test content
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc

KDF/UFP Cold War ? ?

SystemSystem Member, NoReporting Posts: 178,019 Arc User
Cryptic Developers have indicated that the KDF Faction is not active enough to deserve much or any additional work to be done to the faction. One Poll indicates 34% of users would like to play Federation, 33% Romulan, and only 13% KDF. These numbers were taken from only a few users and its accuracy for the entire STO community would need to be adjusted but most likely not by much, but also could be completely off the mark and if the KDF had more content I am sure more users would be interested in the KDF faction.

Even though I do not spend any time on my KDF characters due to of lack of content, I do see the added benefit in having multiple active factions. So saying this I believe a peace treaty between the UFP and the KDF will help the activity on the KDF faction and in turn STO.

Even though it would be a peace treaty between the factions just like the series it would be a love hate relationship or a cold war status.
Google.com wrote:
Cold War = A state of political hostility between countries characterized by threats, propaganda, and other measures short of open warfare.
Any current missions that involve attacking the other faction would still be playable due to the now cold war status, but a peace treaty would also open the other factions missions to be playable by both factions. Some adjusting to the missions and exceptions would need to be made. Federation missions that attack the KDF will not be shared with the KDF and vice versa. This would open a lot of missions to the KDF and many to the Federation. Very little adjustments to the missions would need to be made mostly slight dialogue changes.

I believe doing this would increase the activity on both sides and believe Cryptic should really look into doing this. Currently in STO the KDF and UFP are basically already in a cold war status, sharing STF missions, opening the borders, and so on. So why not just make it official and move alway from open warfare to cold war status and share the love I mean missions.
Post edited by Unknown User on

Comments

  • Archived PostArchived Post Member Posts: 2,264,498 Arc User
    edited May 2012
    MJayMor wrote: »

    Even though it would be a peace treaty between the factions just like the series it would be a love hate relationship or a cold war status. Any current missions that involve attacking the other faction would still be playable due to the now cold war status, but a peace treaty would also open the other factions missions to be playable by both factions. Some adjusting to the missions and exceptions would need to be made.

    Here in lies the issue.
    The adjustment to the existing Fed only missions to allow us KDF the ablity to play them would mean many of those missions would need a complete rewrite just for the KDF toon perspective.

    If such measures are to be taken to make said change, then such measures could just as easily develop new mission exclusively for the KDF faction and solve the whole issue to a better satisfaction of the KDF fan.

    Why take the effort to rewrite the dialouge and portions of 20-30 missions to fit the KDF player intot he event than just create 2-30 simple missions for the KDF over a period of time till the faction is complete and can be left, finally, to just be enjoyed with storyline to match?
  • Archived PostArchived Post Member Posts: 2,264,498 Arc User
    edited May 2012
    Have to agree with Roach there. Also a great deal of the background story that has already been established would become nonsensical and require a huge amount of reworking. The KDF should just get more content, though I agree more people would likely be interested if there was some meat on the KDF side and that how these polls were worded would have a major effect on the answers they got and I haven't seen them myself.

    I, personally, wouldn't play a Klingon anyway as the hybrid Gene Simmons impersonator/transvestite look isn't my thing. Not that there's anything wrong with that...
  • Archived PostArchived Post Member Posts: 2,264,498 Arc User
    edited May 2012
    I spend about 1/3rd of my time on my KDF characters If romulans were here they would get maybe 1/5th
  • Archived PostArchived Post Member Posts: 2,264,498 Arc User
    edited May 2012
    If the KDF actually got some content I would spend 95% of my time there, But if the Romulan faction ever came out 100% of my time would be spent there, even with the same amount of content the KDF faction has now.
  • Archived PostArchived Post Member Posts: 2,264,498 Arc User
    edited May 2012
    Considering you need to do 25 levels just to get to the Klingon side, is it any wonder people don't go awesome, now to start over from scratch.

    If the only way to be a Klingon is to be an alt, isn't it obvious why few people play KDF. Heck even I'm moving further and further away from KDF because all my friends won't make the switch.
  • Archived PostArchived Post Member Posts: 2,264,498 Arc User
    edited May 2012
    Perhaps if the federation was to START at level 30 and Klingons at level 1
  • Archived PostArchived Post Member Posts: 2,264,498 Arc User
    edited May 2012
    Cryptic seems to think they have to build a new map for every mission they make. Map reuse, while not always appropriate, would speed things up considerably.

    But I agree that simply retreading dialog for existing Fed missions does not fit a KDF mindset.

    I'm also not necessarily keen on declaring peace between the KDF and the UFP. It clearly shouldn't be a formal war, either. Warring empires simply do not put aside hostilities when convenient, as seemingly happens in STO.

    What it is, and should be, is a Stand-Off and a sort of limited Cease Fire agreement. Neither side wants to risk a full war with Borg incursions going on, but neither side is inclined to give ground either. Skirmishes are downplayed as 'accidents', 'misunderstandings', and individuals 'exceeding their authority'. Raids are carried out by 'renegade' commanders who are only punished if they got caught at it. Complaints are lodged via the usual diplomatic channels in both directions and usually go nowhere. Constantly testing the resolve of the opposition in every matter of importance and cooperating only when there's something to be gained on both sides.

    That's the way I see it.
  • Archived PostArchived Post Member Posts: 2,264,498 Arc User
    edited May 2012
    Personally, having gathered more and more 'Road to 2409' datachips, I'm leaning towards the opinion that the Klingons are actually right. I wouldn't be surprised if the President of the Federation, or a sizeable chunk of the Council, turns out to be Undine infiltrators, going out of their way to break up the Fed/Klingon alliance to soften up the quadrant (the Klingons go Undine hunting, and that's when the Feds start denouncing them? Suspicious if you ask me). Since we will presumably be getting some Iconian themed missions soon, that seems like the perfect opportunity for something of a resolution to the Undine storyline as well, since SPOILERS (highlight to read) the Undine are only invading because it appears the Iconians have tricked them into believing that the Alpha Quadrant races are trying to invade Fluidic Space. END SPOILERS

    If the Iconian missions begin by revealing the extent of the Undine infiltration, and allowing the Federation and Klingons to work together to stop it, then we can have a united front again against the Iconians. And you wouldn't have to go and change all the random encounters where you fight Klingons, say they're a house opposed to the peace treaty, or pirates, or mercenaries. Just because the governments start talking to each other again, doesn't mean every starship captain has to like it.
  • Archived PostArchived Post Member Posts: 2,264,498 Arc User
    edited May 2012
    not looking good for KDF which is sad
    I think the reason no one does that gap in story hopefuly it will pick up in six they have gotten much TLC in 5
  • Archived PostArchived Post Member Posts: 2,264,498 Arc User
    edited May 2012
    Considering you need to do 25 levels just to get to the Klingon side, is it any wonder people don't go awesome, now to start over from scratch.

    If the only way to be a Klingon is to be an alt, isn't it obvious why few people play KDF. Heck even I'm moving further and further away from KDF because all my friends won't make the switch.

    ^This... Why are there more Feds than Klinks? Well let's see... You need to have a Fed before you can even HAVE A KLINK... It is a self fulfilling prophecy. After grinding 25 levels on your Fed you may not even WANT to bother with a second character, let alone one on a faction you know nothing about by comparison.

    Just let folks start off with either faction and we will start to see some different numbers right off.
  • warpxxxwarpxxx Member Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    Seriously.. The KDF isn't INTERESTING. The game hijacks the currently accepted canon of Star Trek. Just update to a current canon model and all will be better. Make KDF a Federation ALLY, and make Dominion and Borg the enemy. I'm telling you this will work!

    They hijacked the timeline because they want to keep the doors open for EXPANSIONS, but what they need to do is expand it NOW.

    I die within 3-6 seconds of encountering a KDF ship in PvP and I am lvl 42. That's just not right.
  • admiralq1732admiralq1732 Member Posts: 1,561 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    Notice the repeating pattern here Cryptic. The fed toon requirement is killing the KDF. GET RID OF IT
  • tdon7tdon7 Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    I would personally love for the KDF to get some lower level missions to fill in the missing levels and drop the Fed level requirements altogether. I play KDF almost exclusively and the experience is....lackluster, but the Klingons are far more interesting than the Federation for me from a Star Trek Fan standpoint.

    Give us some love here, will ya? What others in the thread have said isn't them talking out of their hind ends. The Klingons need to be a full faction, not just an afterthought like they have been.

    And before anyone says it, including the Cryptic devs, Klingons are not supposed to be Bonus play. Calling them that is just simple bull****.
    A half faction is no faction at all.
  • thunderfoot#5163 thunderfoot Member Posts: 4,545 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    Showing the Klingons some love just isn't in the cards. We all sometimes forget this is a business. Unless and until PWE/Cryptic comes up with a way to make the Klingon faction as profitable as the Fed side is, additional KDF content is a no go. Not because the Devs do not want to. Not because somebody "hates" the Klingons. Not because they are busy working up the Romulans. Or the Borg. Or the Iconians.

    PWE/Cryptic is in this for the money. As would anyone else be as well. You want more Klingon content? Vote with your money, then. Start buying KDF stuff. Using Real Money. If we are not not willing to do this, then we really have no reason to complain about the lack of KDF content. If we do begin to purchase KDF stuff it draws the attention of Sales and Marketing. Who are probably the ones really driving this train. Cynical? Sure am.

    And this would be the point where someone asks why should they spend Real Money on a "Free" game? Nothing is free. Not lunch. Not life. Not expression. Everything has a cost. We can write reams of posts about STO which accomplish nothing at all. Take a good look around these forums. How many excellent ideas have you seen, which would improve the game, that have been used ingame already? We can threaten to stop playing STO. Since most of us are F2Pers anyway, this is a hollow threat. PWE/Cryptic loses no profit over us rage-quitting. We have to give them a reason to care about the KDF. So we hook them with money. And when we have them addicted to us spending Real Money on KDF content, then we can ask for more. Then they'll listen. Yes, it really is this simple.
    A six year old boy and his starship. Living the dream.
  • tdon7tdon7 Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    Showing the Klingons some love just isn't in the cards. We all sometimes forget this is a business. Unless and until PWE/Cryptic comes up with a way to make the Klingon faction as profitable as the Fed side is, additional KDF content is a no go. Not because the Devs do not want to. Not because somebody "hates" the Klingons. Not because they are busy working up the Romulans. Or the Borg. Or the Iconians.

    PWE/Cryptic is in this for the money. As would anyone else be as well. You want more Klingon content? Vote with your money, then. Start buying KDF stuff. Using Real Money. If we are not not willing to do this, then we really have no reason to complain about the lack of KDF content. If we do begin to purchase KDF stuff it draws the attention of Sales and Marketing. Who are probably the ones really driving this train. Cynical? Sure am.

    And this would be the point where someone asks why should they spend Real Money on a "Free" game? Nothing is free. Not lunch. Not life. Not expression. Everything has a cost. We can write reams of posts about STO which accomplish nothing at all. Take a good look around these forums. How many excellent ideas have you seen, which would improve the game, that have been used ingame already? We can threaten to stop playing STO. Since most of us are F2Pers anyway, this is a hollow threat. PWE/Cryptic loses no profit over us rage-quitting. We have to give them a reason to care about the KDF. So we hook them with money. And when we have them addicted to us spending Real Money on KDF content, then we can ask for more. Then they'll listen. Yes, it really is this simple.

    This sort of mentality puts the KDF in to a catch-22. You say that they won't add more content until more players join the KDF and I'm of the mind that more players will not join the KDF until more content is added.

    As for buying stuff for the KDF, there really is very little TO buy
    A half faction is no faction at all.
  • bitemepwebitemepwe Member Posts: 6,760 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    warpxxx wrote: »
    I die within 3-6 seconds of encountering a KDF ship in PvP and I am lvl 42. That's just not right.
    Then the issue may lie in your build or skill level instead of the KDF player you encounter. They may just be more experienced at PvP than you so the concept that your dying to one is not right is not right. This is not the TV shows or Movies. Victory in PvP is up the players not scripting.
    tdon7 wrote: »
    This sort of mentality puts the KDF in to a catch-22. You say that they won't add more content until more players join the KDF and I'm of the mind that more players will not join the KDF until more content is added.

    As for buying stuff for the KDF, there really is very little TO buy
    You are correct.
    I've personally bought all I can and still continue to spend money on my KDF toons, so the whole " We need more money spent of the KDF before they spend money to expand the KDF" is a BS excuse they give to push us aside.
    If they gave the KDF more content then many would try and stick with thier KDF alts or even primary toons.
    The Devs blaiming the whole lack of KDF revenue on the playerbase is wrong as if the faction had been done properly and given better gameplay many more KDF players would have stuck around to play thier toons.
    As it is, according to one poll, many STO players actaully play thier KDF/fed toons equally. SO how does this not show that more for the KDF would bring more revenue is what I ask?
    Leonard Nimoy, Spock.....:(

    R.I.P
  • sechserpackungsechserpackung Member Posts: 135 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    People saying that nothing is happening for the Klingons are pretty bad liars.
    From the top of my Head I could point at the things that they have gotten in tandem with the Federation which shows that they actually do get a lot of attention. What could be said is that the feds are getting a better treatment in total (More Fleet Ships and actual discount on some of theirs).

    On the other hand the Klingons did get an exclusive mission and that gives me hope for more.

    Furthermore there is a lot of blatant bull****ting going on by people that only have their view of things.

    I started with FTP and once my Fed reached 25 I went straight over to Klingon. My first klingon character is 50 and the 2nd 49 by now (I am a on and off player) while my Fed character has barely reached 46.

    For all intents and purposes I feel that the fed side is a boring slugfest with a bloated community and enjoy the klingons far more, what I would realy want is actually MORE escalation against the feds storyline wise and, if there is some time in season 8+) a complete revamp of PvP (which for me is dead anyway because it is either a stomp in one way or another with P2W thrown in. A real monster that should get put down).
  • majesticmsfcmajesticmsfc Member Posts: 1,401 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    bitemepwe wrote: »
    Then the issue may lie in your build or skill level instead of the KDF player you encounter. They may just be more experienced at PvP than you so the concept that your dying to one is not right is not right. This is not the TV shows or Movies. Victory in PvP is up the players not scripting.


    You are correct.
    I've personally bought all I can and still continue to spend money on my KDF toons, so the whole " We need more money spent of the KDF before they spend money to expand the KDF" is a BS excuse they give to push us aside.
    If they gave the KDF more content then many would try and stick with thier KDF alts or even primary toons.
    The Devs blaiming the whole lack of KDF revenue on the playerbase is wrong as if the faction had been done properly and given better gameplay many more KDF players would have stuck around to play thier toons.
    As it is, according to one poll, many STO players actaully play thier KDF/fed toons equally. SO how does this not show that more for the KDF would bring more revenue is what I ask?

    Well said Roach I am personally running out of things to buy myself.

    I agree, if they spent the money, they would gain the money, but the half-TRIBBLE stuff they do is not what we as a community and customers deserve.

    Plus we all know DStahl is pro-Federation and has admitted he only plays his own KDF character for testing out new content, um what new content I ask? :confused:
    For all intents and purposes I feel that the fed side is a boring slugfest with a bloated community and enjoy the klingons far more, what I would realy want is actually MORE escalation against the feds storyline wise and, if there is some time in season 8+) a complete revamp of PvP (which for me is dead anyway because it is either a stomp in one way or another with P2W thrown in. A real monster that should get put down).

    To be totally honest the Federation side needs to be less, well, Klingon. All these missions and they are totally just about fighting. Yes they should have action but not to the extent to what a Klingon crew would do. They need more puzzles, challenges and diplomatic missions. If fans are not into that, well then there are the KDF, who are more about honourable combat and all that.

    The KDF also needs more missions, more Fek'lhri (where did these guys really come from, are they really the mythological beings of Klingon legend or some sort of cloned army for something else), Hurq, Undine (The KDF did uncover them, perhaps mix it in with the Federation war campaign, exposing Undine in the Federation), A Cardassian campaign (perhaps an invasion of Cardassia) and a Romulan or Hirogen campaign. Really if the Dev's put a little bit of effort into it, had any sort of vision I am sure they could really make STO a game to stand out in the MMO market. However with SWTOR going F2P in November I fear STO is really going to feel the pinch.
    Support the Game by Supporting the KDF, equality and uniqueness for all factions!
  • andomiindandomiind Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    Im sure looking forward to playing my kdf character soon,
    all though been kind of bizzy with earning profits (FED side)
    and now also getting into using the foundry.

    Im looking forward to it because,
    I want to play the bad guy aswell, covert and sneaky traits

    I have a suggestion,
    make elite episodes lines with being different races and history.
    Just as you did with the early klingon episode line,
    you take the form and tech of that particular race / history event
    during the course of the episode missions you get the oppertunity
    to get the shot at unlocking these races, ships and items, if all done well (on elite)
    and then, for lets say starting at 200-500 zen.
    So its kind of a stage rocket, you have to unlock the possibility to buy,
    and the road there should be elite with help of others.

    Now you could make this kdf only until rank 50, as a villain expansion
    that could have its own sub-faction, being both vilain-fed or vilain-kdf
    that you choose at rank 50.

    Certainly a welcomed open discussion, looking forward to seeing more.
  • pyryckpyryck Member Posts: 6 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    Over 30-day old thread... :(

    But anyways...as I've said countless times before...if you want equal content then produce the same volume of players with an equal interest in the Klingon story. Those numbers will not lie. They will prove that there is an un-tapped source of potential income to be made by providing more Klingon content.

    Until then, be happy that you do have more than "monster-play".

    At least the Klingon faction is playable.
  • bitemepwebitemepwe Member Posts: 6,760 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    SNIPPED
    Thanks, though to clarify. I only believe the aproach they have taken to the KDF, as far as growing it into a full faction has been half-assed.
    I actually find the pure KDF missions they have made to be excellent and wish we had more to finish our gameplay.

    And some KDF centered agnostic STFs.
    Leonard Nimoy, Spock.....:(

    R.I.P
  • opawaamiwopawaamiw Member Posts: 9 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    pyryck wrote: »
    Over 30-day old thread... :(

    But anyways...as I've said countless times before...if you want equal content then produce the same volume of players with an equal interest in the Klingon story. Those numbers will not lie. They will prove that there is an un-tapped source of potential income to be made by providing more Klingon content.

    Until then, be happy that you do have more than "monster-play".

    At least the Klingon faction is playable.

    This is the kind of backward logic Cryptic has been using for a while now. The argument could be made if the Klingon faction had equal or almost equal content to the Federation, but without that, there is no reason not to assume that the people do not play KDF because there is no content. The faster levelling since F2P doesn't cover it up.

    To me the cheapest way to create new content for both factions would be to revamp PvP. First of all, a basic ranking system with three tiers so that players don't fear PvP. Second, content needs to be diversified. Different types of PvP scenarios, more diverse rewards and some basic territory control + a Romulan faction. A diverse and perhaps more strategy based PvP (or even player with player interactions, like trade missions) would be able to satisfy end game players while allowing the devs to focus on developping the KDF and possibly a Romulan faction (which I'm still hoping for, lol)
  • flekhflekh Member Posts: 233 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    Since this won't sink down soon anyway, I can just chime in. Do I have to bring black robes, candles and some unholy tome to chant from? Nevermind ...

    On topic: I'm pretty sure the numbers don't lie, ~13-20% of the player would be interested in playing Klingon. Why did I use bold set for that? Because there's the mistake they made when asking their questions: they asked for Klingons.
    Of course few people like Klingons. They are ugly and brutish. Yes, with honor, courage, and all the other virtues, a lot more intersting to RP, a lot more scenic, a lot more fun ... yeah, I'm prefering Klingon side myself ... but that's not the average.
    And I wouldn't want to see the numbers if they asked for Nausicaans instead.

    BUT(!): what they failed to ask was Orion. Yes, the Green Space Hookers. In WoW, introducing Blood Elves on Horde Side, which to that point had pretty much only ugly races, managed to fix a faction imbalance from >2:1 to nearly 1:1. Just overnight.
    Why? How? ... Well, because people don't like to be ugly. And especially the juvenile males have only ONE set of options that they prefer above "handsome heroic male hero who gets the girls" ... and that is "the hot chick that makes you play with a constant boner". Sorry for being blunt :P

    STO alreay HAS these. STO just fails to capitalize on it. KDF fails to capitalize on it. If you went around and asked people what they'd rather play, the hot human/trill/bajoran in miniskirt and mirror universe top, or the hot green chick in ... a lot less clothing ... you'd get a lot closer to 1:1 ratio! Same as asking what side they'd rather play on.

    I know this sounds a bit cynical, maybe even trollish, but it isn't, it's just a realistic perception of human urges, and how to use them. If you wanted to get rid of the faction imbalance, all you'd need is a small campaign featuring Orion slave girls. And maybe a short questline that features them, too.
    Instant surge in KDF activity.
    Sure, 'might not be the kind of activity you want (fap, fap, fap), but the solution is right there. Sex sells. Virtual, too. Pixel-perverts buy.
  • bitemepwebitemepwe Member Posts: 6,760 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    And yet the latest Nagus poll shows an over whelming trend of the playerbase to play both factions near equally.

    Though, I am never against Orion call-girls.
    Leonard Nimoy, Spock.....:(

    R.I.P
  • majesticmsfcmajesticmsfc Member Posts: 1,401 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    bitemepwe wrote: »
    And yet the latest Nagus poll shows an over whelming trend of the playerbase to play both factions near equally.

    Though, I am never against Orion call-girls.

    Indeed I play both almost equally, though do prefer playing on the KDF more. :D
    Support the Game by Supporting the KDF, equality and uniqueness for all factions!
  • tdon7tdon7 Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    bitemepwe wrote: »
    And yet the latest Nagus poll shows an over whelming trend of the playerbase to play both factions near equally.

    Though, I am never against Orion call-girls.

    Well there's one solution. Remove the green skin tones from the Fed side of the game. No more Fed Orions. :D

    Kidding...Maybe.
    A half faction is no faction at all.
  • majesticmsfcmajesticmsfc Member Posts: 1,401 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    tdon7 wrote: »
    Well there's one solution. Remove the green skin tones from the Fed side of the game. No more Fed Orions. :D

    Kidding...Maybe.

    And remove the skin coloured one from the Orions, I was under the mistaken impression Orion's were Green not cream. :D
    Support the Game by Supporting the KDF, equality and uniqueness for all factions!
  • bitemepwebitemepwe Member Posts: 6,760 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    As long as they are still call-girls.:P
    Leonard Nimoy, Spock.....:(

    R.I.P
  • tetonicatetonica Member Posts: 142 Arc User
    edited August 2012
    All my characters are orion women, except a level 22 gorn for doff farming. Not sure what it says about me, but that's what I like :o
    Lynis, Orion Engineer, main
    Rrezeth, Gorn Tactical, primary alt
    Nari, Orion Science, secondary alt
Sign In or Register to comment.