Design Your Ship Round 1 [Alpha VS Beta]

krabstarr

#TeamBeta

I wish we had a couple other views of the designs.
In any case, I went with Beta. I'm intrigued by the pylons. They look to be coming off of the pod which is above the main hull section. The saucer shape is also interesting and different. If this is going to be a carrier, I'd go for a more bulky look. This isn't supposed to be sleek and sexy, it's supposed arrive and drop off the kids.

zaph0dd

#TeamBeta

Beta, because it looks like a horseshoe crab

sunfrancks

#TeamBeta

Team Beta here.

No contest really...

imthe13thdoctor

#TeamAlpha

I like the top down look on Alpha but am not so wild about the side view. I despise the top down ultra wide view on Beta but like the side view a lot more than Alpha. I had to go with Alpha because Beta's dorsal view is just to ugly to build.

ynrocjd

#TeamAlpha

Saucer: Alpha
Hull: Beta
Nacelles: Beta
Pylons: Alpha
Strut: Alpha

So I give Alpha a shot

cuchulainn74

#TeamBeta

For me, it's just got to be Beta. For crying out loud, Alpha's profile looks like a cruise ship with nacelles. [engage friendly banter detectors] You Alpha folks aren't really bad. You're just wrong. [disengage banter detection]

uilar1bergon

#TeamAlpha

Alpha. Althought Beta's hull is better looking.

psiameese

#TeamAlpha

Team Alpha.

I like four nacelles. Although, I don't care for one set being smaller than the other set. Unless the ship has dual-vector capability. I can't imagine a carrier reflecting that. So four nacelles to identical scale if the design gets that far along.

gl94

#TeamBeta

I like the sleek profile of Beta! Not a fan of the saucer though. Id like to see a hybrid of Beta and Theta...

Alpha, which looks like the "Jupiter Class" is not doing it for me at all.

artan42

#TeamAlpha

Alpha, it looks nicer. It's no Omega but it's nice. Plus it has a wide hull and 4 nacelles so it looks more like a carrier than Beta.​​

thomaselkins

#TeamAlpha

I like both ships, but I voted Alpha.

gpgtx

#TeamBeta

beta mostly for the saucer

birdwar552

#TeamBeta

Beta. Way too many quad nacelle ships coming out. It also has a bit of a Nebula/Galaxy look to it (which is nice)

colemanstrykr

#TeamAlpha

Unless this ship is bloody huge and has a detachable saucer section, I don't particularly like the big ovoid fore-hull design. The multiple nacells close to the hull are also nice.

PSY

shineshadow

#TeamAlpha

Alpha. Beta's saucer is a nightmare.

kintisho

#TeamAlpha

Typhon - look it up, closest thing to a canon large dedicated role carrier in the Federation

worfdaddy

#TeamAlpha

Just for the saucer section and hull. The four nacelles don't do it. Now if you put the Beta nacelles on it that would be the best one.

dkeith2011

#TeamBeta

Voted for Beta simply because it was the least bad of the 2 options.

qjunior

#TeamAlpha

I like both the Alpha and Gamma designs, so in this poll, Beta is out.

tolmarius

Omega was the best of the lot. But Alpha is better than Beta

bioixi

#TeamAlpha

If all models are already done, why not give us the opportunity to use any model or part we want?

freakium

#TeamBeta

Beta because it looks like it can actually carry a hangar full of shuttles/fighters.

sharpie65

#TeamAlpha

Alpha, just because I prefer the spearhead/triangular style of saucer compared to the large Beta design...it looks too much like one of the Heavy Cruiser variants.

farmallm

#TeamBeta

Beta for me. I like the more traditional saucer. You need space to store the fighters and all the equipment to keep them going.

hartzilla

#TeamAlpha

I liked Alpha more.

farshore

#TeamBeta

I don't like the mission pod on the Beta, but it's otherwise what I want in a carrier.

vawlkus

#TeamAlpha

I think we have enough Prometheus variants already, but I am dead set against a heavy bottomed ship like the Beta idea.

Voted Alpha

bunansa

#TeamAlpha

Alpha looks like it has the mission pod from the nebula up top, and nebula is spiffy...so its alpha so far

awesometific

#TeamBeta

#TeamBeta. I like the rounder saucer and only two nacelles. Have the fighters launch from the bottom center line so the saucer can help sheild during launch.

aesica

#TeamAlpha

Beta's saucer looks like it got smushed and I think it looks awkward. Alpha, on the other hand, looks nice and sleek enough that I would be proud rather than embarrassed to be seen in one.