test content
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc

Bots and the simple truth

ldedric1ldedric1 Member Posts: 36 Arc User
edited July 2015 in General Discussion (PC)
This is a discussion on Bots their origins and how they effects the in game economy of MMO's now.

Here is a brief history of Bots:

Bots have been around for decades they are relatively easy to create by those with relative skill in programming, they began in the mid 60's to do repetitive tasks and as technology has increased so have the bots to do mostly simple repetitive tasks. As more people began investing time into bots they began to get more and more complex and able to do a great variety of tasks making the workload for many business much easier.

Now as the video game industry started moving into MMPOG's games the bots inevitable followed. Most players would use bots to do repetitive tasks to build skill, a small group of people in different games with some programming knowledge began finding new ways to do simple tasks in game to get things like resources or to keep track of rare events. Soon after we would find much of the things they were doing on ebay and other trading sites.

The industry inevitably we after these "exploiters" as they saw them as detrimental to their game however they represents such a small portion of the player base and they were not actually breaking any TOS rules at that time, the overall effects were negligible. However as programmers began making better and better bots the effects started to become more apparent.

====== What the players want to know is here ======

Now here is where it effects you in any game you play where botters and or gold sellers are prevalent.
First and foremost resources: Bots will gather resources for things like professions, and enchantments and some high end bots can even combat the mobs set to guard these points of interest be it nodes or a chest or simply killing mobs to gather from heroic encounters and drops from dragon hoard enchantments. Now how does this effect you as a player? Because of the bots ability to gather a great many of something quickly the price of these items will drop down dramatically for players to purchase, so they the players themselves do not have to do a repetitive task for several hours, this may seem like a good thing however let's look at the rest of it.

As bots are gathering simple resources and selling them and gaining in game currency, they also do many things in game to directly effect the player driven economy by artificiality inflating the price of more rare items by manipulating the market by buying out these items until they reach a level where they can sell them to make even more of the in game currency, this inevitably forces the price of the items to go up, purposefully out of the reach of the casual players ability to get it. The Bots then sell the items at this price while offering to sell you the same item or the Astral Diamonds to buy it in game for actual money. This is where they profit, and you pay, not once not twice not even three times, but every time they make any transaction with a player it costs you the player three times as much. These are only the direct results of the bots within a game.

More indirect actions include, but are not limited to, a loss in public trust in the gaming company to properly manage its product, lost revenue to the video game company, and as this problem increases a clear reduction in players playing their game.

The only thing you as a player can do to combat this is not buy from botters and gold sellers, and encourage your friends to do the same. As long as their is a market for it botters will continue to operate in the game(s) you enjoy playing inevitably destroying them.

Also please feel free to post in other topics regarding the botters their issues and possible solutions for it.
«1

Comments

  • skitzopyroskitzopyro Member Posts: 125 Arc User
    As bots are gathering simple resources and selling them and gaining in game currency, they also do many things in game to directly effect the player driven economy by artificiality inflating the price of more rare items by manipulating the market by buying out these items until they reach a level where they can sell them to make even more of the in game currency, this inevitably forces the price of the items to go up, purposefully out of the reach of the casual players ability to get it. The Bots then sell the items at this price while offering to sell you the same item or the Astral Diamonds to buy it in game for actual money. This is where they profit, and you pay, not once not twice not even three times, but every time they make any transaction with a player it costs you the player three times as much. These are only the direct results of the bots within a game.

    This is not just bots this is the player who thinks he is playing "merchant" these are the "whales" of the game. Players like this are the detriment of the game economy. Like stocks they think buy low, sell high, make marginal profit but of course this just raises prices of items in high demand.
  • edited July 2015
    This content has been removed.
  • edited July 2015
    This content has been removed.
  • ldedric1ldedric1 Member Posts: 36 Arc User
    edited July 2015
    Yes, the botters may manipulate the market to gain profile, but who cares.
    no, a BOT will always sell stock piles and sell at the price the economy asks too, they sell at the price that is selling.
    They are not affecting economy, as they are just offering players advancement.

    A Bot sells whatever they are farming for what they want to, in most cases they sell basic resources for crafting and enhancements from farming skill nodes or running a bot program tied to 5 accounts doing heroics or instances for hours/days on end. Now as I said above these "resources" are cheap for the player because they toss so many of them on the market.

    Now the refineing system is the way it is "because" it is very easy for the average player to buy the enhancements from the botters to level up their artifacts and other gear.

    I can almost guarantee, with a bit of speculation, that the cost of refineing items would be 1/2 of what it is now or less if players had to get the items on their own and with the removal of botters to have the average price of enhancements go up.

    This also benefits the new player and veteran player who chooses to farm nodes/chests as it gives them a legitimate income for in game currency that otherwise would not be available. Combined with a slow reduction in cost of the artifact or equipment (whales will inevitable try to keep prices higher) as a whole and a reduction in the cost of refineing said artifact or equipment because the base refineing points are more difficult to get.

    ====== Conclusion ======

    So in the end without bots, you get a higher costing and more stable way of getting your refineing points, a reduction in how much it costs to get the item and refine the item, as well as a legitimate way for players to earn astral diamond in game which you are asking for anyway.

    So what is the downside, because I don't see one.
  • skitzopyroskitzopyro Member Posts: 125 Arc User
    You have that all backwards Bots are the ones who sell large quantity's at low prices because they only want to obtain currency as fast as possible.
    Players will put prices at higher than the lowest price because they want to make profit and they need to get the most currency for the work they do.
    A player see's his/her time as much more important so they demand more value from an item.
    The botter obtain's insane amounts of items so they see less value in the item and sell at lower prices.

    There are two types of bots in this game.
    The Farmer: This bot collects items to sell.
    The Merchant: This bot is an auction house bot its job is to get the low bids on items and turn around to sell them with high buyouts. Ever wonder why its so hard to beat those bid snipers? This is why.
  • This content has been removed.
  • ldedric1ldedric1 Member Posts: 36 Arc User
    The reality is you can get rid of them if you remove their ability to transfer items and currency to players.
  • edited July 2015
    This content has been removed.
  • This content has been removed.
  • This content has been removed.
  • drkbodhidrkbodhi Member, NW M9 Playtest Posts: 2,378 Arc User
    When you remove the need you remove the exploitation. Create a system where all dungeon runs release BtA or BtC items... such as RP, high-end enchants and gear. Every drop in DD, Skirmishes and bound to the account or to the character.

    They can't sell Seals, they can't sell the items that they get from Seals. Allow them to keep the "HAMSTER greens" and "HAMSTER blues", no one picks those up anyways. Why because no one really needs them. I used to pick them up for gold, but now I run lv 6 Dungeons in SCA for all my gold needs.​​
    ez0sf4K.png
    Atwil "At" - Tiefling TR / Saardush - Black Dragonborn GWF / White - Tiefling OP
    Leadership Council of Civil Anarchy
    SYNERGY Alliance
  • commanderdata002commanderdata002 Member Posts: 312 Arc User
    edited July 2015
    That might be true but in the past during mod1-3 you make a good party and farm CN 2-3 hours daily and you can get a competitve gear.
    I saw a guy with good gear(mod1-3): oh he must have good skills and do lots of good CN/GG runs.

    Now (mod4+) I see someone with BIS gear: Meh. Just another wallet warrior or botter...
    Post edited by commanderdata002 on
    stock and stone I can master, but there's a Wizard to manage here!
  • This content has been removed.
  • edited July 2015
    This content has been removed.
  • putzboy78putzboy78 Member, NW M9 Playtest Posts: 1,950 Arc User
    The argument that BOTs can manipulate the economy is weak. The game company sets the economy through in game vendors and systems like ZEN. BOTs answer to the call of supply/demand. They supply a good to meet a demand in the case of AD and enchants the demand is to provide these goods for less than a player can achieve in game and less than the game company is offering the same or similar services. People are frantic for AD to buy GMoP and wards which can only be acquired from the game company. Since a single GMoP takes four days of refining RAD to acquire progression appears slow (don't forget a rank 10 today is the equivelant of a rank 7 in pre-MOD 6). With the introduction of Module 6 everyone needed 13-22 (companions) enchantment upgrades per playable characters to remain at the same relative level of performance (this does not include the addition of new features like rank 11/12 weapon/armor enchantments, lvling new artifact equipment, and a fourth artifact).

    Each rank 7 enchant would need 5 GMOP's to become rank 10

    13-22 rank 7 enchants upgraded to rank 10 requires 65-110 GMOPs

    That's 6,500,000-11,000,000 AD or 271-459 days of fully refining your RAD (and earning said RAD). This does not include the RP, wards, and other reagents you are required to acquire.

    So in order to get yourself back to the same level you achieved by playing for two years prior to the module release you need to spend 271-459 days just on the enchants. In that time you will also need to acquire new mounts because your BIS mount is no longer BIS. New gear because your Mod 6 BIS gear is no longer BIS. Effectively there is no way for a F2P to keep up with the power curve in the game without turning to other means of acquiring goods at a lower price... insert gold spammers here.

    So you want to know why gold spammers exist, its because they help to make plausible what the game company did not. Once upon a time in NW a person could play X hours a day to overcome the pay wall but since NW has been effectively relegated to RAD refinement limits for income that is not possible. People then moved to alt farms to overcome the RAD limit; however, you cannot play alt farms else you will hit the same challenge above in equipping them. Which is why people turned to methods of income that do not require equipping/maintaining enchants. Insert leadership profession.

    The answer is simple. For F2P players progression should be tied to playing time not daily limits. A F2P player should be able to get an item up to BIS just as it gets replaced. For example its reasonable for a F2P to get their main-hand up to legendary before new BIS main-hands are introduced (the recent trend has been 3-4 months). This ensures F2P players remain competitive and interested so they can serve as fodder to the P2W players.

    As a person living in a low paying/cost of living country where my lunch costs $1.60 US, I can assure you that twisting my arm to buy zen will not work (you cannot draw blood from a stone).
  • locksanpocketslocksanpockets Member, NW M9 Playtest Posts: 111 Arc User

    metalldjt wrote: »
    4.6 mil RP / 50k RP = 90 runs of the dungeon x 4 artifact gear items 360 dungeon runs
    1 dungeon run takes 30-1 hour .
    360 hours / 24hr = 15 days that you need to spend them by doing dungeons.

    This is just for 1 character. Consider the players who would like to be able to play more than one class. It's not hard to see how difficult it would be achieve the above with more than one character, and there are 8 different classes to date, and more on the way.

    This game is so alternate hostile it's toxic.

  • dragoness10dragoness10 Member, NW M9 Playtest Posts: 780 Arc User
    Speaking from a volunteer Dev's side of ye olde NWN Classic:

    Bots are there because people don't want to put in effort and time into what may be a repetitive task. The old UOAbigail and CRN305 crafting systems had bots created for them since somebody didn't want to sit there clicking a button 100 times in a row at a stationary crafting station. The argument against these bots were " if this is a social place where people are supposed to roleplay, and interact with each other being permanently AFK works against this, and is not the goal of the server".

    This makes sense! In order to achieve anything in a game or accomplish goals you need to put in effort. Bots are non-effort cheats that encourage anti-social behaviors. It makes no sense try to get a high level character with best gear if you're going to do nothing with it but stand there for hours AFK defeating the purpose of an MMO.

    Massive Multiplayer Online, not Massive Singleplayer AFK.

    Another reason people have used bots is for the "must have every class and every item and everything and be rich" mentality. This is a lack of focus on quality over quantity. Nobody makes you have 30 charecters. Nobody makes you buy 20 companions, particicpate in events, run dungeons, or open Lockboxes. These are choices, and some people forget they have a choice to NOT have it all. It is okay to not be top everything. Materialism will not bring you play skills - practice will.

    Sure, it helps to have an Epic mount, and maybe some nice dyes over that armor looks better so go ahead and spend a LITTLE money. That supports the game itself, the staff, the developers, and keeps it going for US the players. Just keep to a sensible budget so RL money stays where it's needed most.

    Don't bot "because it's harmless". Don't passively sit there refusing to report bots saying "that's the Devs' job to fix it, not mine". People send bots in with creative new methods that can take time to spot or fix if there are fewer people helping out. The playerbase here can help keep ahead of the bot problem by being the many responsible people whom level responsibly, trade responsibly, and act as a community working together.
    " I tried to figure out the enigma that was you, and then I realized mastering Wild Magic was easier." - Old Wizard in Waterdeep

    "Why is it dragons only use ketchup? I'd like a little wasabi please. Us silvers like a variety of condiments."

    "Don't call them foolish mortals. One, they don't learn from it. Two, It just ticks them off." - An Ancient Red Dragon
  • quspivquspiv Member, NW M9 Playtest Posts: 1,087 Arc User
    ^ You forgot the part where botters can earn lot's of $ with very little effort due to game errors. LIke setting Hard Cap for AD, so botters can profit by offering better exchange rates. There are also other stupid things that can be botted, because Devs didnt gate them behind weekly or daily quests.
  • subnoctesubnocte Member Posts: 341 Arc User
    Bots are mostly a symptom of grind. It's usually the grindiest games that have the biggest problem with them, and mod 6 has made the game exceptionally grindy.

    People do report bots but nothing seems to get done. While gateway may be a source of botting, in game it has to be worse, just looking at AH shows all the literally thousands of refinement stones and profession stuff that is so obviously from bots being sold all day every day.
  • edited July 2015
    This content has been removed.
  • subnoctesubnocte Member Posts: 341 Arc User
    magenubbie wrote: »
    subnocte wrote: »
    Bots are mostly a symptom of grind. It's usually the grindiest games that have the biggest problem with them, and mod 6 has made the game exceptionally grindy.

    People do report bots but nothing seems to get done. While gateway may be a source of botting, in game it has to be worse, just looking at AH shows all the literally thousands of refinement stones and profession stuff that is so obviously from bots being sold all day every day.
    It's not the grind itself that draws bots to a game. It's the level of profit you can gain from grinding in mass numbers that draws them. 15 enchantments an hour is not much, but if you do that with 500 characters at the same it suddenly becomes very profitable, especially if it doesn't require any human interaction.

    It's the grind that creates the demand. Everybody needs so much stuff for refinement and it's no longer feasible to get it, so people buy from bots on AH or from gold sellers.
  • This content has been removed.
  • theycallmetomutheycallmetomu Member, NW M9 Playtest Posts: 1,861 Arc User
    Take down the AH entirely, make 100% of everything Bind to Account on pickup, and then start making things NOT bound (and reintroducing the AH) piece by piece.

    That's the "Tough Decision" that needs to be made to combat bots!
  • subnoctesubnocte Member Posts: 341 Arc User
    magenubbie wrote: »
    subnocte wrote: »
    magenubbie wrote: »
    subnocte wrote: »
    Bots are mostly a symptom of grind. It's usually the grindiest games that have the biggest problem with them, and mod 6 has made the game exceptionally grindy.

    People do report bots but nothing seems to get done. While gateway may be a source of botting, in game it has to be worse, just looking at AH shows all the literally thousands of refinement stones and profession stuff that is so obviously from bots being sold all day every day.
    It's not the grind itself that draws bots to a game. It's the level of profit you can gain from grinding in mass numbers that draws them. 15 enchantments an hour is not much, but if you do that with 500 characters at the same it suddenly becomes very profitable, especially if it doesn't require any human interaction.

    It's the grind that creates the demand. Everybody needs so much stuff for refinement and it's no longer feasible to get it, so people buy from bots on AH or from gold sellers.
    And that's the flaw in the entire refining system. Bots can do it better than legit players can. Hence bots come here, hence they'll continue to make money as long as the system exists, or Cryptic finally decides to take some real action against botters and their clients.

    Yup, but they need to make the whole game far less grindy and more rewarding to play as well. Banning botting accounts is a needed step that they don't seem to be doing, but there are loads of other measures too that could limit the amount undetected bots can make while not impacting on genuine players.
  • theycallmetomutheycallmetomu Member, NW M9 Playtest Posts: 1,861 Arc User
    Make level 61-70+ more like levels 1-60 IMO.

    But, well, let's be frank: levels 1-60 only take a few days, so I can certainly see why that might be extremely difficult to pull off.

    I actually liked the way boons were implemented. There was serious power creep but they were available to anyone who wanted to spend the time to get them. I'm not really sure why they moved away from that model.
  • This content has been removed.
  • wyckedstudioswyckedstudios Member, NW M9 Playtest Posts: 36 Arc User
    Take down the AH entirely, make 100% of everything Bind to Account on pickup, and then start making things NOT bound (and reintroducing the AH) piece by piece.

    That's the "Tough Decision" that needs to be made to combat bots!

    Take away the AH, and you take away most of the need for AD. Take away most of the need for AD, and you take away a good hunk of the need for Zen. Take away any of the need for Zen, Cryptic's profits plummet. Cryptic's profits fall, they have less incentive to maintain or improve this game. Game Over.

    And if you were to slowly start re-introducing the AH, and unbound items, what exactly did you accomplish, outside of just a temporary flat-lining of the economy? the bot/farmers will just start right back up, focusing on those items.
  • darwinsradiodarwinsradio Member Posts: 61 Arc User
    Seems like a simple solution is to track down the Botters and to initiate permanent bans to all ARC games. You smack enough cheaters like that and the allure of doing it will go away

    The solution that is being used on the Gateway is just an easy way out where the developer doesn't really have to do much and the causal player like myself gets screwed.
  • This content has been removed.
  • wyckedstudioswyckedstudios Member, NW M9 Playtest Posts: 36 Arc User
    The truth, as I see it, is that botters are gonna bot. I've played a number of games that I've seen no way to monetize or profit from, yet I knew there were bots there. Perhaps its a compulsion on their part.....they do it because they CAN. Any game that can be botted, will be botted....you may lessen the bot population, but it will never be eliminated.

    Honestly, when the Gateway was introduced, I thought it was Cryptic trying to channel bots there, rather than have them in-game, adding to server load, or fighting the quixotic battle to keep them out.

    That being said.....I really miss being able to have Gateway open (but usually minimized) all day on my work computer.
Sign In or Register to comment.