OK, here is the Stripped Down comparison. For this one, here is what i did:
Zoned 4 times on each ship
Equipped/Uneqipped Gear & Weapons 4 times each ship
Assigned/Unassigned Bridge Officers 4 times each ship
Assigned/Unassigned Duty Officers 4 times each ship
Then Completely stripped both ships of everything
Removed All Boff's & Doff's
Removed All Traits (Starship, Character, Reputation)
Zoned Each Ship 4 more times each
No other ships in close proximity to affect stats (Cruiser Commands, Tac Teams, Etc)
Things I could not change, but are the same on both ships Character Skills
Specializations
Passive Traits/Abilities from Accolades
As you can see, the ACC, CritH, & CritD discrepancies are fixed, however, the JHAS is STILL a little better in Bonus Defense & Flight Speed than the JHSS which is supposed to have +5 Engine Power. So, not sure if that means one of the Bugs is Bugged or if that is the intended stats for the ships. So, not sure what else I can do. I'm about to start leveling up the Mastery on the JHSS to unlock the trait for my video, so once that is done, I'll level up the JHAS as well and do another comparison after the fact and see the stats then
Which I (I guess) is right for the +5 Engine Power.
Hrmmm, are there any up to date formulas out there for calculating both Flight Speed and Turn to work through the math on that? There have been a few changes over the years, so some of the results from a Google are woefully out of date.
Comments
Zoned 4 times on each ship
Equipped/Uneqipped Gear & Weapons 4 times each ship
Assigned/Unassigned Bridge Officers 4 times each ship
Assigned/Unassigned Duty Officers 4 times each ship
Then
Completely stripped both ships of everything
Removed All Boff's & Doff's
Removed All Traits (Starship, Character, Reputation)
Zoned Each Ship 4 more times each
No other ships in close proximity to affect stats (Cruiser Commands, Tac Teams, Etc)
Things I could not change, but are the same on both ships
Character Skills
Specializations
Passive Traits/Abilities from Accolades
http://s42.photobucket.com/user/tre_razor/media/JHSSvsJHAS2_zpslergsr2m.jpg.html
As you can see, the ACC, CritH, & CritD discrepancies are fixed, however, the JHAS is STILL a little better in Bonus Defense & Flight Speed than the JHSS which is supposed to have +5 Engine Power. So, not sure if that means one of the Bugs is Bugged or if that is the intended stats for the ships. So, not sure what else I can do. I'm about to start leveling up the Mastery on the JHSS to unlock the trait for my video, so once that is done, I'll level up the JHAS as well and do another comparison after the fact and see the stats then
Not sure how you are getting this, on an identical loadout I get:
JHAS: Flight Speed: 26.14 Turn Rate: 23.7
JHSS: Flight Speed: 29.23 Turn Rate: 23.8
Which I (I guess) is right for the +5 Engine Power.
Hrmmm, are there any up to date formulas out there for calculating both Flight Speed and Turn to work through the math on that? There have been a few changes over the years, so some of the results from a Google are woefully out of date.
Good comparison thou.