test content
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc

700 boxes and just 1 good item.

claudiuuuxclaudiuuux Member Posts: 6 Arc User
edited October 2013 in General Discussion (PC)
Hey guys i just wanna let you know that i opened 700 boxes in just 2 hours , spent around 15 mil ad and all i got was a pseudodragon ..My opinion is that this is hard time scamming i dunno.Wanna hear ur opinion about this. its like 0.15% chances to get a purples mount or pet .
Post edited by claudiuuux on
«1

Comments

  • mbllanes199mbllanes199 Member, Banned Users, Neverwinter Beta Users Posts: 429
    edited October 2013
    you should have taken a bath before opening any boxes... lol.
  • kozi001kozi001 Member, NW M9 Playtest Posts: 876 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    700 boxes?

    Next time buy p.vorpal+p.soulforged instead...
  • trollgretrollgre Member Posts: 297
    edited October 2013
    just buy from AH if you want box mount
    zen mount > box mount
  • bluedarkybluedarky Member Posts: 1,232 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    claudiuuux wrote: »
    Hey guys i just wanna let you know that i opened 700 boxes in just 2 hours , spent around 15 mil ad and all i got was a pseudodragon ..My opinion is that this is hard time scamming i dunno.Wanna hear ur opinion about this. its like 0.15% chances to get a purples mount or pet .

    I hate to say this, but as I've said before it's next to impossible to get a ratio that's even just a little off off a single positive result. It's like me saying that because I flipped a coin ten times and got 1 heads and 9 tails the odds of getting a Heads result is 10%.

    Cryptic have access to the real numbers and of the results all across the server, I'm fairly certain that if the results were that disparagingly off they'd correct the randomisation algorithms to compensate. (Average tests on lockboxes in CO and STO came out at about 1-2% for the top prize)
  • pers3phonepers3phone Banned Users, Neverwinter Beta Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    Just don't open them, don't be an addict gambler. As a poster above said, buy Perfect enchants instead, screw ugly birdmonster mount and useless pseudominilizard pet... or buy from AH if you really, REALLY must have them.
  • colonelwingcolonelwing Member Posts: 1,448 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    The grand prize, in any cryptic lockboxes usually has a 1% drop chance. It's been like that since they introduced the boxes. At that time, the developers were present in their games and gave insight on numbers. I doubt, that the rates from CO/STO/NW are different. So yeah, 1% seems about right. Not sure about the second prize currently aka. pseudo dragon, but i'd assume that it is slightly higher than 1%.

    Cheers.

  • claudiuuuxclaudiuuux Member Posts: 6 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    The grand prize, in any cryptic lockboxes usually has a 1% drop chance. It's been like that since they introduced the boxes. At that time, the developers were present in their games and gave insight on numbers. I doubt, that the rates from CO/STO/NW are different. So yeah, 1% seems about right. Not sure about the second prize currently aka. pseudo dragon, but i'd assume that it is slightly higher than 1%.

    Cheers.
    welll if it would been 1% i would get 7 mount or pseudo or at least close to 7...but rly just 1 out of 700 boxes seems scaming to me. if i would get at least 3 i would have beed satisfied but 1 its just imposible from them to fk me like that.
  • pers3phonepers3phone Banned Users, Neverwinter Beta Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    claudiuuux wrote: »
    welll if it would been 1% i would get 7 mount or pseudo or at least close to 7...but rly just 1 out of 700 boxes seems scaming to me. if i would get at least 3 i would have beed satisfied but 1 its just imposible from them to fk me like that.

    RNG doesn't work like this. 700 boxes is not enough for you to reach statistical equivalence on your results (although it's a respectable number).

    Just ignore boxes. In a way, they are meant to scam people like it happened to you, just like the casinos... offer the chance of high prizes, and people will think "OMG, I'll be lucky".

    Well, don't be a fool and don't indulge the scammers. Hope you learned something...

    Never buy keys, boxes, never open them, ignore them completely other than selling them to fools.
  • colonelwingcolonelwing Member Posts: 1,448 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    On a sidenote, i yet have to open a box, that doesn't give me the 40k AD i used to buy a key back. So, no it is not always a loss. If Tymora is with you, you will have nothing to fear anyway. *cough*

  • degraafinationdegraafination Member, Neverwinter Beta Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    15 million? On keys? Like someone said, buy the P. Vorpal man. Geez.

    Now, this will make you sick... One guild member opened two boxes (just two, no more), and got two Owl Bears in a row. Instant 2 million AD! Bam!
    PWP_zpsf8f711ce.jpg
    Join Essence of Aggression: PVP-ing Hard Since Beta!
  • tongasaurusrextongasaurusrex Member Posts: 4 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    200 boxes... got not one Owlbear or Dragon.... got more level 6 and 7 enchantments then I could use on 50 characthers tho........oh and a ton of HAMSTER that MIGHT be of use, if the crafing was of much interest to me........

    Mine was a mix of RL Cash and AD...

    What a rip - off.

    I mean I understand random is random.... but come on....

    Not to mention, Zen and In-Game currency purchases that dont find their way to my iventory until AFTER I file a report, that it takes DAYS for them to bother to answer....

    Wish I did not enjoy the missions, so I would have an easier time just dumping this half-assed tragedy of a game.
  • claudiuuuxclaudiuuux Member Posts: 6 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    bluedarky wrote: »
    I hate to say this, but as I've said before it's next to impossible to get a ratio that's even just a little off off a single positive result. It's like me saying that because I flipped a coin ten times and got 1 heads and 9 tails the odds of getting a Heads result is 10%.

    Cryptic have access to the real numbers and of the results all across the server, I'm fairly certain that if the results were that disparagingly off they'd correct the randomisation algorithms to compensate. (Average tests on lockboxes in CO and STO came out at about 1-2% for the top prize)

    lol man..its not like that. do it 100 times or 700 times not 10 times...and u will see u will get it close to 50-50%. I didnt just opened 10 or 100 lets say i done it 7 times x 100 and its just 1 it gave 1% lets say..so ur wrong with ur example
  • theprofessorxxtheprofessorxx Member Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    yeah i say it's a rip-off to..i opened 400 boxes got apsolutly nothing and i just gave up..they are ripping you man sry about you.I know when i opened those 400 if i had more ad out of frustration u wanna open more..SO dont tel that bull**** to buy p.vorpla when you are mad and frustrated ;).You help thm by buying that zen and spend ad to buy zen from players and they just rip you off.Shame on them
  • dndmasterdarkdndmasterdark Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    I got an owlbear mount on my 7th key ever used.
  • sockmunkeysockmunkey Member Posts: 4,622 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    Its been said before. And it seems it needs to be said again, as many times as needed.

    Cryptic's RNG has a tendency to be streaky. This can be both good and bad.

    For example, if you are having good luck. Its worth your time to keep pushing on.

    However if you are on a bad streak. STOP! This is where the complaints of "I failed 10 times on a resource node" or "I failed to fuse 8 times in a row on a 90%" When its obvious you are locked into a bad streak, for pities sake STOP. Do something else, come back later. Break the streak and try again.

    Opening 700 boxes in a rapid series of mass clicks is pretty much a sure fire way for the RNG to lock you into a bad streak and destroy your will for living. It is ALWAYS better to open a few at a time.
  • grungebrmpkgrungebrmpk Member, Neverwinter Guardian Users Posts: 201 Bounty Hunter
    edited October 2013
    Gambling is not good for the wallet :P
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • sapientcrowsapientcrow Member Posts: 57
    edited October 2013
    700 boxes in 2 hours.
    I would advise you to go and invest in day trading or something much more lucrative if you have the time and extra $$ to spend.

    As far as boxes given that the game is free to play and the boxes are their main cash makers I would say the boxes are rigged yes but it is not scam it is blatantly obvious. Boxes is how they make money so I would not be surprised if they have an algorithm that spits out x amount of good items per opens so they can track the metrics and have more on paper investment money.

    But seriously with that kind of gambling you could of made real cash.
  • colonelwingcolonelwing Member Posts: 1,448 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    sockmunkey wrote: »
    Its been said before. And it seems it needs to be said again, as many times as needed.

    Cryptic's RNG has a tendency to be streaky. This can be both good and bad.

    For example, if you are having good luck. Its worth your time to keep pushing on.

    However if you are on a bad streak. STOP! This is where the complaints of "I failed 10 times on a resource node" or "I failed to fuse 8 times in a row on a 90%" When its obvious you are locked into a bad streak, for pities sake STOP. Do something else, come back later. Break the streak and try again.

    Opening 700 boxes in a rapid series of mass clicks is pretty much a sure fire way for the RNG to lock you into a bad streak and destroy your will for living. It is ALWAYS better to open a few at a time.


    This is how it works, you're right




    **
    I have a great method for fusing gems.

    Do not stick to the same stack of gems. Keep switching around, back and forth. Fuse radiants, then for example, empowered runestones, then Darks, then azures etc.

    I almost never fail at fusing, back in CO i fused rank 8's without protection wards by using this method.

    **



    Best of luck to whoever tries out my method.

  • jarlsburgjarlsburg Member Posts: 222 Bounty Hunter
    edited October 2013
    That's a LOT of boxes. I bought a bunch of keys with some spare AD when the keys were on sale and I was in the mood to gamble so I opened a few of the new boxes. I hated the Feywild boxes because IMO they were horrible and am not really seeing the value in these boxes either. They are better than the Feywild ones, but there is still a high chance to get almost nothing of value when you open one. The Profession pack is a huge loss and the enchantment packs are almost always a loss as well because there is no chance at a coal ward. The new equipment pack is another huge loss because the weapons suck. The level 60 weapons (for a 60 player) are WAY worse than all the blues we are finding everywhere. Sadly, unless you get a mount, pet, or idol you pretty much lose money with these boxes and some of them are a total loss. Lucky for me the drop rate of the new boxes is low and I didn't have too many of them to open or I would have wasted even more AD. I think I only had 13 or so total from all of my toons.

    Unfortunately (or actually lucky for me this time) opening those few boxes didn't cure my gambling bug and I still had keys left so I opened a bunch of nightmare boxes. I was after profession packs because I needed some more adventurers and I know they drop pretty steadily from the boxes so I figured I shouldn't lose too badly. I made a killing. After I used 20 keys I got 2 mounts almost back to back. It felt like it was Nightmare Thursday and I was the Lucky one for once. Even if I didn't get the mounts I still would have made money back from the nightmare boxes because the coal wards and adventurers I got almost paid for my keys.
  • clpminiclpmini Member Posts: 5 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    claudiuuux wrote: »
    welll if it would been 1% i would get 7 mount or pseudo or at least close to 7...but rly just 1 out of 700 boxes seems scaming to me. if i would get at least 3 i would have beed satisfied but 1 its just imposible from them to fk me like that.

    I am not sure you understand how statistics work. Each lockbox may give you a 1% chance to get the loot you're looking for (I say "may" because I am not certain exactly what the chance is). So you went through 700 boxes, each box was independent of any other box, so you had 700 attempts at a 1 in 100 shot at a desirable outcome.
  • norobladnoroblad Member Posts: 556 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    it is not a scam. Its just gambling, with --- wait for it --- a low chance to get the "jackpot" reward of a mount or pet and a high chance to get a junk reward of total garbage. That is how gambling works --- you take money from a LOT of suckers and occasionally, you pay a small amount of that back if they "win". Except here, the reward does not even cost PWE anything, lol, its just bits in a data file.
  • jarlsburgjarlsburg Member Posts: 222 Bounty Hunter
    edited October 2013
    Hell, it would only slightly surprise me to find out the *ADMIN* announcements that player so and so got a Stag, or Owlbear, or Dragon or what have you was garbage, manufactured to lure people into thinking they had a legit chance.

    Vegas Slot Machines pay better odds then this horsecrap.

    Nope, they are real winners. I have seen my name in there a few times and I have messaged some of the winners trying to make a deal on the item they just won.

    Honestly, I have the best luck when I open a bunch of lockboxes at one time. Opening 2 or 3 here or there never seemed to do me much good. But....what Sockmunkey said is still true...if I open a bunch and they are giving me junk I stop for a bit to get out of that bad loop. The boxes have a tendency to give you the same prize over and over if you keep going very quickly.

    And I agree 100%....I would not put any RL money into opening lockboxes. For me they just exist as something to waste some AD on when I have a lot just sitting around.
  • sockmunkeysockmunkey Member Posts: 4,622 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    jarlsburg wrote: »
    and I have messaged some of the winners trying to make a deal on the item they just won.

    Thats all but impossible. Considering the message only has the character name and not the players @handle. A little embellishing perhaps?
  • jarlsburgjarlsburg Member Posts: 222 Bounty Hunter
    edited October 2013
    sockmunkey wrote: »
    Thats all but impossible. Considering the message only has the character name and not the players @handle. A little embellishing perhaps?

    Does it say I have messaged EVERY SINGLE WINNER??? No it does not. With the search feature you can find players occasionally with just their name. A lot of the time people open their boxes in PE, and if they are there it is not that hard to figure out who they are. It does not work all the time, but you can find them.

    As a matter of fact....It is not that hard to figure out who it is because I got messages from three different players the other day asking me how many keys I used when I got two Inferno mounts almost back to back. My character's name is a common one and players were still able to find me with no trouble.
  • bluedarkybluedarky Member Posts: 1,232 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    claudiuuux wrote: »
    lol man..its not like that. do it 100 times or 700 times not 10 times...and u will see u will get it close to 50-50%. I didnt just opened 10 or 100 lets say i done it 7 times x 100 and its just 1 it gave 1% lets say..so ur wrong with ur example

    The point was though that you were going off one positive result, as others have said the RNG tends to be streaky but over time averages out to the results Cryptic have programmed.

    Thousands, possibly millions of lockboxes are opened everyday, it's not hard to realise that you can be on an unlucky streak with the RNG. In the grand scheme of things you probably lowered the average drop rates of the mount and pet by a negligible and probably unnoticeable amount.

    1 person getting a 1 in 700 result proves nothing.
  • dndmasterdarkdndmasterdark Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    how many trade bars did you get out of that? Enough to buy 2 or 3 epic mounts?
  • mytgroomytgroo Member, Neverwinter Beta Users Posts: 165 Bounty Hunter
    edited October 2013
    Tried the boxes found them lacking. It is better to save up systematically and buy from the Auction House.
  • krisst0fkrisst0f Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users, Neverwinter Knight of the Feywild Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    "Only God can make a random number" used to claim Albert Einstein...

    And Cryptic's RNG is CLEARLY NOT RANDOM AT ALL, not even close. They need to at least make is so that the advertized drop rates occurs as random...

    It seems that when you get a good drop, the next 5 or so will be good... but if you get a bad one, well, the next 100 probably be as well...

    THIS IS NOT RANDOM. Get to work.
  • adozuadozu Member Posts: 477 Arc User
    edited October 2013
    no computer can make entirely random numbers but they get close enough, i'm sure cryptic has decent rng.

    clustering illusion, really.
  • vortix44vortix44 Member Posts: 680 Bounty Hunter
    edited October 2013
    700 boxes and nothing but one second-rate item?
    So, the rate is more one per thousand than one per cent. 700 is a lot of boxes, definitely enough to test a RNG. When Monsanto tests if their new ADN-modified corn kills bees, they don't use that many bees.

    Are the other areas of the game with a said 1% actually 1%?
    English is not my first language.
Sign In or Register to comment.