Achievement unlocked : EPIC FAIL! Anyway, this topic looks like a good idea, but what can make us think that any of the solutions proposed here are going to be seriously tested by the devs?
man! This is nice try to elude all the arguments posted here and there to demonstrate that the only d&d taste of this game comes from the name and logo! You are trying very hard to distract people from the sad truth : THIS IS NOT D & D No, not even close, despite the name and the logo. please, for example, explain to those…
So, resuming this thread : This is d&d. It has a d&d logo, wotc approves, so this is d&d. If you don't agree that this is d&d, based on your knowledge of the pnp games, editions, etc., then you are stupid. Despite your expectations of such a great licence, the only way the devs could make a game with d&d was this awesome…
Why neverwinter will be a fail : 1) f2p cashshop 2) just another random heroic fantasy themepark that could as well has been called "the chronicles of jobob" 3) as a random themepark, must fight to attract players and keep them from all the f2p or ppm themepark on the market, some of them beeing really interesting with…
bad propaganda no argumentation attacking the people and not what they say Most of the disappointed people here are exactly the opposite of what you pretend they are. The are true AD&D "nerd" playerbase, and were waiting for a mmo more respectfull of the logo d&d and the neverwinter name. And let me say that I firmly…
For what i've had the opportunity to play so far i am not really attracted, and won't buy any pack for now. But i'll keep an eye on this game, just in case...
i don't want to help the feedback of this game, I want this forum to be something else than a fanboys congratulations party. Lots of people are going to visit this forum to make up their mind about the game and the possibility of buying a pack, and they deserve at least some differents points of views. Since I've been…
sorry mate but it is not a matter of me buying this game or not (i already made myself clear about it), no, it is all about debating about this game beeing d&d or not. anyway... Let's take the chocolate again, ok? i love chocolate, and it has been a long time, very long time since i haven't eaten a good one. Then I see an…
so you tell us this is chocolate ice cream, but we realize that it is coffe in fact and disagree, then you tell us that even if you had added some chocolate into it we still would disagree? salesman of the year! this game will fail not because it is not d&d but because it is just another random heroic fantasy themepark…
it is a shame but it is not my point if a random rpg comes out with the 4e ed rules but don't ever mention d&d and wotc, they will surely be suited. so d&d is a ruleset and whatever, there were millions of ways to make a game with a better d&d flavor, and it didn't happen, why? I believe the eyes of the developpment team…
this is not d&d and your version is wrong this is a random themepark without flavor, with a d&d / neverwinter stamp on it to attract lost nostalgic gamers. and the "vast majority" of the biased people here trying to convince people that bladders are lanterns will certainly have left that game 6 month after release.
Lol I can't believe what i read here : so basically every mmorpg is a d&d, because it is not a matter of rules and blablabla ok? and almost everybody here applause with the two hands? poor people... Claiming that the md is always right never meant that he could totally rewrite the rules. You like football? the referee is…
yes you are right, i don't like the game no you are wrong, the game could and should have been done in another way to be more d&d players friendly, it is all a matter of development and a deliberate choice to aim young casual gamers from the xbox and manga generation. It has nothing to see with d&d exept for the label and…
gameplay between an arcade game and wow... and still tastes like a bad wow. and you forget that important detail i stated : bad. I said a bad wow. If it was at least a good wow like i would not complain that much, unfortunately it is not the case. well I'm not going to waste my time here. I assume you love that game at a…
fully instancied 60 levels = wow vanilla high damages 3 templates trees class inspired by wow : dps tank healer / war charge /combo points for rogue / etc. arena pvp tiers sets and possibly special sets for pvp in the future etc. the aimed public is the wow like players my friend, sorry if i destroyed you illusions...
man, there were millions of ways to make this game more d&d player friendly. Making it an action rpg console oriented for the casual gamers / manga generation is only a commercial choice. Cryptic and PW weren't "obliged" at all to make this game look like a bad wow.... i surely will get over it at a point that i will play…
teso without hesitation lol? :) teso isn't a wow like game with a foundator pack, only one server and crappy dungeons! teso isn't a wow like game with a d&d stamp on it teso will have a big open world and 3 factions pvp anyway, whatever teso is, it is million times better than neverwinter...
I totally agree to the OP. All the people stating that the game had to be adapted so it could be a mmo are totally biased at a point that i assume they only are fanboys. So, guys, you take a full d&d ruleset, think about an adaptation for a mmo, and the result is worst than a wow like? and everybody agrees? poor people. So…
sorry to disturb the "this game will be awesome" party here... I am an old ad&d player, right, but i am also an old mmo player, as i said before i began with nexus... As a fervent mmo player, i've seen so much mmo fail that now I know when I see one, and sorry but this game has all the components to be one of them. - A…
60 lvls? woaw! that's innovative! that's creativity! and that's total respect to the ad&d spirit! I am so dissappointed by this game!! friends told me that as soon as it was cryptic / perfect world it was going to be a fail, but still i had a certain hope... so many games behind you and still no lessons learned...
I don't know why but the end of my message cant be seen... so i finish my sentence here : At least people will prefere to pay for a polished and fun game to play to rather than spend time on a boring dej
it is already the case, i am dissapointed by what i read. I played ad&d for years since 1986, stopped at the 3e edition, and for me it was a huge world and lore to explore, not only linear dungeons, it was alignments to play and we weren't all of the same one (pvp happened a lot, yes, with characters death (yes characters…
What the point if it is exactly the same + one stat? You said 2 differents sets (please no sets T1 T2 T3 etc...) because to kill a boss is different than to kill a hero and then the pvp players can kill hero + boss? pve players will immediatly QQ (cry) saying pvp sets (please no sets T1 T2 T3 etc...) are too powerfull,…
this is no more no less than the "combo" mechanics of wow rogues, waow! i'm impress by such creativity!!! and what was a daily to make it not too powerfull can now be used in every combat : well done! Say hi to the horde of "kevin" players that are going to roll rogue to play it wow style... and prepare to say bye, coz…