Harper Bard and Protector's Camaraderle bonus

fra7santo

Harper Bard's attacks don't activate Protector's Camaraderle bonus. Maybe this happen because his attacks don't deal damage, but in the Protector's Camaraderle bonus is only written "whenever your summoned companion attacks" and not "deal damage" so i think that it's right that when he do his "discordant discouragement" attack (power) the bonus have to activate. Bard is one of the few good pet for support and Protector's Camaraderle one of best bonus, so please let they work together.

lucislator

bard does not attack as camarderie requires, it's not a bug, it's it mechanich

fra7santo

bard debuffs enemies it could be an attack.. he doesn't deal damage, but use a spell on the enemies.. so I don't understand why Camaraderle doesn't work ù.ù

brewald

Simply because music isn't considarated as an Attack

vickvega82

An "attack" is not the same as an "ability". Its been known that Harper bard does not trigger ProtCom. When playing a DC, bastion of health doesn't trigger attack based feats, its no different.