Did anyone else notice that the ancient Iconians were rail-thin and androgynous, but the modern Iconians have womanly figures? Most noticeable is that T'ket had a masculine voice 200,000 years ago but her present form sounds like an angry woman. What gives?
And since reproduction requires a male and female, that means either the Iconians are hermaphroditic, or the Heralds provide the male part of the DNA.
So in spite of what Cryptic tells us, this leads me to believe that Iconians and Heralds are actually the same species, and they are a matriarchal society. That is the only way their existence makes any sense.
So in spite of what Cryptic tells us, this leads me to believe that Iconians and Heralds are actually the same species, and they are a matriarchal society. That is the only way their existence makes any sense.
Uhh... but Iconians were already evolved and mastered genetic engineering when Heralds were still animals, as from various dialogues in the mission (with L'Miren, M'Tara and even the one with a wounded Herald). So it can't be that way.
The Iconians lost all the males in their race or became all Lesbians in the LONG TRIBBLE time they had no man.
The Rising of the Delta is the best expansion ever, and people love it to death because it is a good day to die in the endless struggle for supremacy of your own conviction. (A spin off of the Delta Rising is the best expansion ever and all the players love it.)
Never had any males, Iconians don't reproduce. That was always the real issue, there was a set number of Iconians that the Preservers had made, and so the heralds were used for manual labor and other tasks because there just weren't all that many Iconians to start with.
You might be able to clone more, but they never reproduced naturally.
As for the hips, the "Evil is Sexy" theme is pretty common.
Good god, it doesn't matter about the Iconians being all female and unable to reproduce. Maybe they reproduce asexually, it doesn't matter. My point was the physical design of their bodies is different after 200,000 years. They look much more feminine now than they used to. It looks odd.
I'm pretty sure that if you lived for 200,000 years your body would change also. Think of what the human body does during its cycle. Plus, as was said they were master geneticist, then factor in they are now beings of pure energy. I would honestly be surprised that they would resemble their old selves as much as they did.
In the end lets just agree TRIBBLE sell stuff, even if it is on a 200,000 year old energy being....
If you listen to the dialog in game, one of the Iconians admits that they reproduce but it takes a very long time. They said it was over 100 years since the last Iconian was born. So they are reproducing somehow.
the whole iconian mission in midnight when on iconia and speaking of the iconians and heralds. it screamed of mass effect 3 inspired asari and thessia, the dominion from ds9 and assassin's creed. im guessing the "females" of iconia require mates, however one iconian specifically stated that the heralds were found and altered, meaning they could be from iconia itself as a sort of subspieces like a aenar on andoria. how this mating happens and produces a new iconian is unknown.
so they were altered in a similar sort of idea as assassin's creed prsented during the ezio storyline and when desmond was alive. going through some of those puzzles to learn how humans were changed from simple ape like creatures by alien contact. these heralds were likely a sort of primate and then they were altered considerably in a similar means to the dominion and the vorta.
as for the changes, the iconians were likely required these changes in order to protect themselves and to become powerful enemies instead of barely capable of harming anything or anyone. but they may have gone too far on their adaption, they are in part energy beings now. long way from their painfully thin looking stick shapes.
T6 Miranda Hero Ship FTW. Been around since Dec 2010 on STO and bought LTS in Apr 2013 for STO.
If you listen to the dialog in game, one of the Iconians admits that they reproduce but it takes a very long time. They said it was over 100 years since the last Iconian was born. So they are reproducing somehow.
Must have missed that bit. I remember when talking to them about the heralds they implied there was never going to be more Iconians than what there currently was. Even if it took 100 years for them to reproduce, the entire population would double every 100 years because barring accident or violence, Iconians don't die.
Don't assume all Iconians are female and heralds male, they have female voice actors, look a bit feminine and are referred as a "she", but that's because we don't have gender pronouns for genders other than male or female.
For all we know their species might reproduce using a single gender or they might reproduce asexually or they might be hermaphrodite or use a different reproduction method we can't even imagine (it's hard to imagine new things, try imagining a new color).
As for TRIBBLE and hips, even as energy beings they still look androgynous to me, I though they were male until they referred to each other as sisters
BTW it seems like they misspoke when they called themselves energy beings. They are energiovores, it seems, sustaining themselves on energy as opposed to food, but M'Tara doesn't dissipate upon death, indicating she is still made of matter, even if something very different than before.
Christian Gaming Community Fleets--Faith, Fun, and Fellowship! See the website and PM for more. :-) Proudly F2P.Signature image by gulberat. Avatar image by balsavor.deviantart.com.
Good god, it doesn't matter about the Iconians being all female and unable to reproduce. Maybe they reproduce asexually, it doesn't matter. My point was the physical design of their bodies is different after 200,000 years. They look much more feminine now than they used to. It looks odd.
Beings change over time. Adult Humans don't look the same as they did in Elementary or High School.
It's 200,000 years ago, and they look different now. Why does this bother you so much?
Actually I thought it was said that they needed the genetic information stored in the orb to essentially clone themselves if needed.
That was my understanding. They said so long as they had the orb they could rebuild what was lost. I would at least hope that there is enough genetic information to clone new Iconians.
L'Miren is a very competent scientist, so I think she will come up with someway to repopulate. I hope they can clone M'Tara, her death still seems so pointless to me.
Iconians didn't reproduce much in the old days. So, presumably like the giant panda, they need a very specific environment, the World Heart had the information to develop that ecology, and they've been attempting to reconstruct it from scratch.
I'm being a little silly - they may have downloaded themselves to the energy/matter bodies to prolong the remaining portion of their species, but the physiology required was a little different (we don't see the Iconians in the past doing the sort of telekinetic activity common of species making the energy being transition in Star Trek, either).
Fate - protects fools, small children, and ships named Enterprise Will Riker
Member Access Denied Armada!
My forum single-issue of rage: Make the Proton Experimental Weapon go for subsystem targetting!
L'Miren is a very competent scientist, so I think she will come up with someway to repopulate. I hope they can clone M'Tara, her death still seems so pointless to me.
Yet they are not "Iconians" anymore. Their physiology changed completely. Cloning 200.000 years old genetic material would still make the "new" Iconians an entirely different species!
Man, woman, I don't give a damn. They're still dying on the end of a bayonet.
"Great War! / And I cannot take more! / Great tour! / I keep on marching on / I play the great score / There will be no encore / Great War! / The War to End All Wars"
— Sabaton, "Great War"
Actually I thought it was said that they needed the genetic information stored in the orb to essentially clone themselves if needed.
That was my understanding. They said so long as they had the orb they could rebuild what was lost. I would at least hope that there is enough genetic information to clone new Iconians.
L'Miren is a very competent scientist, so I think she will come up with someway to repopulate. I hope they can clone M'Tara, her death still seems so pointless to me.
I was also hoping somehow M'Tara would come back into play in the future timeline, I would say that was the only disappointment I felt after this last episode, that nothing in the past or done by the Krenim ship resulted in things being just different enough that M'Tara never died. But now that they have the orb, we can hope they come up with a way to perhaps even resurrect M'Tara's body? Would be an interesting plot point later to maybe ease T'Kets thirst for continued aggression.
I was also hoping somehow M'Tara would come back into play in the future timeline, I would say that was the only disappointment I felt after this last episode, that nothing in the past or done by the Krenim ship resulted in things being just different enough that M'Tara never died. But now that they have the orb, we can hope they come up with a way to perhaps even resurrect M'Tara's body? Would be an interesting plot point later to maybe ease T'Kets thirst for continued aggression.
Supposedly the rational for keeping T'ket angry is so the pve queues can stay. I would rather they just had them be in the past when the war was still on. Otherwise it kind of means that Qo'noS is stuck as a burning wreck as per Brotherhood of the Sword for a long time.
Let's buy T'ket some flowers, give her a back-rub, and maybe a "The Whole is One" picnic with a newly cloned M'Tara. Then maybe we can start repairing things.
Did anyone else notice that the ancient Iconians were rail-thin and androgynous, but the modern Iconians have womanly figures? Most noticeable is that T'ket had a masculine voice 200,000 years ago but her present form sounds like an angry woman. What gives?
Turns out god like energy beings can look however they damn well please.
Why do I get the feeling you wouldn't be complaining if they all had manly pecs and crotch bulges?
And since reproduction requires a male and female, that means either the Iconians are hermaphroditic, or the Heralds provide the male part of the DNA.
So in spite of what Cryptic tells us, this leads me to believe that Iconians and Heralds are actually the same species, and they are a matriarchal society. That is the only way their existence makes any sense.
Mammals (generally, standard internet disclaimer in case of corner and edge cases) require a male and a female to reproduce.
Iconians had a different evolutionary path than mammals. Nothing much has been said of their reproduction systems. Because they look humanoid does not mean they are human.
Did anyone else notice that the ancient Iconians were rail-thin and androgynous, but the modern Iconians have womanly figures? Most noticeable is that T'ket had a masculine voice 200,000 years ago but her present form sounds like an angry woman. What gives?
Turns out god like energy beings can look however they damn well please.
Why do I get the feeling you wouldn't be complaining if they all had manly pecs and crotch bulges?
Also, T'ket is always referred to as feminine.
Seems like the humanoid form is never allowed to have retractable male bits like some other species have.
Even godlike power isn't apparently enough to figure out a solution to a simple temperature range problem so air cooling. and all the vulnerability involved with it, is still necessary for any sort of male humanoid.
This is my Risian Corvette. There are many like it, but this one is mine.
From what I can tell, the Iconians as a species seem to be androgynous, and lacking in a gender that can be analogued to anything we find familiar. However, for simplicity's sake, they seem to refer to themselves as "she/her" as it seems to be the closest they can get to something we recognize. Note: Heralds still refer to any Iconian as "Master" instead of "Mistress", further evidence that the personal pronouns they use don't precisely mesh with their actual biologics).
Furthermore, the pre-ascended Iconians still have the same body type as their ascended forms, it is just hard to tell that they do under the robes that specifically seem to be layered around their torsos. Their ascended forms bare their signature armor/energy relays, which are far more revealing than their robes. Their pose also, for lack of better phrasing, does kinda cause sharp attention to be drawn to their lower half. But in the few instances of an ascended Iconian simply standing on the ground, it's not as noticable.
It's also been pointed out that the ascended Iconians are partially energy beings, and do still have some matter components to their selves. Probably why M'Tara left a body when she expired instead of simply dissipating, and why T'Ket was able to even have her arm cut off to begin with (even though, yes, her arm did evaporate once it was separated from her body).
It COULD be possible to resurrect M'Tara if she were given a drastic enough infusion of energy, but that may not be possible if her organics can't support the strain any more. And a clone of M'Tara wouldn't really be her, either, even if they ascended the clone.
The Heralds themselves are never referred to in any way that would imply a gender. Considering how closely the Iconians care for them, including their production, the Heralds may simply lack any kind of gender whatsoever. They may not need it considering they are essentially a clone race.
The importance of the World Heart must not be understated here: it is the collected repository of their whole race's history. Only twelve Iconians escaped the bombardment; hardly enough to remember and recollect the knowledge of their whole race. They wouldn't need it for simple genetic material, guys, at least not for themselves. It was because it had everything that was Iconian, before they had to flee. Definitely enough of a peace offering to get them to back off their assault. Not for T'Ket, obviously, but for the remaining 10, definitely more than enough.
As far as Iconian reproduction is concerned, to those of you implying that the Iconians require the Heralds to reproduce:
The Iconians specifically pointed out that they engineered the Heralds into their present form when technology finally outpaced all the physical labor the ancient Heralds could provide.
This implies that the Iconians were a stable and highly advanced species well before the Heralds were even sentient, much less appearing in the form they are in now.
The Iconians do not need the Heralds to reproduce, and never have. They might not even be able to reproduce, as despite coming from the same planet, are still disparate species.
And since reproduction requires a male and female, that means either the Iconians are hermaphroditic, or the Heralds provide the male part of the DNA.
So in spite of what Cryptic tells us, this leads me to believe that Iconians and Heralds are actually the same species, and they are a matriarchal society. That is the only way their existence makes any sense.
(re: the bold part) Err, no. Some reproduction patterns require two sets of DNA, but hardly all reproduction requires males and females. Not even here on Earth, let alone aliens from other planets.
I would put the Devidians out there as a possible example of limited to no outward sexual dimorphism, and of keeping what humans have as "externals" internal.
Christian Gaming Community Fleets--Faith, Fun, and Fellowship! See the website and PM for more. :-) Proudly F2P.Signature image by gulberat. Avatar image by balsavor.deviantart.com.
Note: Heralds still refer to any Iconian as "Master" instead of "Mistress", further evidence that the personal pronouns they use don't precisely mesh with their actual biologics.
I think the first smiley herald dude that you meet on pre-bombardment Iconia referred to M'tara or one of them as 'mistress'... It may be that gender, if indeed they had any, became irrelevant after they became energy beings.
I'm well aware of that. My point is none of them look feminine in their past flesh and blood forms and T'ket had a manly voice. Now they look feminine as hell in their current forms.
Does ALL women in the universe have to look like a human woman?
Comments
Heralds are all male.
And since reproduction requires a male and female, that means either the Iconians are hermaphroditic, or the Heralds provide the male part of the DNA.
So in spite of what Cryptic tells us, this leads me to believe that Iconians and Heralds are actually the same species, and they are a matriarchal society. That is the only way their existence makes any sense.
My Ship Builds: USS Conqueror, HMS Victorious, HMS Concord, ISS Queen Elizabeth, Black Widow III
Click here to view my DeviantArt.
Uhh... but Iconians were already evolved and mastered genetic engineering when Heralds were still animals, as from various dialogues in the mission (with L'Miren, M'Tara and even the one with a wounded Herald). So it can't be that way.
You might be able to clone more, but they never reproduced naturally.
As for the hips, the "Evil is Sexy" theme is pretty common.
I'm pretty sure that if you lived for 200,000 years your body would change also. Think of what the human body does during its cycle. Plus, as was said they were master geneticist, then factor in they are now beings of pure energy. I would honestly be surprised that they would resemble their old selves as much as they did.
In the end lets just agree TRIBBLE sell stuff, even if it is on a 200,000 year old energy being....
so they were altered in a similar sort of idea as assassin's creed prsented during the ezio storyline and when desmond was alive. going through some of those puzzles to learn how humans were changed from simple ape like creatures by alien contact. these heralds were likely a sort of primate and then they were altered considerably in a similar means to the dominion and the vorta.
as for the changes, the iconians were likely required these changes in order to protect themselves and to become powerful enemies instead of barely capable of harming anything or anyone. but they may have gone too far on their adaption, they are in part energy beings now. long way from their painfully thin looking stick shapes.
Been around since Dec 2010 on STO and bought LTS in Apr 2013 for STO.
For all we know their species might reproduce using a single gender or they might reproduce asexually or they might be hermaphrodite or use a different reproduction method we can't even imagine (it's hard to imagine new things, try imagining a new color).
As for TRIBBLE and hips, even as energy beings they still look androgynous to me, I though they were male until they referred to each other as sisters
Christian Gaming Community Fleets--Faith, Fun, and Fellowship! See the website and PM for more. :-)
Proudly F2P. Signature image by gulberat. Avatar image by balsavor.deviantart.com.
Beings change over time. Adult Humans don't look the same as they did in Elementary or High School.
It's 200,000 years ago, and they look different now. Why does this bother you so much?
That was my understanding. They said so long as they had the orb they could rebuild what was lost. I would at least hope that there is enough genetic information to clone new Iconians.
L'Miren is a very competent scientist, so I think she will come up with someway to repopulate. I hope they can clone M'Tara, her death still seems so pointless to me.
I'm being a little silly - they may have downloaded themselves to the energy/matter bodies to prolong the remaining portion of their species, but the physiology required was a little different (we don't see the Iconians in the past doing the sort of telekinetic activity common of species making the energy being transition in Star Trek, either).
Member Access Denied Armada!
My forum single-issue of rage: Make the Proton Experimental Weapon go for subsystem targetting!
— Sabaton, "Great War"
Check out https://unitedfederationofpla.net/s/
I was also hoping somehow M'Tara would come back into play in the future timeline, I would say that was the only disappointment I felt after this last episode, that nothing in the past or done by the Krenim ship resulted in things being just different enough that M'Tara never died. But now that they have the orb, we can hope they come up with a way to perhaps even resurrect M'Tara's body? Would be an interesting plot point later to maybe ease T'Kets thirst for continued aggression.
Supposedly the rational for keeping T'ket angry is so the pve queues can stay. I would rather they just had them be in the past when the war was still on. Otherwise it kind of means that Qo'noS is stuck as a burning wreck as per Brotherhood of the Sword for a long time.
Let's buy T'ket some flowers, give her a back-rub, and maybe a "The Whole is One" picnic with a newly cloned M'Tara. Then maybe we can start repairing things.
Turns out god like energy beings can look however they damn well please.
Why do I get the feeling you wouldn't be complaining if they all had manly pecs and crotch bulges?
Also, T'ket is always referred to as feminine.
Mammals (generally, standard internet disclaimer in case of corner and edge cases) require a male and a female to reproduce.
Iconians had a different evolutionary path than mammals. Nothing much has been said of their reproduction systems. Because they look humanoid does not mean they are human.
Seems like the humanoid form is never allowed to have retractable male bits like some other species have.
Even godlike power isn't apparently enough to figure out a solution to a simple temperature range problem so air cooling. and all the vulnerability involved with it, is still necessary for any sort of male humanoid.
Furthermore, the pre-ascended Iconians still have the same body type as their ascended forms, it is just hard to tell that they do under the robes that specifically seem to be layered around their torsos. Their ascended forms bare their signature armor/energy relays, which are far more revealing than their robes. Their pose also, for lack of better phrasing, does kinda cause sharp attention to be drawn to their lower half. But in the few instances of an ascended Iconian simply standing on the ground, it's not as noticable.
It's also been pointed out that the ascended Iconians are partially energy beings, and do still have some matter components to their selves. Probably why M'Tara left a body when she expired instead of simply dissipating, and why T'Ket was able to even have her arm cut off to begin with (even though, yes, her arm did evaporate once it was separated from her body).
It COULD be possible to resurrect M'Tara if she were given a drastic enough infusion of energy, but that may not be possible if her organics can't support the strain any more. And a clone of M'Tara wouldn't really be her, either, even if they ascended the clone.
The Heralds themselves are never referred to in any way that would imply a gender. Considering how closely the Iconians care for them, including their production, the Heralds may simply lack any kind of gender whatsoever. They may not need it considering they are essentially a clone race.
The importance of the World Heart must not be understated here: it is the collected repository of their whole race's history. Only twelve Iconians escaped the bombardment; hardly enough to remember and recollect the knowledge of their whole race. They wouldn't need it for simple genetic material, guys, at least not for themselves. It was because it had everything that was Iconian, before they had to flee. Definitely enough of a peace offering to get them to back off their assault. Not for T'Ket, obviously, but for the remaining 10, definitely more than enough.
As far as Iconian reproduction is concerned, to those of you implying that the Iconians require the Heralds to reproduce:
The Iconians specifically pointed out that they engineered the Heralds into their present form when technology finally outpaced all the physical labor the ancient Heralds could provide.
This implies that the Iconians were a stable and highly advanced species well before the Heralds were even sentient, much less appearing in the form they are in now.
The Iconians do not need the Heralds to reproduce, and never have. They might not even be able to reproduce, as despite coming from the same planet, are still disparate species.
(re: the bold part) Err, no. Some reproduction patterns require two sets of DNA, but hardly all reproduction requires males and females. Not even here on Earth, let alone aliens from other planets.
Christian Gaming Community Fleets--Faith, Fun, and Fellowship! See the website and PM for more. :-)
Proudly F2P. Signature image by gulberat. Avatar image by balsavor.deviantart.com.
I think the first smiley herald dude that you meet on pre-bombardment Iconia referred to M'tara or one of them as 'mistress'... It may be that gender, if indeed they had any, became irrelevant after they became energy beings.
Does ALL women in the universe have to look like a human woman?