varicrose or dark wanderer with claw?

Both have their advantages, but the Dark Wanderer would probably be best for most occasions.

my free pets are far from my lvl but tweaks posted some stats for lvl 99 pets
L.99 D.Wanderer: 3284 p.atk 0.8 atk speed
L99 Varicose: 3938 p.atk 0.6 atk speed

claw - 30% p.atk or 1.3
bash - 185% patk or 1.85

3284 * 1.3 = 4269 * 0.8 = 3415 for d.wanderer w/o using skills
3938 * 1.3 = 5119 * 0.6 = 3071 for scorpion w/o using skills

bash reuse is 8 seconds so lets take a period of time equal to 8 seconds. in 8 seconds both pets will do only one bash, both have same reuse no matter atk speed.
now to be honest ive never counted how long it takes to cast bash but i suppose its the same as 1 hit or might be 1 second who nows but in my example will take 1 hit


d.wanderer does 6.4 melee hits in 8 seconds
scorpion does 4.8 melee hits in 8 seconds

lets consider one of their hits is bash rest is just melee hit so

d.wanderer does 1 bash and 5.4 hits in 8 seconds
scorpion does 1 bash and 3.8 hits in 8 seconds

d.wanderer
1*1.85*4269 + 5.4*1*4269=30951
scorpion
1*1.85*5119 + 3.8*1*5119=28922

i guess this is the answer
another thing is, to cast next bash wanderer need to do 1 bash and 6 hits and scopion need to do 1 bash and 4 hits because you cant just stop in the middle of a hit to cast bash after cooldown is over

with claw but w/o seems almost the same