A deceptive practice is deceptive if one person does it or if everyone does it. The principle does not depend on the popularity of the scheme. Your argument is invalid.
What you win is the inability of the studio (or its zealous defenders) to pull out "open beta" as an excuse for the state of the game. I have paid for my pack. I want this game to succeed. I want NWO to be a great game, and part of that is having the integrity to own up to the problems, rather than hide behind an "open…
An MMO is never done? Bugs, balance, new content means continuous patching until the doors close. On the other hand, "Open Beta until the servers shut down!" sounds like a great rallying cry for this situation.
Let's do a thought experiment. Player 1: Hey guys, I just found this really weird bug! Could you try it out and see if you can reproduce it? I am writing a report now, but if more people can do it, it would probably help them fix it. Player 2-N: Sure, okay! Wow, that would totally ruin the economy if it was kept in the…
Anyone who used the AH/AD exploit is being banned. Reproducing and documenting a major bug like that is one of the duties of a tester. I will repeat: Reproducing and documenting a major, game breaking bug is EXACTLY what a tester is supposed to do in any phase of beta. If this was a known issue that they wanted people to…
This is the real point, as succinctly as it will ever be written. When "testers" are banned for reproducing a bug, they aren't testers. When beta characters/resources/economy won't be removed before release, they aren't beta. When money is actively changing hands, it is a product. Sleep on, my friends, if it makes you…
"Neverwinter is in Open Beta and there is no indication that this is not true. If a beta tester deliberately sabotages the testing of a beta product they would loose their testing privileges..." Sleep on, friend. You will not be happier when you wake.
Are you cleverly highlighting the fact that "Open Beta" isn't really a beta at all? Or are you just coming to that realization, awakening with dread to the truth that has been lurking all along?