especially for an empire depicted with that level of technology we see them with - and even AFTER losing the world heart, it still shouldn't have been an impediment
Yeah it's a common sci-fi trope of having only one copy of critical data.... Data people would keep triply redundant backups of IRL. Or in the case of the Iconians one per Iconian. I suppose one could argue extreme hubris. Or maybe the bombardment blew up the backups...
especially for an empire depicted with that level of technology we see them with - and even AFTER losing the world heart, it still shouldn't have been an impediment
Yeah it's a common sci-fi trope of having only one copy of critical data.... Data people would keep triply redundant backups of IRL. Or in the case of the Iconians one per Iconian. I suppose one could argue extreme hubris. Or maybe the bombardment blew up the backups...
Considering that we know for a fact only 12 Iconians made out alive from the bombardment, "bombardment blew up the backups" doesn't seem that odd (or maybe the World Heart was a backup but the only backup they could get to safety).
Discovery's going well beyond established events. The latest canon we know of is the 29th Century, with the USS Relativity. Easily enough time between that and the 33rd or 32nd for something major to take place.
Ain't Daniels from the 31st century?
That is correct, seemed like the federation existed in Daniel's version of the 31st century and they finally perfected time travel too, season 3 of Discovery takes place in the 32nd century, I'm more curious about what happened to the federation between the 31st century and the 32nd century, I like to know how the Federation fell apart in the span of a 100 years.
Maybe they got cracked like a whip with paradox out on that end of the timeline which caused civilization to implode on a wide scale or something. And logically, it cannot just be the Federation that collapsed, or the Klingons, Romulans, or some other border-neighbor would have simply annexed it. It would have to be something widespread like the plague that wiped out the Kalandans to cause that kind of Mad Max situation (assuming there is one, the trailers could be misleading).
L'Miren also said that with the World Heart, they could rebuild.
I don't think she was just referring to their planet. Given that their population was not at all or barely growing (like one new Iconian every few centuries) for a long time when the bombardment happened, she must have also been referring to the demographic component of recovering from that attack. Because she knew that had suddenly become a vulnerability, if it hadn't already been.
She also only said that there were 12 of them left, nothing specific about them not being able to reproduce. Which would seem like too important a fact to leave out if you're taking your time to lament the loss of the others while you could be shot at any moment.
If they're going to destroy the Federation and make it such that only a few worlds remain, nothing of STO's storyline of protecting the Federation, building the Khitomer Alliance and possibly even the Galactic Union, will have mattered much in the end.
You're assuming that STO is considered Canon. As far as I am aware, only one element was adopted, the Odyssey Class, as seen in the tie in comic as the USS Verity.
Discovery despite the claims of Picard, seems more in the Driving Seat, to write history for the Future, well at least the more Distant one; we came to know from Voyager, with 29th Temporal Alliance Fleet with Walker. So I'm really curious to know how they resolve that paradox, or if they are rewriting the future completely?
Discovery's going well beyond established events. The latest canon we know of is the 29th Century, with the USS Relativity. Easily enough time between that and the 33rd or 32nd for something major to take place.
You forget Daniels is from the 31st century...going from a massive power that patrols time to a complete lawless meltdown in just a century give or take is a little hard to believe to be honest
But when has continuity or canon ever bothered them? lol
Can't have a honest conversation because of a white knight with power
Except this is completely inaccurate, as its already been confirmed that the Federation still exists in the time of Discovery S3, its just reduced in size. There has been nothing saying it a complete lawless hellhole.
It was practically a lawless hellhole in Picard...or did you forget Seven was part of a group of vigilantes protecting people? Former Borg being kidnapped and harvested...including Starfleet officers. Neutral zone non-existent...massive Romulan fleet in Federation space...Starfleet security infiltrated by Romulans.
The Federation had fallen apart...Discovery crew being chased by people with arm cannons...needs God Queen Commander Burnham to save them
But I keep forgetting who I'm talking to...I'm surprised your avatar doesn't have Borg implants.
Can't have a honest conversation because of a white knight with power
Except this is completely inaccurate, as its already been confirmed that the Federation still exists in the time of Discovery S3, its just reduced in size. There has been nothing saying it a complete lawless hellhole.
Ehm, did you actually watch the trailer for season 3?
An Iconian f(r)action would be interesting...but a lot of brainstorming would have to be done. Perhaps copies of the Lobi/Lockbox ships/gear with the "Midnight" pastel aesthetic, auto unlock of the Vest pieces. Unique species traits: Iconian Genetic Reengineering (decreased Antiproton resistance rating+Antiproton damage bonus), Dark Matter Manipulation (large bonus to control resistance)?
An Iconian f(r)action would be interesting...but a lot of brainstorming would have to be done. Perhaps copies of the Lobi/Lockbox ships/gear with the "Midnight" pastel aesthetic, auto unlock of the Vest pieces. Unique species traits: Iconian Genetic Reengineering (decreased Antiproton resistance rating+Antiproton damage bonus), Dark Matter Manipulation (large bonus to control resistance)?
Copies of the ships would be fine I think.
If needed without the traits or perhaps a less potent version of those and the consoles, which are quite good in the case of the Vonph and Baltim raider I'd say.
These ships don't seem very popular so I don't think it would cause much offense to players who bought them when they were expensive.
And of course there's still the ancient design (think it was called the Apex?) that we could see in one of the episodes before it was updated. That, and their dreadnoughts were never released to players.
So that already makes five ships. Maybe they could then also release a new T6 Dyson ship pack that players have been asking for, including Iconian variants. Or make one (or three) ships, based on elements of both the Dyson designs, faction-specific elements and some Iconian tech that can then be used by all factions like they did with the Carrier bundle and the Edison and associated ships.
An Iconian f(r)action would be interesting...but a lot of brainstorming would have to be done. Perhaps copies of the Lobi/Lockbox ships/gear with the "Midnight" pastel aesthetic, auto unlock of the Vest pieces. Unique species traits: Iconian Genetic Reengineering (decreased Antiproton resistance rating+Antiproton damage bonus), Dark Matter Manipulation (large bonus to control resistance)?
Copies of the ships would be fine I think.
If needed without the traits or perhaps a less potent version of those and the consoles, which are quite good in the case of the Vonph and Baltim raider I'd say.
These ships don't seem very popular so I don't think it would cause much offense to players who bought them when they were expensive.
And of course there's still the ancient design (think it was called the Apex?) that we could see in one of the episodes before it was updated. That, and their dreadnoughts were never released to players.
So that already makes five ships. Maybe they could then also release a new T6 Dyson ship pack that players have been asking for, including Iconian variants. Or make one (or three) ships, based on elements of both the Dyson designs, faction-specific elements and some Iconian tech that can then be used by all factions like they did with the Carrier bundle and the Edison and associated ships.
A good way to flesh out servitors and have a return to Romulan content
An Iconian f(r)action would be interesting...but a lot of brainstorming would have to be done. Perhaps copies of the Lobi/Lockbox ships/gear with the "Midnight" pastel aesthetic, auto unlock of the Vest pieces. Unique species traits: Iconian Genetic Reengineering (decreased Antiproton resistance rating+Antiproton damage bonus), Dark Matter Manipulation (large bonus to control resistance)?
Copies of the ships would be fine I think.
If needed without the traits or perhaps a less potent version of those and the consoles, which are quite good in the case of the Vonph and Baltim raider I'd say.
These ships don't seem very popular so I don't think it would cause much offense to players who bought them when they were expensive.
And of course there's still the ancient design (think it was called the Apex?) that we could see in one of the episodes before it was updated. That, and their dreadnoughts were never released to players.
So that already makes five ships. Maybe they could then also release a new T6 Dyson ship pack that players have been asking for, including Iconian variants. Or make one (or three) ships, based on elements of both the Dyson designs, faction-specific elements and some Iconian tech that can then be used by all factions like they did with the Carrier bundle and the Edison and associated ships.
A good way to flesh out the Solanae a bit more, and return to Romulan content, perhaps.
They never made playable Deferi, sadly. The aliengen copies are unable to actually represent the Deferi we see in the game, because some aliengen-parts are sex-restricted for some reason.
^ Memory Alpha.org is not canon. It's a open wiki with arbitrary rules. Only what can be cited from an episode is. ^
"No. Men do not roar. Women roar. Then they hurl heavy objects... and claw at you." -Worf, son of Mogh
"A filthy, mangy beast, but in its bony breast beat the heart of a warrior" - "faithful" (...) "but ever-ready to follow the call of the wild." - Martok, about a Targ
"That pig smelled horrid. A sweet-sour, extremely pungent odor. I showered and showered, and it took me a week to get rid of it!" - Robert Justman, appreciating Emmy-Lou
The section 31 illusion device already lets your players use models for some un-playable species including Tholian, Hurq, Na'kul, etc.
I can confirm that although these models are in-game, they can prevent you from interacting with some game mechanics. For example, models that cannot kneel are unable to loot Horga'hns in the Risa Horga'hn event because they cannot do the kneel animation. I'm sure there are other actions broken as well. They could be fixed, it may just be matter of coding to allow action to complete without animation, or adding the animations to game. Obviously a Na'kuhl character would be easier to animate than something like a Tholian. There are plenty of humanoid species in Trek that have not been made playable characters, including some species that are members of the federation.
Other stuff is broken as well...for example, Hurq on a surfboard constantly shows you as being underwater even though surfboard is above water.
I'm still waiting for playable Tribble race
Fear a tribble (with no arms no less!) wielding a tommy-gun!
Lack of limbs does not dis-allow combat -- as proof, watch any of the sequels to Attack of the Killer Tomatoes, where the tomatoes wreak havok despite having same number of limbs as tribbles!
It was practically a lawless hellhole in Picard...or did you forget Seven was part of a group of vigilantes protecting people? Former Borg being kidnapped and harvested...including Starfleet officers. Neutral zone non-existent...massive Romulan fleet in Federation space...Starfleet security infiltrated by Romulans.
Literally everything you stated happened in previous Trek series also.
Cases in point
The Maquies Resistance in the Cardassian Delimitarized Zone
The constant infiltration of Starfleet by forces like the Bluegill
The Federation constantly having its borders breached by everything from V'ger and the Whoale Probe, to the Klingons and Dominion
Everything that happen in Picard is typical day to day in Trek.
A good way to flesh out the Solanae a bit more, and return to Romulan content, perhaps.
I do hope that in some way we could have more content as a side benefit with a larger assortment of playable species for use.
"There is iron in your words of death for all Comanche to see, and so there is iron in your words of life. No signed paper can hold the iron. It must come from men. The words of Ten Bears carries the same iron of life and death. It is good that warriors such as we meet in the struggle of life... or death. It shall be life." - Ten Bears (Will Sampson)
Except those other series were never about one character.
Nor is Discovery, unless you are saying Burnham built the spore drive the whole series revolves around?
Guess who decided that the Tardigrade could no longer be used? And who was the first person to replace it?
Moreover, the series doesn't revolve around the spore drive.
That's like saying that TNG revolved around the warp core. It's an instrument to get them where they need to be for the story. And the story is almost always revolving around 'her'.
The section 31 illusion device already lets your players use models for some un-playable species including Tholian, Hurq, Na'kul, etc.
I can confirm that although these models are in-game, they can prevent you from interacting with some game mechanics. For example, models that cannot kneel are unable to loot Horga'hns in the Risa Horga'hn event because they cannot do the kneel animation. I'm sure there are other actions broken as well. They could be fixed, it may just be matter of coding to allow action to complete without animation, or adding the animations to game. Obviously a Na'kuhl character would be easier to animate than something like a Tholian. There are plenty of humanoid species in Trek that have not been made playable characters, including some species that are members of the federation.
Other stuff is broken as well...for example, Hurq on a surfboard constantly shows you as being underwater even though surfboard is above water.
I'm still waiting for playable Tribble race
Fear a tribble (with no arms no less!) wielding a tommy-gun!
Lack of limbs does not dis-allow combat -- as proof, watch any of the sequels to Attack of the Killer Tomatoes, where the tomatoes wreak havok despite having same number of limbs as tribbles!
That is more in line to my thinking as well. I do think there are some other options that can be implemented in missions that could solve the animation problem with some species.
"There is iron in your words of death for all Comanche to see, and so there is iron in your words of life. No signed paper can hold the iron. It must come from men. The words of Ten Bears carries the same iron of life and death. It is good that warriors such as we meet in the struggle of life... or death. It shall be life." - Ten Bears (Will Sampson)
The section 31 illusion device already lets your players use models for some un-playable species including Tholian, Hurq, Na'kul, etc.
I can confirm that although these models are in-game, they can prevent you from interacting with some game mechanics. For example, models that cannot kneel are unable to loot Horga'hns in the Risa Horga'hn event because they cannot do the kneel animation. I'm sure there are other actions broken as well. They could be fixed, it may just be matter of coding to allow action to complete without animation, or adding the animations to game. Obviously a Na'kuhl character would be easier to animate than something like a Tholian. There are plenty of humanoid species in Trek that have not been made playable characters, including some species that are members of the federation.
Other stuff is broken as well...for example, Hurq on a surfboard constantly shows you as being underwater even though surfboard is above water.
I'm still waiting for playable Tribble race
Fear a tribble (with no arms no less!) wielding a tommy-gun!
Lack of limbs does not dis-allow combat -- as proof, watch any of the sequels to Attack of the Killer Tomatoes, where the tomatoes wreak havok despite having same number of limbs as tribbles!
That is more in line to my thinking as well. I do think there are some other options that can be implemented in missions that could solve the animation problem with some species.
idk
I'd like to see the Thompson reclaimable multiple times, as well as the other currently unique ground weapons.
Comments
My character Tsin'xing
Considering that we know for a fact only 12 Iconians made out alive from the bombardment, "bombardment blew up the backups" doesn't seem that odd (or maybe the World Heart was a backup but the only backup they could get to safety).
Maybe they got cracked like a whip with paradox out on that end of the timeline which caused civilization to implode on a wide scale or something. And logically, it cannot just be the Federation that collapsed, or the Klingons, Romulans, or some other border-neighbor would have simply annexed it. It would have to be something widespread like the plague that wiped out the Kalandans to cause that kind of Mad Max situation (assuming there is one, the trailers could be misleading).
I don't think she was just referring to their planet. Given that their population was not at all or barely growing (like one new Iconian every few centuries) for a long time when the bombardment happened, she must have also been referring to the demographic component of recovering from that attack. Because she knew that had suddenly become a vulnerability, if it hadn't already been.
She also only said that there were 12 of them left, nothing specific about them not being able to reproduce. Which would seem like too important a fact to leave out if you're taking your time to lament the loss of the others while you could be shot at any moment.
You forget Daniels is from the 31st century...going from a massive power that patrols time to a complete lawless meltdown in just a century give or take is a little hard to believe to be honest
But when has continuity or canon ever bothered them? lol
It was practically a lawless hellhole in Picard...or did you forget Seven was part of a group of vigilantes protecting people? Former Borg being kidnapped and harvested...including Starfleet officers. Neutral zone non-existent...massive Romulan fleet in Federation space...Starfleet security infiltrated by Romulans.
The Federation had fallen apart...Discovery crew being chased by people with arm cannons...needs God Queen Commander Burnham to save them
But I keep forgetting who I'm talking to...I'm surprised your avatar doesn't have Borg implants.
Ehm, did you actually watch the trailer for season 3?
Things don't look exactly rosy.
We can already create Xindi-Primates since their uniforms, hairstyle and forehead details are available. I've also seen Lukari players walking around.
So I'd prefer if they focussed on Kelpiens and the other do-able Xindi species.
Tal'Shiar/Reman Resistance/Romulan Nemesis uniform, pls.
https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7403/13262502435_5604548f2c_o.png
Copies of the ships would be fine I think.
If needed without the traits or perhaps a less potent version of those and the consoles, which are quite good in the case of the Vonph and Baltim raider I'd say.
These ships don't seem very popular so I don't think it would cause much offense to players who bought them when they were expensive.
And of course there's still the ancient design (think it was called the Apex?) that we could see in one of the episodes before it was updated. That, and their dreadnoughts were never released to players.
So that already makes five ships. Maybe they could then also release a new T6 Dyson ship pack that players have been asking for, including Iconian variants. Or make one (or three) ships, based on elements of both the Dyson designs, faction-specific elements and some Iconian tech that can then be used by all factions like they did with the Carrier bundle and the Edison and associated ships.
A good way to flesh out servitors and have a return to Romulan content
Tal'Shiar/Reman Resistance/Romulan Nemesis uniform, pls.
https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7403/13262502435_5604548f2c_o.png
A good way to flesh out the Solanae a bit more, and return to Romulan content, perhaps.
Tal'Shiar/Reman Resistance/Romulan Nemesis uniform, pls.
https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7403/13262502435_5604548f2c_o.png
Get the Forums Enhancement Extension!
I can confirm that although these models are in-game, they can prevent you from interacting with some game mechanics. For example, models that cannot kneel are unable to loot Horga'hns in the Risa Horga'hn event because they cannot do the kneel animation. I'm sure there are other actions broken as well. They could be fixed, it may just be matter of coding to allow action to complete without animation, or adding the animations to game. Obviously a Na'kuhl character would be easier to animate than something like a Tholian. There are plenty of humanoid species in Trek that have not been made playable characters, including some species that are members of the federation.
Other stuff is broken as well...for example, Hurq on a surfboard constantly shows you as being underwater even though surfboard is above water.
I'm still waiting for playable Tribble race
Fear a tribble (with no arms no less!) wielding a tommy-gun!
Lack of limbs does not dis-allow combat -- as proof, watch any of the sequels to Attack of the Killer Tomatoes, where the tomatoes wreak havok despite having same number of limbs as tribbles!
https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/euphemism
The Federation being under siege is quite different from it being basically dead. Only so that 'she' can save us all.
Except those other series were never about one character.
Garak was as much responsible for bringing the Romulans in as Sisko was. Odo and Kira were instrumental in making the Cardassians switch sides.
Enterprise (NX-01) wouldn't even be flying anymore if it weren't for T'Pol and Dr. Phlox.
To give just two examples of why your comment is nonsense.
I do hope that in some way we could have more content as a side benefit with a larger assortment of playable species for use.
Guess who decided that the Tardigrade could no longer be used? And who was the first person to replace it?
Moreover, the series doesn't revolve around the spore drive.
That's like saying that TNG revolved around the warp core. It's an instrument to get them where they need to be for the story. And the story is almost always revolving around 'her'.
That is more in line to my thinking as well. I do think there are some other options that can be implemented in missions that could solve the animation problem with some species.
idk
I'd like to see the Thompson reclaimable multiple times, as well as the other currently unique ground weapons.
Tal'Shiar/Reman Resistance/Romulan Nemesis uniform, pls.
https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7403/13262502435_5604548f2c_o.png