One common complaint from Pug parties in PVP is that PVP premade parties should go fight each other and leave them alone. Pugs, as well as Solo and Duo Qers get tired of fighting full end game Premade PVP parties and I completely understand as I often solo or Duo Q as well and it's frustrating to wait in Q just to see a full team on the other side.
Along these same lines, my guild finds In-house Premade vs Premade to be the most fun PVP available at the moment as we can dictate the rules of engagement (i.e. No Ambush rings, No broken Shadowclad, No Drains, No Bugs, etc.) and we wind up with a fun, fair match of equal gear vs. equal gear.
We would gladly do this all day long as our primary form of PVP or fight against other guilds who wanted the same format of PVP. All we need to do this is a Private or separate PVP Q for Premade vs. Premade.
This simple step alone would remove my guild full Premades from Qing for regular Domi most of the time. We would do inhouses or Premade against other guilds and Pugs could have more fun, balanced matches.
RIght now, when we try to get an inhouse going, we get two full rainbow match comped teams together (one of each class or the same comps as each other) and Q up. We tried this the other day for a solid 2 hours and got nothing but other pugs or partial premades (i.e. duo or trio Q) and never fought our own groups that we deliberately tried to organize and Q against. This is a direct indicator of how bad the Queue system for PVP is.
If I could make two suggestions to immediately improve PVP they would be:
1) Make a private Q for Premades vs. Premades that allow them to match up lobby style.
2) This would be even better. Allow 1 Queue for Solo or Duo Queue only and 1 for 3+ only. In this way Premades only fight Premades and Pugs only fight Pugs. Then the Queue system would only have to try and balance a Duo Q for Pug Queues and premades could manage their own matches. It's a win win.
Please consider these suggestions @terramak @strumslinger
If anyone agrees with these ideas (I know they're not entirely original but now is the best time to get them going considering the state of PVP and the already existing Queue system in place) feel free to comment or throw up a +1.
Thanks for your time.
On ambush rings: "How would you like PVE if all the mobs were invisible?"