test content
Logo
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc
Options
do you pve?
josiahiyon
Member, NW M9 Playtest Posts: 396 Arc User
Yes, of course! This is a PVE game
Yes, but only to get AD / gear / levels / boons / artifacts for PVP (for self or friend/guildie)
Nope, I PVP only and have BiS gear / enchants / etc already
Yes, but only to get AD / gear / levels / boons / artifacts for PVP (for self or friend/guildie)
Nope, I PVP only and have BiS gear / enchants / etc already
Iyon the Dark
Post edited by josiahiyon on
0
Comments
FaceRoller- regen recovery TR (put on the shelf for now) 14k GS
Supreme CHAOS - IV GF (put on the shelf for now) 16k GS
White Khalifa- tene/hp/regen CW (retired) 11k GS (tene)
Death From Above- TANK ranger 16kGS
(all halfling everything)
Proud rank 6 of: <Enemy Team>
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
Option 2 is still viable for many, though. Frugal spouse, better game immersion, insufficient disposable income, helping guildies / friends get pvp ready, etc.
I hope Cryptic realizes the gold-mine this game can be with just a little PVP investment. It wouldn't take much to turn this into the best MMO PVP available. Thus the countless PVP suggestion / feedback threads. Tremendous potential as of yet mostly unrealized.
PVE attracts. PVP sustains.
Iyon the Dark
You have absolutely no statistical facts to say that. Unless you can provide proof that people play less because of pvp, because a lot of people I know play solely for the pvp.
I never intended to have facts backing me up. That is why I used the words "I disagree". But beyond that, you have no statistical proof to contradict me. I know loads of people that spent 1000's of dollars withing a month of release (rich oilworkers) who abhorred PvP, and said they always did. So I guess we have about the same level of legitimacy to our argument.
Well seeing how there are at least 15 guilds dedicated solely to PvP, each with well over 50 people in each, there are more people that spend money on pvp.
Given that NWO doesn't actually do any PvP content...I don't see how it affects the guys putting out fresh content at all.
44% only enjoy PVE (31% only play PVE)
41% only play for PVP
15% enjoy both
No wonder the friction.
Iyon the Dark
With that math you have approx 750 people dedicated to PVP out of the supposed millions of players in this game...
Note how I said AT LEAST. There are plenty of other guilds that only PvP, and there are people that are not in guilds that are dedicated to PvP also. Most of the PvP only guilds tend to have the top tiered people in them too, the ones that have r8s, perfects, etc.
[ Support Center • Rules & Policies and Guidelines • ARC ToS • Guild Recruitment Guidelines | FR DM Since 1993 ]
Do you PvP?
This is a PvE Game. Believe it or not PvP makes up the minority of players in every MMO that doesn't focus completely on PvP. It just isn't the be all end all that PvPers so commonly believe. If you look into any of the polls most PvE games have more players who are happy to never see any PvP than there are PvPers who avoid PvE at all costs.
Now in Neverwinter I used to PvP quite a bit. I thought it was a lot of fun, more fun than I have ever had in any PvE game's PvP before. Sadly as the game progressed the imbalanced matches became so common that I completely lost interest. I want challenging matches all of the time not matches where I either have no contest wins or losses.
Until a matchmaking system is added into Neverwinter's PvP I don't anticipate I will be PvPing much if at all anymore.
There are MMOs where guilds compete for a "World first".
Yeah, with lots of raids with lots of bosses and lots of gear tiers. So cool.
Also killing bosses in said MMO might take a lot of wipes and practice.
Here we have what? Who kills Valindra that has 3 rehashed spells at her disposal, in a 30 mins dungeon first?
Not gonna work.
This game has PVP and PVE. With just a little investment, Neverwinter can be the best of both worlds. Especially since the MMO PVP benchmark is not very high.
Like it or not, the 2 recent polls suggest that 30 - 40% play this game exclusively for PVP. Another 30 - 40% play this game exclusively for PVE. The game attracts a variety of players. As melodywhr has said, diversity in this game is a key ingredient to its success. PVE-only and PVP-only players should encourage a balance of both aspects in order to sustain the game and its diversity.
The PVP question was asked in a poll posted a few days earlier. I play primarily with people who play only to improve their PVP, so was curious what percentage of the population plays for this purpose. As evidenced, it's a much higher percentage than many PVE-only players care to admit.
This game has PVE. It also has PVP. This is a game, and player-demand determines its future PVP/PVE split. The demand on these forums is quite clear and pronounced.
A match-making system will be great. Couple this with Foundry PVP and a ranking-system, and Neverwinter instantly becomes the best MMO PVP game available.
Iyon the Dark
First, the middle question is poorly phrased. It can easily be misinterpreted as asking if players PVE only to get stuff for PVP, *or* if they PVE to get stuff for their friends/guildies. So answering yes to this prompt doesn't necessarily signify a devotion to only PVPing.
Second, you have to show that the forum population is representative of the entire NW population as a whole. I doubt that can be shown.
Finally, you're essentially making a post hoc argument. You're arguing that since there are PVPers here, that there ought to be more resources devoted to PVP. The presence of PVPers doesn't necessarily justify changing the focus of the game to PVP, any more so than, say, the presence of broccoli in my kitchen doesn't necessarily justify changing my lifestyle to become a vegetarian.
I find it kind of funny that there are so many people here demanding more PVP, more PVP, more PVP, when *it's a PVE-focused game* as stated by the devs and as demonstrated by the overwhelming proportion of resources devoted to PVE over PVP. It's sort of like going into a seafood restaurant, that has most of the menu devoted to seafood but one entree that has steak, and then complaining that the steak tastes funny and demanding better steak. If you want a good steak, don't go to a seafood restaurant! Likewise, if you want a great PVP experience, then don't play a game in which the devs, via their words and by their actions, have shown that their time isn't going to be spent on PVP.
You appear to have just posted everything that I was about to add, but phrased it slightly more nicely. Thank you, it saves typing.
[ Support Center • Rules & Policies and Guidelines • ARC ToS • Guild Recruitment Guidelines | FR DM Since 1993 ]
This is a very sensible and smart approach. Both aspects of the game should be constantly improved.
As for those that keep on saying "it's a PvE only/focused game", are there any dev resources that actually say this? I'm curious.
And if they are, why PvP in this PvE focused game? Because the devs made the mistake to code a very enjoyable combat system with decent amount of theorycrafting available on the side. It's too late to back away from it.
Also, there has to be a sample of players. The forums offer the best way of polling the community for now. Many good players post here, some already made guides, others videos and so on. These are the most important and representative players IMO, not the myriad of level 1-30 that play once every 2 weeks.
Doubt it. I'm a statistician and set up this poll with the intent of combining results from the similar PVP poll, as seen in my prior posts on this thread.
Middle part: "Yes, but only to get AD / gear / levels / boons / artifacts for PVP (for self or friend/guildie)"
I see no potential for misinterpretation from anyone comfortable with the english language.
However, if one were to misinterpret as you suggest, selecting option 2 would still imply that the person only PVEs to help others. Thus, unless they only play the game to help others, they are likely PVP-focused.
As with any study / survey, there are limitations. I've noted this limitation and caveated it in a few posts. With that said, it's the best intel we have available.
The high percentage of pvp-only players suggests that the developers should focus on PVP if they wish to retain and/or grow these players. It also suggests that their design, even if by accident, is well-suited for PVP. The focus of the game is not some predetermined immutable thing; it must evolve with player demand if the game is to succeed in the long run.
You can choose to starve, be malnourished, and/or be wasteful in your kitchen if you want. Or you can adjust and eat the readily available broccoli. Btw, you can still have meat too. We're not talking about going 100% PVP.
Please provide a reference where a developer said this game is a PVE game.
If you find a reference, here's a counter argument: the developers put PVP in the game.
The initial proportion of resources devoted to PVE does not suggest the game is a PVE game. Many games start by establishing their PVE before implementing and improving their PVP. In fact, some games don't have PVP at all on release. In a way, Neverwinter is ahead of the curve with regards to PVP.
If 40% of my customers at my seafood restaurant prefer the steak option, I'm going to listen to their suggestions regarding the steak. Maybe they like coming to the restaurant because it's local, has good music, good atmosphere, etc, and are indifferent to the seafood aspect. I'm not going to ignore and potentially lose 40% of my customers just because I'm too stubborn to listen to my customers' interests. That's a bad business model.
Neverwinter could quite literally be the best PVP MMO game available. It could revolutionize MMO PVP. It could do this with minimal effort and w/o much impact to PVE. Match-making + Foundry PVP. Put some salt on that steak. With the extra cash from the new and retained PVP players, the game could then put more resources into PVE and PVP. Win-win. That's why players push for PVP -- we see the tremendous potential.
Iyon the Dark
Fox Stevenson - Sandblast
Oh Wonder - Without You
Do not go gentle into that good night.
Rage, rage against the dying of the light.
- Dylan Thomas
I cant stress this enough, DEVs if you see this or ANYONE who works for Cryptic, pass this along! This 1000x this.
Neverwinter COULD easily be THE pvp MMO. the combat is second to none I cant say that enough. The thing that sucks about it is its the same two boring maps over and over. No matchmaking, no ranking, no new gametypes no new maps etc.... Absolutely NO resources put into this game.
If you give pvp some attention itll bring back ALOT of players. Maybe even the "streamers" who made it popular in the first few months which THEN pads everyones pockets and allows you to spend more resources on PVE.
Honestly, you could hire a frikin entry level programmer full time for probably <60k/yr and put him to work full time pvp content and easily cover the costs AND more... I know players who would gladly drop $1,000 or more into this game if it just stepped up its pvp. I know players who HAVE contributed thousands (yes plural) to this game and imagine how much more iv you add more pvp.
Its really just so sad, people WANT to give you money, they WANT to play your game they are TELLING you what they want and still people go "its a PVE game" honestly if you cant see the effects a stable and good PVP environment bring to even a PVE focused game, you really I guess deserve to play a dead game... and If cryptic/PWE continue to ignore the facts, they deserve to have their game die....
and then you insult the intelligence of management by suggesting that they don't know how to run a company or how to hire developers. if running a company was so easy and changes so easily implemented, why isn't it happening elsewhere? where is this success story?
i hate to break it to you but people already are giving this company money. and they are playing their game. all you have to do is log in and look around: zen store mounts, zen store fashion, dyes, keys, companions and packs. whether it's a thousand people or just a hundred. they're in there enjoying the game. that's not to say that people don't have wish lists... but trying to put it in such a "sky is falling" kind of way is ridiculous without knowing actual metrics.
I'm shocked that anyone could interpret this passion as insults or threats. Perhaps melodywhr is referencing a different post. I hope the developers see the plea here as constructive, impassioned feedback.
I'm glad people are giving the company money for this game. I want the game to succeed. I believe a couple minor PVP improvements will earn Cryptic more money and thus further help the game succeed.
Iyon the Dark