You could always do the SH Siege the way our Alliance does. Set up a private siege event with two groups, where one group is a single person who just sits and watches their guild hall get destroyed. It works, and both teams get the full rewards. It's a win-win for those who don't like PVP.
As someone in a VERY small guild, I agree, there needs to be a change. We have players that REFUSE to do PVP, and for the most part, the majority DOESN'T want to do it (myself included, as it's not something I enjoy). However, we've been stuck on the Archer's Tower for months, since only about three people do PVP on a…