And throw away the key!

twg042370

I got this idea after reading a thread about demoting Admirals in fleets. I thought it was a rad idea;

You getting demoted back to Captain after a very Trek-like trial on New Romulus for your role in Divide et Imperia. I dunno what an equivalent would be for the KDF and RR would be, but it would help with the Too-Many-Admirals problem.

neoakiraii

The STO storyline only recognizes one Admiral not the rest


Also the Klingons and Romulans don't do that mission.



All Cryptic has to do is make a separate title for rank, that the NPC's will use to make everyone happy, and no one will lose the rank they want.

I'm not getting demoted because players want to be Captain Kirk, I want to be General ****ing Martok

assimilatedktar

twg042370 wrote: »

I got this idea after reading a thread about demoting Admirals in fleets. I thought it was a rad idea;

You getting demoted back to Captain after a very Trek-like trial on New Romulus for your role in Divide et Imperia. I dunno what an equivalent would be for the KDF and RR would be, but it would help with the Too-Many-Admirals problem.

Only two of my characters did that mission. The first one because I thought that after the Feedback in beta they wouldn't let that atrocity go live. The second one because someone I was playing with just couldn't figure out how to skip. The rest of my Feds left not-Zelle to rot on Starbase 39.

talonxv

Bah. I think that we shouldn't of been Admirals and Generals in the first place. Least not a Vice admiral. I mean the events of this game take place from epsidoe 1- current in what a year?

It is UNHEARD of for a new recruit fresh out of the gates to leapfrog the rank structure THAT fast.

Personally rank should of been capped at captain. Or at highest, Fleet captain.

sparhawk

neoakiraii wrote: »

The STO storyline only recognizes one Admiral not the rest


Also the Klingons and Romulans don't do that mission.



All Cryptic has to do is make a separate title for rank, that the NPC's will use to make everyone happy, and no one will lose the rank they want.

I'm not getting demoted because players want to be Captain Kirk, I want to be General ****ing Martok

This. Cryptic won't change the rank structure because a small faction of people have a problem with it.

lordvalecortez

twg042370 wrote: »

I got this idea after reading a thread about demoting Admirals in fleets. I thought it was a rad idea;

You getting demoted back to Captain after a very Trek-like trial on New Romulus for your role in Divide et Imperia. I dunno what an equivalent would be for the KDF and RR would be, but it would help with the Too-Many-Admirals problem.

I would have claimed just following orders. And that as a foreign dignitary with only a ceremonial rank I'm outside Federation jurisdiction. Also I've saved your assess too many times. And why am I not king of everything yet?

On a more serious note, admiralship seems to be the place they put all the crazy captains. Archer was made an admiral (Fleet) after a rather long career. Kirk went crazy for a little while and was an admiral (Rear, Lower half) before coming to his senses. Picard stayed sane, Sisko found religion and left his mortal coil. Janeway had 1 command as a captain before instantly becoming an admiral (Vice) cause Janeway.

So I find it a little funny that the person suggesting that people get demoted, and via a trial even, has a WWJD avatar. Janeway would just demote everyone and that would end of it. Until she promotes you back to your wold rank within a year.

mericpx

i think this is the answer what you want know

neoakiraii

Post removed

twg042370

lordvalecortez wrote: »

Janeway would just demote everyone and that would end of it. Until she promotes you back to your wold rank within a year.

Or if you were Chakotay, just tell you she's really disappointed in you and is going to write as much in her log.

assimilatedktar wrote:

The rest of my Feds left not-Zelle to rot on Starbase 39.

Yeah, I always skip it too because I hate how much of a putz my captain is in it. Classic Trek would have me go, "Wait a minute there, sunshine..."

But the utter lack of blow back in the storyline has always bugged the hell out of me. Especially since you're now running around tagging space bunnies. At least give me a vengeful survivor coming after me or something.

captainhunter1

twg042370 wrote: »

I got this idea after reading a thread about demoting Admirals in fleets. I thought it was a rad idea;

You getting demoted back to Captain after a very Trek-like trial on New Romulus for your role in Divide et Imperia. I dunno what an equivalent would be for the KDF and RR would be, but it would help with the Too-Many-Admirals problem.

I think the whole Rank, Title, and Demotion issue could be simply solved in two ways:

1: "Grandfather" in existing characters who have the "Admiral' Titles already unlocked. Demoting current characters is a bad, BAD idea. It will just make people angry. All new characters created would cap at Captain rank TITLE (not Level - they would still progress to Level 50 and beyond). Fleet (guild) Leaders could still unlock the 'Admiral' title.

2. Divorce Rank from Level. Make ranks a Title unlock only as you progress and have all NPCs adress you by your chosen Title.


Oh, and as for the trial for Divide et Impera, lol! - how timely (literally!). The latest Foundry Challenge "Back to the Past" closes today at 10am. My submission (see sig below) addresses the whole Divide et Impera disaster - though NOT through a trail/demotion. :P

lordvalecortez

twg042370 wrote: »

Yeah, I always skip it too because I hate how much of a putz my captain is in it. Classic Trek would have me go, "Wait a minute there, sunshine..."

But the utter lack of blow back in the storyline has always bugged the hell out of me. Especially since you're now running around tagging space bunnies. At least give me a vengeful survivor coming after me or something.

The biggest issue is that you are rail roaded so hard you can't do anything. Yes I know its an MMO. Yes I know in a MMORPG the RPG denotes a way of leveling and character growth statistically and that is all. Yes I know everyone is the chosen one.

This still doesn't excuse that Vice Admirals, Sub Admirals, and Lt. Generals are all placing tags on small creatures that nature is desperately trying to get rid of. Manually. When you should be
A: Using a wide beam setting to stun everything so you can tag them in peace.
B: Having you underlings do this menial task.
C: Shoot the person how had the gall to ask a high ranking flag officer to do manual labor.
4: Should spending your time doing anything else, like attending a design meeting for an engine prototype that has already been built.

At the end of the day, divorcing level and rank is the way to go. Cryptic should have capped the ranks at Captain but that ship has sailed. While I do agree everyone should be a Captain, you will have to pry those barred pips from my cold dead hands. I'm an Admiral dammit, not an environmentalist. So give me Admiral things to do, not ensign things to do. Especially not Ensign Harry Kim things to do.

artan42

neoakiraii wrote: »

I'm not getting demoted because players want to be Captain Kirk, I want to be General ****ing Martok

Some of us want to be Admiral Ross.