test content
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc

How to avoid Pay to Win

steampunkysteampunky Member Posts: 0 Arc User
edited May 2013 in General Discussion (PC)
So I decided to try an experiment with my control wizard. I have the Guardian pack but I didn't withdraw a single diamond from the bank (on her) and threw away my adventurer's pack and Graycloak's legacy on her.

And then I ran missions, storyline and foundry, hit up skirmishes and dungeons, but I didn't enter into PvP because it's just not my cup of tea. I traded in my astral diamonds for Zen and bought keys for the lockboxes I could afford and sold the rest on the market.

Then I got a Nightmare. And then I sold that nightmare on the market for 2 million astral diamonds. I used another 450,000 astral diamonds on fruitless keys and lockboxes until I won another one. Which I then sold for 1.8 million astral diamonds.

My character is, currently, level 39. And I had 3.3 million astral diamonds before I started shifting them over to other characters. Though, to be fair, I also got the Astral Diamond Statue/Relic quest twice out of the lockboxes I opened, so that was another 80,000 AD I didn't have to actually earn/

So how do you avoid spending money or investing huge amounts of time and make some quick AD/Zen? Alts. You've got 2 character slots to start with. Get them both leveled up and do your dailies the whole way through. Use your AD to get some zen and pop open some lockboxes. Use the winnings to purchase 2 more character slots. Grind up a little more AD and transfer your lockboxes to one character. Offer to buy huge amounts of Zen at 50 AD per zen and then cancel the bid on the "Main Lockbox Opener" character and withdraw the Astral Diamonds for the Lockboxer.

Then buy keys.

It's actually pretty damned fast. My other character I was doing this with is only level 16 right now and I only -really- used her to do daily skirmishes and the Cloak Tower.

TL;DR Version: Get yourself AD from Dailies and such, use a second character to do dailies/prayer -only- while your main character is having fun and leveling up or whatever, buy keys with AD, get lots of AD, use AD to get Zen, profit.

-Rachel-
Great Weapon Fighter tanks? Who are you kidding? Cleric tanks. They draw -all- the aggro.
Post edited by steampunky on
«13

Comments

  • holt3holt3 Member Posts: 333 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    The cash shop griefers are going to hate this post... That might be too much work for them.
  • sasheriasasheria Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Hero Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users, Neverwinter Knight of the Feywild Users Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    steampunky wrote: »
    So I decided to try an experiment with my control wizard. I have the Guardian pack but I didn't withdraw a single diamond from the bank (on her) and threw away my adventurer's pack and Graycloak's legacy on her.

    And then I ran missions, storyline and foundry, hit up skirmishes and dungeons, but I didn't enter into PvP because it's just not my cup of tea. I traded in my astral diamonds for Zen and bought keys for the lockboxes I could afford and sold the rest on the market.

    Then I got a Nightmare. And then I sold that nightmare on the market for 2 million astral diamonds. I used another 450,000 astral diamonds on fruitless keys and lockboxes until I won another one. Which I then sold for 1.8 million astral diamonds.

    My character is, currently, level 39. And I had 3.3 million astral diamonds before I started shifting them over to other characters. Though, to be fair, I also got the Astral Diamond Statue/Relic quest twice out of the lockboxes I opened, so that was another 80,000 AD I didn't have to actually earn/

    So how do you avoid spending money or investing huge amounts of time and make some quick AD/Zen? Alts. You've got 2 character slots to start with. Get them both leveled up and do your dailies the whole way through. Use your AD to get some zen and pop open some lockboxes. Use the winnings to purchase 2 more character slots. Grind up a little more AD and transfer your lockboxes to one character. Offer to buy huge amounts of Zen at 50 AD per zen and then cancel the bid on the "Main Lockbox Opener" character and withdraw the Astral Diamonds for the Lockboxer.

    Then buy keys.

    It's actually pretty damned fast. My other character I was doing this with is only level 16 right now and I only -really- used her to do daily skirmishes and the Cloak Tower.

    TL;DR Version: Get yourself AD from Dailies and such, use a second character to do dailies/prayer -only- while your main character is having fun and leveling up or whatever, buy keys with AD, get lots of AD, use AD to get Zen, profit.

    -Rachel-
    This is what I have been saying all along. I do love NWN and STO have this option. Players can use the current SYSTEM and get everything. They just need to invest in time (and in your case a little luck) BUT it is possible.
    To grow old is inevitable, to grow up is optional.
    Please review my campaign and I'll return the favor.
  • steampunkysteampunky Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    Maybe. But one alt doubles the amount of AD you can earn in a day. Buying two more character slots brings up up to 4 times the normal amount. And you can buy those character slots without putting down a dime on the game.

    -Rachel-
    Great Weapon Fighter tanks? Who are you kidding? Cleric tanks. They draw -all- the aggro.
  • kimmurieloblodrakimmurieloblodra Member, Neverwinter Beta Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    need tremendous luck to get even one nightmare, let alone 2. Your story is one in a million, congrats, you won a mini-lottery. Others are up to 60-70 boxes with no mount, soooo yeah your post is absolutely subjective to your personal experience, but congrats anyways...

    Now go buy a real lotto ticket
  • lemongrenadeslemongrenades Member Posts: 43
    edited May 2013
    I hope you can hear the standing ovation I am giving you from here. Awesome post!
  • sasheriasasheria Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Hero Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users, Neverwinter Knight of the Feywild Users Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    need tremendous luck to get even one nightmare, let alone 2. Your story is one in a million, congrats, you won a mini-lottery. Others are up to 60-70 boxes with no mount, soooo yeah your post is absolutely subjective to your personal experience, but congrats anyways...

    Now go buy a real lotto ticket
    like I said, a little luck, BUT even without getting the mount, there are tons of items you can get in game that have good stats and sell on AH for AD.

    24k a day per character (with alts) so with two it is 48k AD per day (refining rate)
    Then you may earn more via AH from selling different items. This will take a bit of research and item drop.
    To grow old is inevitable, to grow up is optional.
    Please review my campaign and I'll return the favor.
  • stereoblindxstereoblindx Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users Posts: 246 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    Want to avoid pay to win? Play like a gold farmer
  • random1285random1285 Member Posts: 18
    edited May 2013
    need tremendous luck to get even one nightmare, let alone 2. Your story is one in a million, congrats, you won a mini-lottery. Others are up to 60-70 boxes with no mount, soooo yeah your post is absolutely subjective to your personal experience, but congrats anyways...

    Now go buy a real lotto ticket

    This. "Just win a nightmare, guys!", is eye-twitchingly stupid, given that it reportedly has a 0.5% chance to drop from a box. Otherwise the advice is sound, just learn to work the auction I suppose.
  • slashcryslashcry Member Posts: 26 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    steampunky wrote: »
    TL;DR Version: Get extremely lucky.

    Fixxed for you.
  • sasheriasasheria Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Hero Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users, Neverwinter Knight of the Feywild Users Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    random1285 wrote: »
    This. "Just win a nightmare, guys!", is eye-twitchingly stupid, given that it reportedly has a 0.5% chance to drop from a box. Otherwise the advice is sound, just learn to work the auction I suppose.

    Basic economic works well. There are TWO areas that players should work on.

    Auction house
    AD/Zen Exchange

    the problem with this method is that it REQUIRE people who have little patience and want stuff now. Just like real life stock exchange.

    You need to earn a bit of AD and you could play the AD/Zen exchange. Buy low and sell high. The market changes constantly so you could earn them if you have the time (like Day Trading)

    The other takes a bit of research (just like selling stuff on eBay) you need to find what is popular item on the Auction house and then farm said item and sell it. OR, if you are adventurous (some are) you could BUY low in AH and sell high in AH and make some profit. Keep in mind that there is a FEE so this method is not as profitable if you are not careful (again this will take time)
    To grow old is inevitable, to grow up is optional.
    Please review my campaign and I'll return the favor.
  • steampunkysteampunky Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    Yup. I got pretty damned lucky.

    You know what else sells like hotcakes on the market? Nightmare Dye Packs. Something like 70k a pack. And they're purchased with trade bars which you get in stacks of 5-40 each time you open the box. They cost 45.

    Also the statues that you turn in for 40k each.

    And you could probably sell the blue and purple enchants and stuff you get out of the coffers. Even the green enchantment and rune boxes have the chance to drop purples, after all.

    Yeah. I got really lucky to get two Nightmares within a couple of days of each other. So unless you get as lucky you won't get 3 million in a week. But you'll still be able to get hundreds of thousands so long as you use your trade bars for tradeables and get moderately lucky with the coffers.

    -Rachel-
    Great Weapon Fighter tanks? Who are you kidding? Cleric tanks. They draw -all- the aggro.
  • zuldannzuldann Member Posts: 6
    edited May 2013
    See, this is one of those things where the math looks nice on paper, but in reality, doesn't work as well as one would want. Ok, seriously, how much time & effort must be put in per day for each character to actually attain 24k refined AD?? Let alone both characters??

    From the math I did, it'll take around 50k AD to get 1 single key. 1 single chance at getting something big to sell on the AH. Sure, if you are lucky enough, then you're set. But I've read these forums, I've read what people have said. I've heard how much money people have sunk already in keys, and still haven't gotten the mount, or anything really worthwhile. Sure, it's a gamble, but not much of a gamble.

    Now I don't have all day to play this game, but in the time I do have available, I have a 23 cleric, and a 20 guardian. Between both characters, doing dailies, praying, and sometimes through Leadership, I've attained maybe 10k AD between the 2 of them. Also know that I have not spent a single AD on anything, because I'm saving up for a new character slot(214k AD at current rate).

    I definitely see what you're saying, it was my goal in the first place. Though easy, it is completely far from being time efficient, unless you are lucky enough to actually snag a high selling item. Yes, you can do all of this without spending a dime. But it will take forever and a day to do it. That is, unless you're lucky.

    In some ways, it's like telling someone "You can be a millionaire very easy!!! Just buy lotto tickets every single day, and sign up for as much of the Publisher's Clearing House as you can!" :D
  • lokaidraxmartislokaidraxmartis Member Posts: 12 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    holt3 wrote: »
    The cash shop griefers are going to hate this post... That might be too much work for them.

    I think people are confusing our " prices are too high " for not wanting to spend cash. Truth is people like the OP are what we like to call moochers. They arent spending money(well he did which is fine, he spent cash and was able to use what he had to profit). But the point is... some of us want to support the game with our wallet, however we also want value for our cash which this game doesnt give. Its like going to mcdonalds and being charged 35 dollars for a bigmac, and having to pay 20 dollars for your fries and 10 dollars for a drink.

    We want to spend money but over all cash requirement is fairly high...
  • zuldannzuldann Member Posts: 6
    edited May 2013
    I completely agree with you, lokaidraxmartis. So far the community in this game reminds me of the community from a city I used to live in. People with money act like they're better than those without. You can see it in their attitudes. That's why they keep assuming that people who want the prices in the cash shop lowered are just whining because they want everything for free. They just keep assuming we're all a bunch of lazy, no-good freeloaders who want everything for free, all because we don't see the value in the cash shop currently. I'm not a freeloader, I'm a value shopper. I don't like to waste money. Here's an example:

    Character Slot = $5

    Too pricey, imo. Now, if they dropped it to say, $3, I would buy it up. Why? Because, to me, $10 for 3 characters is much better than $10 for 2 characters. Having a total of 5 character slots gives a player with my playing style everything I'd need for awhile. 3 slots for permanent characters, 2 slots for trying out different things(like when new races, or classes become available). Would I buy more later? Probably, because I'm an alt-aholic. But limiting someone with alt-itis his alt-fix unless he's willing to spend a lot of money, is not the best business plan. If I don't see value, I don't buy.
  • kimmurieloblodrakimmurieloblodra Member, Neverwinter Beta Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    Should make a similar thread :

    How to avoid working all your life.

    Buy lottery tickets. Ask your mom for 10$, and go buy lottery tickets. Then, once you win the 60 million from those lottery tickets, you can spend a million of those winnings on more lottery tickets. By that time, you'll have won the lottery twice, bringing you to about 119 million in two weeks.

    See, that was easy, wasn't it!
  • steampunkysteampunky Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    Actually, Lokai, I'm a woman and I do put down money for this game. I bought the Guardian Pack and character slots, I dye my clothes because I like to, and other things.

    I was just putting a counter to the Pay to Win argument through an experiment that took a couple of days.

    If you have got neither time nor money to get stuff in the game, Zul and others, then I don't know what to tell you. It's an MMO so you need to invest one or the other at the very least. Generally a balance of both (for P2P and F2P MMOs) or a larger amount of one or the other (F2P MMOs).

    -Rachel-
    Great Weapon Fighter tanks? Who are you kidding? Cleric tanks. They draw -all- the aggro.
  • steampunkysteampunky Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    And Zul: $5 buys you 2 character slots, not 1. So that's $10 for 4 slots.

    -Rachel-
    Great Weapon Fighter tanks? Who are you kidding? Cleric tanks. They draw -all- the aggro.
  • steampunkysteampunky Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    As for the "Just buy Lotto Tickets!" comparison:

    Yeah. That works. Only I didn't spend any money buying the tickets. It's closer to "Go to a casino with a bucket of money you picked up on the way to the casino but didn't spend any money to buy."

    -Rachel-
    Great Weapon Fighter tanks? Who are you kidding? Cleric tanks. They draw -all- the aggro.
  • kimmurieloblodrakimmurieloblodra Member, Neverwinter Beta Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    steampunky wrote: »
    As for the "Just buy Lotto Tickets!" comparison:

    Yeah. That works. Only I didn't spend any money buying the tickets. It's closer to "Go to a casino with a bucket of money you picked up on the way to the casino but didn't spend any money to buy."

    -Rachel-

    That 'Guardian' tag under your Avatar tells me otherwise ....
  • elenoe8elenoe8 Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    zuldann wrote: »
    Character Slot = $5

    Too pricey, imo. Now, if they dropped it to say, $3, I would buy it up. Why? Because, to me, $10 for 3 characters is much better than $10 for 2 characters.
    Am I the only one who really can't see it? Why $3 is OK and $5 is not? Because I don't think griefers (if that's the word) would stop complaining if it was $3. They would say exactly the same you did but with $1. I really don't see any logical difference between $3 a $5. And the amount ALWAYS means some will buy it and some will not. Because money doesn't have any other value then people's time. And that's differs.

    It's not up to you to prove the price is good or wrong. It is not. It is set to maximize profit. I simply couldn't agree more with that goal. One need to do it with superior product. One does it with outstanding marketing. Other do it with better customer service. One is open and doesn't use sneaky techniques. Just tell me when you meet one doing all of that and profiting long in mass sector.

    Because if you go nice then all those who said "if it was cheaper, if it has no DRM, if it has better service, I will pay" usually don't pay enough for what it really costs. This work usually with relatively small communities.

    People choose. Some will play it, some will leave. I just wish people would leave without a week flaming the forums how they don't care at all about such bad game.
  • papi032papi032 Member, Neverwinter Beta Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    What i read was: "I got a mount from 1 key and used the tons of money i made from selling it to make more money"...
  • banicksbanicks Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Hero Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users Posts: 66
    edited May 2013
    Your example however is flawed, you obviously started with a fair amount of AD from either the Guardian or Hero pack. A F2P account making that amount of AD would take at least a month of average playtime.

    But overall, I do agree this isn't P2W, just P2accessfaster.
    Oceanic Neverwinter Online Guild: http://19thbattalion.com/
  • steampunkysteampunky Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    That 'Guardian' tag under your Avatar tells me otherwise ....
    banicks wrote: »
    Your example however is flawed, you obviously started with a fair amount of AD from either the Guardian or Hero pack. A F2P account making that amount of AD would take at least a month of average playtime.




    But overall, I do agree this isn't P2W, just P2accessfaster.
    For the experiment I rolled a new character, threw out the greycloak's legacy and adventurer's helper pack, and didn't withdraw anything from the AD bank. As I noted in the original post.

    That character had no money spent on her, and anything that was given to her because I spent money was thrown away. I even used only the generic mount and cleric pet.

    -Rachel-
    Great Weapon Fighter tanks? Who are you kidding? Cleric tanks. They draw -all- the aggro.
  • kimmurieloblodrakimmurieloblodra Member, Neverwinter Beta Users Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    banicks wrote: »
    But overall, I do agree this isn't P2W, just P2accessfaster.

    +1

    /tenchar
  • zuldannzuldann Member Posts: 6
    edited May 2013
    steampunky wrote: »
    And Zul: $5 buys you 2 character slots, not 1. So that's $10 for 4 slots.

    -Rachel-

    Well, on that note, I will now eat my words. I could've swore that when I moused over it on day 1, it said 500 points for 1 character. But if it's two, then there's definitely some value there, at least regarding my alt-itis. I humbly admit I read that wrong, and throw my earlier example out the window.

    But I still stick by my other points. XD
  • steampunkysteampunky Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    Oh, I don't hold your other points against you. That's why I rebutted them with the whole "Time or Money" thing. It's kind of a balance.

    Just wanted to enable your altitis. Because I am evil in that way.

    -Rachel-
    Great Weapon Fighter tanks? Who are you kidding? Cleric tanks. They draw -all- the aggro.
  • holt3holt3 Member Posts: 333 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    zuldann wrote: »
    Ok, seriously, how much time & effort must be put in per day for each character to actually attain 24k refined AD?? Let alone both characters??

    This is where I stopped reading your post.
  • sasheriasasheria Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Hero Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users, Neverwinter Knight of the Feywild Users Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    zuldann wrote: »
    See, this is one of those things where the math looks nice on paper, but in reality, doesn't work as well as one would want. Ok, seriously, how much time & effort must be put in per day for each character to actually attain 24k refined AD?? Let alone both characters??

    From the math I did, it'll take around 50k AD to get 1 single key. 1 single chance at getting something big to sell on the AH. Sure, if you are lucky enough, then you're set. But I've read these forums, I've read what people have said. I've heard how much money people have sunk already in keys, and still haven't gotten the mount, or anything really worthwhile. Sure, it's a gamble, but not much of a gamble.

    Now I don't have all day to play this game, but in the time I do have available, I have a 23 cleric, and a 20 guardian. Between both characters, doing dailies, praying, and sometimes through Leadership, I've attained maybe 10k AD between the 2 of them. Also know that I have not spent a single AD on anything, because I'm saving up for a new character slot(214k AD at current rate).

    I definitely see what you're saying, it was my goal in the first place. Though easy, it is completely far from being time efficient, unless you are lucky enough to actually snag a high selling item. Yes, you can do all of this without spending a dime. But it will take forever and a day to do it. That is, unless you're lucky.

    In some ways, it's like telling someone "You can be a millionaire very easy!!! Just buy lotto tickets every single day, and sign up for as much of the Publisher's Clearing House as you can!" :D

    similar to real life, you have to work at it. You "could" be a millionaire overnight by lottery (or inheritance) or the old fashion way.... hard work :)

    Now since this is a game, that is optional. You could do hard work and earn your million AD (over time from refining, but realistically, it is more like you find someone and selling it on eBay for something more). Just like in real life, I may buy something and sell it on eBay that someone else willing to pay more (in case of NWN, you got a item drop from many mission you ran and sell it in AH)

    This is more realistic and easily attainable than winning a lotto BUT it can be done. This is NOT overnight operation or even a month worth (1 month is 720k AD if you max out 24k a day) there are other methods that you can use to boost it (play Exchange market or selling items in AH)

    High AD prices does seem daunting right now because it is in the millions BUT the game just open beta in about a week. Granted that going from 1 to max level in short order built a HUGE demand for AD.

    I also notice that while you may earn 10k at level 24, you could probably earn 24k a day easier at 60. I learn this in STO that I can earn 8k rough dilithium easily a day once I have more open. I don't have a level 60 character yet to test :)
    To grow old is inevitable, to grow up is optional.
    Please review my campaign and I'll return the favor.
  • aetherchargeaethercharge Member, Neverwinter Beta Users, Neverwinter Hero Users, Neverwinter Guardian Users Posts: 359 Bounty Hunter
    edited May 2013
    I'm not sure if the OP here is just choosing to ignore basic economic principles. The average value of what comes out of the lock boxes will settle at the same price as a key. This is not a long term way to make money. You either got very lucky with drops or the current economy has people seriously overpaying for things such as the Nightmare because of the over saturation of ADs from the founders' packs. It's likely a bit of both, and in the future people will never make ADs that fast.
  • steampunkysteampunky Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2013
    So... If the items in it generally balance out to not making any money at all: All the ADs you spend on it are returned and every day you build up on ADs with the different characters you're just adding to your stockpile of ADs.

    I really don't see the downside, here. Either you make money in the short term (or you more or less break even) or you make money in the long term.

    -Rachel-
    Great Weapon Fighter tanks? Who are you kidding? Cleric tanks. They draw -all- the aggro.
Sign In or Register to comment.