All attacks with this weapon ignore 10 Armor Rating.
I grabbed a VR Mk II Antiproton Array [Acc][CrtH][Pen] off the Exchange for testing. I removed any traits that would increase either Armor Penetration or Shield Penetration.
15:01:16:05:57:29.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[617 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,Shield,,-210.274,-281.093
15:01:16:05:57:29.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[617 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,,38.3308,277.846
15:01:16:05:57:30.6::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[617 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,Shield,,-225.232,-301.088
15:01:16:05:57:30.6::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[617 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,,41.0575,297.61
15:01:16:05:57:31.6::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[617 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,Shield,,-279.88,-374.142
15:01:16:05:57:31.6::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[617 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,,51.0193,369.82
15:01:16:05:57:32.6::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[617 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,Shield,,-622.139,-831.673
15:01:16:05:57:32.6::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[617 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,Critical,113.41,822.066
For the AP lines, the two end numbers represent the hull damage and base damage of the attack. So we have the following.
A) 38.3308 hull damage, 277.846 base damage of the attack
41.0575 hull damage, 297.61 base damage of the attack
C) 51.0193 hull damage, 369.82 base damage of the attack
D) 113.41 hull damage, 822.066 base damage of the attack
Against a NPC with their standard shields we can expect 10% bleedthrough.
A) 277.846 -> 27.7846
297.61 -> 29.761
C) 369.82 -> 36.982
D) 822.066 -> 82.2066
We have the [Pen] mod, though, so we're going to expect increased damage. NPC's typically have 0% Damage Resistance. What % increase are we seeing?
A) 38.3308 / 27.7846 = 1.3795699776134981248605342527875
41.0575 / 29.761 = 1.3795739390477470515103659151238
C) 51.0193 / 36.982 = 1.3795711427180790654913201016711
D) 113.41 / 82.2066 = 1.3795729296674476258597241584009
So we are seeing ~37.96% increase in hull damage from the "All attacks with this weapon ignore 10 Armor Rating." stated on the tooltip. This would be equivalent to around a -38.52 damage resistance rating debuff.
I also grabbed a VR Mk II Polaron DBB [CrtH][Dmg][Pen] off the Exchange.
15:01:16:06:21:22.4::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Dual Polaron Banks,Pn.Te8g9u,Shield,,-364.154,-465.733
15:01:16:06:21:22.4::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Dual Polaron Banks,Pn.Te8g9u,Polaron,,51.7481,470.483
15:01:16:06:21:23.4::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Dual Polaron Banks,Pn.Te8g9u,Shield,,-376.699,-454.146
15:01:16:06:21:23.4::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Dual Polaron Banks,Pn.Te8g9u,Polaron,,50.4606,458.778
15:01:16:06:21:24.4::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Dual Polaron Banks,Pn.Te8g9u,Shield,,-367.792,-443.408
15:01:16:06:21:24.4::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Dual Polaron Banks,Pn.Te8g9u,Polaron,,49.2675,447.93
15:01:16:06:21:25.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Dual Polaron Banks,Pn.Te8g9u,Shield,,-711.027,-857.209
15:01:16:06:21:25.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Dual Polaron Banks,Pn.Te8g9u,Polaron,Critical,95.2455,865.953
Again, our numbers would be:
A) 51.7481 hull damage, 470.483 base damage of the attack
50.4606 hull damage, 458.778 base damage of the attack
C) 49.2675 hull damage, 447.93 base damage of the attack
D) 95.2455 hull damage, 865.953 base damage of the attack
Normal hull damage with bleedthrough:
A) 470.4483 -> 47.04483
458.778 -> 45.8778
C) 447.93 -> 44.793
D) 865.953 -> 86.5953
% increase seen:
A) 51.7481 / 47.04483 = 1.0999742160828299305152128299752
50.4606 / 45.8778 = 1.0998914507670376521977950119666
C) 49.2675 / 44.793 = 1.0998928403991695130935637264751
D) 95.2455 / 86.5953 = 1.099892257431985338696210995285
So we are seeing ~9.989% increase in damage with the Polaron DBB.
The expected increase for a -10 DRR debuff "All attacks with this weapon ignore 10 Armor Rating." would be ~1.0998926%. This closely matches the numbers seen from the combatlog.
This suggests that Antiproton weapons are receiving a larger benefit from the [Pen] mod than other weapons.
edit: Okay, it suggested that with the Array. The post below with the Turret and DHCs introduced other issues.
Comments
15:01:16:07:48:36.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Antiproton Turret,Pn.R0c3kr1,Shield,,-83.2911,-106.525
15:01:16:07:48:36.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Antiproton Turret,Pn.R0c3kr1,AntiProton,,11.8361,107.611
15:01:16:07:48:37.0::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Antiproton Turret,Pn.R0c3kr1,Shield,,-168.872,-215.978
15:01:16:07:48:37.0::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Antiproton Turret,Pn.R0c3kr1,AntiProton,Critical,23.9975,218.18
15:01:16:07:48:37.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Antiproton Turret,Pn.R0c3kr1,Shield,,-83.311,-116.168
15:01:16:07:48:37.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Antiproton Turret,Pn.R0c3kr1,AntiProton,,12.9075,107.637
15:01:16:07:48:37.9::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Antiproton Turret,Pn.R0c3kr1,Shield,,-99.7202,-127.537
15:01:16:07:48:37.9::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Antiproton Turret,Pn.R0c3kr1,AntiProton,,14.1707,128.837
A) 11.8361, 107.611; 11.8361 / 10.7611 = 1.0998968506937023166776630641849
23.9975, 218.18; 23.9975 / 21.818 = 1.0998945824548537904482537354478
C) 12.9075, 107.637; 12.9075 / 10.7637 = 1.1991694305861367373672621867945
D) 14.1707, 128.837; 14.1707 / 12.8837 = 1.0998936640871799250215388436552
15:01:16:07:48:36.7::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,Shield,,-142.521,-182.277
15:01:16:07:48:36.7::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,20.253,184.136
15:01:16:07:48:37.1::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,Shield,,-170.545,-218.117
15:01:16:07:48:37.1::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,24.2352,220.342
15:01:16:07:48:37.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,Shield,,-304.079,-424.004
15:01:16:07:48:37.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,Critical,47.1115,392.868
15:01:16:07:48:38.0::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,Shield,,-165.981,-212.281
15:01:16:07:48:38.0::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,23.5867,214.446
A) 20.253, 184.136; 20.253 / 18.4136 = 1.0998935569361776078550636486076
24.2352, 220.342; 24.2352 / 22.0342 = 1.0998901707345853264470686478293
C) 47.1115, 392.868; 47.1115 / 39.2868 = 1.1991686775201848967083091521834
D) 23.5867, 214.446; 23.5867 / 21.446 = 1.099818147906369486151263638907
This on the other hand introduced some other issues, yeah?
So six of those eight hits I posted up there were pretty much what one would expect, right?
The doubles though on the third shot...hrmm.
Thing is, Crits, Dmg, Acc...none of that should affect how penetration works. I need some more caffeine, but I wanted to retest the Array angle anyway.
The DC/Turret thing was just quirky with it being the third shot for both weapons that was like that...
Here are just the hull lines from four cycles of the DC...
15:01:16:07:48:36.7::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,20.253,184.136
15:01:16:07:48:37.1::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,24.2352,220.342
15:01:16:07:48:37.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,Critical,47.1115,392.868
15:01:16:07:48:38.0::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,23.5867,214.446
15:01:16:07:48:39.4::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,26.8112,243.762
15:01:16:07:48:39.8::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,28.1648,256.069
15:01:16:07:48:40.2::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,29.8077,271.006
15:01:16:07:48:40.6::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,36.2243,329.344
15:01:16:07:48:42.1::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,31.9816,290.77
15:01:16:07:48:42.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,34.2341,311.249
15:01:16:07:48:42.9::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,46.4586,387.423
15:01:16:07:48:43.4::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,Critical,79.8545,726.02
15:01:16:07:48:44.8::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,40.9846,372.624
15:01:16:07:48:45.2::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,47.0509,427.777
15:01:16:07:48:45.6::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,47.4461,431.37
15:01:16:07:48:46.0::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Orb Weaver,C[2 Space_Tholian_Cruiser_Web],Dual Antiproton Cannons,Pn.V68yo81,AntiProton,,47.0214,392.116
1-3) 47.1115, 392 .868; 47.1115 / 39.2868 = 1.1991686775201848967083091521834
2-3) 29.8077, 271.006; 29.8077 / 27.1006 = 1.099890777325963262805989535287
3-3) 46.4586, 387.423; 46.4586 / 38.7423 = 1.199169899567139792939500236176
4-3) 47.4461, 431.37; 47.4461 / 43.137 = 1.0998933630062359459396805526578
So it's not a case of it being all third shots, though two of the four cycles saw that on the third shot. Is it a case that each cycle has a double?
Can look at that last line there and see...
47.0214 / 39.2116 = 1.1991706535821032551591875873466
Was that the only one in that cycle? Yep, the only one. Did the second cycle have one too even though it wasn't the third? Nope, the second cycle didn't.
Four cycles...two with it on the third, one on the fourth, and one without.
Wait, the two with the third...did they perhaps have more than one? Nope, just the one.
No clue then...there's no pattern.
But hrmm, yeah - need some caffeine and wanted to look at the AP Array again. Will see what's there for other energy types and pick up a second AP to match if it doesn't match already.
15:01:16:09:17:47.9::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,Critical|Flank,98.4577,895.157
15:01:16:09:17:48.9::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,Flank,51.2973,466.385
15:01:16:09:17:49.9::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,Flank,51.2008,465.507
15:01:16:09:17:50.9::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,,41.4091,376.483
15:01:16:09:17:53.2::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,,40.6654,369.721
15:01:16:09:17:54.2::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,,43.2174,392.924
15:01:16:09:17:55.3::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,Flank,59.1901,538.144
15:01:16:09:17:56.3::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,Critical|Flank,91.1902,829.083
15:01:16:09:17:58.5::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,Flank,61.8994,562.777
15:01:16:09:17:59.6::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,Flank,55.3829,503.53
15:01:16:09:18:00.6::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,Flank,57.0013,518.245
15:01:16:09:18:01.6::Willard the Rat,P[6114054@4209758 Willard the Rat@virusdancer],,*,Tholian Recluse,C[1 Space_Tholian_Battleship],Antiproton Array,Pn.Zkj7wd,AntiProton,Flank,56.292,511.795
1-1) 1.0998930913795010260769898464739
1-2) 1.0998917203597885866826763296418
1-3) 1.0998932346882001774409407377333
1-4) 1.0998903004916556657272705540489
2-1) 1.0998942445790203964611152734089
2-2) 1.0998920910914069896468528265008
And I'm just going to stop there. That was the same array as from the first test.
Could it have just been a bugged NPC for that first test? Hrmm, it looks that way. There was a Disruptor proc later in the parse from one of the other NPCs that was a 1.25998 instead of a 1.0998. That's ~26.17 instead of 10 for the DRR debuff.
I was going to say I needed to go grab some non-AP cannons, but at this point - I'm just going to go to sleep.
I would suspect not all have 0%, save only for the weakest of normal npc enemies but, I could be wrong.
Praetor of the -RTS- Romulan Tal Shiar fleet!
That wouldn't have worked though, because all the other shots were the standard no debuff damage where the line would have been (X * 0.1), X for those two numbers.
[Pen] wasn't the only one I was testing as I was looking for something...I was had looked through one of the parses off the DPS League Table that didn't run Recluses, but there was still -400 to -520 DRR being stacked. Everything else showed expected numbers (even the EAP which I think is broken showed the expected broken numbers)...EAP, Intel Fleet, Disruptor, Corrosive, APB, Sensor Scan...I couldn't test FoMM. It wasn't until I started the [Pen] stuff that this thread ended up being created.
But for that particular parse, I'd only checked to make sure there were no Disruptor procs before I attacked with the single beam. I hadn't bothered to check if there were any after I stopped attacking as I EM'd away so I could leave the instance. So I went back and checked after that additional test showed the same Array working fine...and that's where the -26.21 DRR Disruptor proc showed...so it was meh, I gave up, went to sleep.