Pumpkin Soup has not been updated to the new event food standard yet

This summer, event food was updated to always give a total of 10% stats. Squash Soup from Summer Festival, which was identical in stats to Pumpkin Soup from Masquerade of Liars, was upgraded from 3% critical strike and 5% critical severity to 5% critical strike and 5% critical severity. All other event food, from all events, was downgraded, as they were all giving more than 10% total stats.

Pumpkin Soup from the Masquerade of Liars event has not been updated to reflect this change. New Pumpkin Soup, which can be obtained from Beholder Piñatas, is still giving the old version with 3% critical strike and 5% critical severity. This should be updated to 5% critical strike and 5% critical severity, to total 10% like all other event foods and to make it equal to the summer Squash Soup again.