Anyone slot this? Is it still broken? Put points in it because it sounded nifty and better than the passive it is next to on the same tier (wrathful warrior iirc). Come to see it punishing charge with a dr increase per target hit and a super long cooldown.
What is the point of this thing even if it works. It is not going to replace anvil (super high damage, and a stun in the case of tacticians), or bullrush (sweet cc, lots o damage) or lunging (high damage, interrupt in the case of tacticians, nice gap closer, and for my gf a primary means of movement that is far faster than anything else
).
Even the added DR IF you hit extra targets....bullsrush and lunging already give a +50% dr....why would anyone even think of switching either of these out for lba? Granted, I think when this encounter was planned it was before the dr tweak to LS and BR. None the less it is a really high tier encounter that just seems like garbage.
We should point out more often to the devs that #1 this power is broken and is not wai (afaik) and #2 it really does not belong at the tier it is on.
We should ask for something else entirely. If they are going to put gwf encounters on our plates at that tier it should be something far better than a crappy version of punishing charge.
Comments
It should have more dmg, shorter cooldown and made to either land at your target or behined them.
I'm really with our skills we got though Line breaker assault is bad. Desperate survivals extra deflect doesn't work. It only gives the first 3% no matter if its maxed or not. Commander's strike is ok in pve i guess but bad in pvp. Shield warriors wrath is maybe the best one we got but it's only 5% more dmg than combat superiorty (if you have the feat for combat) and it requires you to block 5 attacks first.....Plus combat superiority is on perminatly with feat so I would still rather slot that....
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
I tested it on preview and that time damage and AP gain were bugged.No damage no AP.But as Crixus said,in is inconvenient to use.You do not know where you will end.It does not has a target,a hit box.And in mod6 staying out of read is of mega essense.So LNBA is out of options for me.
Good point. I should have mentioned I pretty much only pvp. It is useless in pvp.
On my IV I still have simple old ferocious reaction and guarded assault slotted as passives. Sometimes that second passive goes to trample the fallen, but the little bit of reflect dps in protracted pvp battles seems to go a long way.
I saw a cw suicide its self on my gf with ice knife yesterday and I still can't figure out if it was ferocious reaction, sos, or guarded assault that got her, or maybe all of them. In any case I can't see changing out either ferocious or guarded assault for the new higher tier passives. Desperate Survival maybe if it actually worked.
I think that's the issue and I find it quite annoying. Anytime an update comes out or new gear usually the gf gets his stuff all based on defence or team buff and not based on pvp. It should be 50/50. Look at our artifact set bonuses compared to most other classes. We get defence and hp......the defence is pointless and the hp is so small now it makes no difference, when other classes get things like power, crit and armor pen.
Both our new encounters are useless in pvp in my opinion. We should have had a decent pvp encounter.
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
Horrible they would put a bugged inferior version of a mid tier gwf encounter as a near top tier gf power. Take down might be nice though :P
Yeah takedown would be nice or they could give us Unstoppable :P
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
On the good side: commander's strike can make top 3 encounters against PvE bosses that are trivial to survive, have high HP, and don't require mobility, which is basically dragons. This is the one I have used the most.
I generally prefer combat superiority to shield warriors wrath, but in my opinion shield warrior wrath is still an admissible skill because it can be combod with combat superiority for soloing. It only makes sense when you use both. Use one? Probably want Combat Superiority.