test content
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc

Elemental melee

truedragoontruedragoon Posts: 1 Arc User
edited October 2017 in Suggestions Box
I would love to see some new melee powers i.e. thunder punch, or flaming foot of justice. Even with freeform we don't have true elemental melee powers. There have been a lot of new/revamped ranged powers.Let us not forget the guys and gals that get up close and punch evil in the face. Auras only go so far.

Comments

  • dialamxdialamx Posts: 940 Arc User
    Unless they can come up with a way to make it differ from all the other melee powers (instead of "Might but with fire damage" or "Martial arts but with lightning damage") all you're going to get is the current melee attacks with hand or foot auras to represent the element you want.

    It would be a lot of wasted effort to clone the current melee abilities but change their damage type to an elemental type.
  • aesicaaesica Posts: 2,537 Arc User
    They could always use Telekinesis as a model for that, but it's not likely to happen even though I wish it would. :(​​
    (Hopefully) Useful CO Resources: HeroCreator (character planner), Cosmic Timers/Alert Checklist, Blood Moon Map, Anniversary Cat Map, and more (eventually, anyway).
  • spinnytopspinnytop Posts: 16,450 Arc User
    Maybe with the martial arts revamp. Unarmed already has attacks that don't just do physical damage.
  • zhilo1zhilo1 Posts: 14 Arc User
    Hmm, perhaps they could add a new power set, with melee attacks that are similar to a mix between might and unarmed, but that are designed to change depending on which of the elemental passive slots you have active. As an example, lets make an imaginary power:

    Elemental Hook
    Charged melee cone
    Deals 300-1000 melee crushing damage

    (Maybe make these powers scale with EGO instead of STR like ego blades, so elemental dps characters dont feel like they have to pick between range or melee damage over the other)
    -If under the effects of Fiery Form, this power deals fire damage instead
    -If under the effects of Electric Form, this power deals electric damage instead

    and so on.

    There may be coding issues with making the set work, and such a power set may be seen as restrictive since it pretty much forces you to take an elemental passive or you are just being redundant with might. Another problem is that people who want to tank with elemental melee are still out of luck.
  • spinnytopspinnytop Posts: 16,450 Arc User
    zhilo1 said:

    Hmm, perhaps they could add a new power set, with melee attacks that are similar to a mix between might and unarmed, but that are designed to change depending on which of the elemental passive slots you have active. As an example, lets make an imaginary power:

    It will likely have to remain imaginary. Your idea is neat, but out of scope.
  • why? the game already has the ability to apply different effects to a power based on your passive

    i refer you to eldritch shield's imbue with power adv​​
    #LegalizeAwoo
  • spinnytopspinnytop Posts: 16,450 Arc User

    why? the game already has the ability to apply different effects to a power based on your passive



    i refer you to eldritch shield's imbue with power adv​​

    how does that translate into what the OP is asking for?
  • championshewolfchampionshewolf Posts: 4,375 Arc User
    edited October 2017
    Elemental melee is probably up there on the list it's just a matter of them having time to do it as it stands. They would most likely want to make it stand out instead of it being punches with elemental effects right now. But, as it stands it just a matter of resources and time. So who knows what the future holds.
    Champions Online player since September of 2008, forumite since February of 2008.
    Silverspar on PRIMUS
    Get the Forums Enhancement Extension!
  • screwthisprocessscrewthisprocess Posts: 186 Arc User
    Maybe a clone of every Elemental projectile, in the form of melee class. Flame Fist archetype, ice blader, electric devastator and so on. Just a hunch.

    Elemental melee is not a bad idea honestly. It is not like we are getting water. I would prefer close combat variations of elemental archetypes instead of "The Giant" archetype. Which would basically be The Mountain with a different costume. We all know it is coming :p
  • riveroceanriverocean Posts: 1,690 Arc User
    I really miss the various melee attacks (ice, fire, darkness, kinetic) from the "game whose name we dare not say". No other game out there now even bothers much with various flavors of melee damage.

    I'd love to see an elemental attacks make their way into CO. Maybe in the form of a toggle or mod. I'd take that.
    Questions About AT Play? Visit Silverwolfx11's Updated AT Guides!
  • spinnytopspinnytop Posts: 16,450 Arc User
    edited October 2017

    from the "game whose name we dare not say".

    What, you can say city of heroes or CoX or whatever. Say it all you like. Just be prepared for fanboys to dogpile on you before they even know why you mentioned it ^_^




    SO HERE'S A QUESTION:

    What if they came out with weapon geodes that have elemental effects on them? Say, a sword that has some fire on the blade, and a staff covered in lightning effects, and an axe made out of ice. Would that satisfy any part of your need for elemental melee? I don't care if this is possible or not, I'm just trying to gauge what people need.
  • flyingfinnflyingfinn Posts: 8,408 Arc User
    Maybe we get specific Mods, with added elemetal dmg added to them..Since New Mods are the current thing.
    :#
    I still miss Swamp Feet, poison effect on Kick attacks...talk about smelly feet...
    CHAMPIONS ONLINE:Join Date: Apr 2008
    And playing by myself since Aug 2009
    Godtier: Lifetime Subscriber
    tumblr_n7qtltG3Dv1rv1ckao1_500.gif
    Get the Forums Enhancement Extension!
  • mithrosnomoremithrosnomore Posts: 521 Arc User
    edited October 2017

    Maybe we get specific Mods, with added elemetal dmg added to them..Since New Mods are the current thing.
    :#
    I still miss Swamp Feet, poison effect on Kick attacks...talk about smelly feet...

    This would be my thinking.

    A few mods that add this or that damage type to attacks.
    Wouldn't matter what sort of powers you used, this would be a way to attach riders.

    Want a heavy weapons toon to use an "atomic mace"? Add a particle mod to your offense gear.

    Want your might character to be electrically powered? Add an electric mod to offense gear.

    Want your character to wield magical fire? Add either a magic mod to your fire character or a fire mod to your magic character.

    The mods themselves just do a percentage of the power damage as added damage of the appropriate type, and the higher rank the mod the higher the percentage.


    And If they then added some "elemental weapons" to the store with a variety of weapons with built-in effects then all the better.
  • spinnytopspinnytop Posts: 16,450 Arc User
    edited October 2017
    Mods that add elemental damage would be neat, so long as they add visuals ( which would make them power replacers, which the devs hate, so we're unlikely to get that ).
  • flyingfinnflyingfinn Posts: 8,408 Arc User
    I don't think they really hated/hate Power Replacers.
    It's just the way to implement powers that way is/was huge effort to make them actually work.(with limited resources they had)
    That's why the Power Replacer weapons had locked weapon skins. The different auras couldn't be added to weapons. They had/need to make whole new powers.
    And let's think likes of Fire Melee. Would it do just fire dmg? Or crushing and fire dmg. I think that was the fault in Power Replacers, they had to add the replacer dmg to some other powers dmg. It couldn't be 50/50.
    But that was wayyy back when stats and stuff was diffent.
    And i don't really know what i'm talking about. :#

    But getting different powers to added current Frames be nice.
    CHAMPIONS ONLINE:Join Date: Apr 2008
    And playing by myself since Aug 2009
    Godtier: Lifetime Subscriber
    tumblr_n7qtltG3Dv1rv1ckao1_500.gif
    Get the Forums Enhancement Extension!
  • dontwantaforumnadontwantaforumna Posts: 2 Arc User
    edited October 2017
    I think the trick here is to do what most frameworks in the game have done. Have the elemental melee attacks play off the effects of the framework they're part of. Clinging flames, Chill, and Negative Ions. This would allow for several things:

    1. Energy projecters with close range AoE's -such as Pyre or Sparkstorm- can apply the effects already in the game.
    2. Would allow for consumption of conditions like clinging flames and negative ions to apply additional effects. Think Ego Blades and its consumption of Ego Leech adding damage to the attack and buffs to the attacker.
    3. It would also allow forms to trigger, such as the Negative Ions form (the name eludes me atm), and passives already in existence to apply their bonuses to the elemental damage (electric form, in this case).
    4. For elemental melee, you already have self heals I've never seen anyone use in fire and now electricity. Defensive options already exist there too. "Offensive Defense," like Fiery Form dealing damage within melee range per tick, are already in existence.
    5. Simplify inclusion. You wouldn't need to make an entire framework- just some additional attacks in the projector frameworks. Much easier.

    The overall point would be make it fun to work with and build in melee, not just be a cosmetic. For these there needs to be some kind of tactical advantage over using it ranged- with energy projection, that melee usage isn't really as much of a "thing" as it is elsewhere.

    Some example powers based on these ideas:
    Melt:
    Fire, Charged, Melee
    You send an intense burst of heat through your hands to melt your opponents defenses, reducing their resistance to fire damage for a short time by 2% for each clinging flames consumed. 2 point advantage to add a disorient.

    Freeze:
    Ice, Maintain, Melee
    Suck the heat from your targeted foe, escalating in damage per tick. Chance to apply chill per tick. 2 point advantage to guarantee a root if the stack of chill is already full.

    Zap:
    Electricity, Combo, Melee
    Shock your opponent repeatedly, making them think twice about... Well, anything really. If a target is affected by negative ions, the third strike arcs to nearby targets. 2 point advantage to complete the circuit and replace each negative ions charge on the targets with a small damage debuff.
  • theravenforcetheravenforce Posts: 7,148 Arc User
    Honestly,

    I think the "easiest" way to kick start Elemental Melee set is to do this:

    Review the Earth Power Set.

    Remove the melee abilities and lunges that are tied into the Earth Set and flesh out the Earth Set as a mid to long ranged set.

    Take the melee Earth abilities and stick them in a new set called "Elemental Melee".

    ^ That would be a very basic starting point, as I imagine there'd have to be a number of additional powers to be able to make a full "Earth Melee" build.

    Once each 'elemental' set is reviewed, any melee based powers (less than 25ft) should be transferred into Elemental Melee.

    Again, as championshewolf mentioned...it's likely on the to do list and has probably been fleshed out a while ago, but it is a matter of time and resources.
  • screwthisprocessscrewthisprocess Posts: 186 Arc User
    Elemental melee is the way to go for s few reasons.

    All they do is recycle old archetypes, they are running out of old archetypes to copy and paste.

    Elemental melee does not appear difficult or resource centric. dialamx's post is right on the money, which is why I think this is next to happen. All of our archetypes appear to be an wasted effort of stuff already in the game. Did we really need the Rocker when we have the Devastator? One is a tank, the other a dps, so what? Why go through that effort?
  • spinnytopspinnytop Posts: 16,450 Arc User

    Did we really need the Rocker when we have the Devastator? One is a tank, the other a dps, so what? Why go through that effort?

    Absolutely. I wanted a DPS HW AT for years and I'm sure I'm not the only one. I'm hoping they introduce a Might DPS as well when they revamp that framework.
  • screwthisprocessscrewthisprocess Posts: 186 Arc User
    Boy, a lot of work sure goes into these new archetypes. The difference between the dragon spirit and master are very noticeable. If you look really close, the master's tattoo is slight darker than the dragon spirit.

    Really tho, these new alts are a waste of time imo. Elemental melee requires some light work but at least it is somewhat different.
  • spinnytopspinnytop Posts: 16,450 Arc User

    Elemental melee requires some light work but at least it is somewhat different.

    "light work".
  • screwthisprocessscrewthisprocess Posts: 186 Arc User
    Well at least the new flight is fire. I wonder why DCUO cannot do stuff they like, so trash. Glad I came here.

    Though Elemental melee does not look like a future additional to me.
  • screwthisprocessscrewthisprocess Posts: 186 Arc User
    Does the new sidekick do elemental melee? I seen a Ryu blast which would have been neat for us players to have, and her fist imbued with energy.
  • spinnytopspinnytop Posts: 16,450 Arc User

    Does the new sidekick do elemental melee? I seen a Ryu blast which would have been neat for us players to have, and her fist imbued with energy.

    We have those, they're in the Unarmed tree. They've actually always been there too, they're not new.
  • screwthisprocessscrewthisprocess Posts: 186 Arc User
    edited February 2018
    spinnytop said:

    Does the new sidekick do elemental melee? I seen a Ryu blast which would have been neat for us players to have, and her fist imbued with energy.

    We have those, they're in the Unarmed tree. They've actually always been there too, they're not new.
    You mean the burning fist and palm strike? I don't see those animations when using them. I thought maybe I was crazy, so watched others use these moves and did not see these animations.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PPYnp9ghfQ0

    hers have a red fireball from the fist, my palm strike does not display such an animation. Is it a perk from the advantage tree?
  • spinnytopspinnytop Posts: 16,450 Arc User
Sign In or Register to comment.