test content
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc

Elachi Lockbox Loot Tables

dukedom01dukedom01 Member Posts: 462 Arc User
edited August 2013 in The Academy
Same deal as with my Tal Shiar Loot Tables. 2000 Boxes opened for each faction on Tribble.

Disclaimer: Given how small some percentages turn out to be a proper sample size would have been at least 10.000, but take a look for yourself.


2000 Boxes opened with Romulan characters:
  • 10,676 Lobi - 5.3380 avg
  • 37x new console - 1.85%
  • 47x 10k cxp bonus - 2.35%
  • 77x 2k cxp bonus - 3.85%
  • 40x 100 fm - 2.00%
  • 40x 25k fleet credit bonus - 2.00%
  • 81x 5k fleet credit bonus - 4.05%
  • 499x fleet support mini pack - 24.95%
  • 461x reinforcements mini pack - 23.05%
  • 63x prefered customer mining pack - 3.15%
  • 37x VIP customer mining pack - 1.85%
  • 136x elachi duty officers - 6.80%
  • 14x ground trait - firearms specialist - 0.70%
  • 9x ground trait - regenerative tissue - 0.45%
  • 13x space trait - inspirational leader - 0.65%
  • 7x space trait - wing commander - 0.35%
  • 377x elachi crescent weapons - 18.85%
  • 57x mirror ha'nom - 2.85%
  • 5x s'golth escort - 0.25%

2000 Boxes opened with Klingon Empire Characters:
  • 10,714 Lobi - 5.3570 avg
  • 36x new console - 1.80%
  • 41x 10k cxp bonus - 2.05%
  • 77x 2k cxp bonus - 3.85%
  • 44x 100 fm - 2.20%
  • 43x 25k fleet credit bonus - 2.15%
  • 70x 5k fleet credit bonus - 3.50%
  • 428x fleet support mini pack - 21.40%
  • 444x reinforcements mini pack - 22.20%
  • 85x prefered customer mining pack - 4.25%
  • 47x VIP customer mining pack - 2.35%
  • 155x elachi duty officers - 7.75%
  • 12x ground trait - firearms specialist - 0.60%
  • 8x ground trait - regenerative tissue - 0.40%
  • 7x space trait - inspirational leader - 0.35%
  • 8x space trait - wing commander - 0.40%
  • 434x elachi crescent weapons - 21.70%
  • 59x mirror qin - 2.95%
  • 2x s'golth escort - 0.10%

2000 Boxes opened with Federation Characters:
  • 10,630 Lobi - 5.3150 avg
  • 37x new console - 1.85%
  • 30x 10k cxp bonus - 1.50%
  • 78x 2k cxp bonus - 3.90%
  • 31x 100 fm - 1.55%
  • 42x 25k fleet credit bonus - 2.10%
  • 65x 5k fleet credit bonus - 3.25%
  • 463x fleet support mini pack - 23.15%
  • 438x reinforcements mini pack - 21.90%
  • 81x prefered customer mining pack - 4.05%
  • 35x VIP customer mining pack - 1.75%
  • 153x elachi duty officers - 7.65%
  • 8x ground trait - firearms specialist - 0.40%
  • 13x ground trait - regenerative tissue - 0.65%
  • 13x space trait - inspirational leader - 0.65%
  • 8x space trait - wing commander - 0.40%
  • 434x elachi crescent weapons - 21.70%
  • 34x mirror deep space sci - 1.70%
  • 33x mirror recon sci - 1.65%
  • 4x s'golth escort - 0.20%

Totals for 6000 Boxes opened:
  • 32,020 Lobi - 5.3367 avg
  • 110x new console - 1.83%
  • 118x 10k cxp bonus - 1.97%
  • 232x 2k cxp bonus - 3.87%
  • 115x 100 fm - 1.92%
  • 125x 25k fleet credit bonus - 2.08%
  • 216x 5k fleet credit bonus - 3.60%
  • 1390x fleet support mini pack - 23.17%
  • 1343x reinforcements mini pack - 22.38%
  • 229x prefered customer mining pack - 3.82%
  • 119x VIP customer mining pack - 1.98%
  • 444x elachi duty officers - 7.40%
  • 34x ground trait - firearms specialist - 0.57%
  • 30x ground trait - regenerative tissue - 0.50%
  • 33x space trait - inspirational leader - 0.55%
  • 23x space trait - wing commander - 0.38%
  • 1245x elachi crescent weapons - 20.75%
  • 183x mirror ships - 3.05%
  • 11x s'golth escort - 0.183%
Ceterum censeo Otha supplendum in praemiis.
Post edited by Unknown User on

Comments

  • lordhavelocklordhavelock Member Posts: 2,248 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    Thanks for the effort Duke.

    It seems the S'golth Escort is lower than I remember the other lockbox ships? Or am I misremembering?

    You can find/contact me in game as @PatricianVetinari. Playing STO since Feb 2010.
  • dukedom01dukedom01 Member Posts: 462 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    It used to be 0.5% on the previous lockboxes.
    Ceterum censeo Otha supplendum in praemiis.
  • poeddudepoeddude Member Posts: 127 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    Cryptic probably feel the lower drop chance of the ship is fine due to the slightly decreased chance of getting the normal TRIBBLE (last time doffs or weapons was over 75% now it is only 68%) coupled with the fact that the lobi have been slightly increased (old average was only about 4.3).

    Last time the Helmsman trait was actually rarer than the ship.

    But hey, now instead of having to open about 200 boxes to get a ship you now need to open about 400. That is no big difference right? Right?

    Another reason not to play the stupid lock box game.
  • xarles2013xarles2013 Member Posts: 16 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    Seems like it....opened 80 boxes today and got nothing....
  • schneemann83schneemann83 Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    Thanks for your effort.


    Rather surprised by the low droprate of the escort. Due to seeing people getting two or more in a row and the immediate price crash at the exchange, I was somewhat inclined to believe the elachi escort was more common than previous lockbox ships, not rarer.
  • meridian113meridian113 Member Posts: 50 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    so,let us do recap here
    you actually opened 6000 lock boxes???????????????????????????????????????????????
  • exejayexejay Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    Thanks for the work, duke! :)
  • nightmarechi1dnightmarechi1d Member Posts: 62 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    so,let us do recap here
    you actually opened 6000 lock boxes???????????????????????????????????????????????

    He said on Tribble. Keys aren't so hard to get on Tribble.
    ___________________________________________________
    I didn't ask to be President of the Balloon Enterprises! The Balloon Enterprises demanded it!
  • gavinrunebladegavinruneblade Member Posts: 3,894 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    poeddude wrote: »
    But hey, now instead of having to open about 200 boxes to get a ship you now need to open about 400. That is no big difference right? Right?

    Another reason not to play the stupid lock box game.

    Well if you're opening boxes for the ship and deleting everything else, then it's definitely not worth it.

    If you're opening boxes and having fun with what comes out regardless of profit and loss, then it's all good.

    Those are the two extremes, most people fall in the middle somewhere.

    Also, 0.18% is about 550 boxes not 400. .25% would be 400 boxes.
  • corjetcorjet Member Posts: 188 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    I only opened 50, but numbers seem right! Although I will say that on my 2nd box I got an Elachi escort :)
  • fraghul2000fraghul2000 Member Posts: 1,590 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    Well if you're opening boxes for the ship and deleting everything else, then it's definitely not worth it.

    If you're opening boxes and having fun with what comes out regardless of profit and loss, then it's all good.

    Those are the two extremes, most people fall in the middle somewhere.

    This.

    I opened around 100 of them to get enough Lobi to buy the console and the crescent cannon. The most valuable thing I got was the leadership trait, but I'm still not angry at the outcome as the only thing I was really aiming for were those avg. 5 Lobi per box and I regarded any kind of drop other than doff packs or boosts as lucky.

    Most people have seen more than one lockbox cycle and by now it's pretty much known what to expect, what to do and what not to do. Experiments like that of the OP are a big, big help in figuring out if you should open boxes or sell keys on the exchange and just buy whatever you want with EC.
  • lordhavelocklordhavelock Member Posts: 2,248 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    I had a little extra money in my budget recently, a 15% Zen sale e-mailed to me, and a 15% sale on keys... Seemed the perfect storm to open some boxes (and support my Hobby (ie the game I'm addicted to, lol)).

    I opened 150 boxes. I didn't take exact count on everything, but here are some things I did count precisely:
    872x Lobi (5.81333/box ave)
    1x Ground Trait - Firearms Specialist
    1x Ground Trait - Regenerative Tissue
    2x Space Trait - Inspirational Leader
    2x Console ? Universal ? Subspace Integration Circuit


    These are approximations:
    ~8x Mirror Universe Ha?noms, but no other ships.
    ~48x individual Dil Mining certificates (I think I got 3ea VIP and Preferred Claims)
    ~18x various CXP/Fleet buffs
    ~8x Elachi DOff backs and about two dozen of the other DOff Mini-packs.
    ~40x Elachi Crescent Weapon packs.


    Overall I'm pretty pleased with my results. Sure there's some disappointment at not getting the S'golth Escort, but there's enough EC worth of "extra" goodies (ie after I use whatever I'm gonna keep) to be close enough to buy one from the Exchange (last I looked about 12hrs ago, cheapest price was ~62M EC) if I decide I really want one (and honestly, I'm undecided).

    I was very happy to get Inspirational Leader, which I wanted for my Main toon. Getting a second was bonus, I may give it to one of my Primary Alts. I wanted two Wing Commanders for my Carrier Captains, got none, but purchased them "reasonably" (about 10M EC for both) off the Exchange (yeah, I coulda waited for price to drop further, but I wanted instant gratification).

    I opened an Elachi DOff pack, got Purple Grav Sci and Diag Eng DOffs, both of which that toon needed, so that was nice.

    I opened only one of my Elachi Crescent packs and got exactly what I wanted... One of my Dis-based escorts was all Mk XII but for one last DHC Mk XI, and I pulled an Elachi DHC Mk XII [Acc]x2 [CrtH], so that was keen! I'll probably sell the rest of the packs (already sold 8 for a lovely sum).

    I actually really like all the Dil Mining certs, too. And the CXP/Fleet buffs are gonna come in useful, as well.

    All-in-all, it was fun just to experience some "gambling" (like how you can have a good time in Vegas at the tables/slots, even if you don't actually win anything), I got lots of goodies I can use/sell, and enough Lobi to buy a Boss ship or other primo gear (I haven't decided yet).

    You can find/contact me in game as @PatricianVetinari. Playing STO since Feb 2010.
  • hachanshachans Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    poeddude wrote: »
    But hey, now instead of having to open about 200 boxes to get a ship you now need to open about 400. That is no big difference right? Right?

    Another reason not to play the stupid lock box game.

    Well yes, except that probability doesn't work that way. Let's say that the chance of opening a lockbox containing a ship is 1 in 400 at the first try. At the second try the chance is still 1 in 400, because supplies are not limited and the system does not take your previous rolls into account (as far as I know). It's like rolling a die, not pulling a playing card out of a deck hoping for the ace of hearts! :)

    I've seen a lot of misconceptions about it here, and just thought I should clarify!
  • codewarrior316codewarrior316 Member Posts: 53 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    Hi class, welcome to STO statistics everyone! Assuming your chance for opening a box and getting a s'golth escort is observed at 11/6000 or 0.183...%, you might assume that if you were to open 550 boxes (550*0.183=100.65) you would be certain to get your goodies, right? Wrong. Each box opening event is unrelated to any other box opening.

    This is more easily visualized of your chances to not get the ship as 1-0.00183...=0.99816 or 99.8% (still assumed drop rate from the observed stats, also note the repeating 3.) Your chances for not getting the loot in 2 rolls is (0.99816)^2=0.996336694... your true chances for not getting the desired drop at the proclaimed 550 boxes is still (1-(11/6000))^550=36.45%. In order to get a 99% probability of getting the ship (or 1% chance of NOT getting it) you would have to open ln(0.01)/ln(1-(11/6000)) = 2510 boxes. Of course you could get it much sooner, or perhaps even not at all although that would be quite unlikely at that point.

    This all assumes of course that the actual drop rate is exactly 11/6000. While this is a reasonably good sample size, due to the low rate I suspect it is not extremely precise mathematically although it is probably quite sufficient for the intended purpose. I suspect the actual rate might be 0.2% (and the OP was a little unlucky, just 1 more hit in the sample would set it at this precisely) just based off what I might do if I were a Cryptic programmer. Given that it would "only" take opening 2301 boxes to get a 99% probability. Still care to play the lotto?

    Class dismissed!
  • fritzcalamity12fritzcalamity12 Member Posts: 3 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    I have a question about the Elachi boxes. Do you have to be the required rank to obtain one of the ships before unlocking a box or can any rank acquire a ship and then has level up to the proper rank to use it? For example: All my characters are at Lt Commander and Commander rank and I have a bunch of Elachi boxes in my account bank to open up. Can I open them up at that rank to possibly get a ship or should I wait until I have a Admiral to even have a chance?
  • lan451lan451 Member Posts: 3,386 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    I have a question about the Elachi boxes. Do you have to be the required rank to obtain one of the ships before unlocking a box or can any rank acquire a ship and then has level up to the proper rank to use it? For example: All my characters are at Lt Commander and Commander rank and I have a bunch of Elachi boxes in my account bank to open up. Can I open them up at that rank to possibly get a ship or should I wait until I have a Admiral to even have a chance?

    You can still get the ship box at any level, you just can't open it and use it until you reach level 50. The chances of obtaining items are not related to character level in any way.
    JWZrsUV.jpg
    Mine Trap Supporter
  • fritzcalamity12fritzcalamity12 Member Posts: 3 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    Thank you. I was hoping it would be that way. Now if I could only find a way to get my KDF character to the Bajor mining asteroid to use those super Dilithium claims that he got from a lock box
  • mithrosnomoremithrosnomore Member Posts: 390 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    hachans wrote: »
    Well yes, except that probability doesn't work that way. Let's say that the chance of opening a lockbox containing a ship is 1 in 400 at the first try. At the second try the chance is still 1 in 400, because supplies are not limited and the system does not take your previous rolls into account (as far as I know). It's like rolling a die, not pulling a playing card out of a deck hoping for the ace of hearts! :)

    I've seen a lot of misconceptions about it here, and just thought I should clarify!

    Except it kind of does.

    If I roll a die 6 times I may not end up rolling each of 1-6 a single time, because the sample size is too small, but my chances of rolling 6 of a single number are much less than rolling some variety of numbers.
    And if I roll that die 6000 times I should start to see something closer to 1000 of each number.
    Not exactly a 1000 of each, but closer to it.

    If something is contained in approximately 1:500 lock boxes, then if I open 500 it doesn't mean that I will pull that item, but my chances are certainly improved.
    And just because the odds are 1:500 doesn't mean that I won't get it on my first try, but it is a long shot.

    And if I open a million, then yeah, I probably end up with around 2000 of that item.

    Because if not, then those numbers aren't worth anything, and I am guessing that a sample size of 6000 ain't that bad.
  • the1tiggletthe1tigglet Member Posts: 1,421 Arc User
    edited August 2013
    Thanks, explains why all I kept getting were doffs. and a couple of elachi weapons.

    The lobi crystal thing is just weird, they seriously need in game ways of getting those even if it's just a daily! Having ships on the Exchange but then not having an in game means of buying the kits for them is just stupid.

    Even if you're trying to get more people to open boxes those who are gung ho about it still are going to get tired of buying all those keys just to get 800 lobi crystals. They need to have an in game option AND increase the crystals per box or do away with lobis altogether and use dilithium
Sign In or Register to comment.