Demon or Sage

HaJaRaEddie - Heavens Tear
HaJaRaEddie - Heavens Tear Posts: 13 Arc User
edited September 2009 in Venomancer
Ok, so I know there is threads that state what the various skills do and the differences but I want your opinions. I want to know which you chose/will choose and why. I would also like to know your opinion on which way I should go. I am mainly PVE, might get back into PVP one day. I am arcane, 95% magic build. Any thoughts are appreciated.
Post edited by HaJaRaEddie - Heavens Tear on

Comments

  • Sadpuma - Heavens Tear
    Sadpuma - Heavens Tear Posts: 286 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    Of course, everyone has their own opinions, especially on topics like this. Being in Heavens Tear and turing on PK mode at level 50, I alwatys looked forward to the decision of becoming sage/demon.

    As I neared the lvl 89 requirement, many veno's before me had made their selections. Many people know me on the server as a PvP veno. One that can usually stand their ground and didnt run away. When the decision came to choose Sage/Demon I saw almost every other single PvP veno went demon.

    They listed multiple reasons why, the higher damage, you could run faster in fox, and a few others. The more I looked at the differences between Sage/Demon I really wondered why there werent many that experimented with Sage. ( I guess you cant experiment.

    Well push came to shove and I went Sage, and it was the best decision I and any one else can make.

    While Demon does have the chance to do higher damage, thats really all it is, a chance. PKing as much as I do I prefer to rely on the amount of damage I can do and not hope that i get that extra amount to kill the person Im after.

    Obviously the whole running thing is pretty much invalid bc of Holy Path. Some argue that fox form running is free. I make the same arguement for Holy Path running. At 90 you get a daily quest in Old heavens tear that gives you materials to make perfect stones to fuel your genie. So again i argue that holy path is free as well. Not only that but sage veno fox form gives you a much higher physical defense advantage over demon fox.

    Some venos swear by the demon ironwood scarab skill that has a CHANCE to put physical defense to 0. You also do have a skill at 79 that you can get that does the same thing. It even gives you a chance to get magical defense to 0 too.

    I wont go through all the other skills and everything. But Sage Spark is SOOOO much better than demon spark. Not only do you get MORE damage with sage spark (at least if you attack via human form (magic)) but because of its similar look with single and double sparks, you can trick your oppenent much easier (especially in 1v1's) into thinking you have sage sparked.

    Ive made this plenty long already but overall, I argue and believe Sage Veno is better for PK and for PVE.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • _River - Heavens Tear
    _River - Heavens Tear Posts: 834 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    Personally, I prefer the cooldowns and things in demon. But I also went demon to round out my character as I'm a light armor hybrid. But ultimately its up to you. ecatomb.net has the best information I've found on the skills and such. If you're looking for damage sage is most likely the best for that, however if you want the reductions of certain demon skills, then go for it.

    I myself am not getting demon ironwood and I don't pk. So this is from a pve only opinion :P
    _Jaysun_'s Wife
    Heaven's Tear--
    Retired
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

    For all those that told me Lunar Gold wasn't worth the hassle of farming... but now have the Nirvana versions... I laugh at you. Hypocrites.
  • Zoe - Heavens Tear
    Zoe - Heavens Tear Posts: 3,814 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    I chose sage because I don't like random damage. Do I want a chance to do high damage, or do I want to know I'm going to do high damage. Not as high as the spike from demon, but at least you know the damage will be there.

    Ironwood Scarab: Do I want a chance to reduce def to 0 where as the spell does nothing but damage if it fails? Or do I want to know I have 20 seconds of 40% def reduction with every cast?

    Foxform: Why do I need running speed in foxform when I can use speed pots or a genie for the same effect? I'll take the defense boost, and I'm glad I did as I don't die easy. (Take that phoenix flesh ream, you can't kill me!b:victory)

    That's the basic idea of why I went sage. I'm looking forward to getting more of the sage skills so I can really have fun.
    Main characters
    Celestial Sage Venomancer Zoe - 100
    Sage Barbarian Malego - 91
  • tweakz
    tweakz Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    Obviously the whole running thing is pretty much invalid bc of Holy Path.

    The speed burst is when entering fox form which also gives you higher pdef which is possibly needed when you're fleeing a phys ranged mob/boss. Probably not convenient to do Holy Path and Fox Form at the same time.
    Some argue that fox form running is free. I make the same arguement for Holy Path running. At 90 you get a daily quest in Old heavens tear that gives you materials to make perfect stones to fuel your genie.

    The Perfect Stones like anything have a monetary value. Not selling them cost you, so they do cost you.
    Some venos swear by the demon ironwood scarab skill that has a CHANCE to put physical defense to 0. You also do have a skill at 79 that you can get that does the same thing. It even gives you a chance to get magical defense to 0 too.

    Higher probability of pdef to 0 if both are used. 89 skills also tend to be much cheaper and practical than 79 skills.
    Be kind: Help the GMs to depopulate the servers.
  • Caestus - Sanctuary
    Caestus - Sanctuary Posts: 22 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    I just recently went demon on my veno. This is what I have seen so far.

    Ironwood Scarab: While it is no longer 100% chance to land the defense down, the 0% defense on a mob is very beneficial. Backing this up with Myriad Rainbow increases the chances of landing Armor Break onto a monster. I can see why demon venos "swear by" this set up. Sometimes you have good luck and other times you don't.

    Fox Form: The speed increase is good for those of you out there who don't want to constantly waste your chi stones on Holy Path. As stated above, the speed increase is helpful when running away from physical ranged mobs when paired up with the physical defense increase granted by this spell.

    Venomous Scarab: I have yet to learn the spell (not enough spirit) but from the description, it seems very beneficial when grinding since mostly, you spam this spell and the wood defense decrease will help more than anything else.

    Metabollic Boost/Nature's Grace: These cool down times are going to help out greatly, once you are able to learn them. 90 seconds off the cool down timers seems to out weight sage's extra hp/mp granted since most people use charms. I, personally, use Metabollic Boost to prevent my charm from activating. Before I reach 50% hp, I use it.

    I'll give more of my opinion later, but I hope this helps you in your decision.
  • Sadpuma - Heavens Tear
    Sadpuma - Heavens Tear Posts: 286 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    tweakz wrote: »
    The speed burst is when entering fox form which also gives you higher pdef which is possibly needed when you're fleeing a phys ranged mob/boss. Probably not convenient to do Holy Path and Fox Form at the same time.

    I find it plenty convenient using both. Addtionally, sage fox gives you a HIGHER pdef resistance. I believe its better to have the higher and use holy path.
    tweakz wrote: »
    The Perfect Stones like anything have a monetary value. Not selling them cost you, so they do cost you.

    Not selling them doesnt cost you. You are not penalized for not selling the things you earn. If, as a veno, you cant make money unless you sell your perfect stones there might be something wrong....
    tweakz wrote: »
    Higher probability of pdef to 0 if both are used. 89 skills also tend to be much cheaper and practical than 79 skills.

    I agree with you on what you have said on this point, however, I will refer to Zoe's post to counter your point :-P

    Ironwood Scarab: Do I want a chance to reduce def to 0 where as the spell does nothing but damage if it fails? Or do I want to know I have 20 seconds of 40% def reduction with every cast?
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • NhiNhanh - Lost City
    NhiNhanh - Lost City Posts: 38 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    I'm a sage venomancer. I started my character being a heavy build fox form venomancer so sage was best suited for me. I played magic build venomancer on other servers and just wanted to change things up and test different builds ^_^. Now, I am hunting gears to restat and switch back to arcane venomancer due to some stuffs I found and experimented. Before the genie was release, I wished i went demon; however, after the genies were release, I found almost every skills I wanted from demon benefit inside of genie (namely fox form speed boost and anti stun summer sprint). The only skill that I wished I had was hell nova which gives amp in damage. Sage skills are more consistent and personally i like the consistency of stuffs rather than playing with luck since my luck sucks to being with lol ^_^

    fuel wise for genie you can just decompose any gears you find for fuel =\ I run low level BH for people and pick up "junks" that i change into fuel all the time.
  • tweakz
    tweakz Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    fuel wise for genie you can just decompose any gears you find for fuel =\ I run low level BH for people and pick up "junks" that i change into fuel all the time.

    Again, I NPC most of the gears I find for coin. No matter how you slice it: using Genies cost you.

    I asked once if it was worth decomposing equips for genie food or if p.stones were cheaper. The reply was that only 2* are worth decomposing (if not a quest item), and use p.stones under 700 ea otherwise. I've only mildly looked at the math, and it seems reasonable.
    Be kind: Help the GMs to depopulate the servers.
  • Brael - Dreamweaver
    Brael - Dreamweaver Posts: 1,430 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    There's more than that which is worthwhile. Catshops generally sell stones at 2-2.5 coin per stamina which still leaves tree quite cheap. You can also make your own, I just recently did another 800k stamina for my genie the total cost was 400k. So .5 coin per stamina, that's 100 coin for tree, 200 coin for holy path, 90 for relentless courage, and 300 for extreme poison (the 4 skills on my genie). Using a genie can cost you sure, but the right skills get you a better return than other options do, tree in particular.
  • Gasoline - Lost City
    Gasoline - Lost City Posts: 304 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    Both sage and demon are amazing. I had problem choosing to.

    Sage:
    endless chi for bramble hood and parasite nova
    more def in fox
    summer sprint removes bleed
    purge gets aoe - good for TW
    Soul Degeneration removes 20% hp, which is like sage EA sharp tooth and great in TT.
    heaven ironwood scarab is better with decr 40% phy def - demon one is to random specially in pvp it like never kicks when u want to b:cry
    wood mastery is also far better for heaven with 25% dmg

    Demon
    gets 1 additional stun from frost scarab = a hell veno will have 4 ranged stun/paralyzes if you count the nix skill, thats petty OP
    summer sprint makes u immune from stun
    parasite nova pretty much dragons your enemies, great in GV and TW
    Extra speed when u switch in and out of fox. Ppl say thats pointless with holy path out, but i disagree. If u use holy path in pvp you dont have energy for many other genie skills. Also you cant use holy path more than maybe 2 times than u need to wait for it to regen.

    Both demon/sage are great for pvp and pve ^.^
  • King_Solomon - Heavens Tear
    King_Solomon - Heavens Tear Posts: 1,341 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    demon is not any worse than sage for chi. crush vigor has 50% chance to gain 1 spark. cooldown=30s.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

    If you're willing to join another online game do NOT join any hosted by K2 NETWORK. Want to know why? Check BBB complaints.
  • tweakz
    tweakz Posts: 0 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    I chose sage. I use spark (Celestial Eruption) a lot for it's MP replenishing. I think Demon has faster cool downs to compensate. If I'd chose Demon, I may use Ironwood Scarab a lot more often (just a guess) since I wouldn't benefit as much from the spark. Some obscure reasons to go Demon: It's atm less popular so the books are cheaper/ easier to acquire, and Eden is far less challenging than Brimstone.

    The inconsistent dmg may be better for LA/HA builds?
    Be kind: Help the GMs to depopulate the servers.
  • IceJazmin - Heavens Tear
    IceJazmin - Heavens Tear Posts: 4,206 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    tweakz wrote: »
    I chose sage. I use spark (Celestial Eruption) a lot for it's MP replenishing. I think Demon has faster cool downs to compensate. If I'd chose Demon, I may use Ironwood Scarab a lot more often (just a guess) since I wouldn't benefit as much from the spark. Some obscure reasons to go Demon: It's atm less popular so the books are cheaper/ easier to acquire, and Eden is far less challenging than Brimstone.

    The inconsistent dmg may be better for LA/HA builds?

    I would think a LA build would really get nice benefits from going Demon, all the extra critical added to their already high critical could make for some interesting nuking...

    HA I would think would benefit from Sage to get totaly insany Pdef.... The extra fox bonus would allow it to use more arcane gear to balance out the Mdef hole, while still maintaining Barb level Pdef.
    Too often we loose sight of life's simple pleasures. Remember, when someone annoys you, it takes 42 muscles in your face to frown, BUT, it only takes 4 muscles to extend your arm and slap that mother#$@%#^! upside the head.
  • _River - Heavens Tear
    _River - Heavens Tear Posts: 834 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    I would think a LA build would really get nice benefits from going Demon, all the extra critical added to their already high critical could make for some interesting nuking...

    HA I would think would benefit from Sage to get totaly insany Pdef.... The extra fox bonus would allow it to use more arcane gear to balance out the Mdef hole, while still maintaining Barb level Pdef.

    Given my high crit rate as a light armor veno, added with my demon spark (which also recovers mp I may add), I do pretty good damage. While my cooldowns on certain skills are also a lot better than some of the sage skills, I much prefer my demon. Thus why i went it.

    But if you're looking for spike damage when you spark... sage might be best given that isn't sage spark 700% m/attack? if I recall my demon spark is only 500% m/attack. So the spike damage isn't as much as celestial, and chi is no problem as I gain chi rather fast with the channeling and the skills I use to build it first. As stated previous, I will not be getting demon ironwood. Its not worth the chance of armor break. I prefer to know it lands each time, much like I believe Zoe said.

    To be honest... I can pull aggro easily if I'm not careful. I can only imagine if I was pure mag.
    _Jaysun_'s Wife
    Heaven's Tear--
    Retired
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

    For all those that told me Lunar Gold wasn't worth the hassle of farming... but now have the Nirvana versions... I laugh at you. Hypocrites.
  • HaJaRaEddie - Heavens Tear
    HaJaRaEddie - Heavens Tear Posts: 13 Arc User
    edited August 2009
    Thank you all for the responses, it is just as I suspected. I still have no idea which way b:laugh. I will keep watching this thread as I get closer and closer to leveling and will be doing all I can to educate myself on the 2 choices.
  • _River - Heavens Tear
    _River - Heavens Tear Posts: 834 Arc User
    edited September 2009
    I recall someone mentioning this in another thread about demon and sage venos too...

    Sage chi skill you gain 50 chi.

    Demon chi skill, you reduce opponents chi by 50, you do not gain it. And that chi that's been reduced from your opponent does not go to you sadly.
    _Jaysun_'s Wife
    Heaven's Tear--
    Retired
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

    For all those that told me Lunar Gold wasn't worth the hassle of farming... but now have the Nirvana versions... I laugh at you. Hypocrites.
  • Brael - Dreamweaver
    Brael - Dreamweaver Posts: 1,430 Arc User
    edited September 2009
    Right. Sage can gain 50 chi a minute which would be useful any time. Demon can remove 50 chi every 30 seconds, which is only good in PvP.
  • _River - Heavens Tear
    _River - Heavens Tear Posts: 834 Arc User
    edited September 2009
    But if you're looking for spike damage when you spark... sage might be best given that isn't sage spark 700% m/attack? if I recall my demon spark is only 500% m/attack.

    Oops I got the stats wrong. Sage eruption is 900% mag attack and demon is 700%. Lol that's what I get for not paying attention to my own demon spark xD

    *runs before she gets flamed for that*
    _Jaysun_'s Wife
    Heaven's Tear--
    Retired
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

    For all those that told me Lunar Gold wasn't worth the hassle of farming... but now have the Nirvana versions... I laugh at you. Hypocrites.
  • _River - Heavens Tear
    _River - Heavens Tear Posts: 834 Arc User
    edited September 2009
    Right. Sage can gain 50 chi a minute which would be useful any time. Demon can remove 50 chi every 30 seconds, which is only good in PvP.

    Yeppers. I had to ask a few demon friends that just to make sure cause I tried it on mobs just for kicks and nothing. It didn't even aggro them which was funny o.o
    _Jaysun_'s Wife
    Heaven's Tear--
    Retired
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

    For all those that told me Lunar Gold wasn't worth the hassle of farming... but now have the Nirvana versions... I laugh at you. Hypocrites.
  • HaJaRaEddie - Heavens Tear
    HaJaRaEddie - Heavens Tear Posts: 13 Arc User
    edited September 2009
    Just as a close to this thread, I went Sage b:laugh. Thanks for all the information, it really helped me to make my decision.
  • Vidalaire - Heavens Tear
    Vidalaire - Heavens Tear Posts: 389 Arc User
    edited September 2009
    Right. Sage can gain 50 chi a minute which would be useful any time. Demon can remove 50 chi every 30 seconds, which is only good in PvP.

    Keep in mind Demon can gain an average of 50 chi every 30 seconds with Demon Crush Vigor while the Sage version is only useful in PvP.
  • Brael - Dreamweaver
    Brael - Dreamweaver Posts: 1,430 Arc User
    edited September 2009
    Incorrect. I worked it out in the other thread on this, where I compared every skill. It's actually a gain of 35 if you're arcane, a gain of 15 if you're fox. Furthermore, the opportunity cost of using that skill actually costs you more damage than the chi turned into a spark will bring you. Just because it brings 50 chi doesn't mean you have 50 chi more, it means you get 50 chi for that cast. Another ability in that time frame would bring you 15 chi, 50-15=35. If you were to melee instead you get quite a bit too.
  • Vidalaire - Heavens Tear
    Vidalaire - Heavens Tear Posts: 389 Arc User
    edited September 2009
    Then you can say the same thing about the Sage Chi skill in battle situations. In reality, you'd get 35 chi a minute since in the time it takes you to cast that skill, you could've used another chi gaining ability. Demon CV still results in more chi. Plus, the time it takes to go into and out of Fox is not a factor since the logical time to cast CV is right before you cast Amp. In which case, you'd already be in Fox Form.

    The only advantage the Sage skill has is the ability to cast it while not in battle. In which case, I can just whip out a pet and spam pet heal, duel someone and smack them without my weapon unequipped, or there's always the apoth chi pots.
  • thehonos
    thehonos Posts: 3 Arc User
    edited September 2009
    i took a long look on ecatomb and it was a hard decision.

    i choosed demon and one of the reason was ironwood scarab......
    i thought i get ALLWAYS 40% phydeff reduced for 10sec and get A CHANGE to pull it down to 0, but i failed.
    i personally think ironwood scarab for demon is totally **** and no worth skilling it, but i cant get the old skill back.

    about holy path and demon foxform.
    running 9.9m everytime and running 15m sometimes ...demon foxform is better
    but sagefoxform is more useful.

    at least this topic is a great advance for all coming demons and sages.
    Thanx all of u