test content
What is the Arc Client?
Install Arc

Reduce Cooldown on AFK

mazinger2010mazinger2010 Member Posts: 1 Arc User
edited February 2014 in Controls and User Interface
Just ran Mirror universe with 2 friends of mine. We que up for this any chance we get as I'm running a fairly geared character this gives us a chance to run something quick, easy, and fun with a lot of explosions. One of those friends went AFK for a moment, came back, and was hit with a 2 hour AFK penalty. This is completely ridiculous. I could understand a 20 minute penalty but this was just silly.

I purchased my lifetime membership a few months ago because I intended to invest time in this game PLAYING WITH MY FRIENDS. This however limits that capability as if they have anything come up our time gets robbed not just by a reasonable penalty marker but by a 2 hour long delay.

I really wish there was a refund department at this phase, seriously considering just leaving the game all together. I'm guessing this carries no weight with cryptic as they already have my money but I will NEVER suggest to anyone they purchase anything in this game so long as such an outrageous and unfair penalty exists. After all, the penalty in other online games is far lower or well balanced.

I get having a penalty, but this is just ridiculous. It isn't that hard to code the penalty to be 20 minutes from the time they leave the map for an AFK penalty.

Sincerely Your's
Disgruntled Paying Player
Post edited by mazinger2010 on
«134

Comments

  • nobletnoblet Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Music to my ears. Cryptic has finally done something right. Your friend won't be missed.:D
  • mazinger2010mazinger2010 Member Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    So you believe a 2 hour penalty is fair and reasonable? Be a good chap and give your reasoning how such a large penalty should be applied for such a minor infringement?
  • tekehdtekehd Member Posts: 2,032 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Got an AFK penalty for being gone "for a moment"? Bull****.... complete an utter bull****. IT takes more than being "gone for a moment" to trigger an AFK penalty.
  • luihimeluihime Member Posts: 5 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Oh so noblet was one of the people who agreed that 2 hour penalties should be ok... Good to know! You used to go AFK like that in the past in other games, right?

    There's another prestigious MMO that only gives a 30 minute AFK/team drop penalty on a PVP or PVE instance. It's paid though, but I see here that there's paid lifetime subs so in my opinion it should be fixed, right?

    btw... I AM that friend. Bucker off if you do not have something constructive to say instead of being a troll, love.
  • mazinger2010mazinger2010 Member Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Again, I'm not against having a penalty, but seriously, 2hrs is a LARGE chunk out of the day.
  • gofasternowgofasternow Member Posts: 1,390 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    tekehd wrote: »
    Got an AFK penalty for being gone "for a moment"? Bull****.... complete an utter bull****. IT takes more than being "gone for a moment" to trigger an AFK penalty.

    Exactly. The AFK penalty is working as intended. It's a shame your friend got hit with one, but I don't think Cryptic is gonna lower punishment time for that. Especially since players have been griping because of said AFKers. We got a hour punishment for Leavers who run away from "bad' STFs and we got a two hour punishment who try to AFK.

    If your friend had something big to do that required needing to be AFK, then perhaps you should have waited.
  • aloishammeraloishammer Member Posts: 3,294 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    So you believe a 2 hour penalty is fair and reasonable? Be a good chap and give your reasoning how such a large penalty should be applied for such a minor infringement?

    How about first you level with us and tell us precisely how long the "moment" your friend went AFK for was?

    Then do bear in mind that this (fair and generous, in my opinion) penalty is for wasting the time of every single person in a multi-player mission whose time is wasted and fun interfered with when one player decides it's all about them.

    Nope, don't believe your friend left for anything most rational people would call a "moment," and I think they got precisely the harsh heads-up they deserved.

    (And making the fuss about being LTS and signing about how you're a high and mighty "paying player," I guarantee, did you no favors in this discussion- but it did let the rest of us know what we're dealing with.)
    Again, I'm not against having a penalty, but seriously, 2hrs is a LARGE chunk out of the day.

    That's the entire point. It's intended to be noticed, not to just be a minor inconvenience. Your angst is merely proof that it's doing precisely what it's supposed to do.
  • mirrorchaosmirrorchaos Member Posts: 9,844 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Just ran Mirror universe with 2 friends of mine. We que up for this any chance we get as I'm running a fairly geared character this gives us a chance to run something quick, easy, and fun with a lot of explosions. One of those friends went AFK for a moment, came back, and was hit with a 2 hour AFK penalty. This is completely ridiculous. I could understand a 20 minute penalty but this was just silly.

    I purchased my lifetime membership a few months ago because I intended to invest time in this game PLAYING WITH MY FRIENDS. This however limits that capability as if they have anything come up our time gets robbed not just by a reasonable penalty marker but by a 2 hour long delay.

    I really wish there was a refund department at this phase, seriously considering just leaving the game all together. I'm guessing this carries no weight with cryptic as they already have my money but I will NEVER suggest to anyone they purchase anything in this game so long as such an outrageous and unfair penalty exists. After all, the penalty in other online games is far lower or well balanced.

    I get having a penalty, but this is just ridiculous. It isn't that hard to code the penalty to be 20 minutes from the time they leave the map for an AFK penalty.

    Sincerely Your's
    Disgruntled Paying Player

    and? whats your point?

    if you dont like it go away, otherwise accept the fact that the community wanted an afk feature and got it, you and your friend should of planned your run more carefully. if i went afk for a moment and got a 2 hour penalty i wouldnt care, there are other games to play outside sto for 2 hours and it would of been my own silly fault for allowing it in the first place. its fair that an afker wont be taking up valuable spots on an stf let alone leeching off other players hard worked for rewards.
    T6 Miranda Hero Ship FTW.
    Been around since Dec 2010 on STO and bought LTS in Apr 2013 for STO.
  • dahminusdahminus Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    The moral of the story, don't go afk in a match...
    Chive on and prosper, eh?

    My PvE/PvP hybrid skill tree
  • aloishammeraloishammer Member Posts: 3,294 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    luihime wrote: »
    btw... I AM that friend. Bucker off if you do not have something constructive to say instead of being a troll, love.

    Bet you learned not to go AFK again, din't ya love? :P
  • mazinger2010mazinger2010 Member Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    My point is, simply put, the penalty is far to harsh for the crime in this instance. A 2 hour cool-down for afking in an event that lasts one hour? That's a bit silly to begin with. Factor in that her leave was JUST as the Staddi was arriving. That means she was AFK a minute, two at most till the primary part of the match was ended. I suppose your going to count cleanup into that time frame though.

    Still, tell me this, why is the punishment for AFKing harsher than for leaving a match? Further why such a harsh punishment on an event that is considerably easy to run?
  • kjwashingtonkjwashington Member Posts: 2,529 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Not going to lie, yesterday I went AFK for about five minutes during a MU event to go to the bathroom. (The event lasted like 15 minutes, because of the really bad team.) I never got the penalty. Your friend must have been gone longer than just "a moment". Then again, since I contributed more than a third of the team's DPS (even with the 5 minute break), I guess it decided to be merciful.

    To tell you the truth, I would have been fine getting the two hour ban. Why? BECAUSE I DESERVED IT! The AFK ban prevents leachers and the like from ruining the game. Maybe two hours is a bit much, but it should be at least one hour. The same as the leaver penalty.

    I'm not even going to bother commenting on your self-entitlement.
    FaW%20meme_zpsbkzfjonz.jpg
    Support 90 degree arc limitation on BFaW! Save our ships from looking like flying disco balls of dumb!
  • deniedexistencedeniedexistence Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited January 2014

    Still, tell me this, why is the punishment for AFKing harsher than for leaving a match? Further why such a harsh punishment on an event that is considerably easy to run?

    Because it is meant to be a huge inconvenience to the people who blatantly AFK just so they can get their marks/dil and not have to lift a finger. As you said, 2 hours is a substantial bit of downtime, so it will affect those types fairly.
  • nobletnoblet Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    How about first you level with us and tell us precisely how long the "moment" your friend went AFK for was?

    Then do bear in mind that this (fair and generous, in my opinion) penalty is for wasting the time of every single person in a multi-player mission whose time is wasted and fun interfered with when one player decides it's all about them.

    Nope, don't believe your friend left for anything most rational people would call a "moment," and I think they got precisely the harsh heads-up they deserved.

    (And making the fuss about being LTS and signing about how you're a high and mighty "paying player," I guarantee, did you no favors in this discussion- but it did let the rest of us know what we're dealing with.)



    That's the entire point. It's intended to be noticed, not to just be a minor inconvenience. Your angst is merely proof that it's doing precisely what it's supposed to do.

    What is there to ask? Afk timer is 15 minutes. His friend's "moment" has to be longer than 15 minutes.

    Even an Elite STF don't take much longer than 15 minutes. For a Mirror run to last longer than that, it means the team fell apart. One afker will hardly kill a mirror run, it's not exactly hard. It's probably all 3 of his dutchbag group afked, putting the stiff on 2 puggers unfortunately enough to get matched with them.

    If anything, 2 hours is too light. They should not be able to do this to another 2 poor puggers again for the day.;)
  • mazinger2010mazinger2010 Member Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    I'd have been fine with a one hour one, which is my point. It's a harsher penalty for similar infringement.

    Also the timer isn't set to 15 minutes. Our mirror run didn't last a full 5. Do some research, the AFK system is based on DPS and possibly damage healed (no one is too sure on that).

    I took the time to look around a bit before I got on here to complain. My issue is the duration of penalty in culmination with the nature of the penalty. If it was a 15 minute timer I would be far less willing to voice my concerns. Go ahead though and do your own research on it.
  • deniedexistencedeniedexistence Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    I'd have been fine with a one hour one, which is my point. It's a harsher penalty for similar infringement.

    There is a huge difference between leaving early and AFKing. Both are douchebaggy moves, but being afk in a match means EVERYONE else is doing the work for that person. They reap the rewards without lifting a finger, that's hardly fair for anyone. I'd rather someone leave than make me have to do the work for them, and they still get paid for it.
  • aloishammeraloishammer Member Posts: 3,294 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    noblet wrote: »
    If anything, 2 hours is too light. They should not be able to do this to another 2 poor puggers again for the day.;)

    Aye. But given the QQ about 2 hours, there'd be rioting in the streets from the time-impaired.

    I'd have been fine with a one hour one, which is my point. It's a harsher penalty for similar infringement.

    Maybe if you realize it's supposed to be a penalty, or punishment, and not a slap-on-the-wrist minor inconvenience, you'll see why the only people who feel sorry for you and your friend are...you and your friend.

    Oh- and 15 minutes =/= "a moment"
  • luihimeluihime Member Posts: 5 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Yea not even the 480 dilithium was rewarded, so that nice little story about how people in this game who AFK don't get rewards... Only expertise points were rewarded, no drops, no dilithium. What was that about again?
  • mazinger2010mazinger2010 Member Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Please point out where the AFK system is set to trigger after a 15minute time frame? Best I can figure from reading threads is that it's based on damage dealt over time and again possibly healing done over time. That's fine, theoretically we could have defeated the entire match and her leave and trigger the same penalty assuming low DPS coupled with the decrease in DPS over time spent not firing.

    Again, if it were set for a 15 minute trigger, with a penalty of 1hr that would be fine and comparable. After all if someone leaves the match your in the same boat as if they AFK.
  • deniedexistencedeniedexistence Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    luihime wrote: »
    Yea not even the 480 dilithium was rewarded, so that nice little story about how people in this game who AFK don't get rewards... Only expertise points were rewarded, no drops, no dilithium. What was that about again?


    You don't anymore BECAUSE this system is in place. Before, when it wasn't, people did it ALL the time. Which is why there is now a 2 hour penalty

    You got the XP because that is awarded as the mission progresses, not in a lump sum at the end of the match
  • alan171717alan171717 Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    If you do go, can I have your stuffs?

    I will call cryptic ebil if you want
    "I am a travelor of both time and space to be where I have been"
  • doffingcomradedoffingcomrade Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    I still maintain that it is unreasonable this nonsense is applied to PRIVATE matches, where everyone agrees on what the correct behavior is and do not need some arbitrary external standard applied to a private game. The entire point of a private game is so that we can play the way WE want, not to have arbitrarily rules of play imposed by whining morons.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • annemarie30annemarie30 Member Posts: 2,698 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Again, I'm not against having a penalty, but seriously, 2hrs is a LARGE chunk out of the day.

    so basically you are an inconsiderate jerk who thinks going afk in any sort of scenario is acceptable. all you had to do was close the damn game so you would onto incur a penalty AND open a slot for another person in queue.. but noo, it's all about YOU isn't it. are you one of the jerks who just run point to pint in Dyson to get credit for captures you don't participate in?

    as far as leaving a match, stuff happens. I don't really do long term events because our comcast connection randomly brainfarts and we lose connectivity. you wanna know how annoying it is to get the damn borg command ship to 5% and then poof! you get the dreaded disconnect from the server message?
    We Want Vic Fontaine
  • mazinger2010mazinger2010 Member Posts: 1 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Doffing brings up my next point, we are unable to open up our OWN private matches with that team for 2 hrs, again, a penalty nonfunctional.

    Annemarie, condescension will get you nowhere. Also exiting the game/match would still incur the penalty to my understanding. If I'm incorrect please correct me on this.
  • aloishammeraloishammer Member Posts: 3,294 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    luihime wrote: »
    Yea not even the 480 dilithium was rewarded, so that nice little story about how people in this game who AFK don't get rewards... Only expertise points were rewarded, no drops, no dilithium. What was that about again?

    That was the AFK penalty at work, stripping the AFKer of rewards. Working as intended, love.
    Annemarie, condescension will get you nowhere.

    It'll get you farther than pounding your chest about being a paying customer and demanding refunds.
  • jrq2jrq2 Member Posts: 263 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Again, I'm not against having a penalty, but seriously, 2hrs is a LARGE chunk out of the day.

    They can use that time to think if its worth going for that soda or what not next time.

    If your going to queue for something get your s*** together before you queue
    :P


    *t
    *u
    *f
    *f
  • tekehdtekehd Member Posts: 2,032 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Doffing brings up my next point, we are unable to open up our OWN private matches with that team for 2 hrs, again, a penalty nonfunctional.

    Annemarie, condescension will get you nowhere. Also exiting the game/match would still incur the penalty to my understanding. If I'm incorrect please correct me on this.

    It would incur a leaver penalty as opposed to an AFK penalty.
  • deniedexistencedeniedexistence Member Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Doffing brings up my next point, we are unable to open up our OWN private matches with that team for 2 hrs, again, a penalty nonfunctional.

    Annemarie, condescension will get you nowhere. Also exiting the game/match would still incur the penalty to my understanding. If I'm incorrect please correct me on this.

    It depends on what point you leave a match.

    If you are the first or second to leave and it's before 15 mins since it started, you will get a 1 hour penalty

    If you are the third to fifth player to leave before 15 mins, you will not get a penalty

    If you are marked as AFK (no moving, buffing, creating damage to NPC opponents), you get a 2 hour penalty

    If you private a match, you do NOT get a leaver penalty, but you can get a afk penalty from what I understand ( I have not ever seen anyone AFK in a private match, mostly cause the players I form private matches with aren't douchebags)
  • themariethemarie Member Posts: 1,055 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Sounds like the OP is an AFK Troll who finally realiized that he can't AFK Farm anymore.

    Working As Intended! WOO.
  • themariethemarie Member Posts: 1,055 Arc User
    edited January 2014
    Just to be fair... I will throw out that I have been bitten by the AFK bug a few times. Once was due to a critical email, and once due to a tray glitch.

    NOT the end of the world. I am a Lifetime who has spent thousands on Zen for things to play with. While I complain about MANY things, this is NOT one of them. :)
Sign In or Register to comment.