Thank you Admin and People for messing up game sites...

robertjanvaneijk
robertjanvaneijk Posts: 129 Arc User
edited August 2008 in General Discussion
Just want to say something. Since the admins of this site made the review contest I saw lots of stupid reviews popping up. Like PC.IGN: http://rr.pc.ign.com/rrobj/pc/object/856741/ . People that give the game a 9.5+ for graphics, gameplay, sound etc..Come on people.
Comparing to other MMORPG's it has some nice graphics but its not stunning..When real magazins and sites would review this game it would have a 7-8 for graphics, 7-8 for sound 7 for gameplay cause its all grinding (all quests are kill them all which will get a bad rating).

The only review I could take serious here is: http://rr.pc.ign.com/rrview/pc/perfect_world/856741/90379/ . This is the only one who gives a critical reviewing (which is normal), the others still think that how better the ratings they give the higher chance they win something....THIS ISN'T GOOD AT ALL!!!!
I warned for it on the admin page and they already said that you may give a normal rating but i don't thing people readed that....People that don't know the game will be wrong informed about this game now THANKS!
Also the fact that it takes LOTS of months to reach a high level 9max level is almost out of the question here even for HC gamers) and that you realy need to use the cash shop for full game profit would give a negative note to gameplay...so it CAN'T GAIN A 9+ cause 8.5+ is only for PEFECT GAMES.....
Post edited by robertjanvaneijk on
«1

Comments

  • infrequentia
    infrequentia Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    All quests are not to kill something at all.


    And not everyone have the same opinion. Maybe someone thinks this game has stunning graphics, while someone else, who has seen a lot of other games, might not think so at all. It's all about what you, as a person, find nice and what you've seen before this to compare to.
    You can't expect everyone who plays a game to have seen something better.

    After I went to the Sanctuary in game, I think this game looks amazing at some points. Probably wouldn't give it 9.5 or whatever, but still pretty high.

    Also, wouldn't a perfect game get 10? Giving something less than 10 means there are flaws and it's not quite perfect.
  • robertjanvaneijk
    robertjanvaneijk Posts: 129 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    infrequentia wrote: »
    All quests are not to kill something at all.


    And not everyone have the same opinion. Maybe someone thinks this game has stunning graphics, while someone else, who has seen a lot of other games, might not think so at all. It's all about what you, as a person, find nice and what you've seen before this to compare to.
    You can't expect everyone who plays a game to have seen something better.

    After I went to the Sanctuary in game, I think this game looks amazing at some points. Probably wouldn't give it 9.5 or whatever, but still pretty high.

    Also, wouldn't a perfect game get 10? Giving something less than 10 means there are flaws and it's not quite perfect.

    If you look on the site all people give it a 9+ since the contest released (only one not). This isn;t realy reflecting the game cause then it would be better then all other mmorpg's currently excist.....
    I asked Pc.Ign to make their own review cause magazins and gamesites will give this game a 8-8.5 max when reviewing it. (a game almost never gets a 10 and 9+ is already amazing which almost never happens)....
  • infrequentia
    infrequentia Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    robertjanvaneijk wrote: »
    If you look on the site all people give it a 9+ since the contest released (only one not). This isn;t realy reflecting the game cause then it would be better then all other mmorpg's currently excist.....
    I asked Pc.Ign to make their own review cause magazins and gamesites will give this game a 8-8.5 max when reviewing it. (a game almost never gets a 10 and 9+ is already amazing which almost never happens)....

    Yea, but then again, those people reviewing the game in magazines and such are probably a bit more professional than your average player. You're not being fair by compare them like that.
  • robertjanvaneijk
    robertjanvaneijk Posts: 129 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    infrequentia wrote: »
    Yea, but then again, those people reviewing the game in magazines and such are probably a bit more professional than your average player. You're not being fair by compare them like that.

    When you look at the reader reviews of other mmorpg's PW has current the highest note.....Maybe peoplem like the game but thenthey still could give between 8-9 and not idiot scores of 9.8 for graphics and 9-9.8 for overall scores....
  • destruction
    destruction Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    Also...
    Remember the updates, and this is a MMORPG...
    NOT a Console game.
    So yea...
    Plus, ALL reviews are biased, professional or not.
    [SIGPIC]http://i230.photobucket.com/albums/ee122/SpartanCommanderJay/CommanderJay7.png[/SIGPIC]
  • lena
    lena Posts: 243 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    wow we havent even reached open beta and already someone is complaining about the reviews lmao...like destruction said this is MMORPG not a damn console game. If you simply dont like the game then dont play it simple instead of dragging this in the forums knowing full well its going to end up in a flame war sheesh take that **** to the pk grounds lol...and leave it out of the forums
    You Were Never Meant To Arrive In Hell Looking Like A Fashion Plate...Rather To Slide In Backwards..Glass Of Wine In Hand..Hair In Disarray..Totally Exhausted.... Screaming man what a ride !!!!!!!
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • anima
    anima Posts: 5 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    Sometimes you can't even trust Gamespot's reviews. Example: AoC ^^. Watch video, go to forums will be the next steps after reading those words.
    But in most cases, Gamespot's official reviews are good to read.
    Why...so...serious?

    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • destruction
    destruction Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    Or, to simplifie all that...
    GTFO!
    [SIGPIC]http://i230.photobucket.com/albums/ee122/SpartanCommanderJay/CommanderJay7.png[/SIGPIC]
  • robertjanvaneijk
    robertjanvaneijk Posts: 129 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    lena wrote: »
    wow we havent even reached open beta and already someone is complaining about the reviews lmao...like destruction said this is MMORPG not a damn console game. If you simply dont like the game then dont play it simple instead of dragging this in the forums knowing full well its going to end up in a flame war sheesh take that **** to the pk grounds lol...and leave it out of the forums

    I also aksed the question why they even let people review the game when its still in CB. But it are still bad reviews....
  • egaenil
    egaenil Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    lol.. u know, i saw u paying out PW 2 months ago on other sites about MY ENG version. it was almost the same thing.. oh it lags so much the game play is ****.. grind grind grind.. only asian will like it, bla bla bla, i have played many mmorpg games (eg 2 p2p and 3 f2p) b4 this is the shitest game.. do not believe in "free". can u think up something new next time? or u can save urself some time just copy and paste. and u forgot to use "only those asian using their mumi or dadi's credit card will do well in this game"
    zzzzzzzz boring.. think something new
  • robertjanvaneijk
    robertjanvaneijk Posts: 129 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    egaenil wrote: »
    lol.. u know, i saw u paying out PW 2 months ago on other sites about MY ENG version. it was almost the same thing.. oh it lags so much the game play is ****.. grind grind grind.. only asian will like it, bla bla bla, i have played many mmorpg games (eg 2 p2p and 3 f2p) b4 this is the shitest game.. do not believe in "free". can u think up something new next time? or u can save urself some time just copy and paste. and u forgot to use "only those asian using their mumi or dadi's credit card will do well in this game"
    zzzzzzzz boring.. think something new
    IMPOSSIBLE! I know this game since I found the beta key on mmorpg.com a few days before the CB started. I had never heard of this game before that so..... give me the site where you saw it, because:
    *1 I never use another account name then this one.....
    *2 I didn't knew this game excist 2 months ago.....
    *3 I like the game a lot, but the only thing is that it isn't perfect and that is doesn't deserve a 9+ at all.....

    2 months ago I played almost no game, only guild wars 1 hours a day, because I didn't had time for it.....
  • puppetsoul
    puppetsoul Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    robertjanvaneijk wrote: »
    Just want to say something. Since the admins of this site made the review contest I saw lots of stupid reviews popping up. Like PC.IGN: http://rr.pc.ign.com/rrobj/pc/object/856741/ . People that give the game a 9.5+ for graphics, gameplay, sound etc..Come on people.
    Comparing to other MMORPG's it has some nice graphics but its not stunning..When real magazins and sites would review this game it would have a 7-8 for graphics, 7-8 for sound 7 for gameplay cause its all grinding (all quests are kill them all which will get a bad rating).

    The only review I could take serious here is: http://rr.pc.ign.com/rrview/pc/perfect_world/856741/90379/ . This is the only one who gives a critical reviewing (which is normal), the others still think that how better the ratings they give the higher chance they win something....THIS ISN'T GOOD AT ALL!!!!
    I warned for it on the admin page and they already said that you may give a normal rating but i don't thing people readed that....People that don't know the game will be wrong informed about this game now THANKS!
    Also the fact that it takes LOTS of months to reach a high level 9max level is almost out of the question here even for HC gamers) and that you realy need to use the cash shop for full game profit would give a negative note to gameplay...so it CAN'T GAIN A 9+ cause 8.5+ is only for PEFECT GAMES.....

    PEFECT GAMES. I play them.

    Also, that's exactly the intention of the "contest": to generate posititve buzz. They made the event to cause a massive flow of "viral marketing" via word-of-mouth (gamesite reviews); and yes, they were fully aware that most of them would be ****-kissing when they wrote them. In fact, that's the whole point. If they wanted you to write scathing/critical reviews of the game (like "Dude, there's gold farming bots in closed beta"), then they'd just wait for the normal cycle to carry out. But they want to basically drown those out with this flood of ****-kissing reviews so that it looks like the best game ever to anyone who should be browsing that site (much like how Xfire's usage graph for Rohan looking like a cliff diver over the course of a month warded new players of its downward spiral).
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • godcrusher
    godcrusher Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    robertjanvaneijk wrote: »
    IMPOSSIBLE! I know this game since I found the beta key on mmorpg.com a few days before the CB started. I had never heard of this game before that so..... give me the site where you saw it, because:
    *1 I never use another account name then this one.....
    *2 I didn't knew this game excist 2 months ago.....
    *3 I like the game a lot, but the only thing is that it isn't perfect and that is doesn't deserve a 9+ at all.....

    2 months ago I played almost no game, only guild wars 1 hours a day, because I didn't had time for it.....

    Wait, you're angry people like the game or that people are trying to kiss the GM's ****? o0 If so, then I'm sure the GMs aren't going to fall for it, you can always petition after the results. ;s
  • net21431
    net21431 Posts: 4 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    Plz Stop Spamming. Everyone here thinks this game rocks. Go try and play other MMORPGs. There all way boring and smaller than Perfect World. I bet we'll see you back here in another month.
  • darknin
    darknin Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    There was no need for this thread.......if you dont like it fine. You dont need to get attention from people by making this.
  • ren
    ren Posts: 662 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    Anyone rating PW over this is biased/brown nosing:

    Music: 7.0. It's good, but the bitrate ruins the sound quality.
    Sound effects: 3-5: The monster sounds are awful, and using a sword sounds like you are using a wood club.
    Graphics: 6 tops, they are terribly dated no matter how you look at it. It gets as high as a 6 only because it's 8 years old and yet still has better graphics than most MMOs.
    Gameplay: 6-7 tops. Heirograms ruin the game (especially if the cost is high), and PVE is a joke for anything exept werefox because of how hard things hit.
    Community: 7 tops. To many karmelias, whiners, etc. I don't think it's POSSIBLE to have a rating of over 7 for community unless it's a roleplay-enforced community (as lame as I think one would be)
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
    Official PWI irc: (mirc command, opens in a new window and won't interfere with any servers you're already on) /server -m irc.deltaanime.net -j #pwint
  • sikozu
    sikozu Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    Please stop the direct attacks to other members of this forum. Flaming in this thread is an issue.
    I hope a mod logs on and removes this thread.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
    ★ :Sikozu :: Venomancer: ★ :Nebira :: Cleric: ★
  • ren
    ren Posts: 662 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    sikozu wrote: »
    Please stop the direct attacks to other members of this forum. Flaming in this thread is an issue.
    I hope a mod logs on and removes this thread.

    There were no direct attacks.
    The worst I saw in this thread was some blunt statement of truth about some serious no-mans-land-licking.

    The game is good, but it's not a freaking 8+ rated game, period. Anyone smart is going to realize these reviews who omit all faults are full of **** and ignore it. "If it's looks too good to be true, it probably is."
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
    Official PWI irc: (mirc command, opens in a new window and won't interfere with any servers you're already on) /server -m irc.deltaanime.net -j #pwint
  • kuukai
    kuukai Posts: 106 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    ren wrote: »
    Anyone rating PW over this is biased/brown nosing:

    Music: 7.0. It's good, but the bitrate ruins the sound quality.
    Sound effects: 3-5: The monster sounds are awful, and using a sword sounds like you are using a wood club.
    Graphics: 6 tops, they are terribly dated no matter how you look at it. It gets as high as a 6 only because it's 8 years old and yet still has better graphics than most MMOs.
    Gameplay: 6-7 tops. Heirograms ruin the game (especially if the cost is high)is true,in my opinon it ruins the fun in pvp i wonder whats gona happen when a tanker class uses it ;p , and PVE is a joke for anything exept werefox because of how hard things hit.
    Community: 7 tops. To many karmelias, whiners, etc. I don't think it's POSSIBLE to have a rating of over 7 for community unless it's a roleplay-enforced community (as lame as I think one would be)

    well i have to agree with ren ;p
    graphics are pretty good if you play at max..
    sounds are to be worked upon
    community >____________> we will talk about it after ob <___________<
    total rating which i would give would be 7 x.x
    i am still unsure about the pvp fun


    the things in bold is typed by me ;p :)
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • danubus37
    danubus37 Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    Community: 7 tops. To many karmelias, whiners, etc.

    There was your attack. You called out Karmelia basically saying this community sucks because of him and people like him.
  • karmelia
    karmelia Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    ren wrote: »
    The game is good, but it's not a freaking 8+ rated game, period. Anyone smart is going to realize these reviews who omit all faults are full of **** and ignore it. "If it's looks too good to be true, it probably is."

    *warning : the end of the world is near : I agree with Ren on something*

    Quite frankly, when I see 7 reviews giving a note between 9 and 9.6 for this game.... it's a good game, but not that good.... And it's still only in closed beta....

    That make for not too serious reviews really....
    Frankieraye said : "we can promise that we will work to improve all facets of community, engineering, and customer service to ensure that something like this doesn't happen again."


    (We are still waiting to see any improvements or changes beign implemented. More empty promises from PWI?)
  • sikozu
    sikozu Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    kuukai wrote: »
    well i have to agree with ren ;p
    graphics are pretty good if you play at max..
    sounds are to be worked upon
    community >____________> we will talk about it after ob <___________<
    total rating which i would give would be 7 x.x
    i am still unsure about the pvp fun


    the things in bold is typed by me ;p :)

    Fact: I have seen games with better graphics BUT they where a monthly subscription. (I.E. FFXI/EQII/WOW/AoC. But I really enjoy this game and from what I see the equipment graphics are far better than most I have seen in ANY game. The way they capture the light is so awesome ^^

    I do still play FFXI (quit EQII its dying) but for a f2p game its pretty good. This is my first and only F2p game I have ever encountered though ^^ but so far I love it!
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
    ★ :Sikozu :: Venomancer: ★ :Nebira :: Cleric: ★
  • merulz
    merulz Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    sikozu wrote: »
    Please stop the direct attacks to other members of this forum. Flaming in this thread is an issue.
    I hope a mod logs on and removes this thread.

    There was no direct attack anywhere in this thread. What Ren said is true, Karmelia is the king/queen/itruler of the whiners and brown nosing. Please, I see that your registration is in August, so you wouldn't know much about the forums yet.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

    Perfect World IRC:
    Server: irc.deltaanime.net
    Channel: #pwint
  • kuukai
    kuukai Posts: 106 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    sikozu wrote: »
    Fact: I have seen games with better graphics BUT they where a monthly subscription. (I.E. FFXI/EQII/WOW/AoC. But I really enjoy this game and from what I see the equipment graphics are far better than most I have seen in ANY game. The way they capture the light is so awesome ^^

    I do still play FFXI (quit EQII its dying) but for a f2p game its pretty good. This is my first and only F2p game I have ever encountered though ^^ but so far I love it!

    well i did say its pretty good i didn't overrate ;p
    well if you do like p2p then i am sure your also waiting for aion :) right?
    well i am ;p
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • godcrusher
    godcrusher Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    WoW graphic ain't that great... >.<

    Sorry OffTopic...
  • khaai
    khaai Posts: 80 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    I actually think 9.0 is too low rating for a nearly perfect game like this one. My overall rating would be 9.5 or higher. I almost can't think of anything wrong/annoying/lacking in the game, since it is 98% perfect. :eek::eek:
  • sikozu
    sikozu Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    kuukai wrote: »
    well i did say its pretty good i didn't overrate ;p
    well if you do like p2p then i am sure your also waiting for aion :) right?
    well i am ;p

    Never heard of Aion :D but I'm pretty content at PWI and FFXI.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
    ★ :Sikozu :: Venomancer: ★ :Nebira :: Cleric: ★
  • baifang
    baifang Posts: 32 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    Read the rules implicit in the conditions of the contest. Quality > Quantity 3 to 1.

    Dont blame the GM's for a great idea that a horde of review spammers and hopefuls have run off with.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • vigor
    vigor Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    It was a smart idea from them. I would pull off the same to attract more players ;)
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
    Lost City
  • karmelia
    karmelia Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2008
    vigor wrote: »
    It was a smart idea from them. I would pull off the same to attract more players ;)

    But it may backfire on them later when all those players attracted by the great reviews could be disappointed by what they see ingame and write very negative reviews to counterbalance the over positives reviews ...
    Frankieraye said : "we can promise that we will work to improve all facets of community, engineering, and customer service to ensure that something like this doesn't happen again."


    (We are still waiting to see any improvements or changes beign implemented. More empty promises from PWI?)

Categories