Moderator Application Discussion Thread

Michael_Dark - Lost City · October 2010

Since the application thread is closed, can we discuss this now?

Rawrgh - I'll vote yes, but watch the attitude.
LovesTragedy - neutral
Deora - second thought.... no.
Dsholder - neutral
Longknife - no
Grippielover - no, no experience
Zoe - very NO
buttercupcruella - no opinion
FuzzyWuzzy - NO.
LifeHunting - NO.
Krisnda - neutral
FaelinRain - no, not experienced
Barber - yes, with verification of experience
Hanman5000 - no, haven't been here long enough
LOKI_- neutral
Kiyoshi - NO.
Dantell - no opinion xP
Pressa - neutral
KrittyCat - neutral
PAYUPSUCKA - neutral
Nowitsawn - neutral
SerenityMare - yes
Emmanueljr - no, haven't been here long enough
Aesthor - conditionally yes, but I would miss her great posting style xP

'neutral' or 'no opinion' genrally mean to me that they might make fine mods, I just don't have enough of an opinion to vote either yes or no.

I'm not posting my reasons for NO because I don't want to start a flame war. I do have very valid reasons why I post them.

Sorry to those I voted no on, nothing personal. :P

Please post your opinions too, keep it somewhat civil. b:bye

Longknife - Harshlands · October 2010

Longknife for president, ijs.

Airyll - Dreamweaver · October 2010

Longknife - Harshlands wrote: »

Longknife for president, ijs.

+1

Yulk for vice.

Silest - Sanctuary · October 2010

Michael_dark - Lost City wrote: »

l
Deora - yes, intelligent and experienced, maybe a bit too 'sharp' :P

My eyes will burn forever out of their sockets. Her posts make kittens die before they are my born. And my soul diminish into an eternal nothingness, leaving me an empty shell with no consciousness. No thanks. >_>

Airyll - Dreamweaver · October 2010

Deora can be very abrasive. Then again, so can Rawrgh, Aethor and several other posters that applied for moderator. There's a very high chance that we're going to end up with somebody who could be very sharp.

I have to admit, in general I sort of agree with Michael. Some of the names I don't actually no so I won't pass any judgement, and a few of his "yes"s I would actually say no too, but other then that I can't really say I have huge disagreements.

Michael_Dark - Lost City · October 2010

Silest - Sanctuary wrote: »

My eyes will burn forever out of their sockets. Her posts make kittens die before they are my born. And my soul diminish into an eternal nothingness, leaving me an empty shell with no consciousness. No thanks. >_>

I agree that she's sharp and can be abrasive. Her logic is spot-on.

Zoe - Heavens Tear · October 2010

I don't care much for anyone who applied, including myself.

The people who I would really have preferred already left.

ZAPATON - Sanctuary · October 2010

Meh, just make everyone a mod. Would be a lot of fun. Chaotic kind of fun b:pleased

Just picture it:

A makes a new topic

B posts: Hi there!

C edits A's post to: Ima noob!

D posts: Hi noob

E deletes D's post, and moves topic to just any random forum

F locks topic and makes a new topic called A B C D and E are all noob mods.

A reopens his topic.

Then everything repeats itself again and again, until someone smart enough removes the topic completely.

Then you get all the alphabet making their own new topics to flame how noob of a mod each other is.

As a result, PWE wins: Everyone would forget about in-game problems b:chuckle

Dyskrasia - Heavens Tear · October 2010

lol the fact that I'm not even on the list even though I applied does not bode well huh ;x

I think I agree with most of the nos and neutrals, and I think out of all the yes's that Aesthor would be the best choice. For the most part though I don't really care... I think anyone that took their application somewhat seriously and isn't a brand new poster has the potential to make a decent mod.

Elenacostel - Heavens Tear · October 2010

I was tempted to apply for only the Archer subforum.

Nowitsawn - Heavens Tear · October 2010

Zoe - Heavens Tear wrote: »

I don't care much for anyone who applied, including myself.

Pretty much the same for me. I read through most of the applications and aside from the few that just won't cut it (and I agree with michael on those), I wouldn't mind seeing any of the other applicants as a mod.

In fact, I'm already happy that Frankie decided to do things like this. Just an application probably isn't enough though, so there will probably be a vote next (I think Frankie even said so, but I'm not sure on that).

Kupuntu - Sanctuary · October 2010

I'll use your list, much easier this way. b:chuckle

Rawrgh - YES, he'd make the best mod.
LovesTragedy - maybe
Deora - yes, one of the best ones
Dsholder - maybe
Longknife - yes, of course
Grippielover - maybe
Zoe - no
buttercupcruella - yes, usually very good posts
FuzzyWuzzy - yes
LifeHunting - no thank you
Krisnda - maybe
FaelinRain - maybe
Barber - yes, experience is always a good thing
Hanman5000 - maybe
LOKI_- maybe
Kiyoshi - maybe
Dantell - yes
Pressa - yes
KrittyCat - not sure
PAYUPSUCKA - not sure
Nowitsawn - yes, 3rd best one of the list
SerenityMare - yes
Emmanueljr - maybe
Aesthor - yes, one of the best ones

In general, we are going to get relatively good mods.

Zoe - Heavens Tear · October 2010

I'll make this simple, the reason why people won't want me as a mod is because I take the truth, the facts, and force feed them to people.

The fact that players are greedy as hell and want everything for nothing, the fact that the sellers are the ones that control the prices, not the buyers, the fact that most players don't know how to play, the fact that most players are whiny brats that refuse to learn how to play. (see the TT topic)

I take these simple truths, and tell it how it is. Another fact, people can't handle truth. They like to live in their own little world where they are god and never wrong.

Persona 4 puts it well: People only hear what they want to hear and only believe what they wish to believe. They ignore everything that doesn't give them exactly what they want, when they want it, and how they want it. They prefer the foggy world the main characters in this game were fighting against. Truth, is what they fear more than anything.

Michael_Dark - Lost City · October 2010

Zoe - Heavens Tear wrote: »

I'll make this simple, the reason why people won't want me as a mod is because I take the truth, the facts, and force feed them to people.

No, many times you take opinions and state them as fact, and many times your facts are just straight out wrong.

Truth, is what they fear more than anything.

lol. Nice try.

I don't mind people who are opinionated, and I certainly don't mind people who are abrasive. I just have issues with people whose logic is sometimes very flawed. :P

Breathe - Lost City · October 2010

Zoe - Heavens Tear wrote: »

I'll make this simple, the reason why people won't want me as a mod is because I take the truth, the facts, and force feed them to people.

The fact that players are greedy as hell and want everything for nothing, the fact that the sellers are the ones that control the prices, not the buyers, the fact that most players don't know how to play, the fact that most players are whiny brats that refuse to learn how to play. (see the TT topic)

I take these simple truths, and tell it how it is. Another fact, people can't handle truth. They like to live in their own little world where they are god and never wrong.

Persona 4 puts it well: People only hear what they want to hear and only believe what they wish to believe. They ignore everything that doesn't give them exactly what they want, when they want it, and how they want it. They prefer the foggy world the main characters in this game were fighting against. Truth, is what they fear more than anything.

Lol, no. You are hypocritcal. You see the world only through your eyes and can't seem to grasp that you might (gasp) be wrong.

buttercupcruella · October 2010

Heyah guys. Since I'm one of the people that applied, I wanted to say hi to all of ya. No false promises, no nothing. Just hope that most people will be pleased with the outcome of that whole thing; we all deserve it:)))

Wb Michael, hope ya rested and relaxed so you're rather fresh and without any major grudges.

Also, I like the structure of this thread, so don't make it a flame Zoe thing, cause You - Know - Who Shelly will lock it.b:surrender

brent40 · October 2010

lol@ people on the list being all humble like now.

KrittyCat - Dreamweaver · October 2010

Normally, if I'm trying to be "elected" to some post, I do my best to stay out of discussions relating to that post. However, I couldn't fail to notice that Zoe even said herself that she didn't care much for some of the group, including herself. Then she comes back and responds scathingly to other people that say they wouldn't necessarily pick her...

Guess what I'm trying to say is, be consistent. If you don't think you're the best option, don't fault others for saying the same.

ChopChop - Raging Tide · October 2010

Zoe - Heavens Tear wrote: »

I'll make this simple, the reason why people won't want me as a mod is because I take the truth, the facts, and force feed them to people.

The fact that players are greedy as hell and want everything for nothing, the fact that the sellers are the ones that control the prices, not the buyers, the fact that most players don't know how to play, the fact that most players are whiny brats that refuse to learn how to play. (see the TT topic)

I take these simple truths, and tell it how it is. Another fact, people can't handle truth. They like to live in their own little world where they are god and never wrong.

Persona 4 puts it well: People only hear what they want to hear and only believe what they wish to believe. They ignore everything that doesn't give them exactly what they want, when they want it, and how they want it. They prefer the foggy world the main characters in this game were fighting against. Truth, is what they fear more than anything.

I would vote for you . Not because i think you would make a good mod hell you sound like an egotisic ***** , but i would vote for you because maybe you could kill of the game and forums once and for all b:chuckle

Kiyoshi - Heavens Tear · October 2010

brent40 wrote: »

lol@ people on the list being all humble like now.

lol... would would i need to be humble. i'll still tell you off now as i would have before. i am not sure if anyone notice from my posts that i don't give a rat's *** about the current mods. and my app was 99% making fun of them... which probably puts my chance of becoming a mod somewhere between the chance of pwi removing packs all together and pwi resetting all player refines to +1 for **** and giggles.

ZAPATON - Sanctuary · October 2010

Kiyoshi - Heavens Tear wrote: »

resetting all player refines to +1 for **** and giggles.

Don't give them ideas for next patch b:shocked

Fallghost - Raging Tide · October 2010

Rawrgh - Yes
LovesTragedy - I don't know
Deora - Yes
Dsholder - I don't know
Longknife - Yes
Grippielover - I don't know
Zoe - I don't know
buttercupcruella - I don't know
FuzzyWuzzy - I don't know
LifeHunting - No
Krisnda - I don't know
FaelinRain - I don't know
Barber - I don't know
Hanman5000 - I don't know
LOKI_- I don't know
Kiyoshi - I don't know
Dantell - I don't know
Pressa - I don't know
KrittyCat - I don't know
PAYUPSUCKA - I don't know
Nowitsawn - Yes
SerenityMare - Yes
Emmanueljr - I don't know
Aesthor - Yes

Too many people I don't know b:surrender [except Aesthor,SerenityMare,Nowitsawn,LOKI_,LifeHunting,Fuzzy_Wuzzy,buttercupcruella,Zoe,GrippieLuver,LongKnife,Rawrgh and Deora]

Edit: It seems to me that forums hate LongKnife since in my post he is here with "Longk nife" instead of LongKnife.

Sephirothxp - Heavens Tear · October 2010

I like how you "boost" up your chances of being mod Zoe.

A mood needs to care about the forum community, yet you first said you dont care wether you are picked or not. Then come up with a really bad explanation about why people wont vote for you.

All i do is fool around, and i have better chances of being mod than you.( if i applied) Have fun.

Now on topic.

I agree with Michael's list.

AlbireoTwo - Lost City · October 2010

They can keep their modding jobs.

AlbireoTwo for Finance Minister!!!

b:avoid

Sanctam - Dreamweaver · October 2010

I vote Demon_EA for GM.

JanusZeal - Heavens Tear · October 2010

I don't get what there is to discuss -- frankie is gonna pick who he and likely the admins want. In fact, I bet they don't even read this topic unless it's to lock/delete/move it. I don't see why this is such an important event that people need to vote on others unless it's just a lame popularity contest.

TheDan - Sanctuary · October 2010

I like some of the candidates here, and have nothing against them, but the person I would have liked to have seen apply most was considering applying, and she wanted to be considered the "traditional" way. Frankie, I think you know who she is, and I know this process is a compromise, but I sincerely hope you don't close yourself off to considering other viable candidates and options as well. Ultimately it's your decision frankie and I respect that, but I should hope people are still able to be considered the traditional way. I will explain my further reasonings to you in pm frankie as I don't want to de-rail the OPs thread.

Auranne - Sanctuary · October 2010

Anyone who has been permanently banned, with any character in game, or permanentaly banned under another name in the forums, should be eliminated as an applicant.
Banned from game means you could not follow the rules in game.
Banned from forums means you could not follow the rules in forums.
You can't follow the rules but you want the job that makes you responsible for ensuring others do?

One applicant couldn't even bother to respectfully submit an application, but instead chose to post some flippant statement. That should be immediately disqualified.

Some of the applicants have repeatedly been insulting in their responses to posts but now want to be moderator. You cannot post in a respectful way as a mere forum user, yet you want to moderate how others post?

If it says "applications only", and the CM says again to keep it to "applications only" and that all other posts will be removed, those who applied after that was posted twice should be disqualified for either not being able to follow directions or disregard of the posting rules.

As many have stated, it would be beneficial to have forum mods for each forum, or at the very least each sub-section, and in different time zones. It's apparently not for lack of volunteers.

Blancheneige - Heavens Tear · October 2010

None.

Player as moderator is a bad idea.

Hire independant people to do it.

And pay them for the job.

Aesthor - Heavens Tear · October 2010

brent40 wrote: »

lol@ people on the list being all humble like now.

Why would I be humble? My ego is being fed and inflated.

Auranne - Sanctuary wrote: »

Anyone who has been permanently banned, with any character in game, or permanentaly banned under another name in the forums, should be eliminated as an applicant.
Banned from game means you could not follow the rules in game.
Banned from forums means you could not follow the rules in forums.
You can't follow the rules but you want the job that makes you responsible for ensuring others do?

One applicant couldn't even bother to respectfully submit an application, but instead chose to post some flippant statement. That should be immediately disqualified.

Some of the applicants have repeatedly been insulting in their responses to posts but now want to be moderator. You cannot post in a respectful way as a mere forum user, yet you want to moderate how others post?

If it says "applications only", and the CM says again to keep it to "applications only" and that all other posts will be removed, those who applied after that was posted twice should be disqualified for either not being able to follow directions or disregard of the posting rules.

As many have stated, it would be beneficial to have forum mods for each forum, or at the very least each sub-section, and in different time zones. It's apparently not for lack of volunteers.

Why so serious? I see your point, but considering that the admins haven't been on the same page about bans and what's bannable, the history is more or less irrelevant. I don't just say that to make excuses for myself. Obviously I really think being banned before does not disqualify someone, as I personally applied for mod anyways myself.

+1 about having more mods though.

Anyways on a more serious note, Elena would make a good mod for the archer forums. I know that is one of her frequent haunts :P She can add more math!

And I refer to her as feminine because of roleplaying purposes.

SashaGray - Heavens Tear · October 2010

Aesthor - Heavens Tear wrote: »

Why would I be humble? My ego is being fed and inflated.

http://www.freakingnews.com/pictures/9500/Got-Brains-9844.jpg

Moderator Application Discussion Thread

Comments

Categories