Come and Get it Vs Battle Fury

germmaniac

I see quite a few GWFs including Come and Get it and a lot of negative reviews for Battle Fury. Personally, on my live character, I do not use Battle Fury at all (have it set at 1, just in case). Tested it on Preview shard and still not sure if it is worth it. So asking the community's opinion regarding this.

Do you think it is worth investing in and using Battle fury as one of your encounters? Theoretically, Battle fury (5 secs) can last a couple of seconds longer than Come and get it (3 secs) allowing an additional hit-(Pro). Not sure if the damage increase is comparable- is it 20% increase for Battle fury Versus 30% for Come and get it-(Possible Con). Skill animation is longer on Battle fury but the cool-down can be reduced to 14.2 secs when clubbed with feat "Relentless Battle fury", which makes it only a second longer than Come and Get it-(Con). Provides other benefits such as AP generation (pretty low to be noticeable), stamina gain and 25% of effects carry over to the rest of the party as well-(Pro).

Provided below (next post) is a raw combat log of a test run on Preview shard for the following (each being a set of triplicates)

1. Come and get it+IBS
2. Battle fury+IBS
3. IBS alone

I have used a test build which isn't quite polished, but considering it is a constant, it may not have a great impact while comparing the two(correct me if I am wrong-I can provide screenies later). I have been on since Open Beta (GWF main) but never got around to actually testing builds much, so feel free to consider me a novice on this matter and make suggestions. However, I do not intend to add ACT any time soon. Looking forward to a healthy discussion. Cheers :cool:

germmaniac

Come and Get it + IBS
Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 67 (66) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 79 (74) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 81 (79) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Critical Hit! Your Indomitable Battle Strike deals 12475 (11648) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 73 (68) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Critical Hit! Your Come and Get It deals 2119 (1979) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Elven Ferocity deals 681 (636) Arcane to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 268 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 268 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 268 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 146 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 262 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 139 Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 146 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 139 Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 81 (75) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 78 (77) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 77 (75) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Elven Ferocity deals 609 (598) Arcane to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Critical Hit! Your Indomitable Battle Strike deals 12349 (11530) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 81 (76) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Critical Hit! Your Come and Get It deals 2232 (2084) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 146 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 139 Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 250 Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 250 Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 250 Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 250 Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 73 (71) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 78 (76) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 82 (80) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Elven Ferocity deals 609 (598) Arcane to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 255 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 255 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Indomitable Battle Strike deals 6101 (5981) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 75 (73) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Come and Get It deals 1035 (1015) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 255 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 255 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 255 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 255 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 250 Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 255 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.


Battle Fury+IBS
[Combat (Self)] Your Sure Strike deals 828 (812) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 71 (70) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Critical Hit! Your Indomitable Battle Strike deals 12299 (11483) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 80 (75) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Elven Ferocity deals 640 (598) Arcane to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 146 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 139 Physical to Target Dummy.


[Combat (Self)] Your Sure Strike deals 722 (708) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 74 (73) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Indomitable Battle Strike deals 7325 (7181) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 73 (71) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Elven Ferocity deals 609 (598) Arcane to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Sure Strike deals 822 (806) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 80 (79) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Critical Hit! Your Indomitable Battle Strike deals 12886 (12031) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 76 (71) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Elven Ferocity deals 640 (598) Arcane to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 146 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 139 Physical to Target Dummy.

IBS only
[Combat (Self)] Critical Hit! Your Indomitable Battle Strike deals 9657 (9016) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 81 (75) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Elven Ferocity deals 640 (598) Arcane to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 268 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 268 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 268 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 146 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 262 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 146 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.


[Combat (Self)] Critical Hit! Your Indomitable Battle Strike deals 11239 (10494) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 82 (77) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Elven Ferocity deals 640 (598) Arcane to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 268 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 268 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 146 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 262 (250) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 139 Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Shadowtouched deals 250 Necrotic to Target Dummy.


[Combat (Self)] Critical Hit! Your Indomitable Battle Strike deals 9726 (9081) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Terror Weapon deals 73 (69) Necrotic to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Elven Ferocity deals 640 (598) Arcane to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 149 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 146 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

[Combat (Self)] Your Deep Gash deals 146 (139) Physical to Target Dummy.

whatef

I can't say how they compare damage-wise, but in PvE at least I prefer CAGI simply for the pull effect, which synergises nicely with Not So Fast and other AoE abilities.

germmaniac

Just thought I'd resurrect this from the dead . I have been using Battle fury since Mod 3 launched and the results seem better than what they were pre-mod 3. And with the need for GWFs to sprint to avoid damage, Battle fury may find some purpose, thanks to its ability to replenish stamina. Any comments?