extra commodities like bags and potions that save you time from farming in game, giving you an advantage over someone not spending real money. that is pay to win.
I didn't realize this game was pay to win. Saddens me. I don't mind cash shops that are for purely cosmetic things but when people pay to have an advantage, that's just wrong. And saving time is an advantage. When someone can spend dollars and do things in a much easier and quicker way, that is definitely pay to win.