Sword and shield or throwing shield power set?

saroven · August 2016

I have not been able to log in and play for some time even with a lifetime sub. I remember back when I last played talk about adding a throwing shield melee power set (like Captain America) and/or a sword and shield melee power set (like Taskmaster from Marvel) coming. Did they ever put those into the game or adjust some of the existing power sets to include that option?

themightyzenith · August 2016

saroven said:
I have not been able to log in and play for some time even with a lifetime sub. I remember back when I last played talk about adding a throwing shield melee power set (like Captain America) and/or a sword and shield melee power set (like Taskmaster from Marvel) coming. Did they ever put those into the game or adjust some of the existing power sets to include that option?

No.

saroven · August 2016

themightyzenith said:

saroven said:
I have not been able to log in and play for some time even with a lifetime sub. I remember back when I last played talk about adding a throwing shield melee power set (like Captain America) and/or a sword and shield melee power set (like Taskmaster from Marvel) coming. Did they ever put those into the game or adjust some of the existing power sets to include that option?
No.

Ugh, that is disappointing to put it mildly. Thanks for responding though.

themightyzenith · August 2016

saroven said:
Ugh, that is disappointing to put it mildly. Thanks for responding though.

I'd love a shield powerset too mate, but I think they're too busy balancing powers at the moment. Hopefully we'll see some new powersets after that.

saroven · August 2016

I do find it a little odd that sword and shield is such a standard MMO melee build but you can't do it in this game. Here's hoping one day we will see it.

jonsills · August 2016

On the other hand, few other MMOs give you the power to fly at will and send flaming serpents to consume your foes. It's a tradeoff.

Have there been any superheroes besides Cap who threw their shields? I don't recall any offhand - and for legal reasons, you don't want to make the trademark violation almost the only possible build...

saroven · August 2016

There's been a few. USAgent (John Walker) who once was Captain America, Taskmaster will throw shields as well as use sword and shield as a combat style. Same as Black Knight, another classic Avenger. If you want to consider Conan a comic character he is another classic sword and shield user. A slew of Asgardians use it as well like Valkyrie, Sif, etc.

I agree with you that this is not a standard MMO and you get to do gobs of things you can't do in 90% of other MMOs. I just was hoping that that particular melee style would be in the game. I'd like to see more variety for melee characters and sword and shield is pretty classic.

jonsills · August 2016

So, Cap throws his shield, USAgent who used to be another Cap throws his shield, Taskmaster who copied this from Cap has thrown his shield.

I think you can see where this is kind of a referential power. Sure, you could make a shield-throwing toon that wasn't a blatant ripoff, but a) it would be a lot more difficult, and b) the reference would be plain as day in any event.

Sword-and-shield could be possible, I suppose, but it's not that common among superheroes.

beezeeze · August 2016

Well DC comics has Guardian who is a shield using Captain America rip off created by Jack Kirby...
(A man is allowed to make rip-offs of characters he's already created isn't he?)

not sure how often Guardian threw his sheild though...I'd imagine he probably did a few times.

Unknown · August 2016

This content has been removed.

decorumfriends · August 2016

jonsills said:
So, Cap throws his shield, USAgent who used to be another Cap throws his shield, Taskmaster who copied this from Cap has thrown his shield.

There was an old rumor that Marvel has a trademark infringement thing going with "shield throwing". IIRC, it was one of the things they threw at Rob Liefeld for publishing his unused Capt. America pages as "Fighting American". I in no way have any kind of confirmation of this, though.

EDIT: I also don't ever remember Guardian throwing his shield, but I'm hardly an expert on him.

flyingfinn · August 2016

That boss orc threw it's shield in the Tolkien movie.
And Legolas threw one also and surfed on it down the stairs. While shooting arrows. That'll be really cool TP.
...
So now we got
-Captain America
-Guys who were Captain America
-Guy who copied Captain America
-Boss orc
-The Elf
_That Rygar guy
-Oh, oh! and Shield wielding heroes in DCUO

nepht · August 2016

I would pay good money for a decent shield power set. There should be one by now. It has to be the most asked for power set in the game.

decorumfriends · August 2016

More than plant? That's the one I really want.

nepht · August 2016

decorumfriends said:
More than plant? That's the one I really want.

Plant comes a close second but pretty sure Shield tops it. Plant is more likely to happen though. Marvel seem to be acting like dicks at the moment I think Cryptic just dont want the hassle >_>

Unknown · August 2016

This content has been removed.

themightyzenith · August 2016

nepht said:

decorumfriends said:
More than plant? That's the one I really want.

Plant comes a close second but pretty sure Shield tops it.

I hear more people wanting Staffs/Polearms than Shields, but I agree that that Plant Control is right up there.

selphea · August 2016

Closest we have now is Laser Knight with the frisbee throw

hasukurobi · August 2016

With the Energy Shield + Laser Knight you can sort of have a shield out when you do melee attacks. A good Knight set with shield bash stuns and stuff would be nifty though.

Amaterasu sort of threw shields but technically they were mirrors... Does that count? Also Arthur in Ghosts and Goblins throws a shield as a weapon.

markhawkman · August 2016

selphea said:
Closest we have now is Laser Knight with the frisbee throw

Tron Knock off.

jonsills · August 2016

gradii wrote: »

I want a time mini set. Recharge time debuffs and snares/stuns could work nicely.

As in the chroniton weapon sets and temporal gear in STO?

markhawkman · August 2016

Maybe a space manipulating power set with visuals similar to the distortion TPs.

Sword and shield or throwing shield power set?

Comments