Stronghold should show guild marks earned

onlymat

So this way you can see who donates to the coffer and who does not. Even the "offline" people are shown so you can see it easily as guild leader.

firepats12

It shows everything people donate in the Stronghold tab in main menu.

iyodah

It shows what they donated but not the coffer gain or the marks returned to the donator

onlymat

firepats12#3687 said:

It shows everything people donate in the Stronghold tab in main menu.

and if you have 149 players in the guild how can you say how much someone gives to the guild?

firepats12

@onlymat by looking at the record....

wdj40

onlymat said:

So this way you can see who donates to the coffer and who does not. Even the "offline" people are shown so you can see it easily as guild leader.

Agreed, I would like to see total's of everything people donated to the Guild as well as previous Guild's if applicable.

iccyasd

firepats12#3687 said:

@onlymat by looking at the record....

Thank You, ill hire you as my guild accountant, you get 5G per day please record all donor and guild marks they get. By the end of the month i need a summarize record.

destrowod

lol yeah i sometimes look at the coffers donation for the last 10 donators or so, just for fun, but its way too long and tedious to see everything they donated. Showing total Guild Mark earned would probably be a good way to see how much a person usually donate.

But on a different note Stronghold is SUCH a huge scam ... just a way of slowing everybodies progression and making them loose tons of precious ADs and salvagable... Worst expension there ever was...

Don't get me wrong, the concept of having a base to chill out is good. But that thing is completely not personalizable, so whats the point? The tower in OVERLORD was more personalizable than that... Guild leader should be able to choose decoration, build buildings for real like library you could go and read all the in game lore, an armory where the weapons are on display as the guild earn them, personalized banner for the guild and so on and on. The current formula does not even have an interior part... the strongholds all look the same. We are just wasting tons of usefull ressources for some boons... thats it.

Im sorry if my guild think im not donating much (i do make the daily requirements) but im working toward gearing up my character, getting my boons from campaigns and so on and on. Thanksfully i have only 2 character, and sure once i have every boons for sharandar/dread ring etc ill still play the quest for the refinement so the items will be able to be donated, but thats the problem... its really mostly possible to donate such items only when you have finish everything... And gems especially, my god everytime i donate those i feel bad on loosing such precious refinement, it annoy me so much. Anyway...

Unknown

This content has been removed.

destrowod

And yet considering the HAMSTER tons of items you need to invest for them... there not worth it in my opinion... Doing heroics for influence is sooo tedious... and yet its only the tip of the iceberg. Im lucky some people in my guild do invest money on this game, cause without them there is no way we would be that high...

Last mail from guild leader mention extremely high donation needed for the next guild hall or whatever, and im like wow... how the hell are you guys able to afford that??? No way they could without paying... And i refuse to drop money like crazy on a single game. I always said if the game make me happy, i may drop a 10 here and there, to a 100$ maximum pay (the price of a good game at release + dlcs) but thats about it. I will NEVER, EVER, exceed 100$ on this game. Im currently at 20 spent...

Honestly if our leader was not pushing and pushing for building the guild hall, wich it seem to be what he prefer in the game, i personally wouldn't care AT ALL for this. I would had builded to market place rank 4 and thats it, the rest would be donations when you can, vouchers and stuff, but thats it.

Personally im donating what i can, extra campaign stuff sure, if gold is needed ill donate it too(i have no use for it) , i drop most of the purple i earn there as well, but its still far from one per day as i don't run that much. But i can't donate gems that i need to up my artifact like crazy ... I can't waste all my AD there as well, i still need so much to buy what i need... and so on and on...

Unknown

This content has been removed.

iyodah

To get marketplace rank 4 you have to have guild hall rank 8. So his "want" to upgrade the guild hall is probably to get the marketplace. I think you need to learn a little more about how strongholds work before jumping on the sh sucks bandwagon. I agree the donation amounts need to come down but all in all SH was a great addition (once you get high enough)

destrowod

We have MP4 since a long time. I think we are going for guild hall rank 13 now, something like that.

To me what bothers me, despite being able to give generous stats down the line(i am not denying that) is that stronghold has push the repetitive aspect and tediousness of the game to a whole new degree. Done with your boon? Keep farming the campaign for the coffer... AGAIN. Like it was not enough to do it on 2-3 or whatever characters you have. And like i said loosing ADs and so on...

And when you are in a guild, there is no given that you will always remain in it. Could be you wanting a change of air, could be differences with guild leader. Now its not my case, but it can happen to some.

But what bothers me is really the complete lack of roleplaying in that expension, when it was the biggest opportinity for it. All this stuff we donate to the coffer, it could be on display in the armory, we could made our own banners using a similar tool as the emblem creator in COD, our guild hall should be personalizable, our personel in the SH as well. Each members should be able to have his own room again personalizable.

I feel the current SH is just a way of having people shred money into the game like never before...

antwo91

An in-depth list of each member's personal donations will be such a help.
We have certain players tracking throughout the day and it's a hassle but it's what's needed to remove the people who do not contribute.

It would be nice to have that option in game and I agree with that suggestion.

armadeonx

An extra column on the member list that shows donations (by total coffer/guild mark value) over the past 7 days would be sufficient.

It's enough for guild leadership to see who is doing their bit and who isn't, just by glancing down the list - or even sorting the list by input value.

Unknown

This content has been removed.