Are bms truly unnecessary?
Slivaf - Dreamweaver
Posts: 2,106 Arc User
I know I know this may seem more like a rant... or a peev; but francly ,I am a little annoyed with how shafted bms seem to be, in every place we "shine," another class has the potential to outdo us, or live up to what we can do.
Now before you tell me that we are mob control, or just a DD, I know what bms are suppose to do, but we can/are easily outdone by another class.
A Barb can control the mob, and take it away from the party, to avoid a party wipe from exploding mobs, and aoe mobs, they even have roar which guarantees aggro from multiple mobs, and they have flesh ream which also guarantees aggro, I realize roar has a major cooldown, and they will lose aggro from the mob they aren't focusing on pretty quickly, especially after a heal from a cleric, but still if they are as attentive as a cleric (which some are) they can flesh ream the mob they are losing the attention of, to pull it back away from the healer/party, and to sum this up... they are easily better at controlling mobs then us bms.
A archer can out Damage deal us fairly easily too, they hit a lot harder then us, and faster then most of us, and more accurately to boot. Not to mention they have the range effect on there side, which makes them 10 times more appealing to others for any kind of party.
Now I also realize we have the best aoes in the games which allows us to keep the attention better then barbs, but we get hurt so badly that even this is very situational, likewise with our stuns we only have one aoe stun, which can **** us over just as much as if we aoe'd too many mobs at once. I know we do have good physical defense and somewhat decent magic resistance, but magic still hammers us very easily. I know balance is out and I haven't had the chance to toy with the skill yet, but really why use it in pve? The bosses simply take way too long to take down for balance to take off enough damage for us to even half way tank properly. (I know that it should be left to a barbian to tank, which I am fine with.)
Speaking of tanking, we can't even really do that properly especially with a very inexperienced squad, (who may just be impatient or busy elsewhere/needing to go soon) we lose aggro very easily, (I know there's a genie that increases our hate) and we get hurt way too much for clerics to get in a hit or two, let alone give them a small break to res a fallen party member.
Really I am beginning to question my choice in picking a Blademaster, now before you tell me to quick my whining, and go chose another class, I am already a few steps ahead of you, and NO I am not... WILL NOT stop training/playing on my bm, just annoyed and wanted to get my two cents out. =X
Anyways, since we can't tank, and there are other classes that can either do our jobs just as well, if not better, then were do we truly shine at, err rather were are we really needed at 100% of the time?
Now before you tell me that we are mob control, or just a DD, I know what bms are suppose to do, but we can/are easily outdone by another class.
A Barb can control the mob, and take it away from the party, to avoid a party wipe from exploding mobs, and aoe mobs, they even have roar which guarantees aggro from multiple mobs, and they have flesh ream which also guarantees aggro, I realize roar has a major cooldown, and they will lose aggro from the mob they aren't focusing on pretty quickly, especially after a heal from a cleric, but still if they are as attentive as a cleric (which some are) they can flesh ream the mob they are losing the attention of, to pull it back away from the healer/party, and to sum this up... they are easily better at controlling mobs then us bms.
A archer can out Damage deal us fairly easily too, they hit a lot harder then us, and faster then most of us, and more accurately to boot. Not to mention they have the range effect on there side, which makes them 10 times more appealing to others for any kind of party.
Now I also realize we have the best aoes in the games which allows us to keep the attention better then barbs, but we get hurt so badly that even this is very situational, likewise with our stuns we only have one aoe stun, which can **** us over just as much as if we aoe'd too many mobs at once. I know we do have good physical defense and somewhat decent magic resistance, but magic still hammers us very easily. I know balance is out and I haven't had the chance to toy with the skill yet, but really why use it in pve? The bosses simply take way too long to take down for balance to take off enough damage for us to even half way tank properly. (I know that it should be left to a barbian to tank, which I am fine with.)
Speaking of tanking, we can't even really do that properly especially with a very inexperienced squad, (who may just be impatient or busy elsewhere/needing to go soon) we lose aggro very easily, (I know there's a genie that increases our hate) and we get hurt way too much for clerics to get in a hit or two, let alone give them a small break to res a fallen party member.
Really I am beginning to question my choice in picking a Blademaster, now before you tell me to quick my whining, and go chose another class, I am already a few steps ahead of you, and NO I am not... WILL NOT stop training/playing on my bm, just annoyed and wanted to get my two cents out. =X
Anyways, since we can't tank, and there are other classes that can either do our jobs just as well, if not better, then were do we truly shine at, err rather were are we really needed at 100% of the time?
Ah, Mistakes are so easily made. ~ laura resnick
What kind of message are you sending when you insult my intelligence? ~ Me ~ 5/29/2015 (Yes it is possible someone said this before just no idea who/where.)
What kind of message are you sending when you insult my intelligence? ~ Me ~ 5/29/2015 (Yes it is possible someone said this before just no idea who/where.)
Post edited by Slivaf - Dreamweaver on
0
Comments
-
no class can outdo us in group pvp or TW
also u can be useful everywhere... 1 archer 1 bm is alwqays faster run than 2 archer.Nullum crimen sine lege.0 -
I must admit I haven't been to many TW/Twilght temple runs, or been in many pvp brawls.
So it is nice to hear that we do shine elsewhere... that I haven't really ever taken on, though maybe I should check it out, so I can feel... more useful. xdAh, Mistakes are so easily made. ~ laura resnick
What kind of message are you sending when you insult my intelligence? ~ Me ~ 5/29/2015 (Yes it is possible someone said this before just no idea who/where.)0 -
In TW a BM's stuns are crucial, and as far as mob control we don't just have the ability to AoE stun mobs which TRULY is a blessing; we also have the ability to use cloudsprint and will of the bodhisatva to quickly get the hell back to any mobs which maybe attacking our squishies.
Those are just a couple things. Also if you rolled a sword barb, Myriad's debuff is a pretty nice thing to use against bosses. If you'e a fist BM you can cancel a boss's AoE which will make your squad love you if ya time it right.[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]0 -
HH = Heaven's Flame. Venos, clerics, archers... they all love it. Stacks well with Amplify Damage, Extreme Poison and Tangling Mire... and seeing bosses just drop loads of HP in seconds is truly a nifty sight.
We're a 'jack of all trades' DD class. We don't do very high damage, but we're consistent and can take some really hard hits. We can tank when needed in many situations (depending on your build and gear).
When running HH or higher FBs, I stun and DD on mobs, and in case a barb or herc dies, I can usually Alpha Male and steal aggro (and possibly suicide) long enough for a veno to revive a pet or a cleric to rez a tank. I've accepted my role as to keep straggling mobs off the squishies and suicide if necessary.
7x pretty much sucked as a BM, but 8x has been a LOT of fun. Stick with it even though end-game gear is pretty lacking for an axe BM (90 gold)... The only other class I'd really think would be better would be Barb or possibly Heavy Veno, but I'm happy as a BM.I post in forums. This one and others. That's why I post.0 -
Am loving the replies, very constructive. ^^
Maybe I just woke up on the wrong side of the bed today... err yesterday. xD lol
Anyways am glad to hear it does get better, and although it may be situational, it can be pretty interesting rolling a Blademaster, and for the record I indeed rolled with swords. (another choice I am questioning, perhaps its why I am finding us bms so... situational.)
I haven't ever really gotten to be suicidal... which is something i really don't mind doing especially for the squad.Ah, Mistakes are so easily made. ~ laura resnick
What kind of message are you sending when you insult my intelligence? ~ Me ~ 5/29/2015 (Yes it is possible someone said this before just no idea who/where.)0 -
Slivaf - Dreamweaver wrote: »Anyways am glad to hear it does get better, and although it may be situational, it can be pretty interesting rolling a Blademaster, and for the record I indeed rolled with swords. (another choice I am questioning, perhaps its why I am finding us bms so... situational.)
I haven't ever really gotten to be suicidal... which is something i really don't mind doing especially for the squad.
Yeah, 7x sucked so bad I almost quit. 8x has been a lot more fun. Kinda like how Tusk Town and kiting mobs really sucked and the Swamps was a nice change, but moreso.
And I don't *like* to suicide, but if it avoids a party wipe, then it's acceptable.I post in forums. This one and others. That's why I post.0 -
Kniraven - Lost City wrote: »In TW a BM's stuns are crucial, and as far as mob control we don't just have the ability to AoE stun mobs which TRULY is a blessing; we also have the ability to use cloudsprint and will of the bodhisatva to quickly get the hell back to any mobs which maybe attacking our squishies.
Those are just a couple things. Also if you rolled a sword barb, Myriad's debuff is a pretty nice thing to use against bosses. If you'e a fist BM you can cancel a boss's AoE which will make your squad love you if ya time it right.
those are very good points
And keep in mind, Aura of the golden bell stacks with cleric p.def buff, for twice the p.def which can be VERY helpfull in a squad..0 -
I am in the 7x lvls now and have had many friends give up on BM class to start a veno saying that it's a better coin and tank class. I was very dissapointed when an update broke my genie's lure ability, I used to be able to pick one at a time out of a mob now aggro whole group. In TT runs some ppl have a very wierd way do divide drops and seems that BM class is last on list, even though on all bosses are right beside tank (barb) which gets first pick. As for suicide as soon as barb dies aggro is transferred to BM if not stealing aggro already and by that time all in squad are running away. Each class has definte advantages and disadvantages, just kinda partial to being a human...lol since I am pretty sure humans made this game.0
-
I am in the 7x lvls now and have had many friends give up on BM class to start a veno saying that it's a better coin and tank class.
Yes it is... with a herc, but it also no where near as much fun to play as a BM.
The way I see Bm's is in a "squad protection " role, We can mass stun, cancel aoe's, amp dmg,reduce dmg taken etc, so when things go FUBAR, then we are pretty much the only class (apart from barbs) that can rectify the situation and still be standing at the end.
Its been said before we are a jack of all trades class, we can tank,we can DD etc etc, the trick is imo is to be versatile (Getting BH polearm everyday made me buy a pair of cheap fists and learn shadowless kick, along with lightning chaser on a genie has saved many a squishies life).
There is plenty of fun to be had on a BM, more so when you reach lvl 80.0 -
Hippie - Harshlands wrote: »no class can outdo us in group pvp or TW
also u can be useful everywhere... 1 archer 1 bm is alwqays faster run than 2 archer.0 -
As I have mentioned in other cases, the role of the bm in squad, TT, TW, FB's is based on axes skills.
That role does not satisfy my gaming needs. I prefer to add fists, sword and a bow to safisfy my gaming needs/0 -
just a question,... i see here that you say bm is a jack of all trades,...
but i thought veno was that?0 -
With other weapons in mind, I say we are walking Roar of Pride with a NOS button. As for axes, sure, other classes have stronger AoEs, but we have on-demand quick AoE's and can actually take the hits from all the things we are AoEing in TT, FB, etc.[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
"Closing this for excess letter Q's" - hawk0 -
simple as this
there no such a thing as UNNECESSARY character in the game....[SIGPIC] [/SIGPIC]0 -
They're useful for giving barbs that pdef buff. Other than that, yeah, bms are unnecessary.b:chuckle0
-
Mothergoose - Sanctuary wrote: »They're useful for giving barbs that pdef buff. Other than that, yeah, bms are unnecessary.b:chuckle
Lol and the Genie with range pulling makes you venos useless, but hey thats how the game is played. Bms can Tank, DD, and they can do the best thing, crowd control. Also Like all classes(They can be purified, not like Veno pets)
But in all seriousness, Blademasters have alot of uses, they can debuff phy/mag attk/def, they can disrupt mobs/bosses, and slow their channeling. They can stun mass mobs in place, and have a huge number of aoes to take them down. They can bleed many targets at once, thus supporting crowd control. If needed a good blademaster can take on the role as main tank, if a barb cannot be found, or the barb drops. In Tw we can stun enemies and make it hard for them to do anything. So bms have alot of uses.[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
A Knight is sworn to Valor. His heart knows only Virtue. His blade defends the helpless. His might upholds the weak. His words speaks only truth. His wrath undoes the wicked.0 -
At lower levels, when playing around with other characters, bm's do seem really worthless. But, once you get to a higher level (9x), and get some good gear, then bm's are one of the best. Any level bm that knows their class well, can do equal to or better than other classes.0
-
Thread needs more QQ imo.0
-
Are we unnecessary? Well, I saved my team from a squad wipe when our barb got d/c during a boss in TT today. And just now, my RB squad finished the 8th stage of RB Gamma and we left. Why? Our barb was AFK since second boss. No point trying the last boss with 21k left on the charm and no HP buff for the squishes. What's a BM good for? What double wave?
Sure, you can replace us with a second barb for situations like this, but that'd just be silly.[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
"Closing this for excess letter Q's" - hawk0 -
Michael_dark - Lost City wrote: »Yeah, 7x sucked so bad I almost quit. 8x has been a lot more fun. Kinda like how Tusk Town and kiting mobs really sucked and the Swamps was a nice change, but moreso.
And I don't *like* to suicide, but if it avoids a party wipe, then it's acceptable.
I'd say...it basically start's getting better for bms once u get misty forest rings,till then archers are close to invulnerable to ya.
Late game archer magic doesn't usually do enough dmg to by-pass your charm not to mention some stuns + your alter marrow magical make's you more of a tank to magic than barb.
As a lvl 99 wiz I find killing barbs MUCH easier than bms(vit ones are too much) ,and i'm not even counting the stuns. Without using a vacuity pot It'll take right crits at the right time to kill a bm like that.0 -
As a veno who loves to party rather than solo (legasp! blasphemy I know), I prefer to have a bm in my party at all times. Reason: they have SOOOOO many uses. As others in this thread have pointed out they can do more than just give the pdef party buff.
I've seen a bm successfully stop aoe's from lunar bosses in squad mode. That saved the party from a total wipe.
As Signako pointed out, they can tank and DD as well. When I need something tanked, he does it for me. This is not just because I trust his tanking and he knows how to keep aggro from me, but its also because barbs still have a hard time keeping aggro from me and barbs are harder to come by since most are either pk'ing, rebirthing, or already in TT.
With the skills a bm can get, they can get well rounded in the sense that they can amp damage (heaven's flame), stop aoe's from killing a party (shadowless kick), debuff mdef and pdef (glacial spike), reduce phys damage dealt and mag damage dealt (myraid stance).... so they are much more than a pdef buff to me. I'm always happy to have a bm in my party._Jaysun_'s Wife
Heaven's Tear--
Retired
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
For all those that told me Lunar Gold wasn't worth the hassle of farming... but now have the Nirvana versions... I laugh at you. Hypocrites.0 -
I like to peruse the PW forums for insite, tips and opinions in regards to my 2 Characters.
My main is currently lvl78 Cleric - I learned early on that opinions were correct that everyone loves clerics - I would add to that.... AS long as the cleric is happy responding to calls for help "all day long" and willingly surrenders 250k - 300k in mana on dungeon runs(do the math and calculate the cost a "cleric" expends in comparison to the Barbs repairs).
We get creamed as soon as the tank makes a deadly mistake, my goal is always to attempt make sure the tank is fully protected to the best of my ability - for the most part spamming IH on tank Or BBing at crucial moments consistently receives praise.
BUT
In being so helpful and available for others comes at a cost, few people respond when I need a squad for my own progress. I reached a point where I contemplated killing off my cleric out of shear frustration.
Ultimately I decided to create an alt - after reviewing the popularity and abilities of the different classe I settled on the Blademaster.
My blademaster recently leveled to 70 and for the most part I am very pleased to play the role.
I see my role as a backup to the Barb. If barb is tied up with Boss and 1 or more wandering mobs enters the fray the last thing I or anyone else wants is the Barb having to break from boss in order to pull mob off of our squad mates. That's why i'm there, "I" can turn to the mob(s) with a quick stun and grab aggro. Using my aoe skills I can effect much damage on multiple mobs making the time other squad mates are distracted considerably shorter.
I love runing ahead in TT51/59 and stuning multiple mobs allowing all DD the opportunity to get there lock and wield damage easily and in the mean time I continue to use aoe/stun on the multiple mobs.
I don't see any comments here from friends that run with me but they are quick to acknowledge my role in completing dungeon runs, with OR without a barb.
Admitedly, it's the Veno's that get pissed at me cause they want their Herc to lead the way - Prob is that 1 on 1 killing drags the runs out too long.
Don't get me wrong, I love the veno's I play with, they are 2nd on the list of peeps I have to rescue when their pets fail and they are personally targeted by mobs.
Truth be told, I still see myself as a noob on both my characters - mainly because I don't sit around memorizing all the stats and attribs for desired gear, weapons and skills. I just focus on finding "anything" better than what I currently have and keep upping my attribs. Want to stump me? ask me anytime "what weapon you going to next?" OR "are you going for such and such gear?" I'm quick to admit I don't really give a **** ha ha ha... Just keep selling nice gear in catshops/AH and i'll gladly take it off ur hands when I find it!
You tell me? am I a noob?
I decided to use "only" hp stones in my sockets and select my gear for higher def stats built in. At level 70 I only have approx 4300 HP and my Dual axes BUT it seems to be serving me well, even as a tank on bosses - as long as there is a good cleric on me when it's needed. And YES, I realize there are some bosses I can't do(without cleric) at my level - but honestly, even with Higher hp and Def, what barb can either?
Build what you want, damn - quit worrying whether "other" people will agree with you on your build. Have fun - thats why you installed the game, isn't it?0 -
Blademasters are all about stuns. If you have a cleric or wizard friend, you'll be pro at pvp. My husband and I have this thing he calls double dragon (we both dragon... self explanatory) and he has hit 10k+ on people our level. =P It also helps that both blademasters and wizards get OP 90+ b:chuckle .... Also, in the absence of a barb, you can tank a lot of HH's and bosses. For example, 8x venos can't tank 2-1 forshura in squad mode... but I can[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]0
-
Don worry about it, I think all BM's have at some point questioned their choice of class. After all every class seems to outshine us somewhere. Try as you might wizzies and archers hit harder, barbs tank better and for simple quests everyone wants a cleric and barb and no one wants a bm.
The thing you need to keep in mind is that a lot of classes, while they shine in one or two talents, that's all they do. A wiz DD's. A barb tanks. A BM however can do a hundred different things. We tank better than wiz, clerics, archers and even veno pets sometimes. We DD better than barbs and as well as most classes. We can aoe and 1v1. We can stun better than ANY class. We can support a party with extra defence from aura, amping from flame, damage reduction from myraid, canceling with fists, pulling mobs off squishies with aoes, any BM can do all this. We're fairly efficient at catching stray mobs with drakes ray. In grinding and pve we can buff any of our defences depending on the situation, heal ourselves, take on single or multiple mobs. We move the fastest of any class when we have to. In TW and RB we shine most, we're able to mass PvP with our wide selection of aoe's which can stun, slow, amp, reduce defence and damage. We can also become immune to stun/freeze.0 -
I am blademaster. I will not fail. Where you succeed in one area, I succeed in many. A barbarian, can tank, One enemy at a time; I can tank many. Where a venomancer can curse and deabilitate, she will never do it as well as I can. Where the Puller has failed, I will not. The enemy will not get through. When the barbarian falls, I must not. I must allow time for the cleric to restore the Barbarian, or else I fail. I am not necessary, but you will need me in the end, when a suprize comes your way, I can break away from the party and act as a free agent, preventing others from faultering. I can self heal, preventing the cleric from getting distracted by me, and my actions. I can draw a threat away, that would threaten the party, or intercept those who would subdue my friends. I will not failGood intentions are like peeing yourself in dark leather pants, you get warm feelings inside, but it doesn't show.0
-
Haden - Dreamweaver wrote: »I am blademaster. I will not fail. Where you succeed in one area, I succeed in many. A barbarian, can tank, One enemy at a time; I can tank many. Where a venomancer can curse and deabilitate, she will never do it as well as I can. Where the Puller has failed, I will not. The enemy will not get through. When the barbarian falls, I must not. I must allow time for the cleric to restore the Barbarian, or else I fail. I am not necessary, but you will need me in the end, when a suprize comes your way, I can break away from the party and act as a free agent, preventing others from faultering. I can self heal, preventing the cleric from getting distracted by me, and my actions. I can draw a threat away, that would threaten the party, or intercept those who would subdue my friends. I will not fail
That sounds a bit like my rifle in Full Metal Jacket b:laugh0 -
-
Haden - Dreamweaver wrote: »I am blademaster. I will not fail. Where you succeed in one area, I succeed in many. A barbarian, can tank, One enemy at a time; I can tank many. Where a venomancer can curse and deabilitate, she will never do it as well as I can. Where the Puller has failed, I will not. The enemy will not get through. When the barbarian falls, I must not. I must allow time for the cleric to restore the Barbarian, or else I fail. I am not necessary, but you will need me in the end, when a suprize comes your way, I can break away from the party and act as a free agent, preventing others from faultering. I can self heal, preventing the cleric from getting distracted by me, and my actions. I can draw a threat away, that would threaten the party, or intercept those who would subdue my friends. I will not fail
Roflmao sounds like a 'What am I, oath?' xd lol
Also the higher I get, and the more I learn about my skills, the better I have done at tanking bosses, but I still say let the tanking be done by a barb... FAR easier for the clerics to heal then a bm, but if there is no barb available then a bm will suffice IF they are the RIGHT build, that and perhaps a cleric having to BB from the start. (On select bosses) Though I can't blame clerics for not wanting to do that, it is rather costly.
Still some really nice replies coming my way, nice to see the ways... people have used THERE bm. (Which tbh, isnt much different then I have, except fot the tanking part. xD lol)Ah, Mistakes are so easily made. ~ laura resnick
What kind of message are you sending when you insult my intelligence? ~ Me ~ 5/29/2015 (Yes it is possible someone said this before just no idea who/where.)0 -
Haden - Dreamweaver wrote: »I am blademaster. I will not fail. Where you succeed in one area, I succeed in many. A barbarian, can tank, One enemy at a time; I can tank many. Where a venomancer can curse and deabilitate, she will never do it as well as I can. Where the Puller has failed, I will not. The enemy will not get through. When the barbarian falls, I must not. I must allow time for the cleric to restore the Barbarian, or else I fail. I am not necessary, but you will need me in the end, when a suprize comes your way, I can break away from the party and act as a free agent, preventing others from faultering. I can self heal, preventing the cleric from getting distracted by me, and my actions. I can draw a threat away, that would threaten the party, or intercept those who would subdue my friends. I will not fail
Actually that made me smile, nice one. The pve oath of bms? ^^Nullum crimen sine lege.0 -
I think i b:cry just a little....Retired
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]0
Categories
- All Categories
- 181.9K PWI
- 699 Official Announcements
- 2 Rules of Conduct
- 264 Cabbage Patch Notes
- 61.1K General Discussion
- 1.5K Quality Corner
- 11.1K Suggestion Box
- 77.4K Archosaur City
- 3.5K Cash Shop Huddle
- 14.3K Server Symposium
- 18.1K Dungeons & Tactics
- 2K The Crafting Nook
- 4.9K Guild Banter
- 6.6K The Trading Post
- 28K Class Discussion
- 1.9K Arigora Colosseum
- 78 TW & Cross Server Battles
- 337 Nation Wars
- 8.2K Off-Topic Discussion
- 3.7K The Fanatics Forum
- 207 Screenshots and Videos
- 22.8K Support Desk