test content
Logo
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc
Options
Ninja's exploiting the looting system
mavidian
Member Posts: 61 Arc User
This is nothing new, but I wanted to share. I was in the spellplague caverns and our leader dropped early so the lead command went to somebody else. As we were rolling along the foereaver 2-hander sword drops. I'm the only GWF so I roll need, but the control wizard decided he was going to roll need as well. You can guess the rest of the story from there.
Please fix the loot system. People should not be able to roll need on boss drops. I don't think that is to difficult to figure out.
Please fix the loot system. People should not be able to roll need on boss drops. I don't think that is to difficult to figure out.
Post edited by mavidian on
0
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Want to know why Neverwinter is so laggy? Check out the "Latency" section in this thread.
If they go about 'fixing' these little sandbox moments we have, it won't feel like a social game anymore.
I agree the OP just explain what happens in every mmo.
What we determined is this: Why would a company change this rule, when it only makes it harder for ppl to get gear for themselves but it encourages players to ninja loot and sell for AD on the market?
Unfortunately, more AD being spent in the market means somewhere down the line someone's buying that AD.
Wouldn't it be very ninja like to have a topic that says ninja in it, but people are not able to find any trace of said ninjas in the post?
There is nothing ninja about winning a roll, even it is ethically wrong (opinion) to roll need on something you can't use.
I guess he said Ninja's exploiting the loot system, maybe he has proof ninjas actually play the game and know of a loot exploit?
Why not? The CW can sell that sword for AD on the auction hall.
If people want this system implemented then they should have to pay the rest of the group for the drop.
I won't roll need on something the character I'm currently using doesn't need, but don't say I "can't use" it because I can sell it for AD if I want and I NEED them. Again not an argument I'd use, but it can't be ignored either.
Bottom line is unless your with guild mates or RL friends expect no courtesy in an MMO and just be thankful when you get it. Been that way sense before EQ1 came out on open loot games. That's why games without lazy developers give individual loot on kills and quests.
It's not about DnD, it's about MMOs. The only way to fix it is to have random distribution added. The coding for something like this would be a nightmare, especially at this point. There's nothing like combing thousands of lines of code that actually compiles with no errors because an update broke something. I've been through it in NWN.
The system is broken, I have posted more than my share about it, but it is broken in a way that allows need to be abused by everyone, even those who claim they can use an item, even though they might not actually need it. Until the system is fixed, to be truly fair and equitable, everyone should always roll need, on every single item, because that's the only truly fair way to go about it. Claiming loot should be yours due to it being a class item isn't fair, it's called entitlement, it stinks, and is disingenuous. That being said, I'm an old school guy, and if someone is polite, has been pulling their weight in the group, and can obviously use the item, I'll offer it to them; generally just hand it right over if it's a true rare item. But, if I hear one peep of complaint, some entitled drivel, or other childishness, I'll keep it, or give it to some other random person, not even in the group, who has been pleasant to group with in the past.
Other recent games went the instanced loot system and it works great. In fact Neverwinter already has the code in place for that since chests provide instanced loot, and the various white items (potions, scrolls, etc.) are fully instanced as well. I don't think it would be as difficult to make the other part of loot instanced as you might think.
Loot ninjas are "sand box" elements now?
If that is the case, then every game with a loot roll is a sand box game, right?
And no, D&D was never about "every man for himself", because if you are playing the PnP game with friends and your wizard lays claim to the 2-handed sword that the fighter in the group really wanted, then you are just irritiating your friends and making success for the group less likely.
If they will not change the system to allow only people that can use the gear to click the need button, then I can only suggest that everyone click need. On everything.
At least that way you play the odds, loot becomes basically a random distribution, and even if you do not get the thing that you want, you might get the thing that will allow you to trade for what you want or to sell to make the money to buy what you want.
That was the ancient old old definition of it, the slang term used when someone would run up to a body and loot it before you could, after all the killing was done, it took a lot of skill and often misdirection to get you to stall on looting for a moment, usually to reply to a tell etc. hence, they were like ninja's.
As seen as (for the most part anyways) that loot system isn't used anymore, it's not possible and thus the term was adopted and re-purposed to instead mean "someone who is looting things that they can't use, for profit, malice or, even someone they know" essentially the latter being that they're giving their preferred teammate 2 rolls instead of 1.
all semantics aside, which we can argue til the cows come home and personally I'd rather argue with the cows til you come home, on this matter especially. This isn't that terrible early on, when gear is not your main priority and levelling IS, but once you get to the endgame time consuming content, it's simply wrong for your greed and hubris to eat into MY time and effort, this game DOES to at least a considerable degree, have defined class purposes and roles, there is a healer, a dps, and a tank you can be a hybrid in between if necessary to varying degree's of effectiveness, but ultimately If I'm a healer, and you roll need on a healing item for a DC and you're a TR, that's NOTHING short of slapping me in the face and pissing on my shoes for my effort. Would you take a slap in the face from someone pissing on your shoes in real life? so no... in this game you shouldn't have to either, the dev's can deal with it or they can watch their community deal with it. And from what every game has seen when that happens there's usually a LOT of hostility and complaints, as players not knowing any better get systemically punished for honest mistakes.
And one can argue that "you can just need on everything yourself" but that inherently means that i'm simply waiting on you to cause an issue, as opposed to something proactively preventing you from causing it in the first place, and it doesn't stop the fact that there's still one annoying fly in an ointment when it comes to loot distribution, and of course, because folks will again (this is not my first rodeo here on this subject, does it show?) argue that, it's all fair because you're putting in just as much effort to a group as a DPS than as a Healer or Tank, to that I simply exclaim "no, you're talking garbage" yet more often than not, the DPS who are more than abundant in the game as always, are the last players to even roll a tank or healer, outside of maybe focusing on pvp because all that matters to them is "killing doodz and doing deepz"
So... old school archaic systems that are used today, still need the same hardline solutions as before. You don't use the queue at endgame, and you simply control who you let in (haha elitism, sad it's required but hey) and then when someone agree's to the need before greed and breaks it, the entire community needs to name and shame ingame, or create a list of unfavorable handles and just slowly but surely exclude them from further events due to failure to simply play by the agreed looting system. Yes you'll still get griefers that will thrive on this, and Cryptic and PWE will probably as always wash their hands on loot disputes for the sake of sanity, but ultimately griefers will grief and excluding them is the only way to circumvent their rubbish.
^ The sooner everyone starts rolling 'need', the sooner these threads stop appearing. The loot system was obviously made on purpose.
DnD is about a party working together. Working together doesn't mean attempting to steal important loot drops from the class it belongs to.
"Is it better to be feared or respected? I say, is it too much to ask for both?" -Tony Stark
Official NW_Legit_Community Forums
Wicks and Things: NW-DI4FMZRR4 : The Fenwick merchant family has lost a caravan! Can you help?
Beggar's Hollow: NW-DR6YG4J2L : Someone, or something, has stolen away many of the Fenwicks' children! Can you find out what happened to them?
Into the Fen Wood: NW-DL89DRG7B : Enter the heart of the forest. Can you discover the secret of the Fen Wood?