MP Pots useful for Venomancer?

Sherufaniru - Raging Tide
Sherufaniru - Raging Tide Posts: 47 Arc User
edited June 2010 in Venomancer
Hello to the high or low lvl Venos out there.

I was just wondering about those MP pots that heal 50 per second (Magic powder if I remember correctly) that you can make at Apothecary lvl 3.

So far I don't have MP problems cause of Nature grace, but I wonder if those pots are worth makking at my lvl and higher?
Post edited by Sherufaniru - Raging Tide on

Comments

  • Ii_Kaine - Archosaur
    Ii_Kaine - Archosaur Posts: 5 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    umm, i personally don't buy pots at all. only use the ones i find as drops from monsters. and for the Focus Powder (apot pill that heals 50 mp/s) is pretty useless imo***** if you need mp just use hp pots (which costs cheaper than mp pots) and do soul transfusion
  • LifeHunting - Heavens Tear
    LifeHunting - Heavens Tear Posts: 2,023 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    Not really nessacery for Venos o.o

    Especially considering you just need to focus on healing your pet, and keeping your HP up (incase a mob comes running at you) ^^
  • Aliella - Harshlands
    Aliella - Harshlands Posts: 191 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    if your poor you might want it for tw's and pvp o.o
  • Dyskrasia - Heavens Tear
    Dyskrasia - Heavens Tear Posts: 2,161 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    I literally never need mp pots unless I'm tanking something and don't have time to use nature's grace + st.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
    Evict is a sexy chalupa. <3
    retired, etc
  • tweakz
    tweakz Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    You may want them for BH 100 abaddon, though I tend to use Consume Spirit and stow pet. There are times when I'm spam healing and can't replenish MP any other way, and then there are times when I go through it so fast and can't risk an ST or spark. I see an option on Genie called Dampen Magic Curse for a chance to gain MP.
    Be kind: Help the GMs to depopulate the servers.
  • drjiggle
    drjiggle Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    tweakz wrote: »
    You may want them for BH 100 abaddon, though I tend to use Consume Spirit and stow pet.

    Stow pet? Is that a typo or some cool trick I haven't learned yet?
  • sleepcat
    sleepcat Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    if your poor you might want it for tw's and pvp o.o

    Guilty. :(

    But yea, the MP regen buff pots aren't really my cup of tea. MP pots are more useful in those dire situations, and when you're not in one, ST and letting the cleric heal you is good enough for you to go by without using any pots.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • kenlee
    kenlee Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    i use mp regen almost all the time when i tank something that need only to heal like astral but i use those with 100mp/sec. in 10 minutes fight you dont need any other mp pots
  • Vitenka - Dreamweaver
    Vitenka - Dreamweaver Posts: 4,125 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    Well, I made 10 of the 'increase mp regen by 100' back when I was getting my apothecary skill up. So level 70 or so?

    I've used THREE since then.

    No, not often very useful.

    A LOT more useful if you start firing off myriad rainbow a lot, mind you. Though normal MP pots are probably sufficient even then.
  • LinkAway - Sanctuary
    LinkAway - Sanctuary Posts: 60 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    Otherwise just buy Mp Food, ultra cheap and imho really useful. Even more when you start to spam Myriad Rainbow.
  • Solandri - Heavens Tear
    Solandri - Heavens Tear Posts: 2,843 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    tweakz wrote: »
    I see an option on Genie called Dampen Magic Curse for a chance to gain MP.
    That used to be cheaper than MP pots. You were better off selling your MP pots to an NPC, using the money to buy genie stamina, and using the skill to replenish some mana. But they nerfed it greatly when genies were revamped and it's not worth it anymore.

    At 75+, herb yuanxiao is much more cost-effective than pots. And no, MP pots are not "free" because you get them as drops. If you use them to replenish mana, they're costing you the money you would have gotten selling them to an NPC. So sell them, buy some tokens, and make herb yuanxiao. Here's how much dropped pots cost you:

    L90: 1280 coin = 0.545 coin per MP
    L80: 975 coin = 0.500 coin per MP
    L70: 735 coin = 0.454 coin per MP
    L60: 535 coin = 0.428 coin per MP
    L50: 390 coin = 0.398 coin per MP
    L40: 270 coin = 0.370 coin per MP
    L30: 180 coin = 0.353 coin per MP
    L20: 110 coin = 0.333 coin per MP

    And herb yuanxiao:
    20k token price: 1200 coin = 0.24 coin per MP
    15k token price: 900 coin = 0.18 coin per MP
    12k token price: 720 coin = 0.144 coin per MP
    10k token price = 600 coin = 0.12 coin per MP

    That makes yuanxiao the best choice for other casters. Venos have another option though:
    sleepcat wrote: »
    But yea, the MP regen buff pots aren't really my cup of tea. MP pots are more useful in those dire situations, and when you're not in one, ST and letting the cleric heal you is good enough for you to go by without using any pots.
    I've got +19 hp regen and low hp on my spam healing gear (got a nice helmet off AH with +5 mag and two +7 hp regen - one of the perks of being a heavy veno). I just ST when I get low on mana and my hp will have mostly regenerated by the time I need to ST again. I can get through ~4 mil hp bosses using Tree just 2 or 3 times.

    Hmm, I wonder... My spam healing config has 5832 MP. Tree restores 45.2% of my hp, which after a ST translates into 2636 MP. Tree costs 700 stamina, and you can buy/sell perfect stones (720 stamina) for ~800 coin each, so Tree ends up costing me 0.295 coin per MP. Herb yuanxiao is significantly cheaper than even ST + Tree.
  • drjiggle
    drjiggle Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    Hmm, I wonder... My spam healing config has 5832 MP. Tree restores 45.2% of my hp, which after a ST translates into 2636 MP. Tree costs 700 stamina, and you can buy/sell perfect stones (720 stamina) for ~800 coin each, so Tree ends up costing me 0.295 coin per MP. Herb yuanxiao is significantly cheaper than even ST + Tree.

    Interesting. I've often wondered but have been too lazy to do the math. It's perhaps worth pointing out, however, that ST + Tree is still substantially cheaper than regular mana potions.

    I've had people throw fits when they see me use Tree of Protection to heal after a Soul Transfusion, like I'm insane. I have so many Perfect Stones from past dailies that I can't unload them all even at fire sale prices. I basically consider genie use close to free at this point.
  • Sherufaniru - Raging Tide
    Sherufaniru - Raging Tide Posts: 47 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    Otherwise just buy Mp Food, ultra cheap and imho really useful. Even more when you start to spam Myriad Rainbow.


    Where do you buy mp food? >_< Do you need tokens for buying them since I have a few.

    Also thanks for the replys guy, yes I don't use mp pots only the one I got from drops of mobs never had to buy any. But I asked this question cause those mp pots you make seem good for Mages I was wondering if they had any use for Venos.

    Anyway I got my answers thanks for sharing your info guysb:thanks
  • kenlee
    kenlee Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    ppl dont see how useful are those mp regen herbs hehe. i can insert a screwdriver in my healing key and i can talk to phone or go get some drink/food... whatever i want for at least 5 min and my mp is still there
  • Mayfly - Dreamweaver
    Mayfly - Dreamweaver Posts: 6,094 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    MP food from tokens (50 for 3 tokens) is for level 75+. There's another MP food for lower levels from Jolly Old Jones, but it's been so long since he's had an event there probably isn't much around (and none on Raging Tide or Archosaur.)
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
    Weekly Japanese/English bilingual webcomic
    thejapanesepage.com/ebooks/yuki_no_monogatari_manga
  • Solandri - Heavens Tear
    Solandri - Heavens Tear Posts: 2,843 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    MP food from tokens (50 for 3 tokens) is for level 75+. There's another MP food for lower levels from Jolly Old Jones, but it's been so long since he's had an event there probably isn't much around (and none on Raging Tide or Archosaur.)
    On HT, I know of at least 4 cat shops which regularly sell sesame yuanxiao. However, its price has gone up significantly because it hasn't been available for so long. The best priced cat shop sells it for 1350. Since it replenishes 3000 mana, that works out to 0.45 coin per MP. So it's not competitive with mana pots at the lower levels. It's mainly useful for clerics that aren't high enough level to use herb yuanxiao yet. It restores mp faster than blue bubble consumes it. Mana pots can't do that until level 70 or 80.

    Back during the Jolly Jones events and right after, it was commonly selling for 700-900 each. That translates into 0.23-0.3 coin per MP. So at the time it was significantly cheaper than mana pots.
  • Armsman - Archosaur
    Armsman - Archosaur Posts: 46 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    So far, the only time I've used MP regen pots on my 7x veno is to give them to lvl 60-74 clerics during TT runs.
  • Yulk - Heavens Tear
    Yulk - Heavens Tear Posts: 1,951 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    MP pots / powders can be useful if your the one tanking or taking hits. Venoes almost need NO MP at all to grind, except for pet healing. Fox form, then auto attacks and heal pet. Truth, get some accuracy, level up fox form and melee mastery and find out yourself, my daughter's veno is close to pure VIT and can do that quite nicely.

    Anything besides recovery powders are more of a use for certain situations IMO
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

    Thanks for Flauschkatze for siggy b:cool

    VIT > STR > DEX > MAG... GG
    HA > LA > AR... GG

    HA + VIT = win b:bye
  • FoxyCleo - Raging Tide
    FoxyCleo - Raging Tide Posts: 290 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    You only lose alot (means: more than you'll regen by skills in the time they need to cool down) of MP, when you

    - spam heals
    - spam nukes

    If you're losing too much while grinding, slow down on the nukes. Level up the pet's skills also helps a great deal. My DW has Bash 5 and Howl 5, and Howl alone saves a nuke each time it's up (cd 30 sec), which also means, faster kills and less MP used.

    Can't do much against the spam heal situation though. If there's a Cleric, I just use Soul Transfusion while healing, at like 70% mana (to prevent my TB quest charm from ticking). You don't have to interrupt healing for this, your normal latency will suffice. Just keep on clicking :p Solo, herb yuanxiao will be your best bet for battles like Bloodstare. Shorter fights don't matter at all.
  • Epidemy - Sanctuary
    Epidemy - Sanctuary Posts: 33 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    herb yuanxiao are better for mana recovery since they are mathematically cheaper;
    Solandri computed it well.

    BUT -that is a great "but"- you may find yuanxiao herb usefull if you have many MP missing... and need to get that many back fast. But on the opposite way, let's say that you're pet is tanking, and that you just stucked some match on your "heal" key so that you can go AFK while your pet is tanking/being healed. With yuanxiao herbs, you'd have to stay in front of your computer to reslplenish as soon as you are running out of MP. With slow MP pots from apothecary (especially those that add 100 MP/s), you'd be able to spam heal on pet with nearly no need to take care of your MP bar, since you'd recover the same amount (or more) that the one you are spending on healing.

    So.... everything depends on what your current goal.
  • tweakz
    tweakz Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    There is a hidden cost of the apoth products: Inventory space and quickbar space, and shopping time. When I npc pots, I keep 30 for emergency.
    Be kind: Help the GMs to depopulate the servers.
  • Solandri - Heavens Tear
    Solandri - Heavens Tear Posts: 2,843 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    let's say that you're pet is tanking, and that you just stucked some match on your "heal" key so that you can go AFK while your pet is tanking/being healed. With yuanxiao herbs, you'd have to stay in front of your computer to reslplenish as soon as you are running out of MP. With slow MP pots from apothecary (especially those that add 100 MP/s), you'd be able to spam heal on pet with nearly no need to take care of your MP bar, since you'd recover the same amount (or more) that the one you are spending on healing.
    I dunno. The 100 MP/sec apothecary item gets lowered to 25 MP/sec in combat. 5000 MP from a herc yuanxiao at 25 MP/sec is 200 seconds, or 3 min 20 sec. I can't think of many reasons why you can check your computer in 10 min but not every 3 min. Maybe a really long bathroom break? b:chuckle

    Don't get me wrong, the 100 MP/sec pill is superior. But making it seems like a lot of work just so you can go AFK for 10 min instead of 3.3 min. How much does it cost to make at the market price for the herbs anyway? With the parameters you've outlined, you'd need 3 herb yuanxiao to last 10 min, which is about 2k-3k at HT's prices.

    And like I said, I've put together a spam healing set where I can just hit ST every 90-120 sec and I'll regen back most of the HP by the time I hit ST again. I've been thinking of doing the unthinkable and sharding with aquamarines on that gear to leverage this even more.
  • Waterfal - Sanctuary
    Waterfal - Sanctuary Posts: 2,723 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    the only time I use manapots, is while fighting a boss with a lot of hp and an AOE (like in TT or with WB). Or when I have to spam heal and don't have time to nature's grace etc.
    further.. never... it's not really needed..
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
    Thanks Silvychar for the awesome sig :3

    Characters:
    waterfal - lvl 90 demon ferrari veno
    Hazumi_chan - lvl 9x sage seeker
  • kenlee
    kenlee Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    Don't get me wrong, the 100 MP/sec pill is superior. But making it seems like a lot of work just so you can go AFK for 10 min instead of 3.3 min. How much does it cost to make at the market price for the herbs anyway? With the parameters you've outlined, you'd need 3 herb yuanxiao to last 10 min, which is about 2k-3k at HT's prices.
    well for me its free since i craft them myself but no idea for how much ppl are selling those herbs. another thing is, healing gets boring like hell if you do that often so id better move on my other comp and do something else than look at this one.
    you said that you have more hp regen items. well, you can combine that with the cheapest hp regen pots (you can collect them with a lvl 1 character) and do the same thing but using ST




    edit: since i dont want to start another thread about mp regen here is a test i did. how much mp regen per tick a veno, without gear, with different mag? regen is linear and btw you gain 25% from that number while in combat. if you have 16mp regen/tick then will be 4 in combat (healing at bosses for example)
    here is the picture: http://img522.imageshack.us/img522/6959/mpregen.jpg
  • Vitenka - Dreamweaver
    Vitenka - Dreamweaver Posts: 4,125 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    Well, crafting them yourself you're losing the opportunity of selling the herbs. So it's money you could have.

    An interesting point though is normal pots - since you can't sell those at full price, and most people just NPC them. (And NPCs drop more than I can use) - which changes their cost quite a lot.

    Admittedly, I still might be doing the wrong thing by using them and not selling them and buying herbs - but I keep treating herbs as a limited and precious reserve, to only be used on the occasional boss run.
  • tweakz
    tweakz Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited May 2010
    I just may buy some of that herb mp stuff since I blew through a bunch of MP pots last night in Nirvana. (Herc tanks boss while boss leeches your MP).
    Be kind: Help the GMs to depopulate the servers.
  • Gwenwyn - Raging Tide
    Gwenwyn - Raging Tide Posts: 24 Arc User
    edited June 2010
    Natures Grace usually can replace MP pots, however, in the case of me at 70, killing that 75 elite solo that has 2.8M HP, part of a quest, Ravaging Wraith Commander, or something. He hits very hard, and Natures Grace has a channel time that takes up time from healing your pet. Which when dealing with hard hitting mobs, you dont want to risk losing any time from keeping your pet at full HP when ever possible. If you are doing it solo, if your pet dies, you die. So hold onto those MP potions that you get from drops.

    Mob I was talking about does up to 800 damage a hit to my Herc, some hits are lower than that, but I spam healed, and used pots I had to keep mana up for the very long fight, I used at least 10. Natures Grace also has a cool down, so if you are really burning mana fast, you cant always rely on it.

    Normally though, you dont need to use MP pots, or those powders. Venos have virtually no downtime at all. Though powders that restore HP and MP at the same time, that +50 MP and HP per sec are nice, reduced to 12 per sec in combat. And those fast acting consumables also made with apoc, then with pots you get from drops. They are useful if you are soloing something like TT and something goes horribly wrong.

    Better to be prepared for sh*t that might not happen if you are carefull, rather than not be prepared if it does happen and you die.

    Normal pots if you are not in critical need, the fast acting stuff, for those oh **** moments. And in very long, hard, difficult stuff, powders, I have powders, but have not needed to use them yet. Though the effect is reduced while in combat, it still adds regeneration that lasts for 10 minutes.

    Added:
    Mana Leech, some bosses leech your mana like Slitt. MP pots can counter the effects of those annoying mobs with that ability.

    Too bad there is not a potion called "Hot Sauce" that grants the person immunity to sleep effects that the Emprean Slither likes to cast on Herc Venos trying to do that solo. QQ
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • Vitenka - Dreamweaver
    Vitenka - Dreamweaver Posts: 4,125 Arc User
    edited June 2010
    Yeah, I keep a stack of normal MP pots back when I set up a catshop to sell the rest - I don't often need them, but just sometimes, when you can't stop healing or when you've managed to use up your grace and don't dare transfuse because you're inside the AOE.

    So yeah - not very useful, but what the heck, I've got lots to spare.
  • Damewort - Sanctuary
    Damewort - Sanctuary Posts: 573 Arc User
    edited June 2010
    They probably aren't money effective, but I do find 100 MP/sec apoc items useful in two cases:
    1. Long (~10min) spam healing pet on a boss - I am lazy. I better use a Concentration Orb and leave something heavy on healing button. Then I dont really have to worry about keeping my mp up and I can at least read a book or get a drink.
    2. For emergencies - Similar as before. If you suddently need to leave for a bit cause of RL matter, then those orbs are useful too. They last 10min and can keep your mp bar full enough. Though basing on your channeling, mp amount and level of Heal, mp bar can get empty once or twice in those 10min.

    But other than that... I don't find them useful, not for everyday use on mobs or so... just on bosses taking lot of time, or emergencies...