test content
Logo
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc
Nerf astral shield
fasthands23
Member Posts: 48
make it so this skill doesn't stack.
nobody likes cheese strats.
nobody likes cheese strats.
Post edited by fasthands23 on
0
Comments
Patch Notes:
- Credit Cards will charge 10% quicker
Priorities...
Do not nerf Astral Shield. Do not nerf the healing stacking on Astral shield.
Nerf the Mitigation stacking of Astral shield. It should have a DR for each additional shield past the first.
Yes I play a Cleric, I also used to play a Tank. Having a 12K GF who logs on to pray and send minions on crafting only is depressing.
i also play cleric.
Screaming for a full nerf is not the way to go. You need checks and balance.
On the occasions I do run double cleric (not too often I find 2DC groups kinda dull) I try and spread the AS out some anyway. Some mobs (Driders) will strip AS away, other that that putting both AS in the same place just ensures that the entire area is blanketed with splats. Remove the ~90% mitigation that 2 shields give and try and stand in stacked AS in those situations and you'll see very different results.
IMO the mitigation % is the issue, not the healing which in of itself is pretty marginal. The reason its OP currently is getting ~90% mitigation (when stacked) it really dont matter how much your being healed for, your just never going to be in danger. Drop that Mitigation and the healing actually starts to matter, at that point should you be running 2 DC in your group, do you really want thier healing to be halved? Sure we have other spells, Beacon (lol long *** CD) Forgemasters - Awseome *if* you can hug the mob for its duration, Healing word, 12s charge refresh .. etc etc.
Like it or not AS is one of our main spells, calling for a blanket nerf is not the answer, it needs adjusting when stacked yes ... it does not need to be nerf'd the hell out of.
Aye its freaking sad. My GF is geared, Conq spec so holds aggro pretty well and does decent DPS. Of course that DPS is AOE which matters not one bit when the 2 CW are just tossing everything into the pits. Its not that I cant be useful in a group, its just that taking another DPS or Cleric is just *more* useful. /facepalm
This!
Don't destroy your healers. You will soon regret it when you can't get ANY heals anymore. Diminishing returns please, NOT destroying the class and forcing other things.
I play a cleric as main but ive got one of every class to 20+ so i could get to grips with what they do. Its sad that its being abused but its a good spell.
Head of PR
http://www.gamersaurs.com/
- Drizzt Do'Urden
― R.A. Salvatore
That debuff is there so that we use as many pots as the other classes ... apparently.
This. This. This.
Yes, but using 40% more than them now is kinda overboard.
Heh I hate the debuff. Its a dumb mechanic esp since clerics are threat magnets. Apparently the Dev's reasoning behind the debuff was that clerics were not using enough potions in relation to other classes. <font color="orange">HAMSTER</font> metric to balance a class by IMO but whatever. If they fixed GF, you know so that thier threat moves / encounter powers hit more than 3-5 targets and they could hold the adds off a cleric, then I would'ent mind the debuff so much since it would be down to the tank to protect me, you know team work. As is, I kite, alot.
the skill is broken to begin with, flat 40% reduction of everything is obscene. allowing such a skill to stack is laughable to say the least.
Your opinion is your own and I have no desire to change it. As it happens I agree with your opinion on the skill, as worded in the quote, just not your plan of resolution. You claimed that it *should'ent stack at all* I disagree there. The healing should stack, this is not even a debate in my mind. If your against the healing from AS stacking then you must be against the healing from Forgemasters stacking too right? Both are hots, both are proximity based (Blue circle / next to mob) I dont see it. Healing is the core of the class and to not allow it to stack is just not on the table as far as I'm concerned.
Then you dismissed a DR system. Saying that, again, it *should'ent stack at all* ... I disagree again. Its a powerful high level skill. It needs re-tuned yes, I agree here. Stacking 2x40% + 11% Foresight is stupid OP and needs toned down. There should be an advantage having two AS down though over one as far as mitigation goes. DR it, make it heavy, but leave it there. You would'ent call for the second rogue in a party to be unable to damage / debuff any target the first rogue was on would you? So why would you invalidate a second DC?
You don't need to stack it now. It's just easier. As long as double cleric trivializes incoming damage with double astral shield, people will use it. The solution is to let the healing stack but the damage reduction shouldn't stack. If you have double cleric than you get more incoming healing and you also get a wider area of damage reduction, but you don't get to completely trivialize incoming damage.
Having your class based around one broken skill is boring. I hate being that dude that everybody brings to the party simply because you have one irreplaceable buff. Every cleric should be for an astral shield nerf so they can get a balanced, more fun class to play.
Another person who has no clue about the game mechanics. Can someone delete this thread entirely?
I seldom run 2xDC I find it dull. My usual comp is DC, CW, CW, RG, GWF.
As I've mentioned I have a GF character that is pretty much retired. I would love to run a 5 class group, but tbh current state of the game means we just dont require a tank for anything. Still as you can see from the group I generally run, I try to be a varied as poss and we do run 4/5 classes rather then the 2DC/2CW/1RG or 2DC/2RG/1CW groups most seem to run.
explain? ive cleared every t2 with 1 of each class setup.
you are a bright individual.
I think you get my point. You are trying to say if there are 2 clerics, make one of them not count. That is just silly.
im not gona bother explaining to you why that is an awful comparison.
Elocin - Renegade Drow - 39 Devoted Cleric of Selune - Mindflayer
Looking for some Dust of Forum Troll Disappearance ? Sprinkle this on any troll to phase shift them out of your plane of existence.
You couldn't stack PWB in wow, you couldn't stack healing ward, or 2 cleric cel regens or vie in EQ1, you can't stack devo from 2 paladins in wow - and theres a reason games didn't allow you to stack mitigation methods from different players of the same class like this, and that reason is exactly what we're seeing now with people basically just defaulting that method and changing gameplay entirely from what was intended, to a much easier reality.
There are lots of issues with cleric, and I realize that this ability stacking is what makes things possible/easier for a lot of people so there is a lot of reluctance to let go of it, but they should simultaneously fix our other problems and remove this as far as I'm concerned.
So, I at least support this
If Astral Shield is a literally all a cleric is good for, then we have bigger problems.
And it's not like double AS becomes useless if the mitigation didn't stack.
The heal would still stack and you could spread them out so you have more room to work with while still getting mitigation.
i prefer to not give <font color="orange">HAMSTER</font> the light of day
I wish some people would go back to playing their god awful hunters on world of warcraft already... it's almost to the point where I would pay their subs to get them to leave, haha.