should move the respawn point in the room just before this encounter.

I'll wait your ingame review :P

geoff873 · May 2013

Will give your quest a go next time I'm on.

Here's mine.

The Tomb of Valkere
ID: NW-DOA69HDRT
@geoff8733

skratchx · May 2013

@snowballo due to your feedback here are the changes that were made:

Added archers to the first encounter
Cthael spirit dialogue has been fixed
Added wolves to the Aethyn encounter
Moved the Dagger of the Sly to a more easily obtainable spot

Thanks again for the feedback!

@duskdweller78 here are the changes that your feedback contributed to:

Added wolves to the Aethyn encounter
Fixed an issue that was keeping the Golem Brothers from moving

As for the respawn point moving, I can't really move it, just because if for some reason a person dies at the first or second encounter, it would be a spoiler or sorts, and make them backtrack to get to where they died. Thanks again for the feedback tho!

Thanks guys,
- Skratch

skratchx · May 2013

Version 0.2 BETA has been posted with the above changes.

duskdweller78 · May 2013

Hmmm the respawn point should only activate when the player reaches it

skratchx · May 2013

@duskdweller78 where will they respawn if they don't have the point? The original spawn point? Didn't even think about that mechanic.

skratchx · May 2013

Ok @dzogen just played your quest.

Honestly man, one of the funnest quests I've played yet. The humor honestly made it feel like I wasn't even questing, you did an amazing job!

docbach · May 2013

Unholy Matrimony
@DocBach
NW-DPYM52476

hopping on to knock your quest out asap

skratchx · May 2013

@gavell1 Just about to start yours now

phantomrave · May 2013

Nevermore Act I: The ritual
@phantomrave
NW-DPH3M69IO

It's a very plot driven quest, I'm curious about balance and interested in rooting out typo's and what not. If anyone else wants to do a review4review then inbox me your quests and I'll be happy to try them out and give both a rebview on Foundry and a more detailed personal review while I await feedback.

skratchx · May 2013

Ok @gavell1 here it is

Here are some suggestions and things I found in your quest that you might want to fix/change:

Quest Description --- "You feel for her lose" should be "loss".
Quest "Find and speak with the survivor" --- Typo in dialogue "Their dead" should be "They're dead".
Quest "Find and speak with the survivor" --- Typo in dialogue "I feel for your lose" should be "loss".
Zone Wayward Ruins --- Consider moving the campfire further away from the stone block, the effect ring runs onto the block and looks weird.
Ecounter setup --- Consider moving around each individual in each encounter, to make them look more random than just placed.
Quest setup --- Consider creating the boss kill a separate quest from just the "Kill any other undead you run into", it lets the player know they're finishing the map.
Costumes --- Not sure if this was meant to be, but your Lord guy has the Skeleton archer skin, and one of your archer's has the Wright Commander skin (Think they got switched around).

All in all, I like the idea of the quest. It feels alot like an xp grind/heavy combat map, with a quest spin on it, and I like the idea of that (Almost like a dungeon setup, but outside of a dungeon)

Keep working on it,
- Skratch

docbach · May 2013

I like the scenery, and I loved your use of effects like the earthquakes. Would like to see you expand your Atlantis with an actual story driven quest.

skratchx · May 2013

It is in the plans to expand the quest to be a full 15 minute quest, so it will be suitable for the Daily Foundry. Also just moved the plate closer to the edge, should address your issue.

skratchx · May 2013

Ok @eulerdmoogle here's the report

Here are some suggestions and things I found in your quest that you might want to fix/change:

A small problem --- Dialogue with Merchants Guild Rep "Greetins" assuming you forgot the "g", otherwise if this is meant to sound like lingo, ignore lol.
A small problem --- Dialogue with Merchants Guild Rep "Gaddi as the paperwork" assuming its a type on "has".
A small problem --- Dialogue with Merchants Guild Rep "I can't imagine him deliberately willing to anger..." grammar issue, maybe replace "willing" with "wanting".
Metalsmith Courtyard zone design --- Clear blue skies, but thunder sounds, don't work well together.
Metalsmith Courtyard sounds --- Consider adding chicken sounds around the chickens.
Quest "Enter Gaddi's Metalworks --- Door is very hard to target without LoS issues, also change the "interact text" from the standard "Go to the next map".
End of quest --- For some reason, when I went through the portal back to Protector's Enclave, the quest was gone, and I never got my reward. Something to look into.

The story was interesting and cool. Was hoping to get to find out the ending, but the bug ended the quest early. Other than those few things tho, the quest had a great premise, enjoyed it!

Keep it up,
Skratch

dzogen · May 2013

Thanks man, I appreciate it. I'll get by to reviewing yours tonight mate

skratchx wrote: »

Ok @dzogen just played your quest.

Honestly man, one of the funnest quests I've played yet. The humor honestly made it feel like I wasn't even questing, you did an amazing job!

skratchx · May 2013

Ok @geoff873 here's my feedback

Here are some suggestions and things I found in your quest that you might want to fix/change:

Quest "Talk to serving girl" --- Grammar issue in quest name "Talk to serving girl" should be "a serving girl" or "the serving girl"
Quest "Discover Ruins" --- Grammar issue in quest name again, i'd suggest "Discover the Ruins"

Other than those 2 things, it was a solid quest. Enjoyed the whole Mummy sort of feeling, it was neat.

Hope that helps somewhat

Skratch

skratchx · May 2013

Im out for tonight, I'll finish up tomorrow, as well as anyone else who posts here

Please don't forget to review mine as well guys,

Thanks,
Skratch

snowballo · May 2013

Thanks for your feedback Skratch.
Not sure how the npc/encounters ended up that broken during your run (according to the quest name, somehow it loaded up my old version which was a save while I was working on the dialogs)
In my own live trials they worked quite as intended though.

I did an overhaul to the looks now, making it much more one piece and natural.
Will be working more on all aspects once I got more time, for sure.

I am not entirely sure to how to change the quest objective before entering the map, but will figure that one out later.

Would appreciate if you could check it out one more time at some point and see if the npcs still behave this bad.

Trading Reviews/Feedback

Comments